Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

Not contesting that it was anything but a cold reading 'hit', I would just like to say that in spite of its consistent popularity for a few decades, Michael (as a name...and moreso, my own name) has varied year by year in where it came in the top twenty names, so it's incorrect to say it has been the most popular name for decades.

It's only fair that we be careful with such claims. We'd expect the same from any claimant.

BTW, SylviaRox, I'll add my respect to the list. It does take strength to admit where the weakness in your beliefs lie. As you see, we don't all agree here either. We don't worship any one individual as having the answers. We don't need to. Reason and evidence speaks for us instead.

I hope you stick around to see how these things work. Reason is an amazing thing.

Athon
 
1. I was possibly wrong about the GSB guestbook issue. It seems unlikely it was Lancaster who planned or directed it, although it is probable that Lancaster's article and posts were what brought the site to the attention of some here. I apologize.

2. I do not know for sure whether or not Lancaster has violated any copyright issues. It is possible he hasn't but I would think that Lancaster has a very liberal conception of fair use. I apologize.

3. Sylvia got Devlin's first name right, which is still unlikely despite the fact it is a popular name, but she did not get his physical appearance and King was confused/mistaken.

4. Lancaster is wrong to claim that all of the guests on Exploring Psychic Powers Live spoke English, but this is only the phrasing of one sentence as part of the larger article whose general message is honest.

5. It is also wrong to make false predictions or statements to a victim's family if one is not absolutely sure of their correctness. If Sylvia is not genuinely confident about her predictions to these people then there is a problem.

6. I cannot verify or prove the 85% success rate. It is possibly not true.

7. I have falsely linked in my mind certain people and things which are not fair to link: specifically the investigations that Lancaster has done into Sylvia/Novus with the attitude towards religion that people in the skeptical community like Dawkins, Randi and some of the posters here have. I apologize then for any general rudeness.

8. Thank you angrybeliever, DJM, randfan and kittynh.

WOW! :clap:
 
Not contesting that it was anything but a cold reading 'hit', I would just like to say that in spite of its consistent popularity for a few decades, Michael (as a name...and moreso, my own name) has varied year by year in where it came in the top twenty names, so it's incorrect to say it has been the most popular name for decades.

Where's your source?

Year/Ranking
2006 2
2005 2
2004 2
2003 2
2002 2
2001 2
2000 2
1999 2
1998 1
1997 1
1996 1
1995 1
1994 1
1993 1
1992 1
1991 1
1990 1
1989 1
1988 1
1987 1
1986 1
1985 1
1984 1
1983 1
1982 1
1981 1
1980 1
1979 1
1978 1
1977 1
1976 1
1975 1
1974 1
1973 1
1972 1
1971 1
1970 1
1969 1
1968 1
1967 1
1966 1
1965 1
1964 1
1963 1
1962 1
1961 1
1960 2
1959 1
1958 1
1957 1

Type in "Michael" at the popularity index and set for 50 years (You can go back further, but I think this proves the point.)

Source: http://www.ssa.gov/OACT/babynames/
 
Where's your source?



Type in "Michael" at the popularity index and set for 50 years (You can go back further, but I think this proves the point.)

Source: http://www.ssa.gov/OACT/babynames/

Bloody Yanks. :) Ok, I was going on Australia, where they've varied over past decades. To have a consistently popular name...Christ, where does your country get its imagination from?

I stand corrected.

Athon
 
Bloody Yanks. :) Ok, I was going on Australia, where they've varied over past decades. To have a consistently popular name...Christ, where does your country get its imagination from?

I stand corrected.

I seems like you basing it on good data, but not germaine data.
http://www.ocba.sa.gov.au/bdm/babynames.html
I only checked 1997 and 1998 and Michael dropped from 7 to 18 in just that one year.
Here's NSW's site and it appears the same.
http://www.bdm.nsw.gov.au/births/popularBabyNames.htm
(sorry, couldn't find a nationwide site)
 
1. I was possibly wrong about the GSB guestbook issue. It seems unlikely it was Lancaster who planned or directed it, although it is probable that Lancaster's article and posts were what brought the site to the attention of some here. I apologize.

2. I do not know for sure whether or not Lancaster has violated any copyright issues. It is possible he hasn't but I would think that Lancaster has a very liberal conception of fair use. I apologize.

3. Sylvia got Devlin's first name right, which is still unlikely despite the fact it is a popular name, but she did not get his physical appearance and King was confused/mistaken.

4. Lancaster is wrong to claim that all of the guests on Exploring Psychic Powers Live spoke English, but this is only the phrasing of one sentence as part of the larger article whose general message is honest.

5. It is also wrong to make false predictions or statements to a victim's family if one is not absolutely sure of their correctness. If Sylvia is not genuinely confident about her predictions to these people then there is a problem.

6. I cannot verify or prove the 85% success rate. It is possibly not true.

7. I have falsely linked in my mind certain people and things which are not fair to link: specifically the investigations that Lancaster has done into Sylvia/Novus with the attitude towards religion that people in the skeptical community like Dawkins, Randi and some of the posters here have. I apologize then for any general rudeness.

8. Thank you angrybeliever, DJM, randfan and kittynh.

By and large that's a very cool post, SR. Respect!
 
I seems like you basing it on good data, but not germaine data.
http://www.ocba.sa.gov.au/bdm/babynames.html
I only checked 1997 and 1998 and Michael dropped from 7 to 18 in just that one year.
Here's NSW's site and it appears the same.
http://www.bdm.nsw.gov.au/births/popularBabyNames.htm
(sorry, couldn't find a nationwide site)

I'm not sure where you'd find a national register. Most of births, deaths and marriages in Australia are of state registration.

I admit I didn't stop to think about the US being so consistent when I know here the top ten names change from year to year in each state. They tend to publish them in the newspapers as a public interest story around Christmas time.

Athon
 
Thank you Linda for confirming that indeed Ms. Browne and the rest of you couldn't help but come to this forum to have a voice.

Your words fall on deaf ears my dear woman.

Greetings from the good Doctor.

Linda, I know your sentence structure and syntax well enough to sniff you out.
:)
 
Last edited:
Thank you Linda for confirming that indeed Ms. Browne and the rest of you couldn't help but come to this forum to have a voice.

Your words fall on deaf ears my dear woman.

Greetings from the good Dr. Linda.
:)
Perhaps there's an explanation for this post? If so, may we have it?
 
It appears to be:

Ground Beast Samwich is infering the he or she is someone "in the know" with regards to Sylvia Browne and her corporations, and recognizes the original poster as being someone from the said orginization, who's real name is Linda. Ground Beast Samwich is therefore "outing" her to us.

I've only been here a couple of months, but I know this place well enough to know that even something that juicy to those who are against Sylvia Browne will not be accepted blindly and unchallenged.
 
Last edited:
Bravo, this is a big step. Forward.

1. I was possibly wrong about the GSB guestbook issue. It seems unlikely it was Lancaster who planned or directed it, although it is probable that Lancaster's article and posts were what brought the site to the attention of some here. I apologize.
I believe that there are none of us JREFers who wish to be so childish as to "trash" other forums. We may not like what they say, but one of our abiding strengths is that we are prepared to allow others to have their own voice. Even at our own expense. (Besides, have you seen the politics subforum? We beat each other up enough there as it is!)

2. I do not know for sure whether or not Lancaster has violated any copyright issues. It is possible he hasn't but I would think that Lancaster has a very liberal conception of fair use. I apologize.
Rob is always scrupulously fair (see point above). If anyone has an issue with what he has posted, I'm sure he would allow them to comment to him directly.

3. Sylvia got Devlin's first name right, which is still unlikely despite the fact it is a popular name, but she did not get his physical appearance and King was confused/mistaken.
A popular misconception among many people that is VERY hard to shake is that the more people, and the more famous people, who endorse a stand regardless of their lack of expertise, the more likely it is to be "true". It is fallen for time out of number...and is infuriating!

4. Lancaster is wrong to claim that all of the guests on Exploring Psychic Powers Live spoke English, but this is only the phrasing of one sentence as part of the larger article whose general message is honest.
I won't re-ignite that dicsussion...

5. It is also wrong to make false predictions or statements to a victim's family if one is not absolutely sure of their correctness. If Sylvia is not genuinely confident about her predictions to these people then there is a problem.
And the depth of this particular problem is horrific.

6. I cannot verify or prove the 85% success rate. It is possibly not true.
I suggest you research this some more yourself to find any evidence that supports the claim. Such research exercises are very enlightening, even for us skeptics! All sorts of fallacies come to light...

7. I have falsely linked in my mind certain people and things which are not fair to link: specifically the investigations that Lancaster has done into Sylvia/Novus with the attitude towards religion that people in the skeptical community like Dawkins, Randi and some of the posters here have. I apologize then for any general rudeness.
On this forum we have a very cosmopolitan mix of regulars - Christians, Buddhists, Jews, gnostics, agnostics, atheists, truckdrivers, etc, etc. Rudeness, and manners, cross all these boundaries, not run with them.

You will note you have not been edited, censored, or banned. So please feel free to continue to post here, and discuss to your heart's content!
 
Last edited:
The human ego. A truly fascinating thing.

Rox can take all of the time he cares to take as far as I'm concerned. I don't even care if he decides to keep on believing in Sylvia Browne. My ego is not so fragile that everyone has to agree with me.

I want people to make informed decisions. The problem, IMO, is that humans are not by and large critical thinkers. They also are often indoctrinated into their beliefs. Given the human need for many to believe and the importance of world view to individuals it easy for me to understand acceptance of scam artists like Sylvia Browne.

What I won't suffer is piss poor logic or being lectured to by some sycophant to the psychics who can't make a logically valid argument to support his or her claims.

So, rox, if you are reading this I don't care what you ultimately decide or how long it takes you to decide. I really, really don't. I just don't view the world that way. That said, if you come here in defense of Browne then get ready from some rough and tumble debate.

Is it so bloody hard to give people, even people you disagree with a long leech? I prefer to keep it cool and let people that are under a lot of pressure, (as SylviaRox obviously has been) be given some time to rest from the onslaught. There have been 13 pages of posts in a day that he must take into consideration, including some slander (not much) demands of evidence of Browne being right and Lancaster being wrong (very much) and nit-picking about what English-speaking really means. Calm down and drop the Jerry-Springer-guest behaviour.

Now I saw that SylviaRox did post a much better reply to a lot of the issues raised here, including the copyright infringement issue. That is great, and I do bear hope that this we can wrap this up peacefully.
 
SylviaRox, welcome to the forum.

Your latest post shows intellectual honesty and I certainly hope that you will stick around.


3. Sylvia got Devlin's first name right, which is still unlikely despite the fact it is a popular name, but she did not get his physical appearance and King was confused/mistaken.

If the name was the only thing Sylvia had mentioned then it would indeed have been unlikely, a probability of 4-5%. But it's important to take all the guesses into consideration, otherwise we can't estimate how good the reading has been. The wrong guesses include the state the boy was in, where the body would be found (in a forest near two large boulders), the appearance of the man; his skin colour, length of his hair, his hairdo, his height, how he was built, the brand of his car, features on the car, color of the car. This so-called shotgun approach is an important technique in cold reading, where a huge number of guesses are offered, in the hope that a few of them will turn out to be true or at least can be interpreted to be true with some ad hoc rationalizations. We expect by chance alone that a few of them will be true; in this case we only got a single hit, which is probably less than would be predicted by chance.

King's statement also clearly shows how dramatically results can be interpreted when the witness has rose-tinted glasses on. That believers have these habits of focusing on the hits and forgetting the misses combined with ad hoc rationalizations are important reasons why we can't trust anecdotal evidence in these cases.
 
1. I was possibly wrong about the GSB guestbook issue. It seems unlikely it was Lancaster who planned or directed it, although it is probable that Lancaster's article and posts were what brought the site to the attention of some here. I apologize.

2. I do not know for sure whether or not Lancaster has violated any copyright issues. It is possible he hasn't but I would think that Lancaster has a very liberal conception of fair use. I apologize.

3. Sylvia got Devlin's first name right, which is still unlikely despite the fact it is a popular name, but she did not get his physical appearance and King was confused/mistaken.

4. Lancaster is wrong to claim that all of the guests on Exploring Psychic Powers Live spoke English, but this is only the phrasing of one sentence as part of the larger article whose general message is honest.

5. It is also wrong to make false predictions or statements to a victim's family if one is not absolutely sure of their correctness. If Sylvia is not genuinely confident about her predictions to these people then there is a problem.

6. I cannot verify or prove the 85% success rate. It is possibly not true.

7. I have falsely linked in my mind certain people and things which are not fair to link: specifically the investigations that Lancaster has done into Sylvia/Novus with the attitude towards religion that people in the skeptical community like Dawkins, Randi and some of the posters here have. I apologize then for any general rudeness.

8. Thank you angrybeliever, DJM, randfan and kittynh.


Well, I'm impressed by the change in style and content. One small clarification on point 1: "it is probable that Lancaster's article and posts were what brought the site to the attention of some here". In fact, it appears to have been a link on Sylvia's own website that brought it to the attention of those from here who posted in the guestbook:
http://www.gosylviabrowne.com/

Has anyone seen this? Sylvia has a link to this site on her main page now.

See here for the whole thread.
 
Good for you.

However, it is not correct that it is "unlikely" that Sylvia got Devlin's first name right. It is not just a popular name, it is the single most popular name for decades.

I don't know. I do think that it is somewhat unlikely that the name would be correctly guessed, even given its popular status. It is the sort of prediction that, if a "psychic" could consistantly make predictions of similar difficulty, would be compelling evidence of real ability. However, when compared against her record, the obvious conclusion is that it was one of the inevitable hits that will crop up when guessing. Certainly the fact that this one hit occurs surrounded by a bunch of misses and/or unverifiable claims points to this.

So I would phrase it as follows: whilst it would be unlikely for Sylvia to get this one hit correct if looked at as an independent event, it is not unlikely (on the contrary it would be expected according to the laws of probability) that she would get a number of predictions of this type correct when enough guesses are made. (Fans and supporters, especially those who are desperate for some confirmation - grieving relatives being the obvious examples - will then cling onto these examples of hits whilst forgetting, or twisting what was said to make fit, the guesses that were incorrect.)

Oh, and SylviaRox it's heartening to see someone reconsider strongly held views in light of new evidence pointed out to them, especially after watching skeptics on this forum bang their heads against the walls in an attempt to get certain posters (*coughHuntstercough*) to actually look at what is being said. It's not easy to admit that you might have been mistaken, especially when you've been so vocal in your support of an opinion.
 
Not untrue, but look at the change of tone in the most recent post:



Could it be that Gary is starting to get the picture?

post #410 and I believe the first one to predict Gary's change, and the one which started the whole 'benefit of the doubt' debate. (I guess I am feeling left out of getting a pat on the back - meh)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom