Terrible news from Afghanistan

So, are you going to be intellectually honest and withdraw your assertion that I think the insurgents are the good guys, then?

BTW, I may be ignoring the poster rather than the posts.
No. Not until you categorically deny that they are the good guys. You made a statement which could be reasonably interpreted as saying they are the good guys, and your behavior in this thread and others is consistent with that belief. I just asked you to clarify your position in the post you are responding to, and you dodged it. If you are ignoring the poster, it is only because of their posts.

Are the insurgents in Afghanistan good guys? Yes or no.
 
Things must be pretty bad for the "Coalition" if it sees having more respect for human rights than the Taliban as something to be proud of.
Wait, wait, I see what you're trying to pull. You're trying to sidetrack us into a discussion of how pathetic the Coalition is, while carefully avoiding discussion of the Taliban itself.
 
In what possible world are the "insurgents" not the good guys? USA invaded yet another country and bombed and murdered hundreds of thousands of people which is on-going. It's a black and white case of unprovoked aggression, the use of force, a breach of the peace, a war crime under the Nuremburg principles and a violation of the UN charter.

In a world where the insurgents kill more innocents than the Coalition, and the insurgents are still committing suicide bombings in Iraq even after the US has left. In a world where the "brutal band of killers" shield civvies from gunfire with their own bodies.

I'd call 9/11 one heck of a provocation, and I'd like to know what Nuremburg principles or UN charter rules were violated.

Just because the war itself may have been unjustified doesn't make the people fighting it any worse or better. I note that you say nothing about what the insurgents themselves have done, only the Coalition.
 

Attachments

  • 6a00d8341cc90353ef0120a8994e44970b-pi.jpg
    6a00d8341cc90353ef0120a8994e44970b-pi.jpg
    86.6 KB · Views: 3
Last edited:
Was that study conducted in US occupied Afghanistan? And would you say that was relevant?
Do you mean the study, or where it was conducted? Because if it's the latter, then you seem to be saying that factor is relevant.
 
No. Not until you categorically deny that they are the good guys. You made a statement which could be reasonably interpreted as saying they are the good guys,

No, I didn't. Such an interpretation would be unreasonable.

and your behavior in this thread and others is consistent with that belief.

No, it isn't.

I just asked you to clarify your position in the post you are responding to, and you dodged it.

You should have been clear about my position before you made your rash assertion. There's no point in closing the barn door after the horse has bolted!

................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................:h2:

If you are ignoring the poster, it is only because of their posts.

It's usually because of their past behavior as posters. If one ignores a poster and, therefore, all of that poster's posts, the content of their posts becomes irrelevant, i.e. no conclusion can be drawn from the fact that one is ignoring any particular individual post.

Are the insurgents in Afghanistan good guys? Yes or no.

I'll take that as a: "No, I won't be be intellectually honest and withdraw my (unsubstantiated - see hilite) assertion that you honestly think the insurgents are the good guys."



Wait, wait, I see what you're trying to pull. You're trying to sidetrack us into a discussion of how pathetic the Coalition is, while carefully avoiding discussion of the Taliban itself.


If you examine the thread above you will find that it is not me who has been sidetracking obsessively about the Taliban and about who is better and who is worse, etc.

The "We're better than the Taliban" wheeze always makes me laugh, though.



Just because the war itself may have been unjustified doesn't make the people fighting it any worse or better. I note that you say nothing about what the insurgents themselves have done, only the Coalition.

How strange!

The Opening Post:

An American soldier has gone on a killing spree.

This is going to explode now. Right now.

ETA: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/12/world/asia/afghanistan-civilians-killed-american-soldier-held.html
 
Last edited:
The Chinese have already helped "foot the bill" by buying over a trillion dollars worth of US Treasury bonds. Apparently, they do not intend to foot anymore such bills.

They also signed lucrative oil contracts, you know, the oil the US was supposed to invade the country for (according to your anti-war propaganda).

But I guess since it's the Chinese that makes it OK.
 
Jihad, do you agree that the roads are unsafe because of the Taliban?

You claimed they were safer under their rule. But that's because they ruled ruthlessly and oppressed everyone, as I and others have shown. But today, the roads are unsafe because they keep attacking convoys.

You know, the fact that you're avoiding me shows that you are uncomfortable with the facts that I show. You prefer to deny reality than to face it.
 
Last edited:
Afghanis have computers. They are probably quite vocal on many issues in countries such as the UK, France, and so on where life is less difficult.
Do you recall Salmon Rushdie's fatwa death threat?
 
Jane, I believe my interpretation of your post and posts is a reasonable one. If someone says "they have to resist the big meanie invaders with suicide bombings, they have no choice!" that looks almost exactly like they're going "it's okay to suicide bomb to resist the invaders".

I refuse to withdraw my claim until you categorically deny my allegations, which you seem to be going through a lot of effort to not do. You have done so in the past, with regards to the Bali Nightclub bombing. It is also the height of hypocrisy to snark at me for allegedly not knowing your position, yet refuse to state what that position is, even when I ask you to say so. If you won't correct me, if you keep with your mealy mouthed nonsense about how it's "unsubstantiated", you don't get to complain about the interpretation I have.

And you did, in fact, start the "sidetrack" by comparing the US forces in general to the Taliban. Twice, including the laughable and objectively wrong claim that Afghanistan was more secure under the Taliban compared to the "tooled-up night raiders".

But sure, keep linking to the post where BB proved he wasn't actually reading any of the links he scoffed at by asking me for information that was in one of the links. That'll help your case. The one where he quotes your claim about suicide bombing not existing in Afghanistan before the invasion, which is objectively wrong.

I also like how you refuse to say whether the Taliban is or was worse than the Coalition, and can only scoff at the claims to that effect. We can all tell why you're not addressing the points in any substance and avoiding direct questions about your position, Jane. Mocking something is not the same as denying it.

EDIT: I just noticed you cut out part of the final post you responded to.

In a world where the insurgents kill more innocents than the Coalition, and the insurgents are still committing suicide bombings in Iraq even after the US has left. In a world where the "brutal band of killers" shield civvies from gunfire with their own bodies.

I'd call 9/11 one heck of a provocation, and I'd like to know what Nuremburg principles or UN charter rules were violated....
Doesn't gel with your image of the US as jackbooted thugs, does it, Jane?
 
Last edited:
No, I didn't. Such an interpretation would be unreasonable.

No it's not. You look like a little Taliban terrorist supporter to me.

You keep things vague and talk without really saying anything so that when called out, you can have plenty of wiggle-room to evade, equivocate and deny what you just said. But you often let your guard down and come out as a supporter of terrorists and blood-soaked tyrants.

The fact that you sit there posting articles from terrorists and tyrants is a dead give-away. If someone constantly posted articles from David Duke, the KKK and Aryan Nation and had the screen name "NaziJohn" and let slip that they thought Germany was better off under Hitler but denied they supported Nazis, you wouldn't believe them.
 
Last edited:
That, and the fact that she could easily prove me wrong by saying "I think the Taliban are the bad guys" if she thought the Taliban are the bad guys. It's like how on TV the perp goes "you can't prove any of that!" after the cops corner them, right at around the 51-minute mark. Then when the cops show they can prove it, they either blurt out a confession or ask for their lawyer.

But that's enough of a sidetrack about Jane's beliefs. She won't deny it, I won't retract it, let's move on.
 
Last edited:
Who would you rather live under.

a) NATO
b) Al-Qaeda.

Pick one.

In other words you cannot answer my simple question but at the same time feel that you have to respond to it, even though it was not directed at you. Isn't that telling. Just to give you another chance to duck answering my question I will repeat it for you.

Would you approve of your own country being invaded and occupied by a brutal band of killers?


But back to your question. The intent seems to be to suggest that it is OK to invade a country and murder a bunch of people if you are of the opinion that your own government could do a better job than their current government. Is that a fair statement of your own beliefs? Or if it isn't please explain what point you were trying to make there.
 
In other words you cannot answer my simple question but at the same time feel that you have to respond to it, even though it was not directed at you. Isn't that telling. Just to give you another chance to duck answering my question I will repeat it for you.

Would you approve of your own country being invaded and occupied by a brutal band of killers?

I'm not stupid. I don't answer loaded questions.
 
I suspect the context of my own comment is worth reproducing:
In what possible world are the "insurgents" not the good guys? USA invaded yet another country and bombed and murdered hundreds of thousands of people which is on-going. It's a black and white case of unprovoked aggression, the use of force, a breach of the peace, a war crime under the Nuremburg principles and a violation of the UN charter.

In a world where the insurgents kill more innocents than the Coalition, and the insurgents are still committing suicide bombings in Iraq even after the US has left. In a world where the "brutal band of killers" shield civvies from gunfire with their own bodies.

So you are seeking to justify the invasion on the basis of events that happened as a result of and chronologically after the invasion? Does that really make sense to you? Or perhaps we're using different definitions of "good guys". You didn't specify so I am going off the most obvious definition, namely the innocent party, the defenders, the people who are NOT war criminals, the ones who got attacked not the ones who attacked, the ones just seeking to defend themselves and their families as opposed to people who flew across the world to carry death to innocents who had never attacked anyone and had no means to do so. Were you using some other definition?

The USA started it and you can't justify an action by stuff that happens after the action.

I'd call 9/11 one heck of a provocation

Well first of all it's only a "provocation" if other significant events didn't precede it. Are you saying that you know of no events prior to 9-11 that might be characterised as on-going war between the US and Al Qaeda?

Secondly if it was a provocation it wasn't enacted by the government or people of Afghanistan so you know, bombing the **** out of group A because you think group B did something is not logical is it?

Thirdly if it was a provocation and was by Afghanistan it still would be criminal act to respond with an invasion. it would still be a war crime, a breach of Nuremburg and the UN Charter. That's because (1) the action was no on-going so there's no question of self-defence and (2) the response was super ridiculously far out of proportion to the alleged provocation.

I'd like to know what Nuremburg principles or UN charter rules were violated.

So you've never read either one then. OK. Well there's this thing called Google that you can use to find them both.

Try UN Charter article 2 section 3 and 4

And here's the Nuremburg Principles. They are law btw, as is the UN charter.

Just because the war itself may have been unjustified doesn't make the people fighting it any worse or better.

Of course it does. They are war criminals. Being a war criminal makes you a worse person.

I note that you say nothing about what the insurgents themselves have done, only the Coalition.

Defending yourself is not against the law. It is not immoral and on the contrary is praiseworthy and honorable. In addition it is axiomatic that anyone who pursues a criminal action is responsible for all the reasonably foreseeable harm that comes from that criminal action. Therefore the US is responsible for 100% of the deaths and all other damage harm and injuries taking place in Afghanistan as a result of its war.
 
Do you mean the study, or where it was conducted? Because if it's the latter, then you seem to be saying that factor is relevant.

If Saddam Husein had conducted a poll or had one done in Iraq that came out saying everyone was really happy with his rule would you consider that it might be biased? In general do you think any polling done under a military occupation which has been killing people left and right, might be suspicious and prone to bias favouring the occupation?
 
They're not a brutal band of killers. You're confusing them with the Taliban.

Oh clearly my mistake. I'll rephrase for your benefit then.

Would you approve of your own country being invaded and occupied by a brutal friendly, wonderful band of killers?
 
I'm not stupid. I don't answer loaded questions.

Why is it a loaded question? Americans generally appear to be of the view that it is moral to invade someone else's country and murder thousands of people. Is that the case with you? Do you think it would be morally OK for another country to invade America (or whatever country you come from) and kill thousands or millions of people?

Feel free to answer more broadly if you think those exact words are somehow leading or whatever. What position do you hold on the morality of invading a country and killing thousands of people?

Why is that a hard question that you cannot answer because "I'm not stupid"?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom