Summary of WTC tower collapses

Fire and gravity. Anything else I can help you with?
Fire? What floors were on fire?

Gravity? Please explain how gravity explains the collapse of WTC1 and WTC2.

Please, enlighten us. I'm going to give you a fair warning. You can't do it. The smartest move for you to make is to simply not reply. You certainly have a right to reply, but you will fail.
 
I don't think you know anything about structural design. Maybe you should learn something first before trying to establish "facts".

If I'm reading him right, he thinks the 1st floor was designed to hold the weight of the 109 floors above it?
:dl:

It's no wonder they get so lost.
 
If I'm reading him right, he thinks the 1st floor was designed to hold the weight of the 109 floors above it?
:dl:

It's no wonder they get so lost.


I have already encountered your lame argument elsewhere. That is why I clearly stated my definition of "floor" in my fact.

Each floor, meaning the exterior and interior support columns, the trusses, the steel plates and the concrete slabs, were designed to support the current floor and everything above it.

If you claim that I am wrong, please prove I am wrong by providing appropriate documentation. Posting lame gifs doesn't count.
 
Fire? What floors were on fire?


Uh.... the ones where the collapse started.
Gravity? Please explain how gravity explains the collapse of WTC1 and WTC2.
Heavy thing in the air, no resistance below. Heavy thing fall. Go boom.

Please, enlighten us. I'm going to give you a fair warning. You can't do it. The smartest move for you to make is to simply not reply. You certainly have a right to reply, but you will fail.

You lack common sense.
 
I have already encountered your lame argument elsewhere. That is why I clearly stated my definition of "floor" in my fact.



If you claim that I am wrong, please prove I am wrong by providing appropriate documentation. Posting lame gifs doesn't count.
I can't. Nothing that runs counter to your asinine beliefs is allowed entry through your thick skull.

That's not a problem I can solve. That's on you
 
Have I misrepresented the basic structure of WTC1 and WTC2?

Have I? If so, how? Please explain, in detail, how my simplified description has substantively made my points invalid.

Yes, this is wikipedia, but it's accurate. Please explain how my description is substantively wrong from what is contained on this website - http://911encyclopedia.com/wiki/index.php/World_Trade_Center_Floor_Structure

Also, please provide your educational background, degrees, licenses, etc., to establish yourself as an authority on the subject.

You've misrepresented structural design. Please review the NIST's report - it contains detailed explanations of the design basis for the WTC towers.

I didn't realize you were appointed the gatekeeper on authority. When did that happen?
 
You argument is misleading because you want readers to simply assume that the concrete slab on a given floor is not capable of supporting the mass of all of the concrete slabs above it. You are correct at a very basic level, but you are misleading people. The concrete slabs on each floor are not designed to support anything other than the normal expected loads of people, furniture, and other things you would normally find on a floor. If the concrete slabs are not designed to support anything other than what is directly on top of them then how does the building remain standing? The answer is simple. The support columns, trusses and steel plates support the concrete slabs and hold the building up.
Incorrect. The floor-to-column connections are very feeble in comparison to the column strength (meaning, it takes far less to break that connection than to buckle the column). They failed first.


The picture shows one thing. You skeptics have spent years trying to convince people they don't see what is there. Pictures are worth 1000 words, as they say. Your words don't explain away what the picture is clearly telling us.
Speaking of which, here's a picture:
139901890.gif

Can't you see the dust ejections from the falling floors as they break the connections to the columns? The columns clearly stand while the floors fail.
 
Last edited:
Whatever mass was ejected laterally can no longer be used to do any damage to the structure directly below. Can we agree on that?

I'd agree with that, as it's bleeding obvious. However, the amount being ejected is just your guess, isn't it? Fact is that substantial debris hitting the (mostly) intact floor below 10m (say) from the perimeter has no business being ejected, at least early on, though as the collapse progresses the absolute amount that has been ejected would increase while the relative amount - per storey - would be roughly the same until the collapse zone encountered the ground and the debris already on the ground.

The vast clouds of dust that you see contain a high %age of pulverised drywall, drywall which lined the facade and the core area. Here's a diagram to give you an idea:



and if you've ever demolished a platerboard ceiling or wall you'll appreciate how much dust it releases when smashed.

Do the videos and pictures of the collapses of WTC1 and WTC2 look like a small portion of pulverized concrete and building contents was ejected?

"Look like" counts for little. I'd refer you again to my previous comment about relative and absolute amounts being ejected. The absolute, accumulative amount increased as collapse progressed, naturally, but for the first few storeys relatively little moved outside the footprint.

And as for the final footprint of the debris, well, when the ground started offering resistance then naturally the debris spread rapidly sideways, as it was bound to do.
 
You've misrepresented structural design. Please review the NIST's report - it contains detailed explanations of the design basis for the WTC towers.

I didn't realize you were appointed the gatekeeper on authority. When did that happen?
Explain how I have misrepresented structural design.
 
Explain how I have misrepresented structural design.

I showed it to you mathematically, 2600LBS dropped 12 feet breaks one connection.

The floors were much weaker than your estimation adding in the columns, break the connections the floors fall. The interior columns fail as they are vibrated rapidly and unbraced, and the outer columns peal over like the skin on a banana.

Still waiting on your mathematical model of Cole's experiments, on the other thread.
 
If you make a claim it should be accurate. The claim in question is not accurate. The solution should have been simple. Unfortunately, what is simple in one forum seems to be impossible here.

That does not answer the question I asked, and you quoted me asking.
You do know what "context" means, right?
 
Last edited:
Also, please provide your educational background, degrees, licenses, etc., to establish yourself as an authority on the subject

I'm not sure what good that would do. You've already, it seems, rejected a host of domain experts. Why would you lend credence to AZCat (<waves> how are things in Tucson?) no matter what gold-plated qualifications he/she brings to the table?

I see this sort of question asked occasionally by Apollo "hoax" believers, who seek to attack the claims of those maintaining the reality of Apollo by impeaching their domain expertise. They are almost invariably unqualified in the relevant fields themselves, however - as you appear to be - and have already dismissed the broad consensus among the community of actual experts.

So, here as in those cases, I am led to ask, what is the point of the question? What difference would it make to you whether AZCat's entire career was designing steel-framed highrises, or being assistant manager at a Baskin-Robbins?
 
FF,
Nothing ever wrong with having questions and asking them.. and expecting to receive a decent answer. It's probably a healthy thing to question because that leads to understanding.

It appears that there is misunderstand about what NIST did and what their objective was. Accordingly what they published in their reports contains errors, is incomplete, are hypotheses explaining the collapses and is not intended to be proofs. NIST had to use assumptions and values to generate their studies and models. Hulsey will be doing the same. Absent a complete data set all models will produce a resulted limited by and constrained by the assumptions used.

I personally, find their "initiations" to the progression of runaway mechanical failures.. their so called global collapse not satisfying. They may have nailed it. But the complexity of the events means that the unwinding of these buildings could have had a different path.. could have begun in a different location for example. But ultimately all hypotheses need to produce an outcome which matches the visuals...and sounds which is all we have to check the model.

The effects of uncontrolled fires on steel is well known. Same for concrete and other materials. Steel will weaken, will expand, concrete will weaken and spald. Other materials will ignite and burn.

Building have systems to mitigate the effects of fire... steel has insulation and there are sprinklers to cool and extinguish fires. if the suppression systems fail then the fire will do its thing... the materials will lose strength, integrity, distort by twisting, sagging, breaking and so on.

Connection elements are not as strong as the things they connect. It's absurd to expect every single component down to a bolt or a weld to have the strength of the beams and columns and plates and so on they join. It's pretty clear from examining the WTC debris that connections failures played a huge part in the complete collapse of the buildings.

Of course there was the force of gravity which drove the PROGRESSIVE collapse in most cases. This required a threshold mass large enough to destroy the connections etc. on the components upon which they fell for the collapse to proceed in a downward runaway fashion. Buildings with few floors are not given to progressive downward runaway collapse, facade peel, or columns toppling from being too slender when stripped of their bracing. To collapse the low rise structures would require undermining of the structure at the bottom.

The form of a gravity driven collapse is in the "DNA" of the structural design... and were the initial failures are.

Total collapses are usually progressive events. Parts of the structure fail and the mass to be supported has not changed so the other parts of the structure assume additional loads. Structures are designed to perform well below the yield strength and ever component has a "factor of safety" though none is expected to have the same value of FOS. However as parts of the structure fail, and loads are carried by parts of the remaining structure... those redistributed loads will push the factor of safety lower to members and connections seeing new and increased loads. This can eventually lead to the service loads seen as exceeding the yield strength and another connection or member fails... loads ger redistributed and the cycle will repeat especially during the period of constant heat being added which weakens and distorts and fails elements of the remaining structure. The process progresses at an increasing speed and becomes runaway and can involve the entire structure if the design does not have a means to ISOLATE the failures laterally. Ronan Point did... the twin towers' and 7wtc did not.

We will never know precisely how the the failures progressed. There is no time related data. There are no proofs. The hypotheses are driven by the visual record and the design along with understanding of how materials perform under mechanical loads and thermal stress.


And as in a CD... it is gravity which is the main destroyer. Once threshold mass is deprived of designated axial load paths... collapse will be ensue... locally and possibly globally. This is settle science. Gage and his dropping blocks is a prime example of dumb and failing to understand and take into account the structure, engineering and mechanics on the required level.

There is much to learn from engineers, physicists, critical thinkers who have studied and written about these collapse.

If you really want to learn the material is out there on this and other sites like 911 freeforum.

If you want to remain steeped in ignorance and junk science and confirmation boas because you believe everything the media and gov says is a lie... you will not learn a thing.
 
Speaking of which, here's a picture:
[qimg]http://femr2.ucoz.com/_ph/6/2/139901890.gif[/qimg]
Can't you see the dust ejections from the falling floors as they break the connections to the columns? The columns clearly stand while the floors fail.

Another thing you can see in the GIF is that the outside material falling through air at close to FF is moving faster than the ejections down the side of the building. The floor collapse withing the tower is SLOWER than FF.

And you can see material from the collapse coming out of several floors as its volume was quite large at the levels seen in the GIF.
 
Explain how I have misrepresented structural design.

You massively simplified it.
Each floor pan supports its owm load , that load is tranfered to the columns. Overload the floor pan and the floor pan fails.
The connection between perimeter and core structure are necessary to laterally support perimeter and core.

Loss of a floor pan, specifically the trusses, removes that lateral support.

All floor pans, with a few exceptions, were indentical. Only the columns changed from lower to higher levels.
 
I'll never understand why these need to be so wordy.

20 floors fell on one floor. One floor couldn't hold the weight, so 21 floors fell on one floor, which couldn't hold the weight. So 22 floors....

repeat until completed.

..until all gravitational energy is consumed. After about 10 floors.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom