Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
I have to say that these current terms for senators are awfully imprecise - who cares if someone is the senior or junior senator from Arizona, New York, Louisiana or West Virginia: why not just say the senator for Big Pharma, the senator for Wall Street, the senator for Oil Industry, the senator for Coal etc. etc. You would immediately get an idea of what to expect.
 
Re: Manchin...
Or, as yet another alternative explanation...

He understands that West Virginia is a deeply red state. (Republicans generally get around 60% of the vote in both presidential and senate races.) Manchin himself barely won his seat in 2018, 49.6%-46.3%.

Even though the Democrat's policies may be popular in a national level (and even among some people in West Virginia), he has to consider that the majority of voters in west Virginia might actually be opposed to some of the Democrat's plans.
WV is one of the poorest states in the country. It competes with Mississippi to be near the bottom of lists of income, education, health, etc. Maybe Manchin should work to persuade his voters that they would benefit big-time from the money that the infrastructure bills would bring them.
I think any plan that requires "education/Persuading" of voters is doomed to fail. (Especially when you are trying to educate republican-leaning voters.)

Remember, a significant portion of the population still thinks Trump won in 2020. A large number of voters hate Obamacare but like the Affordable care act. Basically, a lot of voters are dumb.

Manchin could put together a very compelling argument for his voters about why the infrastructure bill would be a great thing for West Virginia voters, but there is no guarantee that 1) they would listen in the first place, and 2) the message would stick, since those same voters would probably also tune in to fox news to hear they screech about how its "the first step of communist fascism orchestrated by George Soros and the chinese.".
Of course, as somebody who gets big money from Big Coal, he might not think his voters are his first priority.
I certainly cannot discount the possibility that he is influenced by the coal industry. (At the very least, it is very bad optics.)
 
I certainly cannot discount the possibility that he is influenced by the coal industry. (At the very least, it is very bad optics.)

Manchin isn't influenced by big coal, he is a coal baron. Huge amounts of his wealth are invested in coal businesses he started, and his son runs it in a "blind" trust. :rolleyes:

Though Manchin’s motivations are often ascribed to the conservative, coal-friendly politics of West Virginia, it is also the case that the state’s senior senator is heavily invested in the industry — and owes much of his considerable fortune to it.

For decades, Manchin has profited from a series of coal companies that he founded during the 1980s. His son, Joe Manchin IV, has since assumed leadership roles in the firms, and the senator says his ownership is held in a blind trust. Yet between the time he joined the Senate and today, Manchin has personally grossed more than $4.5 million from those firms, according to financial disclosures. He also holds stock options in Enersystems Inc., the larger of the two firms, valued between $1 and $5 million.

Those two companies are Enersystems Inc. and Farmington Resources Inc., the latter of which was created by the rapid merging of two other firms, Manchin’s Transcon and Farmington Energy in 2005. Enersystems purchases low-quality waste coal from mines and resells it to power plants as fuel, while Farmington Resources provides “support activities for mining” and holds coal reserves in the Fairmont area. Over the decades, whether feeding tens of thousands of tons of dirty waste coal into the power plants in northern West Virginia or subjecting workers to unsafe conditions, Manchin’s family coal business has almost entirely avoided public scrutiny.

Manchin did not respond to multiple requests for comment.

https://theintercept.com/2021/09/03/joe-manchin-coal-fossil-fuels-pollution/
 
Last edited:
Manchin could put together a very compelling argument for his voters about why the infrastructure bill would be a great thing for West Virginia voters
You have that backward. They're the ones who already think it is. He's the one who doesn't.
 
When was the last time there was a more liberal reconciliation bill of infrastructure bill that passed than the one Manchin supports?

I think it tops ARRA in liberal qualities?
 
Last edited:
He understands that West Virginia is a deeply red state.
I have some doubt about this. It never comes up except as an explanation for Manchin,
Why would it come up at any other time?

Its obvious its a deep-red state. Voting records show that. Its not like anyone is going to discuss "flipping" west virginia to the democrats.
but if it were really the driving force behind him, he'd be a Republican, or he wouldn't keep winning for both Senate and Governor.
I really do think Manchin is pretty much stuck in the center. He has voted both for and against funding Planned Parenthood. He voted against certain environmental regulations, but seems to recognize global warming as an issue. He has been at one point, pro-gun, but has also tried to bring in stronger background checks. He was against certain LGBTQ legislation, but is supportive of Obamacare.

To many Democrats, he certainly doesn't look like "one of them", but I don't think he would fit in the republican party either.
Even though the Democrats' policies may be popular in a national level (and even among some people in West Virginia), he has to consider that the majority of voters in west Virginia might actually be opposed to some of the Democrats' plans.
The policies are very popular in WV too.
First of all, I haven't seen any polls which point to the popularity of the infrastructure plan in west virgina. (At least nothing that was a proper opinion poll... maybe one exists and if so, perhaps you could provide it.)

Secondly, when evaluating the popularity of any policy, you have to consider just what people are in favor of. (Its easy to support a vague policy, but more difficult when the details start to get fleshed out.)... west virginia voters might like the idea of increased infrastructure spending (i.e. "Fix up our roads", but they may not like certain other portions of the spending bill (i.e. "Leave our coal alone".)

And, as someone has pointed out, people do not always vote in a way that benefits them. (Look at all the Obamacare recipients who voted for Stubby McBonespurs.) Sometimes its less a case of "Will my voters benefit from this policy" and more a case of "Will my voters be smart enough to understand this policy helps them".
 
New tactic I just thought of:

Whatever amount of money Manchin is worried about not getting if the bill passes, just put a direct payment to him in the bill for that amount. He gets what he wants, everybody else gets what they/we want, the difference in the bill's cost is an insignificant fraction of what it costs anyway, and, for anybody who objects that you can't just make bribery a part of a Congressional bill, this highlights the question of why not, in a system that runs on legal bribery anyway, and might even help to bring public attention to the absurdity of leaving bribery legal in the first place.

* * *

Seriously, unrelated to that half-joke above: With all the attention on the DINOs, it's easy to loose sight sometimes of what an absurd situation we've ended up in, that we not only don't have even one Republican going along with this, but also don't even bother to imagine the idea. Remember when D ideas usually had some R votes and R ideas usually had some D votes?
 
New tactic I just thought of:

Whatever amount of money Manchin is worried about not getting if the bill passes, just put a direct payment to him in the bill for that amount.

You think the Democrats haven't thought of trying to buy him off? Of course they have.

But such an approach can only work if Manchin is looking for a payoff. What if he isn't?
 
I think Manchin's next election is going to look a lot more like a R primary than a general election. Either way, I think he's doing a lot more harm to himself than good for spending so much time making headlines for jamming up Biden's agenda

Manchin is a example of everything that is wrong with US Politics. He is on a ego trip and/or willing to do anything to get reelected.
Call me a centrist who is disgusted with Manchin's antics.
 
Progressive policies are often popular in red states when the people are polled about the issues directly, but that doesn't mean that they won't keep voting for hostile right wing freaks to represent them in government.

Sure. You ask people if they like cake, they say yes. You tell them the baker in question is better known for serving them **** sandwiches, their tune changes.
 

It doesn't change anything really. Manchin is barely a Democrat. People forget that Manchin is Senator from West Virginia that Trump won by about 20 points.
For Manchin to win re-election he has to demonstrate his independence.

If the Dems had a three vote cushion in the Senate they could ignore Manchin and he would be irrelevant. But they don't. I don't like Manchin's politics but I understand them.
 
When he's asked about the switch, he angrily yells that it's caca del toro (in English), which would be a bit difficult to backpedal out of any time soon, so I'm guessing he's not switching soon. But if he were, it might actually be good for the Democrats, not just neutral. It's hard to come up with more of a simple, straightforward, highly public, attention-getting demonstration/example of the idea that the Democrats are the party trying to do what the people want and those who are against us don't belong in that party.

But Biden's suddenly caving in completely on everything about the bill, so apparently he believes it.
 
I'm gonna go ahead and say that I still prefer frustrating inaction and gridlock to clear strides towards fascism. Yup.



The beguiling labyrinth of legislative delays and other bureaucratic minutiae does lack the dramatic draw of daily embarrassment on the world stage, but that's no mark of honor.

Just to poke towards some data that's a bit related to this...

Under Biden, U.S. leadership ratings rebound around the globe after plummeting under Trump

Buyer's remorse for the world no longer alternately laughing at us like crazy and pitying us? That's a strange thing to have buyer's remorse for.
 
Last edited:
Ah, the "Leaving Afghanistan was a disaster" thing is back. I hadn't seen that one for a while. Did any of you ever manage to come up with anything major really going wrong in that at all? I thought the reason that one had dropped off the radar might have been because the complete lack of support for the claim was getting a bit too conspicuous.

Oops, wait... maybe you meant not the withdrawal but the part after that, which everybody in every country already knows doesn't involve Biden or anybody else on this continent. Counting on that to affect his international standing is like counting on a flood in Bolivia to affect the international reputation of a politician in Thailand.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom