Terrible news from Afghanistan

So you are seeking to justify the invasion on the basis of events that happened as a result of and chronologically after the invasion?[...]

You got it the other way round. It's the Taliban who were harboring and helping Al Qaeda, who attacked the US on 9/11, and then the US and the Coalition invaded Afghanistan.

Please do keep up, it's only been 11 years.
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
Oh clearly my mistake. I'll rephrase for your benefit then.

Would you approve of your own country being invaded and occupied by a brutal friendly, wonderful band of killers?

If my country was being ruled by a bunch of religious fundamentalist fascist thugs who controlled every part of life with incredible brutality and savagery, I would welcome the arrival of an international liberating force.

Wouldn't you?
 
Last edited:
Al-Qaeda and the Taliban started it.
Your lies won't work here.

While calling everything you disagree with a "lie" is a truly an amazing tactic on a skeptics board which I am sure will win you many admirers, I feel like I ought to point out that (1) the Taliban and Afghanistan had nothing to do with 9-11 and sadly they were the people the US attacked not "Al-Qaeda" (2) as far as Al-Qaeda itself goes the US and them had been going at it for years before so you must have a definition of "start" that means "middle of".

I mean that other definition of "start" which means the beginning.

I'm kidding. If all you can do is call me a liar then I just won't bother to respond to you of course.
 
Speaking of the UN, here are UN Security Council resolutions 1368, 1378, 1383, 1386, which condemned the 9/11 attacks, their perpetrators and their supporters in Afghanistan, and which allowed the use of force to remove them.

None of those resolutions allow the use of force. Some of them date from after the invasion anyway. From this I conclude that when it comes to UN resolutions you don't know what you are talking about. Is that fair comment in your view? When the UN SC approves force it always includes a phrase like "under the authority of chapter seven". The USA didn't even seek such a resolution, knowing that it would be refused.

You are correct about one thing though which is that in the absence of such a resolution the US action was clearly a criminal invasion.
 
If my country was being ruled by a bunch of religious fundamentalist fascist thugs who controlled every part of life with incredible brutality and savagery, I would welcome the arrival of an international liberating force.

Wouldn't you?

And yet you didn't dare to answer my actual question...... I believe that is quite telling.

Also? Isn't the US ruled by a bunch of religious fundamentalists too?
 
(1) the Taliban and Afghanistan had nothing to do with 9-11 and sadly they were the people the US attacked not "Al-Qaeda" (2) as far as Al-Qaeda itself goes the US and them had been going at it for years before so you must have a definition of "start" that means "middle of".

I mean that other definition of "start" which means the beginning.

I'm kidding. If all you can do is call me a liar then I just won't bother to respond to you of course.

Al-Qaeda's base of operations was in Afghanistan. They were given shelter by the Taliban.

You haven't got half a clue about any of this.
 
That, and the fact that she could easily prove me wrong by saying "I think the Taliban are the bad guys" if she thought the Taliban are the bad guys. It's like how on TV the perp goes "you can't prove any of that!" after the cops corner them, right at around the 51-minute mark. Then when the cops show they can prove it, they either blurt out a confession or ask for their lawyer.

But that's enough of a sidetrack about Jane's beliefs. She won't deny it, I won't retract it, let's move on.

There is another possibility. JihadJane could be playing Devil's Advocate by posting things that are 90 degrees on the belief systems of the majority of the other posters. Just a possibility, to which I am probably wrong...
 
'Afghan villagers told they would pay for bomb days ahead of massacre of 16'

EXTRACT:

"After the incident, they took the wreckage of their destroyed tank and their wounded people from the area," Mr Rasool said. "After that, they came back to the village nearby the explosion site.

"The soldiers called all the people to come out of their houses and from the mosque," he said.

"The Americans told the villagers 'A bomb exploded on our vehicle. ... We will get revenge for this incident by killing at least 20 of your people,"' Mr Rasool said. "These are the reasons why we say they took their revenge by killing women and children in the villages."


Massacring civilians as reprisal for a road side bomb is simply standard orders for the US armed forces is it not? It is to discourage the civilians enough so they try to prevent the resistance forces from using a road side bomb near their village. It's an attempt to co-opt the locals against the resistance by terrorizing them. It's called "winning hearts and minds" or something.

It seems that wouldn't even have been news, certainly not in Iraq, but perhaps in Afghanistan and with it being a fairly large number of people killed in one go, perhaps that was enough.
 
None of those resolutions allow the use of force. Some of them date from after the invasion anyway.

I guess reading isn't your best skill. Anyone can read them for themselves.

And yet you didn't dare to answer my actual question...... I believe that is quite telling.

I did answer your question, I simply rephrased it to make it fit the reality of Afghanistan, which is the topic.

Also? Isn't the US ruled by a bunch of religious fundamentalists too?
I knew this one was coming.

No.

Got other brilliant questions?
 
Last edited:
David's married? Damn, he seemed like such a nice catch, I was about to introduce him to my sister.
 
Here's a thought. This thread has run ten pages before I joined it (just finished catching up) and contained many comments suggesting that the Taliban were somehow responsible for more killings than the US forces in Afghanistan. Now I just observed above that's obviously not true (and when I say "obviously" what I mean is that it is a moral axiom you'd have to violate to believe something so foolish - a statement requiring no knowledge at all about who killed whom).

And yet none of the people who made the false claims (several have commented since) have seen fit to attempt to respond to my simple observation. I'll repeat it again here:

It is axiomatic that anyone who pursues a criminal action is responsible for all the reasonably foreseeable harm that comes from that criminal action. Therefore the US is responsible for 100% of the deaths and all other damage harm and injuries taking place in Afghanistan as a result of its war.

I suppose it is possible that some of those people simply don't think there is any moral issue with invading a country that never attacked you and killing thousands of people. The problem there is that when I ask a simple question like, "Would you like it if some bunch of killers invaded your own country?" there's no response.

This lack of substantial response contrasts with the vigor of the assertions made by many before there was anyone pointing out the problems with these assertions.

Btw? so-called JihadJane is expressing a pretty moderate center-right position here so you probably ought to quit acting like she's some sort of communist. I am a communist. And on the whole I actually do believe the sort of stuff you're falsely saying she believes, but when I actually say it? Crickets. Alright. I just think that's all kinda funny.
 
We've shown evidence that proves the claim that the Taliban have killed and still kill more civilians, we've linked to it more than once.
 
And yet none of the people who made the false claims (several have commented since) have seen fit to attempt to respond to my simple observation.

I reject your axiom, it is faulty. The invasion of Afghanistan was legal, it was approved by the UN Security Council.

I am a communist.

No kidding?

Did you approve of the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan?
 
Called out for an obvious lie, the dogmatic ideologue can do nothing but double down and continue the lie insisting again and again that they are in the right. Would you describe yourself as a dogmatic ideologue because you are doubling down on an obvious lie here.

I guess reading isn't your best skill. Anyone can read them for themselves.

Indeed they can and let me make it easier for them to do just that.

You said:
Speaking of the UN, here are UN Security Council resolutions 1368, 1378, 1383, 1386, which condemned the 9/11 attacks, their perpetrators and their supporters in Afghanistan, and which allowed the use of force to remove them.

So the last three of those resolutions were issued AFTER the US invaded Afghanistan. That is not exactly hard to figure out. Just going to the links you provided will do it. The US invaded on October the 7th 2001. Resolution 1378 was dated November 14, 2001. The other two of course were even later.

Can you please explain to me why you think a resolution that was written after the invasion gave permission for it?

That leaves only the first resolution, 1368 and here is the text of it.

There's no use of chapter seven in that document. Please point to it if your no doubt far superior reading skills do manage to find it in there. I'll be happy to be proven wrong if you can find it in there.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom