Summary of WTC tower collapses

FF.. My credentials in these issues don't matter.

I am a practicing architect.
I worked for the architects of the WTC in 1970
I do no design high rise buildings
I have been in the twin towers scores of times
I have worked with Ed DiPaola's engineering firm Severud (structural engineers) who visited the site post collapse and wrote after reports
I have worked with Guy Nordenson who also wrote a brief in support of a lawsuit alleging there were design flaws in WTC7.
I have been associated with AE911T for less than 6 months beginning in Fall '09 and was appointed to their board. I was tossed out because I was seeking the truth not interested in promoting the bullet points and incorrect points in their Blueprint for Truth and that nano thermite was responsible for the collapse.
I have attended numerous Truth events, communicated with several present and former truthers such as Harrit and Gordon Ross.
I have produced scores of my own graphics about the WTC collapses
I don't publish nor speak at conferences about 911.
I am just a dumb old architect

I am convinced that there was no CD and the collapses were caused by mechanical damage and uncontrolled fires.
 
..until all gravitational energy is consumed. After about 10 floors.

No, because each lower floor that is "broken" also releases the potential energy of that floor. The total gravitational energy (as you put it) doesn't decrease with every impact, it increases.
 
No, because each lower floor that is "broken" also releases the potential energy of that floor. The total gravitational energy (as you put it) doesn't decrease with every impact, it increases.

Velocity is more significant to energy than mass.
 
Velocity is more significant to energy than mass.

That's meaningless, and also doesn't address the point about new PE being released with each floor that is detached.
 
Last edited:
If a mass hits solid structure, it loses a lot of speed.

How much speed was lost by the falling mass of WTC1 or 2 whrn it hit the floor below?
Would a floor in a a WCT tower be able to support the weight of 20+ floors even if they stopped moving? gravity would syill be acting.

Show your work?
 
Velocity drop or velocity is meaningless?

If a mass hits solid structure, it loses a lot of speed.

Saying that velocity is more important than mass is meaningless, as is "loses a lot of speed". It depends. What'll smash your windscreen, a bug at 70mph or a rock at 10mph?

And you've evaded, again, the point that each intact floor has its own PE and that *adds* to the KE of the falling mass when it's released.
 
PE adds to KE, but hardly more than the loss of speed decreases it. And the only destructive force here is the KE.
 
Last edited:
PE adds to KE, but hardly more than the loss of speed decreases it. And the only destructive force here is the KE.

If the original falling section started at 0mph and proceeds from the first impact at 1mph then things just got worse for the prospect of collapse arrest, didn't they? In two ways, in fact: the velocity of the next one-storey fall has started from > 0mph and there is now a greater mass.
 
No, because each lower floor that is "broken" also releases the potential energy of that floor. The total gravitational energy (as you put it) doesn't decrease with every impact, it increases.

NOOOOOOOO it doesn't increase... the total stored PE (gravitational) energy is converted into kinetic (f=ma) energy... it doesn't increase nor decrease...
 
NOOOOOOOO it doesn't increase... the total stored PE (gravitational) energy is converted into kinetic (f=ma) energy... it doesn't increase nor decrease...

You are saying the floors that are broken will float in air JSO?
How is that possible?
 
People the structure only provided 36 percent resistance, actually less so that leaves 64 percent before collapse arrest was possible and that is by Chandler's physics.

Actually the resistance remained the same, while the energy from momentum increased with each strike.
 
Back on topic, I plan on posting revision 3 on Tuesday. There will be few changes. I am fairly confident that it will be the final draft.

Of course adding detail would be possible. Including differences between tower 1&2 would be possible, however those differences apply only for impact and initiation of collapse.

Such additions would run counter to the intent of a brief summary that applies to both towers.
 
Last edited:
If a mass hits solid structure, it loses a lot of speed.

Each story of the twin towers was 12 feet high, that's 144 inches
4 inches of these 12 feet were floors - 2.8% of the height
140 inches or 97.2% of the height is essentially air (partition walls made of gypsum don't provide much resistance, nor does furniture).

So as the falling rubble descends through the large, open office space (;) to certain friends), it meets practically no resistance and picks up kinetic energy at the rate of gravitational acceleration, or g, through 97% of the way.
Then, for a brief moment, it is decelerated as it crashes through the 3% of the way that are reinforced concrete, at a rate several time g.

The average acceleration turns out to have been roughly 2/3 of g.


It's like you are lightly jogging at 2 yards/second forward for 100 yards (=50 seconds), then racing back at 30 yd/s the other direction for 30 yards (=1 second), then turning again and continuing to jog 2 yd/s.
The short fast spurts in the opposite direction do not take you all the way back to the starting line. They take you back just 30 yards, and slow your average velocity to 70 yards / 51 seconds = 1.37 yd/s, or 69% of your forward jogging speed. You can advance like that forever.
Similarly, the impacts with the floor slabs never subtract as much velocity from the fall as the debris gains by falling unresisted between two floor slabs, and thus you gain velocity slab after slab after slab - because the impacts are too short compared to the freefall phase.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom