Summary of WTC tower collapses

I did answer your question in the very first paragraph of my last post.
LOL restating your claim does not answer my question.
Let me be more clear. If there are no photos of mundane office furnishings, then they didn't exist.
That would come as a surprise to police who usually consider lack of evidence to be problematic in proving anything.
They were pulverized. There are thousands upon thousands of photos of the debris field. The vast majority of what we see is steel and dust.
Dust you say. Covering everything you say, turning everything the same colour you say.
Can a gravity-driven collapse do this? No. How do I know this? Simple. I can look at pictures of other gravity-driven collapses and I don't see the same thing, or similar things. If I don't see similar things, then the gravity-driven collapse hypothesis might not explain what happened.
You can look at pictures of the ground around other "gravity driven" ( snort) collapses of buildings even half the size of the twins?
Really? Where?

Now how about explaining what supposedly the lack of intact office furnishings points to,exactly.

I'll make it easy for you. Start with whether or not everything has a bomb attached to it, chairs, desks, telephones, file cabinets, etc. I expect you say no. OK what did this supposed pulverisation of everything?
 
Last edited:
Nonsense.

https://youtu.be/y9-owhllM9k?t=28

The buildings were not hermetically sealed between floors.

What anyone can see in this video, if they choose to open their eyes, does not match your claims that air did this. Some of you claim the collapsing floors pulverized the office furnishings, and now you're claiming air. Which one is it? You really should get together and try to be consistent with your fantasies.

No, air pressure caused ejections of debris. You are the one claiming that you know that everything is "pulverised".
 
I am not an expert. Experts need to discuss the issues


Experts in what?

and come to a solution.


Come to a solution how?

A solution to what problem?

The discussion should be open and transparent. The experts should be vetted


Vetted by whom? Vetted how?

and shown to have as few ties to the government as possible.


Shown how? Shown to whom, by whom?


One person can't solve the issue.

Let's start the process


Start what process? You haven't described a process, just a bunch of idle wishes for some of the characteristics of a process.

Start the process how? Or do you need other experts, vetted and shown to have as few ties to the government as possible, along with more people to vet the vetters and then vet the people who vet the vetters, to tell you that?
 
Way back in pre-history there was an OP Topic.... :) ;)

Thanks again jaydeehess - I think you are at the stage where further comments will not add significant value.

There are two sections I would simply leave out:
Core columns are subject to heating basically from all sides, over the several floors fully involved in the fires, and over the course of fire spread around each level.
( that is to say a column at level x may heat more on one face than that same column at level x-1 or x+1 but that over the several levels involved some columns are heated on all sides and taking into account the changes through time)
I doubt that it adds anything to the SUMMARY - the issue could well be subject of a more detailed discussion.

AND this one:
...
With all columns now having failed over one or more adjacent levels, a large section of the upper building is now falling, accelerating through approximately the distqnce of one level, to next contacts.
Leaving the hilited bit out makes the statement true and avoids the obvious implications of the Szamboti influence.....note the plural "contacts" :thumbsup:
 
Nonsense.

https://youtu.be/y9-owhllM9k?t=28

The buildings were not hermetically sealed between floors.

What anyone can see in this video, if they choose to open their eyes, does not match your claims that air did this. Some of you claim the collapsing floors pulverized the office furnishings, and now you're claiming air. Which one is it? You really should get together and try to be consistent with your fantasies.

The don't have to be hermetically sealed. If you have a piece of plywood that drops onto a dust covered floor the air forced away as the plywood drops causes the dust to shout out in all directions.

If you drop a concrete block into water the water splashes out in all directions... pushed by the descending concrete block.

No two objects can occupy the same space at the same time. The more massive dropping mass of floos slabs sections and debris displaces the air and the displaced air carries with it light "stuff".

Surely you don't deny this?
 
FF asked for a picture showing concrete slabs.
He was given one and immediately dismissed it as not enough.
This is a standard CT tactic.
Whatever evidence is presented is not the evidence they need even if they asked for it.
What they always need is the evidence that isn't available.
 
FF wants others to prove him and his truth guys wrong. This is an ass backwards approach in the first place... AND no manner of "evidence" or argument or science is sufficient. He simply goes off to some other what he and his types believe or "anomalies" which make the event a CD and not something which heat from fires and gravity could cause. Why is the amount of dust... or the number of large chunks of concrete or the absence of toilets or door handles or the amount of dust an anomaly?

The burden of proof is on the truth guys. It's that simple.

This is definitely a failure to think critically problem.
 
FF wants others to prove him and his truth guys wrong. This is an ass backwards approach in the first place###... AND no manner of "evidence" or argument or science is sufficient. He simply goes off to some other what he and his types believe or "anomalies" which make the event a CD and not something which heat from fires and gravity could cause. Why is the amount of dust... or the number of large chunks of concrete or the absence of toilets or door handles or the amount of dust an anomaly?

The burden of proof is on the truth guys. It's that simple.###
This is definitely a failure to think critically problem.###

:thumbsup: :thumbsup:

Well said Sander. Those ### are the three key points.
 
Two 110 story buildings collapsed and you have provided one picture of one concrete slab that appears to be about 30' x 20'. What floor did this slab come from?

I have to give you partial credit, because you did sort of complete the task.

Ummmmm, no. Once again, I provided what you asked for. I mean, I should not have had to - trained Monkey's could have found that so I don't know why you continually have to depend on others to do simple tasks you could do yourself. With such limited investigative skill its no wonder you jump to such wrong conclusions all the time.

Of course now that you have been provided what you asked for you want to do the duck-and-dodge routine again. Why is it that every time you are provided with the information you ask for your next reply is not a thank you but a dodge or evasion?

Here's the problem. Shouldn't there be more concrete slabs if you want to argue that the falling concrete floors were responsible for crushing the office furnishings?

I never claimed such a thing. I would argue there are exactly as many concrete slabs in evidence as there should be after a 1,000 foot fall.

Prove me wrong - but do it somewhere as as this is seriously OT in this thread.
 
Quote:
Here's the problem. Shouldn't there be more concrete slabs if you want to argue that the falling concrete floors were responsible for crushing the office furnishings?

A couple dozen baseball to basketball sized chunks of concrete would pulverise such items just as thoroughly as two large slabs of concrete
 
Way back in pre-history there was an OP Topic.... :) ;)

Thanks again jaydeehess - I think you are at the stage where further comments will not add significant value.

There are two sections I would simply leave out:

I doubt that it adds anything to the SUMMARY - the issue could well be subject of a more detailed discussion.

AND this one:
Leaving the hilited bit out makes the statement true and avoids the obvious implications of the Szamboti influence.....note the plural "contacts" :thumbsup:
My tablet seems unwulling to connect to wifi at the location I am stuck at several times a week with little else to do. My phone is woefully inadequate to editing a long post.
When I get time at home where my tablet does work, I will do another revision with these suggestions in mind.
Your first I , I think I will leave the explanatory note in, but the second, concerning first drop I will rewrite that passage
 
The don't have to be hermetically sealed. If you have a piece of plywood that drops onto a dust covered floor the air forced away as the plywood drops causes the dust to shout out in all directions.

If you drop a concrete block into water the water splashes out in all directions... pushed by the descending concrete block.

No two objects can occupy the same space at the same time. The more massive dropping mass of floos slabs sections and debris displaces the air and the displaced air carries with it light "stuff".

Surely you don't deny this?

Unlike your sheet of plywood, the collapse mechanism generated the dust.

Unlike your dropping concrete block, there was no body of water being impacted.

Surely you can't deny this?
 
Unlike your sheet of plywood, the collapse mechanism generated the dust.

Unlike your dropping concrete block, there was no body of water being impacted.

Surely you can't deny this?

Drop a load of gravel down a tube and the air will compress below it as it falls, provided of course it fills the tube as it falls now tell me the concrete slabs would not have had some light weight agrigate in them. Or that the materials would not have fallen inside the tube.

Also some of the expulsions will be do to chemical events, and crushing of tanks and heating ducts before the collapse even reaches the spot in Question.
 
Last edited:
My tablet seems unwulling to connect to wifi at the location I am stuck at several times a week with little else to do. My phone is woefully inadequate to editing a long post.
When I get time at home where my tablet does work, I will do another revision with these suggestions in mind.
Your first I , I think I will leave the explanatory note in, but the second, concerning first drop I will rewrite that passage
Understood.

No problem either way - your understanding and mine always close and no doubt we could continue fine tuning nuances. BUT little further benefit for the intended audience.

:thumbsup:
 
Unlike your sheet of plywood, the collapse mechanism generated the dust.

Unlike your dropping concrete block, there was no body of water being impacted.

Surely you can't deny this?

No there was no water... it was an illustration of what happens when two objects; a block of concrete and water try to occupy the same space at the same time.

The collapse of the top surely dustified several acres of ceiling tiles and acres of GWB... doesn't take much force to do that... does it? And the dust get carried away with the escaping air... simple... easy peasy to understand.
 
Nonsense.

https://youtu.be/y9-owhllM9k?t=28

The buildings were not hermetically sealed between floors.

What anyone can see in this video, if they choose to open their eyes, does not match your claims that air did this. Some of you claim the collapsing floors pulverized the office furnishings, and now you're claiming air. Which one is it? You really should get together and try to be consistent with your fantasies.

So, you have never waited for a subway train?
 
No, I'm not in denial. I can accept valid evidence. Can you?

you have no evidence to support CD. End your participation in the discussion, you have nothing past failed physics, zero research, and no practical knowledge of 9/11 events. You can't calculate the energy of collapse to understand what caused the damage seen on 9/11. Armed with no evidence, you are reduced to this to support your fantasy CD claim - projecting on others.

As the rest of 9/11 truth you are overly armed with logical fallacies.

Most of 9/11 truth posts like this one you made are projection, the psychological phenomenon where someone denies an aspect of their behavior or attitudes and assumes others are doing or thinking so.

You must show up with evidence for CD, not this BS. Your loud sounds are not proof of anything but 9/11 truth's failure to understand simile.

Zero evidence, and all you are left with is projection and logical fallacies.
Have a great Sunday - 15th year of lies about CD, no evidence, going for the record of eternity.

Unlike your sheet of plywood, the collapse mechanism generated the dust.

Unlike your dropping concrete block, there was no body of water being impacted.

Surely you can't deny this?
No CD on 9/11, you can't deny. Why is 9/11 truth unable to come up with evidence for CD?
 
Last edited:
I did answer your question in the very first paragraph of my last post. Let me be more clear. If there are no photos of mundane office furnishings, then they didn't exist. They were pulverized. There are thousands upon thousands of photos of the debris field. The vast majority of what we see is steel and dust. Can a gravity-driven collapse do this? No. How do I know this? Simple. I can look at pictures of other gravity-driven collapses and I don't see the same thing, or similar things. If I don't see similar things, then the gravity-driven collapse hypothesis might not explain what happened.

You've seen other gravity-driven collapses of 110 story buildings?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom