ozeco41
Philosopher
You take that back!
Yeah I often notice things after posting. I will add, subtract, or correct text. Might be more than 50% of my posts include the "last edited by..." line
You take that back!
Yeah I often notice things after posting. I will add, subtract, or correct text. Might be more than 50% of my posts include the "last edited by..." line
Agreed, agreed, agreed - all three points.Yes. However I think its a level of detail that does not fit in this generic summary of both collapses.
Collapse ensued when columns lost the ability to hold the upper section up. Which column or subset of columns failed first is detail that is somewhat different between the two collapses.
If a floor sags down at the core end due to one column being shorter, then some load must be greater on adjacent truss connections.
Its a minor point. Damaged columns are simply not the same as pristine ones.
Yes, perimeter core columns would be most affected by impact. damaging one perimeter core column puts extra stress on nearby truss to belt girder connections.I know this is detail stuff and far afield of the summary...
The core stuff has little to no impact on the OSS flooring except if the belt girder moves or fails or parts or drops... and the belt girder was carried by the 24 perimeter core columns not the 23 interior ones.
All of which suggests you are referring to only one tower whereas this summary is generic and to refer to each tower.I do believe that the core erosion progressed to the south... and east and west... the north was in bad shape from the plane hit.
My guess is that the core was eventually structural gutted and the core's perimeter finally went with the 2 corners being the last columns standing and when they buckled the tool all the belt girder that was left with them... and the OOS floors up there slipped down and was pulled in and this was the initiation of ROOSD. The plunging antenna is the tell that the center of the core AND the hat truss has failed (first).
We do know impact, fire, time period, collapse.Agreed, agreed, agreed - all three points.
I would go a step further with the third point.
We will never know the sequence -- first, second, third......nth
Time to lock it up jaydeehess.
Yes, perimeter core columns would be most affected by impact. damaging one perimeter core column puts extra stress on nearby truss to belt girder connections.
All of which suggests you are referring to only one tower whereas this summary is generic and to refer to each tower.
Really? Nothing was going to stop the collapse? You mean nothing, like the tens of thousands of tons of cold, undamaged steel that had always been supporting the mass above?Once collapse initiation began, collapse progression was inevitable and there was nothing going to stop it.
The "nonsense" is called dynamic load.I guess the collapsing mass exerted too much force for the structure below. Oh, wait...I guess you skeptics have never heard of apparent weight. I can't wait to see what nonsense you have to explain that away.
Really? Nothing was going to stop the collapse? You mean nothing, like the tens of thousands of tons of cold, undamaged steel that had always been supporting the mass above?
I guess the collapsing mass exerted too much force for the structure below. Oh, wait...I guess you skeptics have never heard of apparent weight. I can't wait to see what nonsense you have to explain that away.
You managed to ignore this thread for two months and then pick a post in the middle to respond to. Nice troll manouver.Really? Nothing was going to stop the collapse? You mean nothing, like the tens of thousands of tons of cold, undamaged steel that had always been supporting the mass above?
I guess the collapsing mass exerted too much force for the structure below. Oh, wait...I guess you skeptics have never heard of apparent weight. I can't wait to see what nonsense you have to explain that away.
apparent weight.
Really? Nothing was going to stop the collapse? You mean nothing, like the tens of thousands of tons of cold, undamaged steel that had always been supporting the mass above?
I guess the collapsing mass exerted too much force for the structure below. Oh, wait...I guess you skeptics have never heard of apparent weight. I can't wait to see what nonsense you have to explain that away.
Originally Posted by Mark F
Once collapse initiation began, collapse progression was inevitable and there was nothing going to stop it.
Really? Nothing was going to stop the collapse? You mean nothing, like the tens of thousands of tons of cold, undamaged steel that had always been supporting the mass above?
I guess the collapsing mass exerted too much force for the structure below. Oh, wait...I guess you skeptics have never heard of apparent weight. I can't wait to see what nonsense you have to explain that away.
Correct, FF. The tens (actually hundreds) of thousands of tons of cold, undamaged steel columns that had always been supporting the mass above were not going to lend their support, physical, moral or otherwise to the collapsing mass above them, for the simple reason that they were literally in no position to.
The collapsing mass destroyed the floor/truss connections which had only needed to support the static load of a single floor, not the whole upper building falling on it.
You can hold a brick on your head for as long as you want. Do you want to check what happens if it's thrown on your head from a height of 3.6 metres?
Correct, FF. The tens (actually hundreds) of thousands of tons of cold, undamaged steel columns that had always been supporting the mass above were not going to lend their support, physical, moral or otherwise to the collapsing mass above them, for the simple reason that they were literally in no position to.
The collapsing mass destroyed the floor/truss connections which had only needed to support the static load of a single floor, not the whole upper building falling on it.
Once support for the upper section failed at the impact and fire points, the sections tilted as they fell, missing the columns beneath them, and striking the topmost floor assemblies. A floor assembly can't possibly support even the static weight of the building above, much less the dynamic force of the falling mass, and the assembly fails at the truss/floor connections to the column, and the collapse continues.
This has been explained to you repeatedly, but going in one ear and out the other, encountering zero resistance (but more importantly, zero absorption) in between. I won't even try to explain or illustrate to you the difference between a static and dynamic load. I'd have better luck with my Scottish Terrier.
Well, if I was stationary when the brick impacted I am certain it would hurt quite a bit.
Now, if I was falling at the same rate as the brick I wouldn't feel a damn thing.
Now, let's think about this for a minute. If the upper mass of WTC1 fell on the lower stationary mass of WTC1, it stands to reason that the impact would do damage to the lower mass. Right? I mean if the brick would hurt my head, the upper mass of the tower would certainly do damage to (a small portion of) the lower mass.
But the lower mass was collapsing at the rate of the upper mass. How could the upper mass do so much damage when the apparent weight was less than it was when the upper mass was stationary?
Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm?
Oh, wait, I know it's coming. Skeptics claim I know nothing about physics. Sure I don't.
You know that feeling you get when you go down that first drop of a roller coaster? That feeling is your brain telling you that your government is lying to you, and the skeptics on this site are frauds.

I have to give you credit for this explanation. It's some good fraud - single malt, 150 proof, and finely aged. It fools most people who can't see through it because they either don't want to think or they can't think.
I think you've just described "crush down / crush up".But the lower mass was collapsing at the rate of the upper mass.