gumboot
lorcutus.tolere
- Joined
- Jun 18, 2006
- Messages
- 25,327
Just as a backstory, the purpose behind the graphic - and jaydeehess is quite right, it's only a (very simple) graphic, not a scientific schematic - was to use as a reference point for erroneous observations about the collapse that muddied discussion and allowed truly ludicrous proposals to slip in. Things like claims that the structure was turned to dust, or that the entire lower portion of the building was pancaked by an intact upper section, and so on.
My primary source was video and photos of the actual collapse, photos of the debris field (particularly an enormous and sobering aerial photograph taken shortly after the collapse that showed the debris field in mind-blowing detail) with supporting input from eyewitness accounts mostly inside and above the collapse area.
The basic point was to establish that there were essentially three basic elements to the building; exterior columns, floor trusses, and core columns, and that each of these elements interacted with the collapse in different ways. If I did the graphic again I would probably improve it by making each of these three elements a different colour. (Admittedly that confession reveals that my original statement that I see no reason to modify it is a lie!).
The critical thing it attempted to show was basically that the collapse initiation caused failure of the integration of the three main elements, causing the elements to break apart, detatch, and fail independently of each other. The failure of each element in turn led to failure of the other elements. As a result of this structural integrity was irreversibly undermined the moment the collapse started.
It certainly wasn't intended as anything detailed or scientific, but enough to help a layman decipher the apparent chaos of the event. As an example, without any sort of knowledge the debris field just looks like a random mess of building, but if you are familiar with the structural elements you recognise that floor truss, core column and exterior column debris form three distinct debris fields, and these alone tell us quite a lot about how the collapse progressed - namely that the floor trusses collapsed vertically onto each other with tremendous force, that the exterior columns peeled away from the structure and fell outwards in large swathes, and that the core structure failed last. Watching video of the collapse confirms these three distinct behaviours.
My primary source was video and photos of the actual collapse, photos of the debris field (particularly an enormous and sobering aerial photograph taken shortly after the collapse that showed the debris field in mind-blowing detail) with supporting input from eyewitness accounts mostly inside and above the collapse area.
The basic point was to establish that there were essentially three basic elements to the building; exterior columns, floor trusses, and core columns, and that each of these elements interacted with the collapse in different ways. If I did the graphic again I would probably improve it by making each of these three elements a different colour. (Admittedly that confession reveals that my original statement that I see no reason to modify it is a lie!).
The critical thing it attempted to show was basically that the collapse initiation caused failure of the integration of the three main elements, causing the elements to break apart, detatch, and fail independently of each other. The failure of each element in turn led to failure of the other elements. As a result of this structural integrity was irreversibly undermined the moment the collapse started.
It certainly wasn't intended as anything detailed or scientific, but enough to help a layman decipher the apparent chaos of the event. As an example, without any sort of knowledge the debris field just looks like a random mess of building, but if you are familiar with the structural elements you recognise that floor truss, core column and exterior column debris form three distinct debris fields, and these alone tell us quite a lot about how the collapse progressed - namely that the floor trusses collapsed vertically onto each other with tremendous force, that the exterior columns peeled away from the structure and fell outwards in large swathes, and that the core structure failed last. Watching video of the collapse confirms these three distinct behaviours.

