Summary of WTC tower collapses

Prove this.
already done... the shallow, aka zero research exposed again.

Go to a library. You offer questions, no evidence, no valid claims.

When will you prove fire did not do it? never (ask questions, and answer them)
 
FalseFlag, I'd still like to hear your reply to my question in post 116. This is not a trick question.
 
Think about what you are saying. If their reports contain errors, or are incomplete, don't you think we need a new investigation?

Second, if they had access to massive amounts of information that the public will never see, what on earth makes you think the explanations given by "internet experts" are better than what NIST gave?

You, in your own words, have proven that there needs to be a real investigation into the collapses of WTC1, WTC2 and WTC7. At the very least, the new investigation needs to start with WTC7. Once we get the results, we can go from there.

I don't object to a new investigation. But it has to be for a good reason. I don't believe incriminating evidence has been withheld nor destroyed. My use of the term "mistakes" may be judgement calls, presumed assumption of fire behavior etc. and collapse hypothesis.

Essentially I believe there are other fire induced progressive collapse scenarios to consider... also speculative based on other assumptions which would lead to a similar outcome... total collapse.

I suspect that NIST make a "mistake" and down played the importance of the structural design as a driver of the collapse... and failed to stress that this building was quite unique in its design.

I would have liked to see the NIST fire assumptions used to model a similar sized building of more traditional design such as One Liberty Plaza from the same era... and see what the outcome is.

It appears that the lessons learned and applied are limited to:

emergency egress paths need to be more robust
fire suppression and fire protection systems need to be more robust
(codes need to reflect these)

I have not proven anything by my words. I expect official reports will always have a CYA aspect to them and rarely report civil or criminal charges be filed using the report findings as evidence.

I suspect this is what the truth movement expects from a new investigation... the uncovering of criminal wrong doing as insider conspiracy of some manner and an insider cover up of same.

My own speculation about 7wtc is that a tower should not have been built over a huge power station relying on massive load transfers and have tens of thousands of gallons of fuel stored on the site and in the building. I suspect the hubris (and greed in some cases) of developers, engineers, building officials and builders contributed to the decision to build over the power station.
 
A car takes off from a full stop and accelerates. Keep the pedal to the metal and it accelerates steadily for, let's say 5 seconds.

Now do the same thing but every five feet it has to punch through a large paper barrier. The act of destroying the paper will take energy from that being used to accelerate the car. However the car never has its acceleration drop to zero.

That is a wrong analogy. Imagine a some sort of brick wall that the car cannot punch through without kinetic energy, like a building can carry all the potential energy when it's standing.

Then let the car accelerate with full force 100 feet before hitting the first wall. It punches through, but loses most of it's speed. It accelerates then 5 feet distance, but cannot punch through many more because it is continiously losing speed, and 5 feet acceleration is not enough to punch through.
 
So, here as in those cases, I am led to ask, what is the point of the question? What difference would it make to you whether AZCat's entire career was designing steel-framed highrises, or being assistant manager at a Baskin-Robbins?

If he was assistant manager at a Baskin-Robbins I would consider him an authority on ice cream. I might ask him for suggestions on a good flavor, but I would not consider him an expert on engineering topics.

If he was an engineer, I would consider him an authority on topics related to engineering. I might ask him for his opinions on engineering topics. If he gave his opinion, and it clearly contradicted basic physics and the opinions of other engineers, I would still consider him an authority but his opinions would have no credibility. I would not ask him for future opinions. I would also consider his presence on a forum such as this highly suspect.

To beat you to your next post - I already said I am not an expert. You should not consider me an authority on engineering issues. What you should do is pay attention to credible engineers, and use your own judgement and understanding of basic physics to know who is right.
 
Last edited:
That is a wrong analogy.
Why did you not address my analogy? I believe it is a correct analogy.

Imagine a some sort of brick wall that the car cannot punch through without kinetic energy, like a building can carry all the potential energy when it's standing.

Then let the car accelerate with full force 100 feet before hitting the first wall. It punches through, but loses most of it's speed. It accelerates then 5 feet distance, but cannot punch through many more because it is continiously losing speed, and 5 feet acceleration is not enough to punch through.

Are you saying the first floor to collapse was 20 times higher than all others below? That would be wrong by a factor of 20 :)
So your analogy is wrong, too. You should have equidistant walls - all 100 feet apart.

If the car can break through the brick wall after acceleration from 0 for 100 feet, AND it has some velocity left, then anothe 100 feet later, it will be faster than it was just before the first wall (because this time it got a running start), and will punch through the second wall more easily, retaining more velocity, and so on. Wall after wall after wall, that car will be faster than it was punching through the wall before.
 
That is a wrong analogy.

Every analogy is wrong to some degree. Some are less wrong than others.

Imagine a some sort of brick wall that the car cannot punch through without kinetic energy, like a building can carry all the potential energy when it's standing.

Then let the car accelerate with full force 100 feet before hitting the first wall. It punches through, but loses most of it's speed. It accelerates then 5 feet distance, but cannot punch through many more because it is continiously losing speed, and 5 feet acceleration is not enough to punch through.

This is known as "pulling numbers out of thin air" (in the more polite form). Why do you arbitrarily choose the numbers you've chosen, and most obviously, why have you chosen to have a much greater distance for the first period of acceleration than all the subsequent ones?

Try modifying your analogy slightly. Suppose the car has thirteen feet in which to accelerate, at which point it hits the first wall, and that the wall is weak enough that the car breaks through it without coming to a stop. It then has another thirteen feet to accelerate, after which it hits another wall. It's going faster this time, because the second thirteen feet of acceleration wasn't from a standing start, so if it slows down the same amount it'll be going faster than it was after hitting the first wall. It should be fairly obvious that, as long as the car gets to accelerate between walls, no number of walls will stop it; it will be going faster and faster after every collision.

Now, which of these analogies is less wrong when applied to a building where the spacing between floors is constant? Yours, where the first spacing is arbitrarily chosen to be twenty times all the others? Or mine, where they're all equal?

That's a rhetorical question, by the way.

Dave
 
Also imagine that the bricks from the first wall are moving with the car adding to its mass when it hits the next wall and so on.
 
That is a wrong analogy. Imagine a some sort of brick wall that the car cannot punch through without kinetic energy, like a building can carry all the potential energy when it's standing.

Then let the car accelerate with full force 100 feet before hitting the first wall. It punches through, but loses most of it's speed. It accelerates then 5 feet distance, but cannot punch through many more because it is continiously losing speed, and 5 feet acceleration is not enough to punch through.

Your analogy goes way too far in the strength of the barrier, mine is way too far in the other direction.

You can see by my analogy that in changing the strength of the barrier, the effect on acceleration can be negligible. In fact unless that barrier is such that it reduces acceleration to ZERO, the vehicle will be accelerating from having gone through each barrier, with an initial non-zero velocity.

v=v0+0.5at
The first acceleration starts with v0=0, next acceleration past first barrier v0>0

"a" only changes during the time the barrier is being destroyed, which is pretty momentarily. After that, between barriers, acceleration is the same as it was initially.

You seem to be having difficulty recognizing the difference between acceleration and velocity and how they are related here.

At each barrier the velocity after destruction of that barrier need not be less than initial impact velocity. It CAN and, in the case of the WTC towers does, accelerate through it. Its that acceleration that is less than at initial impact, slightly less in the case of the towers. (As Oystein points out ~1/23 reduction, since force is directly proportional to acceleration)
 
Last edited:
That is a wrong analogy. Imagine a some sort of brick wall that the car cannot punch through without kinetic energy, like a building can carry all the potential energy when it's standing.

Then let the car accelerate with full force 100 feet before hitting the first wall. It punches through, but loses most of it's speed. It accelerates then 5 feet distance, but cannot punch through many more because it is continiously losing speed, and 5 feet acceleration is not enough to punch through.

The car is not subject to the force of gravity.

Gravity. It's the law! :thumbsup:
 
That is a wrong analogy. Imagine a some sort of brick wall that the car cannot punch through without kinetic energy, like a building can carry all the potential energy when it's standing.

Then let the car accelerate with full force 100 feet before hitting the first wall. It punches through, but loses most of it's speed. It accelerates then 5 feet distance, but cannot punch through many more because it is continiously losing speed, and 5 feet acceleration is not enough to punch through.

For reasons that others have mentioned this is not a suitable analogy. I'm beginning to think that you're not sincere about wanting to debate this issue in a rational manner.
 
That is a wrong analogy. Imagine a some sort of brick wall that the car cannot punch through without kinetic energy, like a building can carry all the potential energy when it's standing.

Then let the car accelerate with full force 100 feet before hitting the first wall. It punches through, but loses most of it's speed. It accelerates then 5 feet distance, but cannot punch through many more because it is continiously losing speed, and 5 feet acceleration is not enough to punch through.
First off, your car most likely does not accelerate at g, a Porsche 911 Carrera S can hit .67 g, there are some which can. We need $$$100,000 or more to do this... the bricks, or what ever mass you hit would then accelerate at the new speed of the car and the bricks based on momentum transfer, and this new mass would continue to accelerate at g...
A car is a bad example, it is not falling. When a car hits something, does the something including stuff ejected then follow the car at g? The WTC is up, and it is falling down, and the earth is driving the collapse at g, and we observe the velocity over time based on momentum transfer.

The WTC is falling down, the acceleration of all the mass is at g.

The WTC falling, when a lower floor fails, the speed is only decreased by the momentum exchange. The data for the fall of the WTC shows it matches the rate of fall of a momentum model. Lost velocity for the first impact; You said 5 percent, not most? Is 5 percent most?

The WTC collapse slowed 5 percent at the first impact going about 7 m/s, but at the next floor the speed was over 10 m/s. Do the math, not what you think will happen, what happens based on physics, not BS. The kinetic energy of the mass at the second impact is twice the kinetic energy of the first impact due to distance falling in a gravity field; the new velocity, and 5 percent more mass.

In addition, the WTC floors fail when overloaded. The floors can hold 29,000,000 pounds based on the connections to the shell and core, and fail above that. A WTC floor overloaded fails; add up the upper sections; on 911 the top sections falling were more than 29,000,000 pounds.
Thus a car analogy is not very good, does the brick wall fail when the car touches the brick wall? In the WTC if the upper section touches, sits on the lower floor, the floor fails instantly; does the brick wall? Plus would bricks hit then go forward with the car at the acceleration of g... in the WTC floors which fail push on the accelerator and accelerate at G like a $350,000 dollar super car... can the brick wall do that?

The WTC falling is like a super car accelerating, for free, due to gravity. If we want our stock cars to be some of the fastest cars in the world, drop them from great heights.
 
If he was assistant manager at a Baskin-Robbins I would consider him an authority on ice cream. I might ask him for suggestions on a good flavor, but I would not consider him an expert on engineering topics....

To avoid splitting the topic across two threads, my reply to FalseFlag is over in the "If it doesn't agree..." thread.
 
My analogy was a car that is accelerating. The engine is the supplier of a constant force.

Its a valid analogy. The only difference is that the force is horizontal and the barriers vertical.

Yep, it was a fair enough analogy until kjr63 decided to arbitrarily change the spacing of periods of acceleration/collisions
 
Incorrect. The floor-to-column connections are very feeble in comparison to the column strength
If the floor to column connections failed first, then what caused the columns to fail? Remember, the pancake collapse theory was abandoned, so whatever wizardry and nonsense you use for your explanation better not have one floor falling on another.
 
My analogy was a car that is accelerating. The engine is the supplier of a constant force.

Its a valid analogy. The only difference is that the force is horizontal and the barriers vertical.

I was showing kjr that his analogy is flawed. He's missing gravity in his analogy with cars running through walls.
 
If the floor to column connections failed first, then what caused the columns to fail? Remember, the pancake collapse theory was abandoned, so whatever wizardry and nonsense you use for your explanation better not have one floor falling on another.

You refer to the ones that still existed after the aircraft struck the building?

Fire made them fail first, then the weight of the building did.

I had a gut feeling they were coming down before they even did. Am I in on it? :jaw-dropp

I based my feeling on the pretty well established common knowledge that steel doesn't fare well in fire. Especially one of that ferocity. I also suspected (since confirmed) that there were no efforts to fight the fire. What's taking you so long?
 
Can't you see the dust ejections from the falling floors as they break the connections to the columns? The columns clearly stand while the floors fail.
Yes, some columns are standing while the floors are pulverized and ejected laterally. You should really stop saying that they fall. It makes people assume that everything came straight down. That is not what happened.

I also see pulverized building contents being generated and ejected laterally at a near constant rate. Do you see that too?

In your picture, I see pulverized contents being laterally ejected to the right. In fact, the pulverized contents are being laterally ejected at nearly the same rate and with nearly the same force that it appears there is another mass falling at the same rate at an equal distance from the footprint of the tower? Do you see that, too? That column of dust on the right that seems to have a consistent width? I wonder how the collapse could be so symmetrical, and the forces so constant.

I also wonder what the laws of physics tell us when something continues to accelerate as it falls. What do the laws of physics say about this? Something about apparent weight. Hmmm. Could that be a clue? If something is accelerating, what is it's apparent weight? Is it more or less than its static weight? Hmmm. Could the answers to these questions be clues?

Nah. Nothing to see here.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom