Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
OMG!

Democracy can't work if only one party participates...

This is good news. Trump gave the Dems Georgia doing the same thing. Between 50,000 COVID-19 deaths at a 5-1 rate for Republicans and this, he could swing Florida blue. Same for the other swing states. To get healthy, Republicans need to see Trump's treason as a losing proposition.
 
They saw the results last time, too. These aren't Democrats we're dealing with; they'll probably learn from their past results.
 
*sigh*

Biden’s Federalist Society loaded Supreme Court commission proves to be a farce.

To poke at Senator Whitehouse's reply -

Washington, DC – Senator Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI), Chair of the Senate Judiciary Courts Subcommittee, released the following statement regarding the interim report of the Presidential Commission on the Supreme Court of the United States:

“This report is a disappointment to anyone who’d hoped for a hard-hitting effort to address the Supreme Court’s deep troubles. From this report, you would never know:

(a) that the last three Supreme Court vacancies were filled through the efforts of a private organization (the Federalist Society) receiving enormous contemporaneous anonymous donations;

(b) that anonymous individual checks as large as $17 million funded Supreme Court confirmation battle advertising, with no way to know what business those donors had before the Court;

(c) that orchestrated flotillas of anonymously-funded right-wing amici appear regularly before the Court, and achieve virtually perfect success with the Republican appointees;

(d) that a peculiar fast lane has emerged that rushes politically loaded cases to the Supreme Court through deliberate trial and appellate court losses;

(e) that intensely political partisan decisions have hinged on findings of fact that were not an appellate court’s ordinary province, that were not supported by a factual record, and that ultimately were demonstrably false;

(f) that ‘regulatory capture’ is not limited to administrative agencies but can infect courts as well;

(g) that as much as $400 million in anonymized money has been spent through an array of coordinated groups seemingly designed to capture the Supreme Court, a sum not usually spent without motive; and

(h) that in civil cases decided by a 5-4 partisan Supreme Court majority in which there was an evident Republican donor interest, the donor interest win record was an astonishing 80-0.”
 
This is good news. Trump gave the Dems Georgia doing the same thing. Between 50,000 COVID-19 deaths at a 5-1 rate for Republicans and this, he could swing Florida blue. Same for the other swing states. To get healthy, Republicans need to see Trump's treason as a losing proposition.

They won't reason this out. Instead, they will continue to believe that they way to winning is by cheating before and after the election.
 
Sen. Manchin determined to make Biden a one-term, lame duck president.

Sen. Joe Manchin (D-W.Va.) has told the White House the child tax credit must include a firm work requirement and family income cap in the $60,000 range, people familiar with the matter tell Axios.

Why it matters: While Manchin’s demands would dramatically weaken one of President Biden’s signature programs to help working families, they also would reduce the package’s overall costs.

https://twitter.com/axios/status/1449866575964688394

In retrospect, Democrats probably botched the messaging of the Biden win, setting expectations too high. Despite the D by the names of some of the congressional members, the party does not have a workable majority in the legislature and will be unable to take meaningful action.
 
Last edited:
I think Manchin's next election is going to look a lot more like a R primary than a general election. Either way, I think he's doing a lot more harm to himself than good for spending so much time making headlines for jamming up Biden's agenda
 
Sen. Manchin determined to make Biden a one-term, lame duck president.



https://twitter.com/axios/status/1449866575964688394

In retrospect, Democrats probably botched the messaging of the Biden win, setting expectations too high. Despite the D by the names of some of the congressional members, the party does not have a workable majority in the legislature and will be unable to take meaningful action.

two thoughts


1) How much does this save? We are still talking the only savings being the time value of money over less than a year? That sounds cheap.

2) Considering liberals found it acceptable under years in power to not advance the child tax credit, that would make a 60k limit pretty liberal. I don't know why people are getting so worked up about not getting a permanent version of something they didn't have a year ago. It is like getting angry when plane wifi was down.
 
he's doing a lot more harm to himself than good for spending so much time making headlines for jamming up Biden's agenda
He's only harming himself if he plans to run for office again. His actions indicate that he doesn't.

I heard a few months ago that he's never liked being a Senator and seemed to be planning to return to being Governor, which he had actually liked. But showing this much dedication to going against the will of the people of WV looks like he doesn't care about being Governor again either.

S&M are steadily making a case against term limits: a politician with no intention to get re-elected has no incentive to serve the voters.

As an alternative explanation, he's gotten away with going against the will of the people and still getting re-elected anyway so far, so maybe the lesson he's learned from that experience is that he's immune because the voters don't pay attention to what their Senators actually do. If it's true that the voters have finally started paying more attention this time, he's not acting like he believes that they have.
 
He's only harming himself if he plans to run for office again. His actions indicate that he doesn't.

I heard a few months ago that he's never liked being a Senator and seemed to be planning to return to being Governor, which he had actually liked. But showing this much dedication to going against the will of the people of WV looks like he doesn't care about being Governor again either.

S&M are steadily making a case against term limits: a politician with no intention to get re-elected has no incentive to serve the voters.

As an alternative explanation, he's gotten away with going against the will of the people and still getting re-elected anyway so far, so maybe the lesson he's learned from that experience is that he's immune because the voters don't pay attention to what their Senators actually do. If it's true that the voters have finally started paying more attention this time, he's not acting like he believes that they have.

If we're speculating about Manchin's motives, it seems as likely as not that Manchin correctly understands that his political threat in the state comes from the right. He's a Democrat serving in a state that went 68% for Trump in both 2016 and 2020. He narrowly beat his Republican challenger in 2018, his most recent election. His ability to win under the Democratic label, a liability in his state, is a testament to his personal popularity.

I honestly wouldn't be surprised if he outright changed his party affiliation to Republican in the near future to head off a Republican challenger. If not that, he needs to continue to prove his "independent" streak by being obstinately conservative while still pretending to be a Democrat.

For all intents and purposes, Manchin really ought not be considered a reliable Democratic vote in the Senate.

Manchin's intransigence is understandable. Sinema is another story entirely, and her stunts seem to be a long shot gamble that, so far, seems to be totally alienating her from the very people that elected her.
 
Last edited:
Re: Senator Manchin
he's doing a lot more harm to himself than good for spending so much time making headlines for jamming up Biden's agenda
He's only harming himself if he plans to run for office again. His actions indicate that he doesn't.

I heard a few months ago that he's never liked being a Senator and seemed to be planning to return to being Governor, which he had actually liked. But showing this much dedication to going against the will of the people of WV looks like he doesn't care about being Governor again either.

S&M are steadily making a case against term limits: a politician with no intention to get re-elected has no incentive to serve the voters.

As an alternative explanation, he's gotten away with going against the will of the people and still getting re-elected anyway so far...
Or, as yet another alternative explanation...

He understands that West Virginia is a deeply red state. (Republicans generally get around 60% of the vote in both presidential and senate races.) Manchin himself barely won his seat in 2018, 49.6%-46.3%.

Even though the Democrat's policies may be popular in a national level (and even among some people in West Virginia), he has to consider that the majority of voters in west Virginia might actually be opposed to some of the Democrat's plans.
 
I honestly wouldn't be surprised if he outright changed his party affiliation to Republican in the near future to head off a Republican challenger.
That would end his career. He'd be primaried by a screaming GQP racist and never hold office again.

I would be more sympathetic to the practical considerations of being a Democrat elected in WV if he did not also have deep conflicts of interest like his family coal company or his daughter's role as a pharma CEO. His political stance may or may not be what his constituents most desire, but they are directly and substantially funneling money into his family's businesses.
 
Or, as yet another alternative explanation...

He understands that West Virginia is a deeply red state. (Republicans generally get around 60% of the vote in both presidential and senate races.) Manchin himself barely won his seat in 2018, 49.6%-46.3%.

Even though the Democrat's policies may be popular in a national level (and even among some people in West Virginia), he has to consider that the majority of voters in west Virginia might actually be opposed to some of the Democrat's plans.



The thing is, that's just wrong. Who they preferred as President doesn't tell the tale. Polling in WV about the actual issue of passing this law or not shows far more support for the bill than for President Biden:

Conservative backing appears even more robust in West Virginia, home of Manchin, a moderate Democrat who is one of the critical holdouts on the budget bill and whose efforts could derail the entire plan – or see large chunks of it scrapped as he balks at the budget’s price tag.

But according to the survey, 80% of more than 800 people surveyed in his home state believe he should vote to pass the bill. That includes 77% of conservatives who responded to the survey.


If he really did care about winning his next election, passing this bill would be a no-brainer.
 
Or, as yet another alternative explanation...

He understands that West Virginia is a deeply red state. (Republicans generally get around 60% of the vote in both presidential and senate races.) Manchin himself barely won his seat in 2018, 49.6%-46.3%.

Even though the Democrat's policies may be popular in a national level (and even among some people in West Virginia), he has to consider that the majority of voters in west Virginia might actually be opposed to some of the Democrat's plans.

WV is one of the poorest states in the country. It competes with Mississippi to be near the bottom of lists of income, education, health, etc. Maybe Manchin should work to persuade his voters that they would benefit big-time from the money that the infrastructure bills would bring them. He's not up for re-election until 2024. That gives him a lot of runway to try to do some good.

Of course, as somebody who gets big money from Big Coal, he might not think his voters are his first priority.
 
That would end his career. He'd be primaried by a screaming GQP racist and never hold office again.

I would be more sympathetic to the practical considerations of being a Democrat elected in WV if he did not also have deep conflicts of interest like his family coal company or his daughter's role as a pharma CEO. His political stance may or may not be what his constituents most desire, but they are directly and substantially funneling money into his family's businesses.

That might just be a chicken and the egg problem?

Like saying a politician from California has conflicts of interest with the entertainment industry or a New Jersey politician has ties to chemicals. The ties to local industry might be viewed as a plus.
 
his political threat in the state comes from the right. He's a Democrat serving in a state that went 68% for Trump in both 2016 and 2020... His ability to win under the Democratic label, a liability in his state...
He understands that West Virginia is a deeply red state.
I have some doubt about this. It never comes up except as an explanation for Manchin, but if it were really the driving force behind him, he'd be a Republican, or he wouldn't keep winning for both Senate and Governor. And I've seen a WV insider giving a more intricate description of WV politics, but I don't recall the details or where to find it again. In any case, though...

I honestly wouldn't be surprised if he outright changed his party affiliation to Republican in the near future to head off a Republican challenger.
Under the current circumstances, he'd be throwing away the power & attention he's getting now, by making the Senate 51-49 in favor of the party that he has no special position within.

If not that, he needs to continue to prove his "independent" streak by being obstinately conservative while still pretending to be a Democrat.
Even though the Democrats' policies may be popular in a national level (and even among some people in West Virginia), he has to consider that the majority of voters in west Virginia might actually be opposed to some of the Democrats' plans.
The policies are very popular in WV too. If that were what this is about, he would've voted for it back when it was 6 trillion. He's probably still used to living in the paradigm of everybody wanting Democrat policies but half of them still hating Democrats anyway. Any danger his re-election might be in would need to be based on the paradigm finally shifting to one in which the voters have started to notice which party is actually pushing for the policies they've always wanted, or have started to pay more attention to policy and less to party. But even under the old paradigm, if his main concern were popularity with the voters, he could have voted for what he knows they want and then campaigned on the issues. The fact that he not only hasn't done so before, but also still refuses to do so now even with more public attention finally on policies instead of parties than before, tells me he's not being driven by any kind of appeal to voters one way or the other. Like most other politicians in any system where bribery is legal, he's mostly just doing what the people who bribed him bribed him for. And what he figures is best for his own personal stake in the coal industry.
 
Last edited:
I have some doubt about this. It never comes up except as an explanation for Manchin, but if it were really the driving force behind him, he'd be a Republican, or he wouldn't keep winning for both Senate and Governor. And I've seen a WV insider giving a more intricate description of WV politics, but I don't recall the details or where to find it again. In any case, though...

Under the current circumstances, he'd be throwing away the power & attention he's getting now, by making the Senate 51-49 in favor of the party that he has no special position within.

The policies are very popular in WV too. If that were what this is about, he would've voted for it back when it was 6 trillion. He's probably still used to living in the paradigm of everybody wanting Democrat policies but half of them still hating Democrats anyway. Any danger his re-election might be in would need to be based on the paradigm finally shifting to one in which the voters have started to notice which party is actually pushing for the policies they've always wanted, or have started to pay more attention to policy and less to party. But even under the old paradigm, if his main concern were popularity with the voters, he could have voted for what he knows they want and then campaigned on the issues. The fact that he not only hasn't done so before, but also still refuses to do so now even with more public attention finally on policies instead of parties than before, tells me he's not being driven by any kind of appeal to voters one way or the other. Like most other politicians in any system where bribery is legal, he's mostly just doing what the people who bribed him bribed him for. And what he figures is best for his own personal stake in the coal industry.

Progressive policies are often popular in red states when the people are polled about the issues directly, but that doesn't mean that they won't keep voting for hostile right wing freaks to represent them in government.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom