Terrible news from Afghanistan

I reject your axiom, it is faulty. The invasion of Afghanistan was legal, it was approved by the UN Security Council.

Sorry - did you mean to say that you ACCEPT my axiom but you don't think it applies because you think the US invasion was not criminal? So you just goofed your wording there?
 
Recognizing the inherent right of individual or collective self-defence in accordance with the Charter

Calls on all States to work together urgently to bring to justice the perpetrators, organizers and sponsors of these terrorist attacks and stresses that those responsible for aiding, supporting or harbouring the perpetrators, organizers and sponsors of these acts will be held accountable;

Calls also on the international community to redouble their efforts to prevent and suppress terrorist acts including by increased cooperation and full implementation of the relevant international anti-terrorist conventions and Security Council resolutions, in particular resolution 1269 of 19 October 1999;

Expresses its readiness to take all necessary steps to respond to the terrorist attacks of 11 September 2001, and to combat all forms of terrorism, in accordance with its responsibilities under the Charter of the United Nations


Seems pretty clear to me.

OR maybe you're not just a communist, but a truther as well?
 
A truly astounding argument.

Well, it was a truly stupid observation you made.

Can you enlarge upon it even more than you did just there?
How many times can one repeat the same thing?

Al Qaeda was harbored and helped by the Taliban, they had training camps in Afghanistan. The invasion and removal of the Taliban was justified.

Where have you been the last 11 years?

Sorry - did you mean to say that you ACCEPT my axiom but you don't think it applies because you think the US invasion was not criminal? So you just goofed your wording there?

I reject your axiom full stop.

I think whoever does a crime is responsible for that crime, whatever happened before, whatever lead to the crime being committed.

The Coalition is not responsible for the thousands of roadside bombings and suicide attacks on civilians made by the Taliban and AQ, the terrorists are. Your logic is faulty, and abhorrent. You could justify anything with that reasoning.
 
Last edited:
If Saddam Husein had conducted a poll or had one done in Iraq that came out saying everyone was really happy with his rule would you consider that it might be biased? In general do you think any polling done under a military occupation which has been killing people left and right, might be suspicious and prone to bias favouring the occupation?
You seem to have missed the several links throughout the past few pages pointing out that the Taliban is objectively more dangerous for the people of Afghanistan than the Taliban is. They both kill more people than the Coalition, and deliberately target civilians.

Also, you're dismissing a study that disagrees with you on the grounds it might be biased. Not trying to find out whether it is biased, you're just assuming it is. Look, there's me considering that it might be biased. The study we are discussing might be biased.

Turnabout is fair play; can you consider that it might not be? Can you say "The study might not be biased?"

And, really, the fact that you consider Hussein comparable to the Coalition is absurd. He was a tyrant, a despot, an oppressor, and he had a silly beard when they found him.
 
Why is it a loaded question? Americans generally appear to be of the view that it is moral to invade someone else's country and murder thousands of people.
Murder requires deliberately attempting to kill people with malice aforethought. Killing civilians by accident in a war is not murder. Deliberately targeting civilians, like Osama did on 9/11 and Islamic extremists do every day is murder. Flying a plane into the Twin Towers was an act of war. What do you think the US should've done, pray tell? Smacked Osama on the back of a wrist with a ruler?

Is that the case with you? Do you think it would be morally OK for another country to invade America (or whatever country you come from) and kill thousands or millions of people?
Depends. Did America support terrorists who killed thousands of people?

Feel free to answer more broadly if you think those exact words are somehow leading or whatever. What position do you hold on the morality of invading a country and killing thousands of people?
Do you really want us to get into WW2 comparisons here? Because that is really all it takes. I also note that you're rather vague on whether these folks are combatants or not.

Why is that a hard question that you cannot answer because "I'm not stupid"?
He refused to answer because he felt it was loaded.
 
Recognizing the inherent right of individual or collective self-defence in accordance with the Charter...

OK so what you are showing is that you have no idea what you are talking about here. Is this the first time you've ever read a UN SC resolution? You heard from somewhere the war was legal - presumably the never lies ever at all US government, which certainly isn't a biased source - so you assumed it must be true. Then what? You Googled those UN SC resolutions and slapped them down without reading any to shut me up? So three of four dated after the invasion which makes you look like a prize fool for quoting them as resolutions permitting the invasion. It's clear you are out of your depth but you soldier on.

So instead of asking you why you think the stuff you quoted says that the UN SC permitted the invasion let me ask you a more open question.

What in YOUR opinion (hint: I already gave the correct answer on the previous page) is the means by which you can tell if a UN SC resolution is actually giving its permission for an invasion and not just mouthing off platitudes with no force or meaning in law?
 
Maybe I should turn your question back to you David.

Do you think the Canadian, Mexican and US governments are responsible for whatever crime the American Natives commit, have committed, and will commit, since their lands have illegally been taken from them centuries ago?
 
I reject your axiom full stop.

Do you understand what that word means? You're not just saying that because you're too dogmatic and ill-informed to back down from an argument once you've started for example?

So you are saying that a criminal is NOT necessarily responsible for the reasonably foreseeable results of their criminal actions?

But you cannot explain why you think this way?
 
So three of four dated after the invasion which makes you look like a prize fool for quoting them as resolutions permitting the invasion. It's clear you are out of your depth but you soldier on.

The first resolution allowed the use of force against terrorism and their sponsors. They ask the Afghans to commit to not allowing their country to be used as terrorist training grounds.

The other resolutions recognize the authority of the interim government, which means the UN doesn't recognize the Taliban as a government body, it clearly puts them in the camp of the terrorists, and use of force is allowed to suppress them and remove them, and bring them to justice.
 
So you are saying that a criminal is NOT necessarily responsible for the reasonably foreseeable results of their criminal actions?

A criminal is not responsible for the crimes of other criminals.

Each person is responsible for their own actions.

Even if the Coalition was a criminal organization, which it's not, the Taliban are responsible for the deaths they cause.
 
I suspect the context of my own comment is worth reproducing:




So you are seeking to justify the invasion on the basis of events that happened as a result of and chronologically after the invasion? Does that really make sense to you? Or perhaps we're using different definitions of "good guys". You didn't specify so I am going off the most obvious definition, namely the innocent party, the defenders, the people who are NOT war criminals, the ones who got attacked not the ones who attacked, the ones just seeking to defend themselves and their families as opposed to people who flew across the world to carry death to innocents who had never attacked anyone and had no means to do so. Were you using some other definition?
One much less specific, yes; people who are morally justified in their actions. As opposed to bad guys, who are people who are morally unjustified. The Coalition did not fly across the world to kill civilians. It seeks to reduce harm to civilians wherever possible, but mistakes happen in a war. The Taliban, by contrast, actively targets civilians.

It's also ironic that you specifically mention flying across the world to attack innocents, and that exactly fits the description of 9/11.

The USA started it and you can't justify an action by stuff that happens after the action.
Al Qaeda started it with 911.

Well first of all it's only a "provocation" if other significant events didn't precede it.
False. If a bully has been bothering a child for weeks, and teases his victim into hitting him, was he not provoked? In fact, I'd be very surprised if you could find a single dictionary that supports your claim that a provocation has to be the first event of its kind.

http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/provoke
http://www.thefreedictionary.com/provoke
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/provoke
http://www.macmillandictionary.com/dictionary/british/provoke
http://thinkexist.com/dictionary/meaning/provoke/

Are you saying that you know of no events prior to 9-11 that might be characterised as on-going war between the US and Al Qaeda?
Conflict, yes. Full blown capital letters there'll be a quiz in the history books War, no.

Secondly if it was a provocation it wasn't enacted by the government or people of Afghanistan so you know, bombing the **** out of group A because you think group B did something is not logical is it?
The Taliban supported Osama and Al Qaeda. They actively hired Al Qaeda members as enforcers.

Thirdly if it was a provocation and was by Afghanistan it still would be criminal act to respond with an invasion. it would still be a war crime, a breach of Nuremburg and the UN Charter. That's because (1) the action was no on-going so there's no question of self-defence and (2) the response was super ridiculously far out of proportion to the alleged provocation.
I don't see how that follows. Where does the UN say a response has to be "proportional", or needs to be "on-going"? The US acted to end a proven and known threat to its people and parcel. Should the US have said "well, it's not an ongoing threat, so that's all right, then?" You said it yourself; 9/11 wasn't the first time Al Qaeda had clashed with the US. Even after the war, they were still planning to strike at the US, ten years on.

So you've never read either one then. OK. Well there's this thing called Google that you can use to find them both.
Nice try. When you make a claim, you present evidence. This is a skeptics' forum. Asking you to present evidence is not a sign of ignorance.

As I recall, Afghanistan under the Taliban didn't actually give two craps about the UN. Otherwise they'd probably have had a word with them about the human rights violations, and did in fact condemn them. They also said that Bin Laden needed to be turned over to the US for the 1998 embassy bombing.

On 8 December, by resolution 1214 (1998), the Council demanded that the Taliban stop providing sanctuary and training for international terrorists and their organizations and that all Afghan factions cooperate in bringing indicted terrorists to justice.
We all know that didn't happen.

And here's the Nuremburg Principles. They are law btw, as is the UN charter.
Let me guess. You're going to assert that the actions of the Coalition were war crimes, because the NP says they were war crimes, but you are not going to be more specific. I can't find anyone else endorsing this viewpoint except far-far-left blogs.

Of course it does. They are war criminals. Being a war criminal makes you a worse person.
The Taliban are war criminals. In fact, they have committed many, many more crimes. Including deliberately targeting civilians. 8-year old girl. Tricked into being a human bomb.

Defending yourself is not against the law. It is not immoral and on the contrary is praiseworthy and honorable.
So it's "praiseworthy and honorable" to trick children into being bombers and to deliberately target civilians who have nothing to do with the Coalition?

In addition it is axiomatic that anyone who pursues a criminal action is responsible for all the reasonably foreseeable harm that comes from that criminal action. Therefore the US is responsible for 100% of the deaths and all other damage harm and injuries taking place in Afghanistan as a result of its war.
So the Taliban is not responsible for any of the innocents they choose to murder, and it's all the big bad Americans' fault for invading the country because this was a "reasonable consequence".

I would argue that this was not reasonable. Attacking innocent civilians, and using kids to do so, are the actions of lunatics and fanatics, not reasonable men.

Also: There is something wrong with you.

Good day.
 
Last edited:
Defending ourselves is what we did by ousting the Taliban and destroying AQ in Afghanistan.
 
Called out for an obvious lie, the dogmatic ideologue can do nothing but double down and continue the lie insisting again and again that they are in the right. Would you describe yourself as a dogmatic ideologue because you are doubling down on an obvious lie here.

You must be projecting. Since you're a Communist. Communists wrote the book on being a dogmatic ideologue, not to mention being the greatest mass murderers in human history.

Which is interesting in itself, someone who identifies with an ideology responsible for the deaths of a hundred million innocent people complaining about civilian casualties.
 
Last edited:
You must be projecting. Since you're a Communist. Communists wrote the book on being a dogmatic ideologue, not to mention being the greatest mass murderers in human history.

One can see why he's so adamant to protect and justify the Taliban and their savagery.
 
Al-Qaeda and the Taliban started it.

Your lies won't work here.
I don't think "lies" are the right word here. He seems more akin to a Truther and their usual cognitive dissonance, their Very Special Dictionaries, such as his definition of "provoke".
 
BTW David, if the Coalition is responsible for the Taliban attacks, isn't the USSR responsible for creating the Taliban to begin with? After all, there wouldn't have been any Mujahideen fighting the Soviets if they hadn't invaded Afghanistan illegally in the first place.

So by your own axiom, the USSR is 100% responsible for whatever happened after their invasion.
 
Speaking of the UN, here are UN Security Council resolutions 1368, 1378, 1383, 1386, which condemned the 9/11 attacks, their perpetrators and their supporters in Afghanistan, and which allowed the use of force to remove them.
:blush:

Can I marry you?

There is another possibility. JihadJane could be playing Devil's Advocate by posting things that are 90 degrees on the belief systems of the majority of the other posters. Just a possibility, to which I am probably wrong...
There has been no indication of such. She gives every indication of honestly believing what she's saying. Which is somewhat terrifying.
 
BTW David, if the Coalition is responsible for the Taliban attacks, isn't the USSR responsible for creating the Taliban to begin with? After all, there wouldn't have been any Mujahideen fighting the Soviets if they hadn't invaded Afghanistan illegally in the first place.

So by your own axiom, the USSR is 100% responsible for whatever happened after their invasion.

Which means, what, Marx is responsible for the USSR? And The Russian Royal family for the Russian Revolution? Heck, let's just go all the way back; why did that jerk Adam eat the apple? Why did God create him if he was responsible? God was responsible for it! Put him on trial!

In al seriousness, isn't it odd how David's responsibility chain starts after 9/11 when he himself pointed out the US and AQ were in conflict before 9/11? In fact, it's a chain with only one link; the Coalition invasion of Iraq. He doesn't want to talk about 9/11, or the fact that the Taliban is deliberately killing civvies and the Coalition are not. In fact, 9/11 fits his description of "bad guys" almost exactly.

Or perhaps we're using different definitions of "good guys". You didn't specify so I am going off the most obvious definition, namely the innocent party, the defenders, the people who are NOT war criminals, the ones who got attacked not the ones who attacked, the ones just seeking to defend themselves and their families as opposed to people who flew across the world to carry death to innocents who had never attacked anyone and had no means to do so. Were you using some other definition?
It's still kind of sad that he's insisting deliberatly bombing innocents is a defensive action against the Coalition. I mean, by that logic, the civilians would be justified in bombing the insurgents. Or, heck, even the US, which would provide an interesting logic bomb for he, Jane, and their apologist ilk when they try to say the US using suicide bombers is wrong but the Taliban doing it is right. Come to think, I don't recall whether either has actually decried AQ's actions on 9/11, only ignored it or tried to talk around it.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom