Summary of WTC tower collapses

This argument is irrelevant. The complexity of a task is not proof it can't be done.

The Manhattan project was kept secret. Over 100,000 people worked on it.

The moon landings were an extremely complex achievement. Are you saying we didn't land on the moon because it was difficult?

But the Russians new all about the Manhattan project while it was supposedly still secret. 'Whistleblowers' told them.
 
If you want to claim you're correct, shouldn't you be able to provide a link to a credible source that supports your claims?

Sorry, but I don't know of any credible sources that are written for morons. If it isn't obvious that falling a thousand feet and getting crushed between slabs of falling concrete at the bottom will pulverise most things, then what is?

Dave
 
But real experts have investigated. You reject their reports and conclusions.
Who should the new set of 'real' experts be?
That's easy.

Photos of dust covering everything + no photos of crushed, but still discernible office contents = everything but the structural steel was pulverized.
 
What forces can explain such massive destruction? Does it really make sense that a gravity driven collapse pulverized and ejected so much concrete and office furnishings? When a concrete building collapses due to an earthquake, do we see such massive pulverization, or are there still recognizable objects?

Here's where it gets good. Now skeptics are going to claim that an earthquake collapse of a concrete building is different. Yes, it is. But so are collapses from verinage, and the collapses of Ronan Point and Skyline Towers.

LOL.
None of that answers my question.
If there are no photos of mundane office contents, why is that significant?

Try addressing this without asking another question.
 
I am not an expert. We need experts to do a real investigation to determine the answers to the questions we are all asking.

I have done the investigation, I know the answers, that's why I am not interested in doing further experiments to debunk morons like Cole.

He has no multi stage fire in his sulfidication experiment.

He hasn't tried building a real thermite cutter, that will function in a real fire.

He hasn't experimented with the chemistry of the fires to determine reaction induced by said chemistry.

He hasn't done experiments with real welds and real bolts and connections similar to what were in the buildings.

I have done in my back yard, on my farm all those things, Why can't Jonathan Cole, an engineer with an engineering degree do one freaking experiment right?
 
None of that answers my question.
If there are no photos of mundane office contents, why is that significant?

Try addressing this without asking another question.

Also might ask, since FF hasn't apparently seen my post yet, that he address this issue with respect to the nature of the thread title.
The purpose was to come up with an easy to digest, easy to read, summary of the collapses of the towers. In that light, what does the final condition of the office contents suggest should be added to that summary?
 
I will not guess what the answer is to that question. That is why we need an investigation. We need real experts to perform a real investigation to get the answer to that question.

List of names and why they are "experts"

:popcorn1
 
Sorry, but I don't know of any credible sources that are written for morons. If it isn't obvious that falling a thousand feet and getting crushed between slabs of falling concrete at the bottom will pulverise most things, then what is?

Dave

Show me slabs of intact, or semi-intact, concrete in the rubble pile.
 
Feel free to return to this thread and discuss your ideas on how you would want such an investigation to be constituted.
I am not an expert. Experts need to discuss the issues and come to a solution. The discussion should be open and transparent. The experts should be vetted and shown to have as few ties to the government as possible.

One person can't solve the issue.

Let's start the process, and then solve the issues as they arise.
 
Show me slabs of intact, or semi-intact, concrete in the rubble pile.

Once again, 5 seconds on Google and look,...

September_14_2001_Ground_Zero_01.jpg


You should really try it sometime. Its amazing what you can come up with when you don't have to rely on others to do all of your thinking for you.

I am not an expert.

Really?

Experts need to discuss the issues and come to a solution. The discussion should be open and transparent. The experts should be vetted and shown to have as few ties to the government as possible.

One person can't solve the issue.

The above is all done and done. I ask again, investigate what and why and be precise if that is possible.

Let's start the process, and then solve the issues as they arise.[/QUOTE]
 
Last edited:
You should really try it sometime.

Two 110 story buildings collapsed and you have provided one picture of one concrete slab that appears to be about 30' x 20'. What floor did this slab come from?

I have to give you partial credit, because you did sort of complete the task.

Here's the problem. Shouldn't there be more concrete slabs if you want to argue that the falling concrete floors were responsible for crushing the office furnishings?
 
Last edited:
Two 110 story buildings collapsed and you have provided one picture of one concrete slab that appears to be about 30' x 20'. What floor did this slab come from?

I have to give you partial credit, because you did sort of complete the task.

Here's the problem. Shouldn't there be more concrete slabs if you want to argue that the falling concrete floors were responsible for crushing the office furnishings?

This question doesn't need to be answered. 350,000 tons of materials came down in a 1 acre vertical avalanche and you want to know how many large chunks of slabs there were? Why?

FF Nothing will satisfy you... you are the skeptical one who refuses to accept that the record of evidence does not support a CD...

No one has to prove a thing to you. You need to use critical thinking. You don't need experts... a new investigation will produce a similar conclusion though it could model a different sequence of mechanical destruction. You don't understand physics so you don't believe your eyes.

You will likely never change your mind because it is informed by irrational beliefs.
 
Two 110 story buildings collapsed and you have provided one picture of one concrete slab that appears to be about 30' x 20'. What floor did this slab come from?

I have to give you partial credit, because you did sort of complete the task.

Here's the problem. Shouldn't there be more concrete slabs if you want to argue that the falling concrete floors were responsible for crushing the office furnishings?

Take it up with the cameraman.

Do you think the entirety of the WTC site is in that shot?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom