Summary of WTC tower collapses

Fire made them fail first, then the weight of the building did.

Fire made every support column fail at once? Really?

I based my feeling on the pretty well established common knowledge that steel doesn't fare well in fire.
If steel doesn't fare well in a fire, then why use it as a building material? If it does not fare well in a fire, then why haven't more steel-framed buildings collapsed from fire? Oh, I forgot. Firefighting. Yeah, right.
 
FF,
Nothing ever wrong with having questions and asking them.. and expecting to receive a decent answer. It's probably a healthy thing to question because that leads to understanding.

It appears that there is misunderstand about what NIST did and what their objective was. Accordingly what they published in their reports contains errors, is incomplete, are hypotheses explaining the collapses and is not intended to be proofs. NIST had to use assumptions and values to generate their studies and models. Hulsey will be doing the same. Absent a complete data set all models will produce a resulted limited by and constrained by the assumptions used.

I personally, find their "initiations" to the progression of runaway mechanical failures.. their so called global collapse not satisfying. They may have nailed it. But the complexity of the events means that the unwinding of these buildings could have had a different path.. could have begun in a different location for example. But ultimately all hypotheses need to produce an outcome which matches the visuals...and sounds which is all we have to check the model.

The effects of uncontrolled fires on steel is well known. Same for concrete and other materials. Steel will weaken, will expand, concrete will weaken and spald. Other materials will ignite and burn.

Building have systems to mitigate the effects of fire... steel has insulation and there are sprinklers to cool and extinguish fires. if the suppression systems fail then the fire will do its thing... the materials will lose strength, integrity, distort by twisting, sagging, breaking and so on.

Connection elements are not as strong as the things they connect. It's absurd to expect every single component down to a bolt or a weld to have the strength of the beams and columns and plates and so on they join. It's pretty clear from examining the WTC debris that connections failures played a huge part in the complete collapse of the buildings.

Of course there was the force of gravity which drove the PROGRESSIVE collapse in most cases. This required a threshold mass large enough to destroy the connections etc. on the components upon which they fell for the collapse to proceed in a downward runaway fashion. Buildings with few floors are not given to progressive downward runaway collapse, facade peel, or columns toppling from being too slender when stripped of their bracing. To collapse the low rise structures would require undermining of the structure at the bottom.

The form of a gravity driven collapse is in the "DNA" of the structural design... and were the initial failures are.

Total collapses are usually progressive events. Parts of the structure fail and the mass to be supported has not changed so the other parts of the structure assume additional loads. Structures are designed to perform well below the yield strength and ever component has a "factor of safety" though none is expected to have the same value of FOS. However as parts of the structure fail, and loads are carried by parts of the remaining structure... those redistributed loads will push the factor of safety lower to members and connections seeing new and increased loads. This can eventually lead to the service loads seen as exceeding the yield strength and another connection or member fails... loads ger redistributed and the cycle will repeat especially during the period of constant heat being added which weakens and distorts and fails elements of the remaining structure. The process progresses at an increasing speed and becomes runaway and can involve the entire structure if the design does not have a means to ISOLATE the failures laterally. Ronan Point did... the twin towers' and 7wtc did not.

We will never know precisely how the the failures progressed. There is no time related data. There are no proofs. The hypotheses are driven by the visual record and the design along with understanding of how materials perform under mechanical loads and thermal stress.


And as in a CD... it is gravity which is the main destroyer. Once threshold mass is deprived of designated axial load paths... collapse will be ensue... locally and possibly globally. This is settle science. Gage and his dropping blocks is a prime example of dumb and failing to understand and take into account the structure, engineering and mechanics on the required level.

There is much to learn from engineers, physicists, critical thinkers who have studied and written about these collapse.

If you really want to learn the material is out there on this and other sites like 911 freeforum.

If you want to remain steeped in ignorance and junk science and confirmation boas because you believe everything the media and gov says is a lie... you will not learn a thing.

I have just now seen this post. Please give me time to read it, understand it and then reply. I am not ignoring you.
 
Fire made every support column fail at once? Really?

Who said they did? Some failed an hour or so before the building collapsed.


If steel doesn't fare well in a fire, then why use it as a building material?

Because it's strong, when it's not heated up.

If it does not fare well in a fire, then why haven't more steel-framed buildings collapsed from fire? Oh, I forgot. Firefighting. Yeah, right.
And here you suggest that a building that's on fire, and has no effort to suppress the fire, should fare just as well as a building where the fire is being fought - assuming identical construction.

:crazy:
 
FF.. My credentials in these issues don't matter.

I am a practicing architect.
I worked for the architects of the WTC in 1970
I do no design high rise buildings
I have been in the twin towers scores of times
I have worked with Ed DiPaola's engineering firm Severud (structural engineers) who visited the site post collapse and wrote after reports
I have worked with Guy Nordenson who also wrote a brief in support of a lawsuit alleging there were design flaws in WTC7.
I have been associated with AE911T for less than 6 months beginning in Fall '09 and was appointed to their board. I was tossed out because I was seeking the truth not interested in promoting the bullet points and incorrect points in their Blueprint for Truth and that nano thermite was responsible for the collapse.
I have attended numerous Truth events, communicated with several present and former truthers such as Harrit and Gordon Ross.
I have produced scores of my own graphics about the WTC collapses
I don't publish nor speak at conferences about 911.
I am just a dumb old architect

I am convinced that there was no CD and the collapses were caused by mechanical damage and uncontrolled fires.

Thanks for providing this. I will now give much more thought to your posts. I know I will be attacked for saying this, but I want to make it perfectly clear that everything you say will carry much more weight that you think it does.

That being said, I am still not convinced. I am only saying this now to show you that I am looking over your posts right now. I am not ignoring you. You have put quite a bit of thought in your posts, and they deserve a meaningful response.
 
Because it's strong, when it's not heated up.
Engineers know that buildings catch on fire. If steel was so problematic, why would they keep using it?

And here you suggest that a building that's on fire, and has no effort to suppress the fire, should fare just as well as a building where the fire is being fought - assuming identical construction.
:crazy:
I have never said this. You are only making an assumption.
 
Thanks for providing this. I will now give much more thought to your posts. I know I will be attacked for saying this, but I want to make it perfectly clear that everything you say will carry much more weight that you think it does.

That being said, I am still not convinced. I am only saying this now to show you that I am looking over your posts right now. I am not ignoring you. You have put quite a bit of thought in your posts, and they deserve a meaningful response.

Nope. Your actual problem is that you did not expect to find a motley assortment of actual pilots, architects, scientists and engineers who know for a fact that your baloney claims, are in fact baloney.

You thought a priori that you were dealing with others who were as ignorant of science and physics as you proudly claim to be. You thought that you were dealing with laymen like yourself.

The last thing you expected was to confront subject matter experts, right here.
 
Engineers know that buildings catch on fire. If steel was so problematic, why would they keep using it?

Because they knew other engineers that made this stuff you can put on the steel to protect it. It's interestingly called "fireproofing", something of a misnomer though, as it doesn't make it impervious to fire indefinitely.


I have never said this. You are only making an assumption.

You absolutely did, when you minimize the role of firefighting. You said exactly that.
 
Engineers know that buildings catch on fire. If steel was so problematic, why would they keep using it?
.

1) They did not expect a loss of a significant number of columns due to aircraft impact PLUS a widespread fire attack on these structures. It was not designed in anticipation of that.

2) The structure's passive fire resistance was somewhat compromised by aircraft impact, something again not taken into account in design.

3) The structure's active fire fighting was compromised, water supplies to affected floors was destroyed.

However, had you deigned to read the FEMA and/or NIST reports, you'd already have known this.
 
The material coming horizontally out the windows (broken) is basically the clg tiles, gyp bd partitions, particle board furniture, carpets and all things which were not strong and strongly attached to the structure.

OK. I completely understand your statement. I am not rejecting it. I simply have a question.

Please watch this video. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y9-owhllM9k
Around 30 seconds the collapse becomes visible enough to clearly see smoke and pulverized building contents being laterally ejected. Are you claiming that what I see is pulverized ceiling tiles, gypsum board, particle board, furniture and all the things that were not strong and attached to the structure immediately after the collapse started? Are you claiming that all of this material consists of what you mentioned, but no floor material? If so, where are the floors?

At 54 seconds you can clearly see the top portion of the building is nearly gone. Where did the floors go, if they are not part of the pulverized contents?

The air speed reached as much as 400 mph if you calculate how fast the air around the core on the long span side (60' from the facade) moved in about 0.1 seconds.

Are you sure floors would have caused this? Could anything else explain the airspeed you claim?
 
1) They did not expect a loss of a significant number of columns due to aircraft impact PLUS a widespread fire attack on these structures. It was not designed in anticipation of that.

Wrong. Absolutely wrong. WTC1 and WTC2 were designed to withstand the impact of a Boeing 707. The buildings did not collapse after the initial impact; therefore, they performed as they were designed to do.

2) The structure's passive fire resistance was somewhat compromised by aircraft impact, something again not taken into account in design.

Wrong. Please provide the NIST experiment that relates to fireproofing and aircraft impacts.

However, had you deigned to read the FEMA and/or NIST reports, you'd already have known this.

I have, which is why I have pointed out your errors.
 
Wrong. Absolutely wrong. WTC1 and WTC2 were designed to withstand the impact of a Boeing 707. The buildings did not collapse after the initial impact; therefore, they performed as they were designed to do.

Is this a direct quote from the lead designer? Do you need one or do you think he lies too.........
 
Another thing you can see in the GIF is that the outside material falling through air at close to FF is moving faster than the ejections down the side of the building. The floor collapse withing the tower is SLOWER than FF.

And you can see material from the collapse coming out of several floors as its volume was quite large at the levels seen in the GIF.

Not that it matters, but I want to go on record saying that I agree with your observation. Actually it does matter, because it proves that I don't reject everything a skeptic says.

Some questions:
Don't you find it odd that it appears that the pulverized building contents are being produced at roughly the same rate? Don't you find it odd that the pulverized contents are being ejected approximately the same distance as well? It's almost like there is a new column of constant width at a constant distance falling faster than the part in the footprint. What explains such a uniform creation of pulverized contents?
 
Is this a direct quote from the lead designer? Do you need one or do you think he lies too.........

If you are tying to prove I am wrong, why is it so hard for you to provide a link, or anything, other than your own statement claiming I am wrong?
 
So far I have only encountered one "expert" who might have credibility. You are not that expert.

What are your credentials to make such a judgment? None.

How do I know that? Because you told us you have none.

I provided mine. You provided nothing but fantasies.
 
Yes, some columns are standing while the floors are pulverized and ejected laterally. You should really stop saying that they fall. It makes people assume that everything came straight down. That is not what happened.

I also see pulverized building contents being generated and ejected laterally at a near constant rate. Do you see that too?
What you see being ejected is mostly lighter contents including a hell of a lot of pulverized gypsum board. I see absolutely no evidence that concrete floor pans are being ejected laterally.

I also wonder what the laws of physics tell us when something continues to accelerate as it falls. What do the laws of physics say about this? Something about apparent weight. Hmmm. Could that be a clue? If something is accelerating, what is it's apparent weight? Is it more or less than its static weight? Hmmm. Could the answers to these questions be clues?

Nah. Nothing to see here.

If something continues to accelerate as it falls it means that the forces directed downwards are greater than any forces acting in the opposite direction.

In the Earth's gravity well an object that is falling AT g would have an 'apparent weight' of zero, or weightless. However when it impacts something the force of impact is not zero. If you throw a cannonball into the air and let it fall on your head it will be weightless on the way down but be far from having zero force when it hits your head. In fact it will hit with more force than if you simply balanced it on your head. That is because its momentum must be imparted to your head over a period of time and momentum transferred over time IS force. Its actually the way Newton described his Second Law of Motion in his Principia Mathmatica. The change in momentum over change in time.
 
If you are tying to prove I am wrong, why is it so hard for you to provide a link, or anything, other than your own statement claiming I am wrong?
Does the lead designer say the building was designed to withstand the crash of a 707? Yes or no?

You claim it was.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom