Summary of WTC tower collapses

What you see being ejected is mostly lighter contents including a hell of a lot of pulverized gypsum board. I see absolutely no evidence that concrete floor pans are being ejected laterally.
Then you're not looking, or you are playing a semantics game.
 
If you are tying to prove I am wrong, why is it so hard for you to provide a link, or anything, other than your own statement claiming I am wrong?

You, yourself, have conceded that you are not an engineer, scientist or anything much of anything.

You post bollocks on the basis of a self admitted lack of knowledge.

You are corrected by those who actually are scientists and engineers and you reject those.

Religion. That is all you have.
 
Wrong. Absolutely wrong. WTC1 and WTC2 were designed to withstand the impact of a Boeing 707. The buildings did not collapse after the initial impact; therefore, they performed as they were designed to do.
And they in fact withstood the impact of Boeing 767s.
They did not however withstand BOTH the impacts plus a fire condition that saw large area fires over several floors immediately after impact.


Wrong. Please provide the NIST experiment that relates to fireproofing and aircraft impacts
Why? you didn't know this was discussed in the NIST reports? Thought you read them.



I have, which is why I have pointed out your errors.

No, you could not have, otherwise you'd know these things. If you'd have read these forums you'd know its been discussed many many times over the past 1.5 decades.
 
This thread started out so nicely with jaydeehess' OP.

Then a small debate breaks out between jaydeehess and JSanderO over a specific data point. ozeco41 joins in and what occurs is a substantive discussion of ideas about the collapses with Oystein joining in.

These guys know what they're talking about and none have a horse in the official story race. Just guys debating structural failure. A layman such as I can learn a lot just from shutting up and reading this stuff.

Then the usual suspects show up.

What is clear from the first two pages and the last two up until this point is who knows what they are talking about and who does not.

Just an observation. I hope this fades back into serious discussion at some point soon.
 
And they in fact withstood the impact of Boeing 767s.
They did not however withstand BOTH the impacts plus a fire condition that saw large area fires over several floors immediately after impact.
Do you really think the engineers would assume a plane would crash without causing a fire?

Why? you didn't know this was discussed in the NIST reports? Thought you read them.
Have you provided the information I requested? I have read the portion necessary in order to know your claim about fireproofing is wrong. I asked you to show this information. You have failed to do so.
 
Do you really think the engineers would assume a plane would crash without causing a fire?
In the 70s they had no way to model such a fire. Aircraft impact was a secondary concern driven only by public fear of it occurring. It was not a driver of the engineering.


Have you provided the information I requested? I have read the portion necessary in order to know your claim about fireproofing is wrong. I asked you to show this information. You have failed to do so.

Since you have it at your fingertips...........

Sander does not believe it was a major factor, I did not state it was a major factor, but it WAS a factor.
Aircraft impact debrided spray on fire insulation in varying degree, on a significant number of structural components on impact floors. This reduced fire resistance of those structural steel components.
Really, you believe that one can essentially shred a 767 and have the pieces travel into the building at 100+ MPH and those pieces will simply bounce off spray foam insulation?

http://nist.gov/public_affairs/factsheet/wtc_faqs_082006.cfm
 
Last edited:
This thread started out so nicely with jaydeehess' OP.

Then a small debate breaks out between jaydeehess and JSanderO over a specific data point. ozeco41 joins in and what occurs is a substantive discussion of ideas about the collapses with Oystein joining in.

These guys know what they're talking about and none have a horse in the official story race. Just guys debating structural failure. A layman such as I can learn a lot just from shutting up and reading this stuff.

Then the usual suspects show up.

What is clear from the first two pages and the last two up until this point is who knows what they are talking about and who does not.

Just an observation. I hope this fades back into serious discussion at some point soon.
I believe I pointed this out to FF before. Let me think, yes, yes I did.
Amazing! You want to sticky a thread based on response to your derail of the thread.
Do you or do you not have anything at all to contribute to the subject of the thread?

So far nada but derails and denial of facts in evidence.
 

Are you typing?

If yes = then <wrong>
If no = then <not_yet>

Pretty simple where I sit.

The buildings weren't designed to withstand what happened. How do we know? Because they didn't. You're pretty damn fixated on inventing scenarios that go against reality, but I don't see any thought put in to any alternatives.

Only two things could have happened.
1)Aircraft impact + Fire
2)Something else.

Why not start another thread and tell the class about your own personal view on #2?
 
Your CD is wrong, Cole is wrong.

The WTC towers were design to stop a 707 at 180 mph; stop it at the shell.

The 707 at 180 mph kinetic energy is equal to 187 pounds of TNT.

Flt 11 at 490 mph kinetic energy is equal to 1400 pounds of TNT. The plane will not stop at the shell, and will damage 6 core columns.

Flt 175 at 590 mph kinetic energy is equal to 2093 pounds of TNT. The plane will break the shell and damage 10 core columns.

The design of the WTC would have kept the jet fuel outside the WTC shell for a 180 mph jet impact, some fire inside, not all the fire inside.

Did you have a point in the wrong thread again?
 
OK. I completely understand your statement. I am not rejecting it. I simply have a question.

Please watch this video. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y9-owhllM9k
Around 30 seconds the collapse becomes visible enough to clearly see smoke and pulverized building contents being laterally ejected. Are you claiming that what I see is pulverized ceiling tiles, gypsum board, particle board, furniture and all the things that were not strong and attached to the structure immediately after the collapse started? Are you claiming that all of this material consists of what you mentioned, but no floor material? If so, where are the floors?

At 54 seconds you can clearly see the top portion of the building is nearly gone. Where did the floors go, if they are not part of the pulverized contents?



Are you sure floors would have caused this? Could anything else explain the airspeed you claim?

The ejected material is anything BUT the floors. The floors were behind the spandrels. For them to get pulverized and ejected horizontally they would be intact for about 2 feet of vertical drop.... being pulverized...(not) and then something would then forced them out the windows which were about 7 1/2' tall. NO

What happened was the floors fractured at first into large chunks and were then the face the the collapsing debris floor mass. Each impact on a floor caused the mass of chunks about to get crushed finner. Imagine a bag or dishes dropping multiple times... First drop big chinks of plates and saucers and next drop they get smaller and so on until after 7 or 8 drops you have a lot of very small material... and after 20 iterations it lots of dust and it just gets crushed smaller and smaller. But of course the last impacted would be the large chunck on the pile/ makeing up the pile... the dust gets carried away on the hot air from the collapse.

The top sections floors became the ROOSD mass and dropped into to top section.. some spilled out the holes in the building.

Virtually ALL the material shooting out through the facade is NOT floor slab concrete.

I am not a skeptic
 
I suspect SFPM did get removed. Not much from the plane impact because not much of the plane impacted steel and left it in place. Some of it probably shook loose.... Maybe.
The plane impacts may have sent the building materials flying about and bashing the steel and knocking it off. Maybe. Things like flying gyp bd shaft walls, metal studs would do it.

A plane part... dunno...
 
I suspect SFPM did get removed. Not much from the plane impact because not much of the plane impacted steel and left it in place.


Do you consider the fuel mass as part of the plane? Purdue seems to think it had a greater effect on the structure then the NIST considered.
 
What did the lead designer say about this?

One would not know from the link he provides. No direct quotes there.

This is so 2003 that so far I find that Robertson said: "The two towers were the first structures outside of the military and nuclear industries designed to resist the impact of a jet airliner, the Boeing 707. It was assumed that the jetliner would be lost in the fog, seeking to land at JFK or at Newark." but the link provided at the site I was on is broken now.

Then there is this
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NgXvmMkpRpU

"the fuel load of a 707 was not considered" ,,,, "I don't know how it could've been considered",,,,, "707 was a landing aircraft"

Satisfied NOW FF?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom