Summary of WTC tower collapses

People the structure only provided 36 percent resistance, actually less so that leaves 64 percent before collapse arrest was possible and that is by Chandler's physics.

Actually the resistance remained the same, while the energy from momentum increased with each strike.

not stated properly... you can't increase energy... each released floor had stored potential energy... and that became kinetic energy... adding to that of the already dropping mass.
 
PE is a set quantity. mgh
It doesnt increase or decrease (assuming h remains constant)

When the balance of forces is no longer in effect, when a mass begins falling, that PE converts to KE at the rate of g.
 
The average acceleration turns out to have been roughly 2/3 of g.
Of what? If you mean the collapse front, that does not sound right. Acceleration decreased to zero (if we're to accept the measurements of femr2/achimspok/etc., which I have no problem in accepting a priori). To me that indicates that air friction induced a terminal velocity.

I'm only nitpicking on that because your wording suggests you're not talking about a theoretical simplified model but about what happened in reality.
 
NOOOOOOOO it doesn't increase... the total stored PE (gravitational) energy is converted into kinetic (f=ma) energy... it doesn't increase nor decrease...
I think that GlennB's point is that it doesn't start to convert into KE until it's released, therefore that energy is not "available" up until that point. It's not a rigorous explanation but from the point of view of what contributed to the collapse, a floor doesn't contribute until it is detached.
 
These "energy" discussions are pointless really...

JayDee's summary doesn't need to address quantities of energy. This is not necessary to conceptualize what happened.
 
NOOOOOOOO it doesn't increase... the total stored PE (gravitational) energy is converted into kinetic (f=ma) energy... it doesn't increase nor decrease...

:rolleyes: If you wish. It won't help kjr63 to understand though.

The whole point is that each floor that yields adds to the destructive potential of the collapse, and that's what we were discussing.

p.s. KE isn't quantified as f=ma, that describes a force. KE is 1/2mv2
[/nitpick]
 
Last edited:
:rolleyes: If you wish. It won't help kjr63 to understand though.

The whole point is that each floor that yields adds to the destructive potential of the collapse, and that's what we were discussing.

p.s. KE isn't quantified as f=ma, that describes a force. KE is 1/2mv2
[/nitpick]

As long as we stay in high school physcis, i understand quite well. These floors cannot add anything to the destructive force. Each collision is a loss of kinetic energy.
 
As long as we stay in high school physcis, i understand quite well. These floors cannot add anything to the destructive force. Each collision is a loss of kinetic energy.

Apart from the energy added by their mass.
 
As long as we stay in high school physcis, i understand quite well. These floors cannot add anything to the destructive force. Each collision is a loss of kinetic energy.

For the original impacting body alone, yes, this is true. But if a new 'body' (the impacted floor) is released to fall then as long as the original body also continues to fall - as it clearly did - the total kinetic energy of the falling body (now enlarged by one floor's worth of mass releasing its potential energy) increases.

But I've already said this.
 
Last edited:
Yes, but minus the loss of speed when colliding with these all kind of structures below.

This has been addressed a couple of times already and you've ignored it.

The original speed of the collapsing mass was 0 mph. If, having slowed at impact, it moves on at 1 mph then that makes things *worse* for the building in terms of collapse arrest.
 
Last edited:
Yes, but minus the loss of speed when colliding with these all kind of structures below.

How much speed?
We are right back where you started?
How much resistance did each floor offer?
 
This has been addressed a couple of times already and you've ignored it.

The original speed of the collapsing mass was 0 mph. If, having slowed at impact, it moves on at 1 mph then that makes things *worse* for the building in terms of collapse arrest.

I don't understand what you are saying? You mean that when the upper block hits the lower floor and they get stuck together, the speed of the floor increases?
 
Oystein, perhaps it more like jogging and every 10 feet you must break through a paper wall.

That would be a different analogy.

It's difficult for many people to properly think about and visualize acceleration - it's a second derivative.
It's easier to think about velocities.

The actual situation is: Long bouts of small, positive acceleration (2nd derivative of distance) interruped by short burst of large, negative acceleration. Result: Velocity (1st derivative of distance) goes down, but not all the way back to the initial velocity (say, 0).

My analogy takes this down one level of derivatives: Long bouts of small, positive velocity (1st derivative of distance) interruped by short burst of large, negative velocity. Result: Distance (0th derivative of distance) goes down, but not all the way back to the starting line.
 
Of what? If you mean the collapse front, that does not sound right. Acceleration decreased to zero (if we're to accept the measurements of femr2/achimspok/etc., which I have no problem in accepting a priori). To me that indicates that air friction induced a terminal velocity.

I'm only nitpicking on that because your wording suggests you're not talking about a theoretical simplified model but about what happened in reality.

I am not sure I ever actually saw femr2's/achimspok's work on that - and who would be "etc."? I tend to doubt their terminal velocity is real.
I would, if any empirical work, be going with David Chandler's measurement of the first 3 or 4 seconds or so of collapse, which happens to be in the ball park of theoretical considerations of CoM-only.
 
I don't understand what you are saying? You mean that when the upper block hits the lower floor and they get stuck together, the speed of the floor increases?

No, he means the top was not moving before it started to fall. It started at 0 and it smashed the floor it hit.
That means it was already moving when it started to fall towards the next floor and the next etc.
If it could smash through a floor when it started from rest then it could certainly smash the next floor when it was already moving and had the mass of the floors it already smashed added to it.
 
No, he means the top was not moving before it started to fall. It started at 0 and it smashed the floor it hit.
That means it was already moving when it started to fall towards the next floor and the next etc.
If it could smash through a floor when it started from rest then it could certainly smash the next floor when it was already moving and had the mass of the floors it already smashed added to it.

Ok. But it gained the KE from the demolished structures what fire and the planes caused. The structures below were not like that. The top could not increase it's KE while smashing structures into pieces. That work is done by losing speed and KE.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom