Summary of WTC tower collapses

Do you consider the fuel mass as part of the plane? Purdue seems to think it had a greater effect on the structure then the NIST considered.

Yes it was part of the plane and hugely destructive at it slammed into things and then atomized and ignited.

I am with Purdue on that one.
 
Some questions:
Don't you find it odd that it appears that the pulverized building contents are being produced at roughly the same rate? Don't you find it odd that the pulverized contents are being ejected approximately the same distance as well?

Same volume of air is ejected on each floor. Nothing odd about it.
 
<<What you see being ejected is mostly lighter contents including a hell of a lot of pulverized gypsum board. I see absolutely no evidence that concrete floor pans are being ejected laterally..>>

Then you're not looking, or you are playing a semantics game.


Then the bulk of my post:
If something continues to accelerate as it falls it means that the forces directed downwards are greater than any forces acting in the opposite direction.

In the Earth's gravity well an object that is falling AT g would have an 'apparent weight' of zero, or weightless. However when it impacts something the force of impact is not zero. If you throw a cannonball into the air and let it fall on your head it will be weightless on the way down but be far from having zero force when it hits your head. In fact it will hit with more force than if you simply balanced it on your head. That is because its momentum must be imparted to your head over a period of time and momentum transferred over time IS force. Its actually the way Newton described his Second Law of Motion in his Principia Mathmatica. The change in momentum over change in time.
delta p/delta t

No response whatsoever.
 
Last edited:
Yes, some practically all columns are standing while the floors are pulverized fractured and dust is ejected laterally.
FTFY to be more precise.


You should really stop saying that they fall. It makes people assume that everything came straight down. That is not what happened.
The floors came straight down while they pancaked. That's what I call the collapse front.


I also see pulverized building contents being generated and ejected laterally at a near constant rate. Do you see that too?
Approximately.


In your picture, I see pulverized contents being laterally ejected to the right. In fact, the pulverized contents are being laterally ejected at nearly the same rate and with nearly the same force that it appears there is another mass falling at the same rate at an equal distance from the footprint of the tower? Do you see that, too? That column of dust on the right that seems to have a consistent width?
It's the trail of dust of a free-falling cluster of panels. There were several like that. Nothing special about it, even if Chandler claims this is proof they had rockets or some nonsense like that.


I wonder how the collapse could be so symmetrical, and the forces so constant.
Those who have measured the speed of that collapse front say that it reached a constant speed (zero acceleration). I attribute that to air compression (air friction, cushioning) causing a terminal velocity. With constant velocity, the expected air pressure is the same.

Robert McCoy, ex-AE911T panel member, said he expected to see exactly that kind of ejections in a pancake collapse. He didn't see them, but that speaks poorly of his capacity for watching the collapse, because obviously they were there:

Now we have the mass of that building from up above coming down, in strong... you know, it's going to begin to impact the whole building as it comes, as everyone has described. But it's going to come down in a pancake fashion, in a staccato kind of a way, bang bang bang bang bang as it comes. It's not going to come as a smooth fall. You're going to see puffs of pulverizing concrete, each time a floor or a series of floors hits another floor. I didn't see that.
​
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sfgXDnn8V_I

It's also pretty obvious that the ejected dust is not the majority of the concrete in pulverized form. The volume hardly justifies that, and the density is clearly low (otherwise it would fall much faster, if not at free fall).

Dust is produced when concrete is fractured, then said dust is ejected. You can see it in this still from the moment of the collapse (due to fire) of the TU Delft building:

bouwkunde-explosion.jpg


And in this demolition:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8qKIikDcDII

(around second 17). You're not claiming that the majority of the concrete in these floors went out the windows, are you?

Dust is also produced when gypsum board is crushed, and when fireproofing is dislodged.
 
Last edited:
The proof that no special consideration was given to a fire started by a fuel-loaded plane is that there was nothing special in the fire systems and fireproofing used: They were just "to code," which was based on a normal office fire.
 
I suspect SFPM did get removed. Not much from the plane impact because not much of the plane impacted steel and left it in place. Some of it probably shook loose.... Maybe.
The plane impacts may have sent the building materials flying about and bashing the steel and knocking it off. Maybe. Things like flying gyp bd shaft walls, metal studs would do it.

A plane part... dunno...


Take a look at the street on the :30 mark in this video. This is after impact, before collapse. Most of the dust you see there would be fireproofing.




Fireproofing is by far the most fragile when compared to concrete or drywall you can crush it into dust with your bare hand.
The concrete is also covered on one side by steel floor pans and carpet or vinyl on the other. The drywall is also covered both sides by paper and or vinyl. This would act to contain a portion of the dust.

If you watch video of the impact you will see a column of what looks like smoke that falls to the ground and just lays there.

zUntitled-1_small.jpg


My opinion is most of what you see below the red arrows is fire proofing.

The material coming horizontally out the windows (broken) is basically the clg tiles, gyp bd partitions, particle board furniture, carpets and all things which were not strong and strongly attached to the structure.

You also need to add fire proofing to this list. If you look at the photo below and imagine what happens when the mass above crashes on to this floor. Most of that fire proofing is going to come off, mix with the air, and be carried out the windows with it.


1_8_wtc_truss_insulation.jpg



Also remember that all those red grey chips that Jones found in all the samples, is in reality buried underneath the fire proofing on those trusses. If the chips were scattered all across the city, the fire proofing that covered them had to be too.
 
Take a look at the street on the :30 mark in this video. This is after impact, before collapse. Most of the dust you see there would be fireproofing.




Fireproofing is by far the most fragile when compared to concrete or drywall you can crush it into dust with your bare hand.
The concrete is also covered on one side by steel floor pans and carpet or vinyl on the other. The drywall is also covered both sides by paper and or vinyl. This would act to contain a portion of the dust.

If you watch video of the impact you will see a column of what looks like smoke that falls to the ground and just lays there.

[qimg]http://i995.photobucket.com/albums/af74/waypastvne/zUntitled-1_small.jpg[/qimg]

My opinion is most of what you see below the red arrows is fire proofing.



You also need to add fire proofing to this list. If you look at the photo below and imagine what happens when the mass above crashes on to this floor. Most of that fire proofing is going to come off, mix with the air, and be carried out the windows with it.


[qimg]http://i995.photobucket.com/albums/af74/waypastvne/1_8_wtc_truss_insulation.jpg[/qimg]


Also remember that all those red grey chips that Jones found in all the samples, is in reality buried underneath the fire proofing on those trusses. If the chips were scattered all across the city, the fire proofing that covered them had to be too.

Of course the sprayed on FP would do to dust when the floors collapsed. But the vast majority of the dust was ground up concrete... and gwb... maybe.
 
If steel doesn't fare well in a fire, then why use it as a building material? If it does not fare well in a fire, then why haven't more steel-framed buildings collapsed from fire? Oh, I forgot. Firefighting. Yeah, right.

Steel is used because it is strong and, all things considered, cheap. In developed countries, reinforced concrete is more expensive because of labor costs. In 3rd world countries, lower labor costs make reinforced concrete cheaper than steel. So ironically, 3rd world countries have an edge in fire safety.

In developed countries, builders compensate for the relative vulnerability of steel by (1) passive means (applying insulation), (2) automatic means (sprinkler systems) and (3) active means (firefighting).

90 West St. burned for days, but survived. It had absolutely outstanding passive fire resistance, and the fire was fought.

In the Twin Towers, (3) was not possible, and 1 and 2 were knocked out by the airliner impacts. But at least you got one of the three. You're making progress, of a sort. :rolleyes:
 
If you claim I'm wrong, provide proof I am wrong.
It's in the basic principles of structural engineering. Go read up on them, perhaps in the NIST reports where they describe the relevant issues, but any other decent reference would do as well.
 
Wrong. Absolutely wrong. WTC1 and WTC2 were designed to withstand the impact of a Boeing 707. The buildings did not collapse after the initial impact; therefore, they performed as they were designed to do.
Is this a direct quote from the lead designer? Do you need one or do you think he lies too.........
If you are tying to prove I am wrong, why is it so hard for you to provide a link, or anything, other than your own statement claiming I am wrong?

Still utilizing the LOGICAL FALLACY of shifting the burden of proof, I see.

DGM simply asked you for your source of your claim.

Can you provide support for your claim? It appears not, as you're once again asking for others to disprove your assertions instead of you providing any proof of those assertions. Why should anyone take your assertions seriously, given that history?

https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/burden-of-proof

burden of proof

You said that the burden of proof lies not with the person making the claim, but with someone else to disprove.

The burden of proof lies with someone who is making a claim, and is not upon anyone else to disprove...

Hank
 
Last edited:
Still utilizing the LOGICAL FALLACY of shifting the burden of proof, I see.

DGM simply asked you for your source of your claim.

Can you provide support for your claim? It appears not, as you're once again asking for others to disprove your assertions instead of you providing any proof of those assertions. Why should anyone take your assertions seriously, given that history?



Hank
:thumbsup: :thumbsup:
 
FF has got this wrong almost every time. His disbelief and lack / limit of understanding of physics and engineering drive his disbelief and so he demands others prove what is essentially settled science and engineering to him on his level. He and most truth guys refuse to learn or understand and rely on false notions of how these things work. So you get block mechanics as demonstrations of what they see as applying physics and engineering.

For example... truth guys cannot understand how collapses create dust from most building materials... dust which can be carried aloft and leaves no recognizable "thing" post collapse. Where are all the telephones and toilets and computers?... and so on.

NB that the top down collapses of the twins produced the same sort of "dust" as the bottom up destruction of 7wtc. Take away is that hundreds of thousands of tons of collapsing building materials can be equally destructive... crushing up or crushing down.
 
For example... truth guys cannot understand how collapses create dust from most building materials... dust which can be carried aloft and leaves no recognizable "thing" post collapse. Where are all the telephones and toilets and computers?... and so on.
I do understand that collapses can create dust - lots of it. You can clearly see the massive amounts of dust in collapses of any type. Dust is not proof that anything is wrong with the official story.

The issue is not dust. The issue is massive amounts of pulverized building contents being ejected laterally at a near constant rate. What is causing this? You claim the upper mass is causing this. Newton disagrees. I disagree based on what Newton is telling me. I don't reject your argument because I want to. I reject it because it does not conform to basic physics.

The laws of physics tell us what happened. Your explanation is based on failed support columns, fire, poor engineering, etc. I don't deny that those issues could cause a building to collapse. They can, without a doubt. The issue is how the building collapsed, not what caused the collapse. That is a huge fact that skeptics refuse to accept. Cause is not the issue. The actual collapse, and what is observed during the collapse, are the issues.
 
Last edited:
I do understand that collapses can create dust - lots of it. You can clearly see the massive amounts of dust in collapses of any type. Dust is not proof that anything is wrong with the official story.

The issue is not dust. The issue is massive amounts of pulverized building contents being ejected laterally at a near constant rate. What is causing this? You claim the upper mass is causing this. Newton disagrees. I disagree based on what Newton is telling me. I don't reject your argument because I want to. I reject it because it does not conform to basic physics.

The laws of physics tell us what happened. Your explanation is based on failed support columns, fire, poor engineering, etc. I don't deny that those issues could cause a building to collapse. They can, without a doubt. The issue is how the building collapsed, not what caused the collapse. That is a huge fact that skeptics refuse to accept. Cause is not the issue. The actual collapse, and what is observed during the collapse, are the issues.

A building is only as strong as the connections, parts that hold it together, FF, take those away and the building becomes a set of disunited parts, connections can not be made perfect and welds and bolts are never as strong as the steel they join.

A pin from a Bell saw tree cutter.
20150327_090325_zps9boa0cws.jpg
 
I do understand that collapses can create dust - lots of it. You can clearly see the massive amounts of dust in collapses of any type. Dust is not proof that anything is wrong with the official story.

The issue is not dust. The issue is massive amounts of pulverized building contents being ejected laterally at a near constant rate. What is causing this? You claim the upper mass is causing this. Newton disagrees. I disagree based on what Newton is telling me. I don't reject your argument because I want to. I reject it because it does not conform to basic physics.

The laws of physics tell us what happened. Your explanation is based on failed support columns, fire, poor engineering, etc. I don't deny that those issues could cause a building to collapse. They can, without a doubt. The issue is how the building collapsed, not what caused the collapse. That is a huge fact that skeptics refuse to accept. Cause is not the issue. The actual collapse, and what is observed during the collapse, are the issues.

Ummmmmm,.... no. Just no.

While this metaphor is not new, it bears repeating;

A box of matches falls off a table, spreading its contents all over the floor.

The investigator wants to know why the box fell off the table.

The conspiracy theorist wants to know why each match ended up where it did.

You FF, are firmly in that second camp.

Once collapse initiation began, collapse progression was inevitable and there was nothing going to stop it. Everything that happened after collapse initiation is simply a product of the chaos of collapse. What maters then, really the only thing that matters is what initiated the collapse.

And we certainly do not need to discuss things that did not happen in the collapse progression phase, like lateral ejection of building components. The situation gets confused enough without bringing in stuff that didn't happen.
 
You can clearly see the massive amounts of dust in collapses of any type. Dust is not proof that anything is wrong with the official story.

The issue is not dust. The issue is massive amounts of pulverized building contents being ejected laterally at a near constant rate.

Since dust and pulverized building contents are precisely the same thing in this context, and you are clearly stating that "massive amounts" are expected to be created in any collapse, is it therefore your claim that the issue is that these fully expected massive amounts of dust are being ejected "laterally at a near constant rate," and that this disagrees with Newton's laws?

Dave
 
I do understand that collapses can create dust - lots of it. You can clearly see the massive amounts of dust in collapses of any type. Dust is not proof that anything is wrong with the official story.

The issue is not dust. The issue is massive amounts of pulverized building contents being ejected laterally at a near constant rate. What is causing this? You claim the upper mass is causing this. Newton disagrees. I disagree based on what Newton is telling me. I don't reject your argument because I want to. I reject it because it does not conform to basic physics.

The laws of physics tell us what happened. Your explanation is based on failed support columns, fire, poor engineering, etc. I don't deny that those issues could cause a building to collapse. They can, without a doubt. The issue is how the building collapsed, not what caused the collapse. That is a huge fact that skeptics refuse to accept. Cause is not the issue. The actual collapse, and what is observed during the collapse, are the issues.

You have been informed that studies have been done that show the collapse front reached a constant velocity. Why then is ejections at a constant rate, remarkable.
wrt what is being ejected, how do you arrive at the conclusion that it is significant, and exactly what is significant about it?

You say cause of collapse is not the issue. Good to know. You just want to know the mechanism by which it did so. One question though, what's the difference between the cause of collapse, and how it collapsed?

That said, if you read the OP and the subsequent revisions, you will see how the majority of us understand the collapse. Odd, you haven't ever referenced the OP or the revisions.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom