Terrible news from Afghanistan

The Coalition are helping build Afghanistan, the Taliban are destroying it.

Here are Canadians troops helping to rebuild a bridge that was damaged by a Taliban suicide attack:
http://www.cefcom.forces.gc.ca/pa-ap/fs-ev/2010/03/19-eng.asp


Instead, The Taliban place road side bombs that demolish roads, and they even attaclk road workers at night:
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/wor...killed-in-Taliban-attack-on-road-workers.html
Noorullah Bidar, director of the company, said: "They [the Taliban] destroyed a lot of our equipment including vehicles and equipment used for road construction ... we don't know why they attacked us ... they are doing this to prevent reconstruction in Afghanistan."
They also place landmines on roads, landmines that threaten the civilians and their livestock, landmines our soldiers have to risk their lives to seek out and disable:
http://ipsnews.net/news.asp?idnews=39174
Afghanistan’s Interior Minister Zmaray Bashari told the press on Wednesday that 860 civilians have been killed or injured by landmines and improvised explosive devices (IEDs) laid on the sides of roads since January 2007.


Here are Canadian troops and engineers helping the Afghans build a college for women:
http://www.cefcom.forces.gc.ca/pa-ap/fs-ev/2010/10/26-eng.asp
Some 70 construction projects currently under way have already improved — and will continue to improve — safety for the residents of the Kandahar City area. Our involvement in Kandahar Province began five years ago, and our projects have touched on every aspect of civil engineering. To name only a few, we have built or rebuilt many roads, bridges, schools, police stations and artesian wells, as well as Sarposa Prison and its supporting infrastructure. By refurbishing the defences of all the police stations in the city, we also contribute to the safety of the Afghan government's elected representatives and civil servants, thus helping them connect with the people, respond to their needs and bring them essential services.

We also helped the people build their capacity to improve their academic infrastructure. The Afghans know very well that the future of their country will be better, thanks in part to a more educated populace. In fact, considerable efforts have been put in place to ensure the construction of a network of safe schools and institutions for training the next generation of teachers.


Instead, the Taliban destroy schools:
http://www.dawn.com/2011/12/21/taliban-destroy-two-schools-in-charsadda.html
Police and locals said that militants planted improvised explosive devices at the buildings of government girls primary schools Matta Mughalkhel and primary school for boys Sa Ghundai at the night between Monday and Tuesday. Bahir claimed Afghanistan’s "enemies" were resorting to the use of mines and IEDs since they are unable to take on the security forces in direct battles.
And here, five more schools in Pakistan:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2009/jan/20/pakistan-taliban
Islamic extremists blew up five schools in north-west Pakistan yesterday, the latest targets in a Taliban campaign against education.
One hundred and eighty three government schools have now been destroyed. Last week the Taliban banned education for girls.
 
Last edited:
I stopped responding to BB because he's not being intellectually honest, barring my one last Parthian shot where I showed he wasn't actually reading the links he scoffed at. Which makes it ironic when he says I was bluffing. Speaking of which, let's clear something up; when you said

were you saying suicide bombing in Afghanistan is justifiable? How does that gel with them going after civilian targets as well?

The Taliban kills more civilians than all the Coalition forces in Afghanistan, combined, and deliberately. If the US is bad for killing civvies, then the Taliban, logically, is worse because it kills more civilians, and on purpose. These pieces of human scum used an 8-year old girl as bombers. Even Amnesty Intl doesn't support them. Even your claim that "Suicide bombing didn't exist in Afghanistan before the invasion.", as Noah pointed out, is factually incorrect. In fact, it was pointed out back when you made the initial claim, so you hurriedly claimed they were "imported from Tunisia" and moved the goalposts.


But hey, keep trying to distract us from your lack of sources, and not directly claiming that the Taliban are, in fact, bad guys, and that you're ignoring posts that prove you wrong.


So, are you going to be intellectually honest and withdraw your assertion that I think the insurgents are the good guys, then?

BTW, I may be ignoring the poster rather than the posts.
 
Last edited:
So, are you going to be intellectually honest and withdraw your assertion that I think the insurgents are the good guys, then?

You sure post links that put them in a good light to excuse their behavior.

Don't you understand that the roads are unsafe precisely because of the Taliban attacks?
 
Are you still going to claim life was better and safer under the Taliban?


Here are some more examples of life prior to the invasion:

Forced conscription:
According to Amnesty International, on 10 October 1996 the Taliban rounded up scores of young boys and men in raids on a number of mosques, telling them they "would have to fight with the Taleban fighters against forces loyal to the ousted government" (AI Nov. 1996, 21). The attached 12 October 1996 Le Monde and the 15 October1996 Washington Post reports also refer to the Taliban forcibly conscripting Kabulis who were picked up near mosques
Ethnic cleansing:
[SIZE=+1]BETWEEN 4,000 and 6,000 Afghan Hazaras - three times more than recent Amnesty International estimates - were massacred by the Taliban when they captured areas of northern Afghanistan last month, according to diplomats.[/SIZE]
http://www.unhcr.org/refworld/country,,USCIS,,AFG,,3ae6a6a7c,0.html
The Taliban has targeted several ethnic groups including the Tajik, Uzbek and Hazara minorities and nearly two million refugees have fled the fighting and repression since the Taliban began its rise to power in 1994.
The banning of women from hospitals:
In June 1998, the Taliban banned women from attending general hospitals in the capital, whereas before they had been able to attend a women-only ward of general hospitals. This left only one hospital in Kabul at which they could seek treatment
You can read more on the wiki page: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taliban_treatment_of_women

Here are more example of their brutal reign:

http://www.religioustolerance.org/rt_afgha.htm

[FONT=trebuchet ms,arial,helvetica]In 1996-OCT, Amnesty International accused the new Taliban rulers of conducting a reign of terror through house-to-house searches. 1 "Families are...afraid that their loved ones will suffer the brutal consequence of being found 'un-Islamic' by the militia." Some girl's schools were closed. In some areas, women are being confined to their homes. AI reported an incident in which an 8-year old boy was physically abused by Taliban guards. His crime was to play with a musical toy. Radios and cassette players were been seized in Kabul because they are un-Islamic.[/FONT]
I could go on and on...
 
Last edited:
Thank you for admitting the Taliban is worse than the Coalition.

Things must be pretty bad for the "Coalition" if it sees having more respect for human rights than the Taliban as something to be proud of.
 
Things must be pretty bad for the "Coalition" if it sees having more respect for human rights than the Taliban as something to be proud of.

The Coalition does care about human rights:

Education, sanitation and infrastructure:


Members of the civil military operations (CMO) section within the 178th are supervising the reconstruction process of schools and other infrastructure projects.
The Georgetown-based, South Carolina Army National Guard unit has been stationed at Camp Phoenix in Kabul for more than four months and has already helped alleviate many of the struggles Afghanis face daily. The CMO has completed several projects, has plans for more, and has a future goal of continuing to enhance living conditions throughout the area.
Past projects include security lighting improvements at Kabul University, village water and sanitation upgrades, and construction of a vehicle bridge between two villages to improve economic opportunities, said Amy Capt. Kevin McClure, assistant CMO leader.
Here's a list of Canadian forces development programs:

http://www.afghanistan.gc.ca/canada-afghanistan/projects-projets/institutions7.aspx?lang=eng&view=d

Take the first one on the list as an example
The Kandahar Rapid Village Development Project helped five villages in Kandahar province by:

  • Establishing community-based reconstruction projects, which included refurbishing old school buildings.
  • Providing short-term employment to local labourers.
  • Improving agricultural productivity, by providing crates to farmers that reduced damage to goods during transport.
Or just Google "Zabul Agribusiness Development team", you'll see their great and important work at inoculating the Afghan's livestock and teaching the inhabitants how to take care of their primary resource:

http://www.minnesotanationalguard.org/adt/

http://www.dvidshub.net/news/84621/...abul-province-veterinary-seminar#.T2zLDo5rrTU



You can't deny that these things are happening in Afghanistan, thanks to the Coalition's efforts.
 
Last edited:
Jihad, I'm posting all these links for your benefit, since you seem misinformed about the Coalition's work in Afghanistan. The least you could do is to read them.

I know only reading socialist websites and antiwar propaganda has skewed your view of reality, I just want to expand your horizons a little bit, and make you see what's really going on in the every-day reality of Afghanistan.
 
I remember JJ claiming that Afghanis hated coalition forces more than the Taliban.

When shown a study that refuted the claim.

Silence..............
 
The Great Unravelling

More fall-out from the massacre:

' China condemns US’ Afghan war strategy'

"""" The government-owned China Daily featured an editorial today containing a devastating condemnation of the US-led war in Afghanistan. The context is the massacre of 16 Afghan civilians in Kandahar on March 11, which has “infuriated” the Afghan people and “strained the already tense” Afghan-US relations.
...

“There is also no guarantee that the US will not leave Afghanistan in as big a mess as it did in Iraq.”

... Beijing is taking off the gloves; this is a no-holds-barred attack on the US’ war in Afghanistan. The tone of condemnation is harsh and is unprecedented.

What has caused this? Obviously, China is judging that the US is quickening its exit and the entire war strategy has now come to devolve upon the modalities of exit. Beijing is deeply cocerned that US is leaving behind a highly unstable country on China’s borders and the prospects of Afghanistan stabilising in a near term are dim indeed.
""""
 
JihadJane's sole purpose on the forums is to spread lies and hate against the civilization that shields her from a brutal and harsh existence.
 
Last edited:
More fall-out from the massacre:

' China condemns US’ Afghan war strategy'

"""" The government-owned China Daily featured an editorial today containing a devastating condemnation of the US-led war in Afghanistan. The context is the massacre of 16 Afghan civilians in Kandahar on March 11, which has “infuriated” the Afghan people and “strained the already tense” Afghan-US relations.
...

“There is also no guarantee that the US will not leave Afghanistan in as big a mess as it did in Iraq.”

... Beijing is taking off the gloves; this is a no-holds-barred attack on the US’ war in Afghanistan. The tone of condemnation is harsh and is unprecedented.

What has caused this? Obviously, China is judging that the US is quickening its exit and the entire war strategy has now come to devolve upon the modalities of exit. Beijing is deeply cocerned that US is leaving behind a highly unstable country on China’s borders and the prospects of Afghanistan stabilising in a near term are dim indeed.
""""

So, the US and likely NATO, should stay in Afghanistan until the Taliban is beaten because China wants us to? Sure, if they help foot the bill...
 
...wow. JJ doesn't say what you claim she says remotely in the post you linked to. She said:

In what possible world are the "insurgents" not the good guys? USA invaded yet another country and bombed and murdered hundreds of thousands of people which is on-going. It's a black and white case of unprovoked aggression, the use of force, a breach of the peace, a war crime under the Nuremburg principles and a violation of the UN charter.
 
I remember JJ claiming that Afghanis hated coalition forces more than the Taliban.

When shown a study that refuted the claim.

Silence..............

Was that study conducted in US occupied Afghanistan? And would you say that was relevant?
 
Endgame

So, the US and likely NATO, should stay in Afghanistan until the Taliban is beaten because China wants us to? Sure, if they help foot the bill...

The Chinese have already helped "foot the bill" by buying over a trillion dollars worth of US Treasury bonds. Apparently, they do not intend to foot anymore such bills.

The US was warned that it would be militarily unable to "pacify" Afghanistan. Ridiculous, smoke-screen fantasies that violently "beating" the Taliban would somehow create a compliant Western-style democracy have been exposed as hopelessly, crackpot naive.

China's unusually forthright stance is a symptom of the US occupier's declining global power, brought about, in large part, by the chaos created by its failed, disastrously mismanaged, aggressive, 9/11 resource wars along with the catastrophic collapse of its mismanaged financial system. Meanwhile, a still bellicose but increasingly cornered US is attempting to apply sanctions to Chinese banks re Iran. Moscow has also served notice that Obama administration can no longer dictate the trajectory of the Afghan war.

Afghan outrage over Robert Bales' supposedly aberrant and allegedly drunken rampage, along with the urinating and book-burning PR disasters, has put a question mark over President Karzai's signing of a strategic agreement between Washington and Kabul before the NATO summit in Chicago in May. Karzai has expressed extreme skepticism about the US version of the Panjwayi killings.
 
Last edited:
The US was warned that it would be militarily unable to "pacify" Afghanistan. Ridiculous, smoke-screen fantasies that violently "beating" the Taliban would somehow create a compliant Western-style democracy have been exposed as hopelessly, crackpot naive.

China's unusually forthright stance is an a symptom of the US occupier's declining global power, brought about, in large part, by the chaos created by its failed, disastrously mismanaged, aggressive, 9/11 resource wars along with the catastrophic collapse its mismanaged financial system. Meanwhile, a still bellicose but increasingly cornered US is attempting to apply sanctions to Chinese banks re Iran. Moscow has also served notice that Obama administration can no longer dictate the trajectory of the Afghan war.

Afghan outrage over Robert Bales' supposedly aberrant and allegedly drunken rampage, along with the urinating and book-burning PR disasters, has put a question mark over President Karzai's signing of a strategic agreement between Washington and Kabul before the NATO summit in Chicago in May. Karzai has expressed extreme skepticism about the US version of the Panjwayi killings.

Aggressive? It all goes back to 9/11 and the people who were responsible for it. Maybe we should talk about that.

Since you support the Taliban and claim they provided such great security then you might be interested to know who they brought in as enforcers for the "security". Al-Qaeda.

Al-Qaeda were the Taliban's "security" enforcers, you support the "security" the Afghans lived under, therefore you support Al-Qaeda.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom