Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

I am NOT a liar by omission because Lancaster has CONTINUALLY made it clear what his position is on this issue. Just examine the tone of StopSylviaBrowne.com, it is extremely anti-Sylvia and it is made obvious that the quotation I gave is how Lancaster really feels.
LOL. Boy, would I love to get you on a witness stand.
 
is his lie better or worse than your claim that she only makes "minor errors"

the man was speaking English, he was therefore an English speaker. You may quibble on the exact definition of this but you are stretching if you want to call it a deliberate lie.



Provide a link so we can see that phrase in context- you have been told how you can do this.

I'm sure that you wouldn't selectivity quote a phrase, which was asked as a question, as a positve statement would you?

That would be a little dishonest, don't you think?


I mean- for instance, taking the example of someone saying "Is she a well-intentioned spiritual leader, with actual psychic powers? Is she a fraud, making money by callously manipulating and using the bereaved? Or is she something else entirely?" and claiming that this is a positive claim that Sylvia is a fraud would border on a deliberate lie, wouldn't it?

I can say "Hello, how are you?" in French ("Bonjour, ça va?"). Does this make me a French speaker? Would you describe me as such to a friend or business partner? Yes or no?
 
I have already indicated to you that I am not here to defend Sylvia Browne's track record. I am here to show that Mr. Lancaster has lied about it.

We are having a difficult time knowing how to see that RSL has lied about it, if you can't show us that he has lied.

Simply stating that he lied doesn't mean he did, just as Larry King saying the description of Shawn Hornbeck's abductor being spot on doesn't mean it was.
 
I am NOT a liar by omission because Lancaster has CONTINUALLY made it clear what his position is on this issue. Just examine the tone of StopSylviaBrowne.com, it is extremely anti-Sylvia and it is made obvious that the quotation I gave is how Lancaster really feels.

Are you sure that Lancaster is making a point? Perhaps the evidence, which you yourself can verify, is making the point for him.
 
I can say "Hello, how are you?" in French ("Bonjour, ça va?"). Does this make me a French speaker? Would you describe me as such to a friend or business partner? Yes or no?

No, it does not. Can you move on to the other issues we are talking about?
 
I have already indicated to you that I am not here to defend Sylvia Browne's track record. I am here to show that Mr. Lancaster has lied about it.

??? this makes absolutely NO SENSE.

How could you possibly prove RSL is lying about sylvia brownes track record without discussing sb's track record?
 
I've asked three times now:

SylviaRox: Are you gong to respond to Robert's Direct and polite response to you in this thread at all?
 
SylviaRox, doesn't it bother you that Sylvia was lying when she said the entire audience was German?

I know you just want to talk about Robert's site in this thread.. but just curious about this issue.

Thanks.
 
Prewitt, I will state AGAIN that it is NOT my duty to DEFEND BROWNE'S track record. This thread is about LANCASTER, it is NOT another "let's attack Sylvia Browne and her followers" thread like the hundreds of others you people revel in.

Well, unfortunately for you, if you want to prove that Robert is engaging in lies and slander, you're going to have to prove that what he says about Sylvia Browne is incorrect.

So yes....It is your duty to defend Browne's track record.
 
Here it is again in case you missed it.
RSLancastr said:
Mr. Richardson:

Although I find it difficult to believe that your post is not a parody, I will take you at your word that it is not, and will respond to your points.

I am sure an admin will delete this message because it disagrees with the stated goals of the JREF. I feel I must post it anyway.
While some other forums (such as the "Go Sylvia browne" forum) routinely delete posts by those with opinions which strongly differ from those of the site's owner, it is not the policy of the JREF forum to do so. So long as a person sticks to board rules about profanity and a few other things, neither you nor your posts will be deleted.

Besides, the primary stated goal of the JREF is education, and the discussions which arise from differing opinions can be very educational, sometimes for people on both sides of the discussion.

Stop Robert S. Lancaster, slanderer of Sylvia Browne. Robert S. Lancaster has made a hostile and concerted attempt to slander, libel and defame Sylvia Browne.
As I understand them, the terms "slander" and "libel" are only accurate if what is being said or written is false, and furthermore, is known to be false to the person saying or writing them.

I assure you that I know of no statements I have made on the site which are false. And if you can show me to my satisfaction that any statement on my site is false, I will retract it. I mention this in a few places on the site - perhaps I shuld add it to the home page as well - if anyone finds anything on the site which is inaccurate or untrue, I would like to know about it. I will post a correction, and, if appropriate, will post an apology as well.

Browne, a woman who has brought an immeasurable amount of comfort and assistance to men and women across the country, as well as help to police departments, has been treated in a fashion completely and utterly shocking to any civilized person.
Well, this is obviously a matter of opinion, and you are certainly welcome to yours.

Browne's success rate of 85% is ignored,
No, it is unsubstantiated.

I mention several times on the site that her claimed success rate - the last I heard - is 87%. I do not ignore that claim at all. But I also have fuond nothing at all which supports that claim, and much which refutes it.

Mr. Lancaster, in his sham of a website, obsessively harps on every minor error that Browne makes in her prediction. For example: when Sylvia Browne accurately predicted the nature and appearance of Shawn Hornbeck's abductor, he pretended that she had not,
She stated that the abductor was built like a basketball player, that he was Hispanic, and had dreadlocks. Do any of these seem to you to be an accurate description of Michael J. Devlin, the man accused in the case?

... and distorted her actual reading to the Hornbecks.
I provide a verbatim transcript of the reading, and an actual video of the reading. How can this be a distortion?

Larry King even SAID that she got it mostly right, but Mr. Randi and Mr. Lancaster have tried to deny it!
I have not "tried to deny it," I have provided actual evidence that her description was totally inaccurate.

Lancaster at first tried to pretend that his analysis was scientific and forthright, but it has become increasingly frenzied and over-the-top with his hatred for Sylvia. With each new appearance of an article on StopSylviaBrowne.com, his attitude becomes more and more extreme, a trend that is disturbing to me, a follower of Browne.
If you would provide an example of my attitude being "extreme," I could better answer your charge.

Lancaster's main argument seems to be that because Browne is occasionally un-eloquent in her speech, this means that she somehow had faked a master's degree in literature.
That is by no means my "main argument," and is not even my main argument as to why her claim to have such a degree is unproven and suspect.

Some months ago, Heather Brown, the webmaster of the "Go Sylvia Browne" web site, stated that proof of Browne's Master's degree would go up on her site. This has yet to happen, despite her having direct access to Browne.

I have a recording of Sylvia Browne stating that proof of her degrees was being sent to me. That recording was made months ago, yet I have not received anything from her, directly or indrectly, other than the transcript from a college she attended for a little more than three years, where she apprently earned no degree whatsoever (that according to staff at the college's registrar office).

He hunted down Browne's ex-husband for the express purpose of getting him to lie to that effect (a liar that was later debunked).
No, my express purpose ws to interview him and hear what he had to say. My interview of Gary Dufresne lasted for over an hour, and we spent only a couple of minutes on the issue of Browne's education.

Also, when Browne sent me proof (the aforementioned transcript) that Mr. Dufresne was incorrect about his assessment of the number of years she had been in college when they met, I immediately posted that on my site. And it did not prove that Mr. Dufresne lied, merely that he was wrong on that point, whether intentionally or not.

His other arguments are that because Browne occasionally misses a minor fact (like the hair color of a missing person), she is somehow a fake.
Offhand, I don't recall mentioning her being wrong about the hair color of a missing person, but, as others have already asked:

Do you think that whether a person is alive or dead is a "minor fact?" Because she has been wrong on that point in most of the cases I've discussed on the site (Shawn Hornbeck, Lynda McClelland, Eve Brown, Opal Jo Jennings and Holly Krewson are all examples of this).

This is again IGNORING her 85% success rate.
Again, until I see some evidence of this, it is nothing more than an unproven claim.

There are thousands of positive testimonials in favor of Browne and it is clear from a simple reading of Amazon.com reviews of her books that she has helped INNUMERABLE people.
Even if we assume this is true, it does nothing to excuse the horrific, manipulative readings she gives to the families of the missing.

Mr. Lancaster has always engaged in a vigorous campaign to attack GoSylviaBrowne.com, a completely innocuous fan website. Mr. Lancaster has been utterly vicious in this, soliciting people from this website, the JREF, to assault and destroy her guestbook.
This is totally false. I have not been on the Go Sylvia Browne site since it was closed to non-registered visitors, but unless Heather Brown has changed her opinion of me since then, she had stated many times that I had been nothing but cordial and friendly with her. I did not orchestrate any such attack no her site, and in fact, if you read the thread titled "Go Sylvia Browne" on this site, you will find that I discouraged people from trolling the GSB site. Heather thanked me for doing so, and acknowledged that fact on her site more than once.

Now it is filled with hundreds of spammers, due to these 'skeptics' (more like Fascists to me) signing up the site with spam companies.
I don't even know whether it is possible to "sign the site up" for such spam. And even if it is, I would strongly disapprove of doing so to any site.

Whenever Mr. Lancaster has had interactions with those in the fan community he has been nasty, and never anything short of condescending.
Please show me even ONE example of me being nasty or condescending with anyone in the Browne fan community. Just ONE.

This man who has so little positive to contribute to the world has instead set his sights on Mrs. Browne, a great spiritual leader.
Whether I am contributing anything positive to the world is of coure, a matter of opinion. You feel that I am not. Others disagree.

Mr. Lancaster has apparently also started a campaign against Dr. Kaz deMille-Jacobsen, a 9/11 survivor and inspirational speaker, and a descendant of famous film director Cecil B. Demille.
This is where your post truly seems to cross the line into parody, but again, I will take you at your word that it is not.

"Kaz" and her nonsense was thoroughly debunked on my StopKaz.com site, and subsequently sank out of sight, more than a year ago.

He has also insulted and questioned the honor of Montel Williams, a navy hero, who is currently suffering with multiple sclerosis.
What does his having MS have to do with wheter or not he has honr? What does it have to do with whether or not Browne is psychic?

Nothing, so far as I can tell.

Lancaster is also a vigorous copyright abuser (posting both clips of Montel's show, transcripts, images of Sylvia, quotes from her books, and the Hay House logo), as noted by Browne's lawyers.
Please read up on "fair usage" in copyright law.

Let's hope they pursue this case to the fullest extent of the law and stop Robert S. Lancaster's campaign of terror.
You can bet that if Browne's attorneys thought they had a case, they would have pursued it months ago.

I may be out of town for a couple of days, but once I return, I will respond to any reply you make.
 
Last edited:
Sylvia's predictions for them may have been wrong, but she is right most of the other times. Why do you think so many people seek her out as an authority?
That's actually a very good question, but not as you intended it to be (a rhetorical question meant to somehow prove that her readings are accurate). I suspect it has something to do with desperation. She seems to prey on the most vulnerable.

Also, many people go to her for the same reason many people use Q-ray pendants, magic homeopathic water, and so on. At the very least, it's because they have limited critical thinking skills.

Why do you think she is called back time and time again by Montel Williams?
Because they both make lots of money at it.
Why do you think she has become so successful as a writer, a spiritual leader and a psychic? BECAUSE SHE GETS THINGS RIGHT! That's why. That's what puts her ahead of all of the other psychics. That's why she's Sylvia.
So, by your reasoning, good sales of a book is proof that its contents are accurate? Ever read anything by Charles Fort? Do you believe in every successfully published conspiracy theory? (That is a rhetorical question, because many of these contradict one another, so it is impossible to accept them all.)

Popularity is not proof. Can you give us an example where she used psychic powers to give any meaningful and helpful reading in a missing person case? Let's start with just one before we start worrying about the 85% claim.
 
I am NOT a liar by omission because Lancaster has CONTINUALLY made it clear what his position is on this issue. Just examine the tone of StopSylviaBrowne.com, it is extremely anti-Sylvia and it is made obvious that the quotation I gave is how Lancaster really feels.

Looks like I'm not the only one who takes umbrage with your debating tactics. Your use of quotation is intended to deceive. That would make you a liar.

But, I am sure RSL does think she's a fraud. He's assembled a pretty convincing pile of evidence. I am certainly convinced.

But the point is, the only thing that makes his site extremely anti-Sylvia is that the only evidence he can find to post shows her to be..... well, a fraud.

Find some contrary evidence and I'm sure he'll post it. The day you can post reliable evidence to the contrary and RSL doesn't take it seriously, then you have something to complain about.
 
I have already indicated to you that I am not here to defend Sylvia Browne's track record. I am here to show that Mr. Lancaster has lied about it.

How can you even claim that Robert has lied about Sylvia's track record when you can't even give evidence of what her track record is? Does that make any sense, what so ever, to you? I can claim that the moon is made of green cheese and NASA's lying when they say it isn't, but if I can't prove my claim, I can't expect anyone to respect my claim that NASA is lying. People can claim anything they please, but if they can't back it up with anything other than appeals to authority or popularity, they're not going to get much respect.

Personally, I really resent the claims that you've been making about Robert. You claim that we're making personal attacks against you (I've only seen 2 that could be interpreted that way at all) yet you continue to make unsubstantiated attacks not just against Robert, but against other people who post to this forum.

Don't expect to get any respect until you can present some logical arguments that are backed up by solid evidence.
 
Mr. Richardson:

Although I find it difficult to believe that your post is not a parody, I will take you at your word that it is not, and will respond to your points.

While some other forums (such as the "Go Sylvia browne" forum) routinely delete posts by those with opinions which strongly differ from those of the site's owner, it is not the policy of the JREF forum to do so. So long as a person sticks to board rules about profanity and a few other things, neither you nor your posts will be deleted.

Besides, the primary stated goal of the JREF is education, and the discussions which arise from differing opinions can be very educational, sometimes for people on both sides of the discussion.

As I understand them, the terms "slander" and "libel" are only accurate if what is being said or written is false, and furthermore, is known to be false to the person saying or writing them.

I assure you that I know of no statements I have made on the site which are false. And if you can show me to my satisfaction that any statement on my site is false, I will retract it. I mention this in a few places on the site - perhaps I shuld add it to the home page as well - if anyone finds anything on the site which is inaccurate or untrue, I would like to know about it. I will post a correction, and, if appropriate, will post an apology as well.

Well, this is obviously a matter of opinion, and you are certainly welcome to yours.

No, it is unsubstantiated.

I mention several times on the site that her claimed success rate - the last I heard - is 87%. I do not ignore that claim at all. But I also have fuond nothing at all which supports that claim, and much which refutes it.

She stated that the abductor was built like a basketball player, that he was Hispanic, and had dreadlocks. Do any of these seem to you to be an accurate description of Michael J. Devlin, the man accused in the case?

I provide a verbatim transcript of the reading, and an actual video of the reading. How can this be a distortion?

I have not "tried to deny it," I have provided actual evidence that her description was totally inaccurate.

If you would provide an example of my attitude being "extreme," I could better answer your charge.

That is by no means my "main argument," and is not even my main argument as to why her claim to have such a degree is unproven and suspect.

Some months ago, Heather Brown, the webmaster of the "Go Sylvia Browne" web site, stated that proof of Browne's Master's degree would go up on her site. This has yet to happen, despite her having direct access to Browne.

I have a recording of Sylvia Browne stating that proof of her degrees was being sent to me. That recording was made months ago, yet I have not received anything from her, directly or indrectly, other than the transcript from a college she attended for a little more than three years, where she apprently earned no degree whatsoever (that according to staff at the college's registrar office).

No, my express purpose ws to interview him and hear what he had to say. My interview of Gary Dufresne lasted for over an hour, and we spent only a couple of minutes on the issue of Browne's education.

Also, when Browne sent me proof (the aforementioned transcript) that Mr. Dufresne was incorrect about his assessment of the number of years she had been in college when they met, I immediately posted that on my site. And it did not prove that Mr. Dufresne lied, merely that he was wrong on that point, whether intentionally or not.

Offhand, I don't recall mentioning her being wrong about the hair color of a missing person, but, as others have already asked:

Do you think that whether a person is alive or dead is a "minor fact?" Because she has been wrong on that point in most of the cases I've discussed on the site (Shawn Hornbeck, Lynda McClelland, Eve Brown, Opal Jo Jennings and Holly Krewson are all examples of this).

Again, until I see some evidence of this, it is nothing more than an unproven claim.

Even if we assume this is true, it does nothing to excuse the horrific, manipulative readings she gives to the families of the missing.

This is totally false. I have not been on the Go Sylvia Browne site since it was closed to non-registered visitors, but unless Heather Brown has changed her opinion of me since then, she had stated many times that I had been nothing but cordial and friendly with her. I did not orchestrate any such attack no her site, and in fact, if you read the thread titled "Go Sylvia Browne" on this site, you will find that I discouraged people from trolling the GSB site. Heather thanked me for doing so, and acknowledged that fact on her site more than once.

I don't even know whether it is possible to "sign the site up" for such spam. And even if it is, I would strongly disapprove of doing so to any site.

Please show me even ONE example of me being nasty or condescending with anyone in the Browne fan community. Just ONE.

Whether I am contributing anything positive to the world is of coure, a matter of opinion. You feel that I am not. Others disagree.

This is where your post truly seems to cross the line into parody, but again, I will take you at your word that it is not.

"Kaz" and her nonsense was thoroughly debunked on my StopKaz.com site, and subsequently sank out of site, more than a year ago.

What does his having MS have to do with wheter or not he has honr? What does it have to do with whether or not Browne is psychic?

Nothing, so far as I can tell.

Please read up on "fair usage" in copyright law.

You can bet that if Browne's attorneys thought they had a case, they would have pursued it months ago.

I may be out of town for a couple of days, but once I return, I will respond to any reply you make.

1. It is not the policy of the JREF to delete posts? You're right. They have plenty of other ways to stifle truth and spread lies and misinformation (I read Randi's weekly column, his intellectual dishonesty astounds me).

2. You know the statement that you made about the German person who allegedly spoke English is false. Liar.

3. You have delibrately ignored any evidence to support Sylvia. Why don't you post some of the posts from GoSylviaBrowne.com about how much Sylvia has helped people? You only post negative things. Obviously I can't prove you have ignored things, but it's a logical deduction.

4. King stated that the description was accurate. SYLVIA GOT MICHAEL DEVLIN BY HIS FIRST NAME. The chances of that happening are very slim (ever picked up a baby name book, Mr. Lancaster?)

5. You distorted the Shawn Hornbeck reading in your analysis.

6. Your hateful and disdainful attitude is evident in everything you say and do. You are an extremist and radical skeptic who hates and despises anyone who disagrees with him as evidenced by your appearance on Anderson Cooper 360.

7. The fact that Heather Brown has not posted evidence does not make it true. She probably has bigger fish to fry than to respond to your every desire for evidence.

8. You are a liar. You coaxed Dufresne into making a false statement WHICH YOU LATER ADMITTED TURNED OUT, at least partially, FALSE.

9. Where are all the skeptics coming from on the guestbook then? They go there because you told them to go there here on the JREF forum.

10. You can indeed sign up a site for spam, google 'mugu guymen'.

11. I am not joking or parodying anyone. I am completely serious. I admit that I went too far by bringing up Mrs. Demille because I have not read your articles on her.

12. I know about fair use, and you are stretching it to the breaking point, far beyond a defensible position.
 
I can say "Hello, how are you?" in French ("Bonjour, ça va?"). Does this make me a French speaker? Would you describe me as such to a friend or business partner? Yes or no?
While the answer to your exact question is obviously "No", it is a misleading and irrelevant question.

If I spoke to you in French and you responded in French, "I can understand your words", I would have to assume you can understand French.
 
Sylvia's predictions for them may have been wrong, but she is right most of the other times. Why do you think so many people seek her out as an authority? Why do you think she is called back time and time again by Montel Williams? Why do you think she has become so successful as a writer, a spiritual leader and a psychic? BECAUSE SHE GETS THINGS RIGHT! That's why. That's what puts her ahead of all of the other psychics. That's why she's Sylvia.

How do you know she is right most of the other times?

We have given you concrete examples of when she is not right.

Can you give us concrete examples of when she is right? As in "most of the other times"?
 
I am sure an admin will delete this message because it disagrees with the stated goals of the JREF. I feel I must post it anyway.
Just to back up on this for a minute. I have seen several posts by admins on this thread. Neither they nor (as far as I can tell) anyone else has suggested that your posts be deleted or that you be banned as long as you follow basic rules of legality and manners.

You see, those at the JREF, are not afraid to let others speak, even if they disagree with them. They are not afraid that somehow the truth might be revealed. Can any pro-Sylvia Browne site make the same claim?
 
??? this makes absolutely NO SENSE.

How could you possibly prove RSL is lying about sylvia brownes track record without discussing sb's track record?

Because I can address individual instances of Lancaster's deceit without going through the entire history of Sylvia Browne and ever case she's been through. I'm not a psychic investigator and I don't have a case book on Browne from which I can extract charts and other data. I'm just a humble participant on this forum.
 
Oh well I see a rational response from "Gary" has devolved into "liar liar pants on fire."

RSL's evidence is clearly posted on his website. Perhaps you could provide evidence that support your 12 assertions, please?
 
3. You have delibrately ignored any evidence to support Sylvia. Why don't you post some of the posts from GoSylviaBrowne.com about how much Sylvia has helped people? You only post negative things. Obviously I can't prove you have ignored things, but it's a logical deduction.

Really, we don't have to go past this one. Please post this evidence that has been ignored. Until you can do so, you are talking out your posterior.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom