TheTelekinesiologist,
I see a problem with your methods, as described. Allow me to explain.
If I put a piece of paper on a pin in a room, and don't try to do anything special, just sit there and watch it, it just kind of spins back and forth.
Now, suppose I randomly wrote down on a padr a series of "lefts" and "rights". Now, I sit there and just watch the paper, again not trying to do anything with my mind. Suppose the first thing on the pad is "left". Well, sooner or later the paper will spin left. Then, say the next thing on the pad was left. Well, if the paper keeps spinning, I will say what is written on the pad matches what happened. Suppose the paper stopped spinning, but then started spinning to the left. Again, a hit. Suppose it starts turning to the right, but then goes back to the left. Once again, a hit.
And that's a problem. You can sort of talk yourself into almost any behavior being a hit. Not ANYTHING, but just about, if you see what I mean.
Then you have other ways of fooling yourself. Suppose it is spinning to the left, and you notice it is slowing down. So you think to yourself, "okay, maybe it is time to make it spin to the right". Well, it's slowing down because there is air convection that is pushing it the other way, so, it is almost probably going to go right. I'm not saying you are doing this consciously. Think about it - you do best when you are tired and half asleep, when you are almost in a dream state.
Another thing is that you are sitting there and watching the paper, and can get a feel for patterns. For example, if it has been spinning left for 10 seconds, and that is a long time for it to go in a single direction, you will probably decide to try to make it go right. And it will probably go right anyway, all on it's own, because so much time has gone by.
Again, I'm not accusing you of cheating, but pointing out how our normal skills of pattern recognition would lead you to correctly predict the movement of the paper much better than you think you could.
Now, a way to fix this is to write down on a pad of paper what you are going to do ahead of time. IE: 30 seconds spin left, 30 seconds spin right, 30 seconds no movement. You have to define what will contitute a success or failure. - If the paper normally wavers back and forth every 5 seconds then of course you will see it go left at somepoint in that 30 seconds, and you are guaranteed a 'hit' just from random movements from the paper. So, account for that.
Finally, run some sessions where you aren't trying to control it using the test above, and record the result. Just let the normal room air currents move the paper around.Then, do the tests again where you try to influence the paper with your mind. Do it several times each way, and try to have everything the same - same time of day, heat turned to the same level, etc.
Let us know what you find out. I think you will learn a lot about how we are fooled by the pattern recognition pathways in our brain.