Virus
Philosopher
- Joined
- Jun 19, 2006
- Messages
- 6,875
Would you approve of your own country being invaded and occupied by a brutal band of killers?
Who would you rather live under.
a) NATO
b) Al-Qaeda.
Pick one.
Would you approve of your own country being invaded and occupied by a brutal band of killers?
No. Not until you categorically deny that they are the good guys. You made a statement which could be reasonably interpreted as saying they are the good guys, and your behavior in this thread and others is consistent with that belief. I just asked you to clarify your position in the post you are responding to, and you dodged it. If you are ignoring the poster, it is only because of their posts.So, are you going to be intellectually honest and withdraw your assertion that I think the insurgents are the good guys, then?
BTW, I may be ignoring the poster rather than the posts.
Wait, wait, I see what you're trying to pull. You're trying to sidetrack us into a discussion of how pathetic the Coalition is, while carefully avoiding discussion of the Taliban itself.Things must be pretty bad for the "Coalition" if it sees having more respect for human rights than the Taliban as something to be proud of.
In what possible world are the "insurgents" not the good guys? USA invaded yet another country and bombed and murdered hundreds of thousands of people which is on-going. It's a black and white case of unprovoked aggression, the use of force, a breach of the peace, a war crime under the Nuremburg principles and a violation of the UN charter.
Do you mean the study, or where it was conducted? Because if it's the latter, then you seem to be saying that factor is relevant.Was that study conducted in US occupied Afghanistan? And would you say that was relevant?
Would you approve of your own country being invaded and occupied by a brutal band of killers?
No. Not until you categorically deny that they are the good guys. You made a statement which could be reasonably interpreted as saying they are the good guys,
and your behavior in this thread and others is consistent with that belief.
I just asked you to clarify your position in the post you are responding to, and you dodged it.

If you are ignoring the poster, it is only because of their posts.
Are the insurgents in Afghanistan good guys? Yes or no.
Wait, wait, I see what you're trying to pull. You're trying to sidetrack us into a discussion of how pathetic the Coalition is, while carefully avoiding discussion of the Taliban itself.
Just because the war itself may have been unjustified doesn't make the people fighting it any worse or better. I note that you say nothing about what the insurgents themselves have done, only the Coalition.
An American soldier has gone on a killing spree.
This is going to explode now. Right now.
ETA: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/12/world/asia/afghanistan-civilians-killed-american-soldier-held.html
The Chinese have already helped "foot the bill" by buying over a trillion dollars worth of US Treasury bonds. Apparently, they do not intend to foot anymore such bills.
Do you recall Salmon Rushdie's fatwa death threat?Afghanis have computers. They are probably quite vocal on many issues in countries such as the UK, France, and so on where life is less difficult.
Doesn't gel with your image of the US as jackbooted thugs, does it, Jane?In a world where the insurgents kill more innocents than the Coalition, and the insurgents are still committing suicide bombings in Iraq even after the US has left. In a world where the "brutal band of killers" shield civvies from gunfire with their own bodies.
I'd call 9/11 one heck of a provocation, and I'd like to know what Nuremburg principles or UN charter rules were violated....
No, I didn't. Such an interpretation would be unreasonable.
Who would you rather live under.
a) NATO
b) Al-Qaeda.
Pick one.
In other words you cannot answer my simple question but at the same time feel that you have to respond to it, even though it was not directed at you. Isn't that telling. Just to give you another chance to duck answering my question I will repeat it for you.
Would you approve of your own country being invaded and occupied by a brutal band of killers?
In what possible world are the "insurgents" not the good guys? USA invaded yet another country and bombed and murdered hundreds of thousands of people which is on-going. It's a black and white case of unprovoked aggression, the use of force, a breach of the peace, a war crime under the Nuremburg principles and a violation of the UN charter.
In a world where the insurgents kill more innocents than the Coalition, and the insurgents are still committing suicide bombings in Iraq even after the US has left. In a world where the "brutal band of killers" shield civvies from gunfire with their own bodies.
I'd call 9/11 one heck of a provocation
I'd like to know what Nuremburg principles or UN charter rules were violated.
Just because the war itself may have been unjustified doesn't make the people fighting it any worse or better.
I note that you say nothing about what the insurgents themselves have done, only the Coalition.
Do you mean the study, or where it was conducted? Because if it's the latter, then you seem to be saying that factor is relevant.
They're not a brutal band of killers. You're confusing them with the Taliban.
I'm not stupid. I don't answer loaded questions.
The USA started it and you can't justify an action by stuff that happens after the action.