Bravo, this is a big step. Forward.
1. I was possibly wrong about the GSB guestbook issue. It seems unlikely it was Lancaster who planned or directed it, although it is probable that Lancaster's article and posts were what brought the site to the attention of some here. I apologize.
I believe that there are none of us JREFers who wish to be so childish as to "trash" other forums. We may not like what they say, but one of our abiding strengths is that we are prepared to allow others to have their own voice. Even at our own expense. (Besides, have you seen the politics subforum? We beat each other up enough there as it is!)
2. I do not know for sure whether or not Lancaster has violated any copyright issues. It is possible he hasn't but I would think that Lancaster has a very liberal conception of fair use. I apologize.
Rob is always scrupulously fair (see point above). If anyone has an issue with what he has posted, I'm sure he would allow them to comment to him directly.
3. Sylvia got Devlin's first name right, which is still unlikely despite the fact it is a popular name, but she did not get his physical appearance and King was confused/mistaken.
A popular misconception among many people that is VERY hard to shake is that the more people, and the more
famous people, who endorse a stand
regardless of their lack of expertise, the more likely it is to be "true". It is fallen for time out of number...and is infuriating!
4. Lancaster is wrong to claim that all of the guests on Exploring Psychic Powers Live spoke English, but this is only the phrasing of one sentence as part of the larger article whose general message is honest.
I won't re-ignite that dicsussion...
5. It is also wrong to make false predictions or statements to a victim's family if one is not absolutely sure of their correctness. If Sylvia is not genuinely confident about her predictions to these people then there is a problem.
And the depth of this particular problem is horrific.
6. I cannot verify or prove the 85% success rate. It is possibly not true.
I suggest you research this some more yourself to find any evidence that supports the claim. Such research exercises are very enlightening, even for us skeptics! All sorts of fallacies come to light...
7. I have falsely linked in my mind certain people and things which are not fair to link: specifically the investigations that Lancaster has done into Sylvia/Novus with the attitude towards religion that people in the skeptical community like Dawkins, Randi and some of the posters here have. I apologize then for any general rudeness.
On this forum we have a very cosmopolitan mix of regulars - Christians, Buddhists, Jews, gnostics, agnostics, atheists, truckdrivers, etc, etc. Rudeness, and manners, cross all these boundaries, not run with them.
You will note you have not been edited, censored, or banned. So please feel free to continue to post here, and discuss to your heart's content!