Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

You don't out-and-out say it, but just in case, if you think Trixie is a mod, I must disabuse you of that notion. It may not appear to be the case, but we have standards.

Merc,
How high could those standards be? I mean, YOU'RE a mod....
 
We can at least pretend it is so.

Let's horse trade.

Consider anything I said that you found inappropriate to be retracted. And an apology offered.

From your end, please gather 29 of your Internet friends and go to the Forum Community and vote for my Hooftie The Buckling post for the TLA award in May. I'm way behind.

Hooftie is buried in an unmarked grave and you know that's not very jake. Bad things can happen. So, with my TLA jackpot, I plan on traveling to the Adirondacks, locating Hoofie's burial site and adorning same with an appropriate marker.
 
Merc,
How high could those standards be? I mean, YOU'RE a mod....

I am grandfathered in from the olde days, when such abominable cockups could be blamed on Hal. "Standards", in those days, involved a powdered wig and tights. Or maybe a codpiece, I don't really remember; it has been a while.
 
Fair enough. If nothing else the fact that she refuses to provide documentation for her claimed success rate or to take these sorts of tests should be food for thought.

I'd also like to point out that even finding ONE lost child, alive or dead, is worthy, and if she did that it wouldn't matter to me if her success rate was once in a lifetime. If she has in fact found a missing person or solved a crime, everyone here would like to see the evidence, and Robert has said many times that he will put it on his website.

If there were a smoking gun (i.e.: getting the name and location of a murderer, or finding a child before the police could do it) which absolutely proved Sylvia was a true psychic, then I would stop any doubt, even if she got dozens of other cases dead wrong. I just kind of presumed that at least some level of strong evidence existed before.
 
I just kind of presumed that at least some level of strong evidence existed before.

Now that you have seen there is neither strong nor weak evidence in existence, what's your opinion on Browne? And what's your revised opinion on Robert Lancaster?
 
You know, I think it may be instructive to SylviaRox to see that we are not a monolithic group here, all goose-stepping to the R&R beat of Robert and Randi. I'm glad that so many of us are fighting, sneering, squabbling, teasing and laughing at each other.

That's the thing. We may all (or mostly) claim to be skeptics, but that hardly make us a cult. We're just people who share some traits and clash on others. Just like real people.

So keep it up, all you snarkshooters. We are family. And, if my family is any indication, families fight a lot.

Hang around, SR. You'll see a lot worse. The good news is that there are only a very few homophobes here. That was bravely spoken, by the way. I'm impressed.

You know...some people (uh oh, I said "some people" again) have seemed to suggest that Sylvia or NS is a cult...I really have to disagree. If you look at the basic tenets of the group as listed on Sylvia's website, they are pretty positive and affirmative ideas and don't have the standard 'closing you off from the real world' characteristics of cults. But it was the strength (unproven, yes) of her psychic powers which made me take her religious ideas much more seriously than I otherwise would have.
 
You know...some people (uh oh, I said "some people" again) have seemed to suggest that Sylvia or NS is a cult...I really have to disagree. If you look at the basic tenets of the group as listed on Sylvia's website, they are pretty positive and affirmative ideas and don't have the standard 'closing you off from the real world' characteristics of cults. But it was the strength (unproven, yes) of her psychic powers which made me take her religious ideas much more seriously than I otherwise would have.

There are several people here who are former NS members. I would suggest you speak with them before forming any conclusions as to whether or not it's a cult.
 
You know...some people (uh oh, I said "some people" again) have seemed to suggest that Sylvia or NS is a cult...I really have to disagree. If you look at the basic tenets of the group as listed on Sylvia's website, they are pretty positive and affirmative ideas and don't have the standard 'closing you off from the real world' characteristics of cults. But it was the strength (unproven, yes) of her psychic powers which made me take her religious ideas much more seriously than I otherwise would have.

That actually brings up something that I personally have wondered for quite some time. I wonder how many of her ministers begin that path because of her (yes, unproven) psychic powers and how many just due to her professed religious ideas.
At one time I believed in Sylvia and was considering her religious ideas simply because I believed that she was really psychic.
Anyway, I'm glad you're sticking around SylviaRox. This is a great place to be!
 
If there were a smoking gun (i.e.: getting the name and location of a murderer, or finding a child before the police could do it) which absolutely proved Sylvia was a true psychic, then I would stop any doubt, even if she got dozens of other cases dead wrong. I just kind of presumed that at least some level of strong evidence existed before.

Well done SylviaRox. And now you have answered an earlier question. Why do so many people believe in Sylvia Browne when there is no proof? The answer is that most people also believe that if she is so famous and ect... then there must be proof, thousands of people can't be wrong, can they? I mean she appears all over the TV, at least someone (Montel - Larry King) must have some proof and the rest of us just hasn't seen it yet?

It's like reading a really really long thread from the beginning. But you are lazy and just read a few here and there and then the last posts. You see at the end that something amazing happened so there must have been something in-between. You are just taking the word of all those people in the middle that there was something, maybe there wasn't anything and everyone is duped?

Penn & Teller did this "Amazing Indian Rope Trick" in India for their magic tour, they brought in two unsuspecting tourists into a set staged just for the tourists. The rope dropped just as the tourists got in and everyone in the "audience" applauded. The tourists left feeling like they had seen the trick done successfully. The "audience" felt so special that they were "in on it" that they didn't want to give it away. Now nearly everyone believes that the trick was done and it is spreading all over that area.

Sylvia Browne's "audience" also feels special, they may have not yet felt that they should challenge their beliefs. Did they see her get away with something? I'm sure they have many times but "everyone has an off day, next time she will do it for reals, besides she is doing so much good for the world, if I expose this then I will be out of her inner-circle, and maybe harm her" I'm sure if they approached her and asked for an explanation she would give one. At least one good enough to keep them from asking again.

Susan
 
If there were a smoking gun (i.e.: getting the name and location of a murderer, or finding a child before the police could do it) which absolutely proved Sylvia was a true psychic, then I would stop any doubt, even if she got dozens of other cases dead wrong. I just kind of presumed that at least some level of strong evidence existed before.

Interesting...do you ever wonder (irrespective of SB) that with all of the psychic claims of helping police find a body or solve a crime, there aren't police officers and investigators coming forward not only asking for help but praising psychic help? Scotland Yard, the FBI and every major police force that I am aware of, not only say that there are no investigations that have been solved as a result of psychic insights, they say that psychic help is actually a distraction.

Just note, had the police tried to follow SB's suggestions in the Hornbeck case, who would they have arrested or put under suspicion, someone named Michael who in every other detail -- including the crime of murder -- would have been completely innocent.

Does it concern you, after reading the details of the Hornbeck case, that Sylvia's help not only caused the parents extreme distress, but could have, if heeded by police, hurt the investigation and put an otherwise innocent "Michael" under suspicion because he fit a completely bogus discription? And, as you think about that, think about other "psychics" and their "help" to police investigations...as well as what they do to families desperate for any information.

In the end, SB claims to have helped solve police cases...part of her 85+% success rate, I assume...do you at all wonder why she doesn't name the cases she's helped solve? It can't be about client privacy or confidenitality, as criminal cases are a matter of public record.
 
Minarvia,
I never paid much attention to SB's psychic claims although that it was always something I couldn't get away from in spiritual discussion groups that concentrated on her work...no matter how hard I tried.
I like the philosophy of an all-loving God and the general "do unto others" and "the reason for being" factor of it all but many people were only interested in the psychic aspect.

TBT
 
I would agree that it's not a cult if a necessary characteristic of a cult is separating members from their family and normal society (and I think it is).

The term "cult" should not be applied to any upstart religion.

I think there's plenty of evidence that it's a scam though--not from the perspective of branch congregations, but from the HQ. If Sylvia really weren't in this just for the money, and was sincere in all her claims, she could easily take JREF's million dollars and then disseminate all her NS materials for free, or at least at reduced prices.

On the other hand, I think most religions are or have been scams at least at some point in their histories I frequently find myself sort of defending things like NS whenever I hear a member of a more conventional religion badmouthing them. As far as I'm concerned, once you take something on faith (defined as believing something when there is no evidence), there's no way you can filter out belief in ANYthing else.
 
Now that you have seen there is neither strong nor weak evidence in existence, what's your opinion on Browne? And what's your revised opinion on Robert Lancaster?
Now, now, don’t make him say “uncle”, too.

I think this is really cool. A defender of a woo camp examines his position, finds the evidence lacking, and adjusts his position based on the facts.
If that sums it up, kudos for you, SR!

Future skeptic perhaps?:D
 
Sorry, just thought of something. I imagine that her inner-circle really does know she is a fraud. I know from what was said on SSB site that she does not go into the office all that often, but works from home. But she has had some people work for her for over 20 years. What would that be like to always have "believers" in her office all the time. I mean people would always be stopping by her office to ask her stupid questions, like "so who is going to win on XXXX show tonight Sylvia?" or "should I move my car so I don't get a ticket" or "Sylvia, do you think that the bakery next door has any of those chocolate donuts left from the morning rush, I hate to ask but I don't want to go all the way over there just to find them gone, besides I will bring you back some too".

Wouldn't that be hell to be surrounded by those people. And if she didn't answer all these questions then they might grow resentful (because they got a parking ticket, or walked to the bakery for no reason ect...). And from listening to some of her past readings, she does get into details like this, I mean is the spirit world really concerned with donuts and parking tickets?

Just my last two cents, off to work now to hang out with my believers

Susan
 
Just note, had the police tried to follow SB's suggestions in the Hornbeck case, who would they have arrested or put under suspicion, someone named Michael who in every other detail -- including the crime of murder -- would have been completely innocent.
They did. No arrests (or really any results at all), but they wasted time and money searching the woods to the southwest, looking for the two "stupid" rocks that would indicate the burial spot.

I'm not saying that anything else productive could have been done on the Hornbeck case at that time, but surely there was plenty of work to be done on other cases that was at least postponed to check out this info.
 
They did. No arrests (or really any results at all), but they wasted time and money searching the woods to the southwest, looking for the two "stupid" rocks that would indicate the burial spot.

I'm not saying that anything else productive could have been done on the Hornbeck case at that time, but surely there was plenty of work to be done on other cases that was at least postponed to check out this info.

I don't know that anything could have been done in the Hornbeck case...given what in fact went on. But, to the extent that the police spent anytime following down SB's claims --even if just 20 minutes -- it was 20 minutes misdirected and away from the real criminal. And that is, in part my point, even if you credit her with getting Michael as a psychic development (given the proof of the popularity of Michael as a male name, a highly doubious conclusion), what ever else she had to say was not only wrong, it was dangerously wrong and could have severly derailed an investigation. It is irrelevent that the investigation was thwarted on other grounds...SB's help, IMO, was bordering on obstruction of justice...maybe not legally, but certainly morally.

My question to SR is this: Am I wrong? Given how wrong SB was, wasn't her alleged revelation so wrong as to have diverted the investigation to the extent that it was heeded? And, if she knew it to be wrong...i.e. she knows she hasn't any "power"...isn't she ethically and morally reprehensible -- not to mention the pain she put the parents through?

And, if she is morally and ethically reprehsible in this situation...we have to assume she knows she is a fake, BTW, because she won't provide any usable evidence to counter that assumption...isn't she, in fact, morally and ethically reprhensible every time she gives a "reading" that someone believes?
 
You know...some people (uh oh, I said "some people" again) have seemed to suggest that Sylvia or NS is a cult...I really have to disagree. If you look at the basic tenets of the group as listed on Sylvia's website, they are pretty positive and affirmative ideas and don't have the standard 'closing you off from the real world' characteristics of cults. But it was the strength (unproven, yes) of her psychic powers which made me take her religious ideas much more seriously than I otherwise would have.

I'm relying on memory so I could be wrong, but the mention of "cult" I recall on this thread was a joke someone made about "any cult deprogammers here?", which I responded to in the same spirit. My assumption of the post was that it made reference to the fervent belief you displayed in your earlier posts.

I don't think NS is displaying traditional cult practices, but I have very limited knowledge of their practices so it's just a guess. As for the philosophy itself, I'll save that for another thread. I think some of the former Novus members are best suited to offer their insights in this particular discussion, as some have already.
 
There are several people here who are former NS members. I would suggest you speak with them before forming any conclusions as to whether or not it's a cult.

Yes, there are many of us here, and I can say that just because SB or the Board Members of NS say that they are not a cult doesn't make it so. Afterall, don't most cult leaders openly claim that they are not a cult?

The more that one studies the workings and organization of NS, the more one can compare it to scientology.

Now, for the average layperson and study group member, this is not evident since there is so little contact between them and the "office" in Campbell. But, as one progresses in NS, becomes more known, becomes more involved, and breaks through the shield of secrecy, more evidence of NS being a cult of control and dominance becomes evident.

I have spoken about this with many ex-NS people, and all have pretty much come to the same conclusion.

Like any "religion", you put the good stuff up for the public, never how it really is.

I went through one of the Journey of the Soul Books, Topic 8, NS, last night and compared how SB said NS was to how it really is, and it is two totally different things. And one very glaring, telling are is when SB talks about her dream of 20 years (which was in 1986, so it would put her dream at 41 years now) of building a hospice, an old peoples home, centers for healing, for helping children, etc..... and not one of these things have been done, even though there is more than enough money brought in to cover all of these, and many more.

Is NS a cult? Yes, and one only needs to read the tread about NS being a Cult on the GSB site to see that yes, NS is.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom