Terra revolving round Sol question

Sorry, but that still does not address anything about the question. Let me explain: NASA asked the question what Newton(-ian mechanics) would say about a stationary earth in a rotating universe, and assumed Newton(-ian mechanics) would say that such an earth would not bulge.
That's right. If the Earth wasn't rotating, Newtonian mechanics says there's no bulge. If you put the Earth inside a shell of matter, Newtonian gravity says the Earth doesn't feel any resultant gravity. If you then spin the shell, neither say that the Earth bulges.

However, I don't think he/it would say that, because (barring something like sol invictus' super-strong cables solution) Newton(-ian mechanics) would have to posit some way for the universe to freely rotate around the earth that is itself consistent with Newtonian mechanics. This would result in some set of fictitious forces that would necessarily behave exactly like the fictitious forces that arise in a rotating reference frame. This would then necessarily subject the mass of the earth to internal stresses that would cause it to bulge.
You don't need a universe, just a shell of matter. Or even just a ring. In Newtonian mechanics all the forces are on the ring, and in Newtonian gravity the Earth is unaffected. You have to go to "GEM", which was Heaviside's extension to start predicting an effect. See gravitomagnetism on wiki for that. But take a bit of care, it says "a moving electric charge creates a magnetic field" which is wrong because it's the electromagnetic field and we can move at different speeds through it. Plus it gives a fluid analogy rather than the rubber analogy. And the important thing is that The main consequence of the gravitomagnetic force, or acceleration, is that a free-falling object near a massive rotating object will itself rotate. That's because it's "twisted space". If you flew through space twisted like this, you find yourself turning. And if you had a rubber Earth in that NASA image, the twist reduces the equatorial diameter rather than increasing it. At least I think so, but I'm happy to stand corrected on that.
 
That's right. If the Earth wasn't rotating, Newtonian mechanics says there's no bulge. If you put the Earth inside a shell of matter, Newtonian gravity says the Earth doesn't feel any resultant gravity. If you then spin the shell, neither say that the Earth bulges.

You don't need a universe, just a shell of matter. Or even just a ring. In Newtonian mechanics all the forces are on the ring, and in Newtonian gravity the Earth is unaffected.
Am I really making my point that badly?
My point is that there is not such a shell or ring that can carry loads or provide a centripetal force across the orbit around the earth.
It's just loose stars and planets and gravity, so if Newtonians have to say whether the universe as we observe it rotating around the earth would make it bulge at the equator, then I think the answer is yes, because there would need to be some universal force on the stars to keep them in orbit around the earth.
To be consistent with Newtonian mechanics, this force must work exactly like the centrifugal force that arises in rotating formulations of Newtonian mechanics (only in the other direction), and it will not work on the mass of the earth, because it is not rotating in this example, and will therefore cause it to bulge.

Also, I'd like to point out that we're arguing over what is basically a marginal objection to NASA's article by a stubborn "professional Newtonian".
 
Last edited:
Am I really making my point that badly?

Before you blame yourself, I might suggest wandering over to any of the other recent Farsight threads (Black Holes, Relativity+ are long ones; Nuclear Strong Force Is A Fiction, though short, was the last straw for me) to see how many gallons of perfectly-clear physics explanations have vanished down Farsight's voluminous drains.
 
To be honest, I'm getting tired of talking about it.
I don't blame you. It must be quite tedious for you at his point. I guess my asking for confirmation of this aspect of GR so many times and in so many ways is because it is the most remarkable and counterintuitive thing I have ever encountered in science. In any case, I think it will remain difficult to accept until I can understand the underlying mathematical basis for myself -- if I am ever able to do so.

There are two separate issues.

(a) Are we allowed to label the coordinates of everything in the Universe in just such a way that your top's coordinates are constants, like an object sitting still, rather than rotating? Yes we are. If we do so, do the relabeled-laws-of-physics still predict that the top stays upright, gyroscope-style? Yes they do; the relabeled laws of physics include centripetal and Coriolis forces which indeed account for the stable angle between your top and the Earth.

(b) "Well," you say, "I don't wanna deal with centripetal and Coriolis forces. I want to just look at the distant stars, pick a coordinate system in which those stars are at rest, and declare myself finished with wacky coordinates, can't I do that?" No you can't. In the presence of gravitomagnetic effects, centripetal and Coriolis forces are still there in the coordinate system in which distant stars are at rest. In the presence of gravitomagnetic effects, to find a centripetal-force-free coordinate system, you have to pick one where the distant stars are rotating.

(c) Suppose you are locked in a room with your spinning top. You've waved your arms around and determined that the room is feeling no centripetal forces. But you can't look at the mass distribution around you. Can you predict, based on this information, whether the stars are sweeping past your window (as though you were rotating) or not (as though you were still)? No you can't---a nearby spinning mass, shell-like or otherwise, would make you make the wrong prediction.

(d) You're not in a windowless room. Look into space. Is there actually a huge shell of matter out there, spinning? No. (Well, there could be one beyond the observable horizon.) Therefore there is no gravitomagnetic source-current that would make you spin. So don't worry about it.
That's very helpful, thanks.
 
Last edited:
You can tell it's got a mass because you fall down.
Or does the mass fall up to you? When two things concurrently fall down from opposite sides of the mass towards it’s centre is the mass actually falling up to both of them? Does that mean the mass expands?

When two things move toward a third thing at different speeds how does that third thing alternatively move toward the two things concurrently at different speeds?
 
Last edited:
ben m
Are we allowed to label the coordinates of everything in the Universe in just such a way that your top's coordinates are constants, like an object sitting still, rather than rotating? Yes we are. If we do so, do the relabeled-laws-of-physics still predict that the top stays upright, gyroscope-style? Yes they do; the relabeled laws of physics include centripetal and Coriolis forces which indeed account for the stable angle between your top and the Earth.

In my recent review of the properties of tensors, my studies have revealed that a tensor equation holds true regardless of any transformation of coordinate system (I am currently trying to learn something about the mathematics of this stuff). So, when I look at

[latex]R_\mu_\nu - \dfrac{1}{2}g_\mu_\nu R + g_\mu_\nu \Lambda = \dfrac{8\pi G}{c^4}T_\mu_\nu[/latex]

and imagine a change in frame of reference on the left side of the equation (of the metric tensor), I see that things have to change in the stress energy tensor, for the equation to hold. Is it these changes to [latex]T_\mu_\nu[/latex] that result in these "centripetal and Coriolis forces"?
 
H'ethetheth said:
Am I really making my point that badly?
There's obviously some kind of problem, sorry if it's me. Ben's unhappy bcause he and his friends peddle woo and I call them out. On the black hole thread they were trying to say space is infalling in a gravitational field, which is total trash.

H'ethetheth said:
My point is that there is not such a shell or ring that can carry loads or provide a centripetal force across the orbit around the earth.
It's just loose stars and planets and gravity...
OK. And there's nothing that can keep some distant massive star moving in a circular orbit around the Earth. The Earth's gravitational field isn't up to the job.

H'ethetheth said:
...so if Newtonians have to say whether the universe as we observe it rotating around the earth would make it bulge at the equator, then I think the answer is yes, because there would need to be some universal force on the stars to keep them in orbit around the earth.
The Newtonians wouldn't entertain this for a moment. They'd point to one distant massive star and say it's moving at a ridiculous speed, and the force required to keep it going round in a circle would have to be matched by an equal and opposite and force on the Earth. Then they'd point to all the other distant massive stars, and tell you this: the forces on the Earth wouldn't make the equator bulge, they'd pull it to bits in an instant.

H'ethetheth said:
To be consistent with Newtonian mechanics, this force must work exactly like the centrifugal force that arises in rotating formulations of Newtonian mechanics (only in the other direction), and it will not work on the mass of the earth, because it is not rotating in this example, and will therefore cause it to bulge.
Sure. I note Sol's cables, but he didn't spell out the upshot. It would be something like a bicycle wheel where you cut off the rim and solder a big lead weight on to each of the spokes. Then you cut out the hub and replace it with a ball of sand. Then you try spinning the thing.
 
OK. And there's nothing that can keep some distant massive star moving in a circular orbit around the Earth. The Earth's gravitational field isn't up to the job.
So far, so good.

The Newtonians wouldn't entertain this for a moment. They'd point to one distant massive star and say it's moving at a ridiculous speed, and the force required to keep it going round in a circle would have to be matched by an equal and opposite and force on the Earth.
No it wouldn't, because if they carefully observe the heavenly bodies, they will see that the mystery centripetal force on the bodies is proportional (among other things) to their distance from the rotational axis of the universe. Since this axis pierces the earth, the mass of the earth experiences relatively little of this mystery force.

What they could also do is analyze this whole thing in a frame of reference rotating with the universe, and they will find that the mystery force precisely cancels out the centrifugal force, leaving only the elasticity of the earth to provide the centripetal force on the (now rotating) earth's mass, thereby making it bulge at the equator.

Sure. I note Sol's cables, but he didn't spell out the upshot. It would be something like a bicycle wheel where you cut off the rim and solder a big lead weight on to each of the spokes. Then you cut out the hub and replace it with a ball of sand. Then you try spinning the thing.
Forget sol's cables. They are not part of the hypothetical observed universe I'm talking about.
 
Ben's unhappy bcause he and his friends peddle woo and I call them out.

Just to be clear here, when you say "he and his friends", you would include people like Robert Wald, or Charles Misner, Kip Thorne, and John Wheeler, right? And when you say they "peddle woo", you are referring to the interpretation of General Relativity offered in widely used textbooks such as Wald's General Relativity or Misner, Thorne, and Wheeler's Gravitation. Is that correct?

These are among the people who have failed to properly understand Einstein's theory, yes?
 
There's obviously some kind of problem, sorry if it's me. Ben's unhappy bcause he and his friends peddle woo and I call them out. On the black hole thread they were trying to say space is infalling in a gravitational field, which is total trash.
The fact is you've been shown to be incorrect in your understanding of general relativity. You've even been shown to be wrong about fairly basic geometry of curved spaces, let alone GR. You don't seem to have recognised that and learnt from the errors however.

Some analogies may not be perfect, but sol for example was perfectly happy to give more detail on the nature of the waterfall analogy and be quite explicit about what physics it was intended to elucidate and how it did so, if I recall correctly.

They'd point to one distant massive star and say it's moving at a ridiculous speed, and the force required to keep it going round in a circle would have to be matched by an equal and opposite and force on the Earth. Then they'd point to all the other distant massive stars, and tell you this: the forces on the Earth wouldn't make the equator bulge, they'd pull it to bits in an instant.
This is a strange thing to say. It's coming through perfectly loud and clear from those on that side of the argument that choosing a new coordinate system has no physical effects. How could you possibly come up with the idea that they would come up with a prediction that the Earth would be torn to bits?
 
The fact is you've been shown to be incorrect in your understanding of general relativity. You've even been shown to be wrong about fairly basic geometry of curved spaces, let alone GR. You don't seem to have recognised that and learnt from the errors however.
In your dreams. I haven't been shown to be incorrect at all.

Some analogies may not be perfect, but sol for example was perfectly happy to give more detail on the nature of the waterfall analogy and be quite explicit about what physics it was intended to elucidate and how it did so, if I recall correctly.
He was peddling woo. Space is not falling inwards in a gravitational field. It's garbage

This is a strange thing to say. It's coming through perfectly loud and clear from those on that side of the argument that choosing a new coordinate system has no physical effects. How could you possibly come up with the idea that they would come up with a prediction that the Earth would be torn to bits?
It's not a strange thing to say at all. Go check up on Newton's laws of motion, and pick one massive star. Note the first law: The velocity of a body remains constant unless the body is acted upon by an external force. That star is supposed to be rotating around the Earth, and it is massive. Now note the third law: The mutual forces of action and reaction between two bodies are equal, opposite and collinear. And then add another star to the mix, and another, and another.
 
In your dreams. I haven't been shown to be incorrect at all.
The thread is there for all to read. I'll just let people 'do their own research' on it, as you're fond of saying.

It's not a strange thing to say at all. Go check up on Newton's laws of motion, and pick one massive star. Note the first law: The velocity of a body remains constant unless the body is acted upon by an external force. That star is supposed to be rotating around the Earth, and it is massive. Now note the third law: The mutual forces of action and reaction between two bodies are equal, opposite and collinear. And then add another star to the mix, and another, and another.

Actually I misunderstood what you were trying to say there. Apologies.

I'm not sure I do understand what you are trying to say there but never mind. It certainly wasn't as I originally misread it.
 
It's not a strange thing to say at all. Go check up on Newton's laws of motion, and pick one massive star. Note the first law: The velocity of a body remains constant unless the body is acted upon by an external force. That star is supposed to be rotating around the Earth, and it is massive. Now note the third law: The mutual forces of action and reaction between two bodies are equal, opposite and collinear. And then add another star to the mix, and another, and another.

I presume you mean looking at the effect that the gravitational "pull" of surrounding stars has on the Earth itself?

So as you add more stars in a homogenous (or isotropic) universe the net effect would be?

Additionally what is the numerical value of these forces? Large or small?
 
No it wouldn't, because if they carefully observe the heavenly bodies, they will see that the mystery centripetal force on the bodies is proportional (among other things) to their distance from the rotational axis of the universe. Since this axis pierces the earth, the mass of the earth experiences relatively little of this mystery force.
They wouldn't think of it as a mystery force, they'd call it the force of gravity. They'd be familiar with heavenly bodies rotating about their common centre of mass, and if they carefully observe the heavenly bodies they know about the rotation of Jupiter's moon's. Maybe they'd be familiar with galactic rotation. A galaxy rotates in about 15 million years, so they'd small a rat with rotation every 24 hours. The force of gravity would have to be millions of times bigger to maintain the rotation.

What they could also do is analyze this whole thing in a frame of reference rotating with the universe, and they will find that the mystery force precisely cancels out the centrifugal force, leaving only the elasticity of the earth to provide the centripetal force on the (now rotating) earth's mass, thereby making it bulge at the equator.
I'm not clear what you mean there. If the Earth is now rotating they're back to standard Newtonian mechanics, and saying the Earth has an equatorial bulge because of the laws of motion. There's a "fictitious" force in the Coriolis effect, but that's just plain-a-day roundabout inertia, and they aren't using Mach's principle because it isn't part of Newtonian mechanics. It isn't part of relativity either. E doesn't equal mc² because of all the other mass in the universe, it's because of the energy-momentum there in front of you. Yes in the wikipedia article there's a section on Modern General Relativity along with a reference to the Lense-Thirring effect, but note the quote that says "If one rotates [a heavy shell of matter] relative to the fixed stars about an axis going through its center, a Coriolis force arises in the interior of the shell; that is, the plane of a Foucault pendulum is dragged around". This is what Gravity Probe B detected and it's incredibly weak. It isn't the thing that makes the Earth oblate.

Forget sol's cables. They are not part of the hypothetical observed universe I'm talking about.
OK.
 
Actually I misunderstood what you were trying to say there. Apologies.
Apology accepted. I'm sorry that I didn't twig that H'ethetheth was talking about heavenly bodies rotating like a galaxy with the Earth in the middle.
 
They wouldn't think of it as a mystery force, they'd call it the force of gravity.
No they wouldn't. When they look carefully at the planets, they see that the planets influence each other at a distance through a force that decreases with the square of their respective distances and their masses in addition to a force that increases proportionally to the distance from the universal axis.

They'd be familiar with heavenly bodies rotating about their common centre of mass, and if they carefully observe the heavenly bodies they know about the rotation of Jupiter's moon's. Maybe they'd be familiar with galactic rotation. A galaxy rotates in about 15 million years, so they'd small a rat with rotation every 24 hours. The force of gravity would have to be millions of times bigger to maintain the rotation.
So that's why gravity can't be the mystery force.

I'm not clear what you mean there. If the Earth is now rotating they're back to standard Newtonian mechanics,...
No, not quite. We're analyzing our rotating universe in a rotating frame of reference. That's not an inertial frame of reference.
 
I presume you mean looking at the effect that the gravitational "pull" of surrounding stars has on the Earth itself?

So as you add more stars in a homogenous (or isotropic) universe the net effect would be?
Nil. There would be no net pull.

Additionally what is the numerical value of these forces? Large or small?
Zero. Sorry, H'ethetheth's equatorial bulge and sol's cables had me thinking tetherball rather than rotating galaxy.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom