I suspect the context of my own comment is worth reproducing:
So you are seeking to justify the invasion on the basis of events that happened as a result of and chronologically after the invasion? Does that really make sense to you? Or perhaps we're using different definitions of "good guys". You didn't specify so I am going off the most obvious definition, namely the innocent party, the defenders, the people who are NOT war criminals, the ones who got attacked not the ones who attacked, the ones just seeking to defend themselves and their families as opposed to people who flew across the world to carry death to innocents who had never attacked anyone and had no means to do so. Were you using some other definition?
One much less specific, yes; people who are morally justified in their actions. As opposed to bad guys, who are people who are morally unjustified. The Coalition did not fly across the world to kill civilians. It seeks to reduce harm to civilians wherever possible, but mistakes happen in a war. The Taliban, by contrast,
actively targets civilians.
It's also ironic that you specifically mention flying across the world to attack innocents, and that
exactly fits the description of 9/11.
The USA started it and you can't justify an action by stuff that happens after the action.
Al Qaeda started it with 911.
Well first of all it's only a "provocation" if other significant events didn't precede it.
False. If a bully has been bothering a child for weeks, and teases his victim into hitting him, was he not provoked? In fact, I'd be very surprised if you could find a single dictionary that supports your claim that a provocation has to be the first event of its kind.
http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/provoke
http://www.thefreedictionary.com/provoke
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/provoke
http://www.macmillandictionary.com/dictionary/british/provoke
http://thinkexist.com/dictionary/meaning/provoke/
Are you saying that you know of no events prior to 9-11 that might be characterised as on-going war between the US and Al Qaeda?
Conflict, yes. Full blown capital letters there'll be a quiz in the history books War, no.
Secondly if it was a provocation it wasn't enacted by the government or people of Afghanistan so you know, bombing the **** out of group A because you think group B did something is not logical is it?
The Taliban supported Osama and Al Qaeda. They actively hired Al Qaeda members as enforcers.
Thirdly if it was a provocation and was by Afghanistan it still would be criminal act to respond with an invasion. it would still be a war crime, a breach of Nuremburg and the UN Charter. That's because (1) the action was no on-going so there's no question of self-defence and (2) the response was super ridiculously far out of proportion to the alleged provocation.
I don't see how that follows. Where does the UN say a response has to be "proportional", or needs to be "on-going"? The US acted to end a proven and known threat to its people and parcel. Should the US have said "well, it's not an ongoing threat, so that's all right, then?" You said it yourself; 9/11 wasn't the first time Al Qaeda had clashed with the US. Even after the war, they were still planning to strike at the US, ten years on.
So you've never read either one then. OK. Well there's this thing called Google that you can use to find them both.
Nice try. When you make a claim, you present evidence. This is a skeptics' forum. Asking you to present evidence is not a sign of ignorance.
As I recall, Afghanistan under the Taliban didn't actually give two craps about the UN. Otherwise they'd probably have had a word with them about the human rights violations,
and did in fact condemn them. They also said that Bin Laden needed to be turned over to the US for the 1998 embassy bombing.
On 8 December, by resolution 1214 (1998), the Council demanded that the Taliban stop providing sanctuary and training for international terrorists and their organizations and that all Afghan factions cooperate in bringing indicted terrorists to justice.
We all know that didn't happen.
And here's the Nuremburg Principles. They are law btw, as is the UN charter.
Let me guess. You're going to assert that the actions of the Coalition were war crimes, because the NP says they were war crimes, but you are not going to be more specific. I can't find anyone else endorsing this viewpoint except far-far-left blogs.
Of course it does. They are war criminals. Being a war criminal makes you a worse person.
The Taliban are war criminals. In fact, they have committed many, many
more crimes. Including deliberately targeting civilians. 8-year old girl. Tricked into being a human bomb.
Defending yourself is not against the law. It is not immoral and on the contrary is praiseworthy and honorable.
So it's "praiseworthy and honorable" to trick children into being bombers and to deliberately target civilians who have nothing to do with the Coalition?
In addition it is axiomatic that anyone who pursues a criminal action is responsible for all the reasonably foreseeable harm that comes from that criminal action. Therefore the US is responsible for 100% of the deaths and all other damage harm and injuries taking place in Afghanistan as a result of its war.
So the Taliban is not responsible for any of the innocents they choose to murder, and it's all the big bad Americans' fault for invading the country because this was a "reasonable consequence".
I would argue that this was not reasonable. Attacking innocent civilians, and using kids to do so, are the actions of lunatics and fanatics, not reasonable men.
Also: There is something
wrong with you.
Good day.