[split]WTC7 and CD - split from: Question for Ryan Mackey

I wasn't talking about the Store. I was planning to go straight to the show's producers.

Surely something of such earth-shattering importance is worth a few inquiries in the real world, no?

In any case, I cannot believe that Chief Nigro was lying, not without a whole lot more and verified evidence. $100 says realcddeal simply misheard or misremembers.
One of the most bizarre things about this claim is that Mr. Szamboti says he didn't think anything more about Silverstein's open demolition admission because it made sense to him.

Made sense? How the hell did they perform a controlled demolition on a blazing skyscraper at Ground Zero on the afternoon of 9/11? And how the hell did this incredible feat not get reported anywhere, ever? By the way, Mr. Szamboti lives not far from NYC. It's not as if he's isolated from news sources.

Oh, and note that in the post I've been linking to he says he saw the History's Business show in 2002, but here he says it was in 2004.

The History Channel is also suppressing a video of Larry Silverstein actually saying Bldg. 7 was a "controlled demolition for safety reasons" on a Sunday morning show called History's Business in early 2004. I know as I watched him say it and at the time I was not suspicious about 911 and that comment made sense to me as I had never understood Bldg. 7's complete collapse. It seems to me that the original plan may have been to admit it was a controlled demolition, but for safety reasons. It looks like it got to be a problem after Dr. Steven Jones' paper was published and people started asking when there would have been time to set the charges and then asking about the towers given all of the testimony about explosions being seen, heard, and felt after the Oral Histories were released in August 2005. I personally asked myself the question of when there would have been time to set the charges in Bldg. 7 only after reading Dr. Jones' paper in early 2006.

http://www.911blogger.com/node/10741#comment-157751
Mr. Szamboti, I'm begging you to just stop. You cannot see how irrationally you're behaving, but everyone else can. This isn't good, Tony.
 
Last edited:
One of the most bizarre things about this claim is that Mr. Szamboti says he didn't think anything more about Silverstein's open demolition admission because it made sense to him.

Made sense? How the hell did they perform a controlled demolition on a blazing skyscraper at Ground Zero on the afternoon of 9/11? And how the hell did this incredible feat not get reported anywhere, ever? By the way, Mr. Szamboti lives not far from NYC. It's not as if he's isolated from news sources.

Oh, and note that in the post I've been linking to he says he saw the History's Business show in 2002, but here he says it was in 2004.

Mr. Szamboti, I'm begging you to just stop. You cannot see how irrationally you're behaving, but everyone else can. This isn't good, Tony.

I am not being irrational. Who do you think you are to even say that? This also isn't the same as Christopher Brown's claim that he saw a documentary about a concrete core in the towers, which photos seem to show differently, and for which nobody has seen any show listing. I showed you the show was real and I happened to be watching it. As for thinking it was in 2004 that was before somone posted the link showing it was in 2002, after I told them what he had said on that show. I did not realize there was an issue until early 2006 and just remembered I had seen him say that as I distinctly remembered what he said about Bldg. 7 because it settled the puzzlement I had about Bldg. 7's collapse. I wasn't asking questions such as "how the hell would they have performed a controlled demolition on a blazing skyscraper at Ground Zero?" because at the time I wasn't thinking how much would have been involved and didn't know what the level of fire in Bldg. 7 was, nor was I suspicious of anything, only puzzled about the complete collapse of Bldg. 7. Most people were not susppiciuos at that time. Silverstein said this on that show and made that comment about Bldg. 7 and that is the absolute truth of the matter. There were not a lot of people questioning 911 until much later and I do not believe History's Business is a highly rated show.

If it wasn't true I would not say it, and certainly not here. I have no desire to make things up to prove anything. I would prefer to believe that things were on the up and up concerning what happened on 911. However, after delving into it I now simply can't believe they were. Something is wrong with what we have been told with 911 and the changing stories, which I unfortunately am a witness to, indicates that there is a problem.

Mark, why don't you call the History Channel and see if you can get a copy of that show?
 
Last edited:
You are lying about Silverstein claiming that building 7 was a controlled demolition. Let's be clear about this: you do not "remember" him saying this because he never said anything of the sort. You are lying.

How can I be sure? Easy--it wasn't front-page news on every daily in the country. Really, it's as simple as that. Something you fantasists always overlook is that any scrap of your "evidence," if validated, would win a Pulitzer Prize for the reporter who broke the story.

Maybe every news outlet in the country is part of the Impossibly Conspiracy. So, why can't you peddle your snake oil in other countries?

I am not lying about anything and you have a lot of nerve to say that. You can't be sure of anything because you have not seen the show and are trying to prove something with a negative. I would not say this if it weren't true and certainly not here. The fact of the matter is that Silverstein did say that on that show and I was not suspicious at the time and I remember it well as at the time it settled my puzzlement over the complete collapse of Bldg. 7.

Why don't you see if you can get ahold of a copy of that show?
 
Last edited:
I'm not asking you to prove a negative that nobody else saw it, I'm merely remarking that it is awfully suspicious. The Truth Movement should be jumping all over this, if it was true. The fact that they aren't doesn't prove anything -- but it does raise your true burden of proof.

What I'm asking you to do is prove a positive, namely that he did indeed say this. I simply don't buy it.

How would he even know?

If what you say is true, it means that Fire Chief Nigro is a liar. We can source his statement. We cannot source yours. Until proven otherwise, the balance suggests that you merely heard him wrong. That's all there is to it.




This may be true, but you have to admit, it's awfully convenient. Who did you contact? May I try to contact them and see what they say? Please send a PM with contact information, and I will not make it public.

I called and e-mailed the History Channel. I just used the main number for buying DVDs and VHS tapes. I also e-mailed them about it and no reply was sent.

You don't need my permission to see if you can get a copy of that show. By all means go see if you can get it.
 
Last edited:
You need to produce facts to support that assertion in order for me to accept it. You saying it is so does not make it so, especially when the data about how much and from where the U.S. is purchasing its crude oil is easily available.


Did you watch "Oil, Smoke, and Mirrors" yet? It is only a 50 minute video. Get back to me after you watch that and we can discuss it.
 
I called and e-mailed the History Channel. I just used the main number for buying DVDs and VHS tapes. I also e-mailed them about it and no reply was sent.

You don't need my permission to see if you can get a copy of that show. By all means go see if you can get it.

That's not exactly what I'd call "thorough."

I'll try them anyway, but at this point, you need to accept that you have no proof whatsoever. It's abundantly clear that you simply misunderstood or misremembered.
 
I am not being irrational. Who do you think you are to even say that?
I'm a rational person who has read all of your extremely irrational posts. Please pay attention to the comments made by the rationalists here. It is very important that somehow, some day, you come to realize how you are behaving.

Mark, why don't you call the History Channel and see if you can get a copy of that show?
Why? There is no reason in the world that anyone should believe you. If you have something to prove to the world, you're going to have to do the work. Is anything unclear about that, Tony?

And do you finally understand why your claims of believing the official explanations into 2006 and believing controlled demolition since 2002 are incompatible, to a rational person (not to mention the fact that believing CD of WTC 7 is irrational on its own)?

Or would you like me to try to find another way of explaining it to you?
 
Last edited:
That's not exactly what I'd call "thorough."

I'll try them anyway, but at this point, you need to accept that you have no proof whatsoever. It's abundantly clear that you simply misunderstood or misremembered.

I know what I heard and I only have myself to answer to on that. As for proof to others you are right in that I don't have absolute proof, only my word, and that is why I was loathe to even mention it here and other places. There is proof for others to see that the show I mentioned does exist.

As for being thorough, you do realize that I have to work for a living and have other responsibilitiies. I did what I could for the position I am in at the moment.

You should try to see if you can get a copy of the show.
 
Last edited:
I'm a rational person who has read all of your extremely irrational posts. Please pay attention to the comments made by the rationalists here. It is very important that somehow, some day, you come to realize how you are behaving.

Why? There is no reason in the world that anyone should believe you. If you have something to prove to the world, you're going to have to do the work. Is anything unclear about that, Tony?

And do you finally understand why your claims of believing the official explanations into 2006 and believing controlled demolition since 2002 are incompatible, to a rational person (not to mention the fact that believing CD of WTC 7 is irrational on its own)?

Or would you like me to try to find another way of explaining it to you?

As for your supposed incompatibility, my believing that Bldg. 7 was a controlled demolition, after watching Silverstein say it in 2002 is not incompatible with doubting the official explanations in 2006, after reading Steven Jones' paper. Why would I doubt Silverstein in 2002 when I watched him say that the building was taken down for safety reasons? Between 2002 and 2006 I hadn't read what FEMA hypothesized about Bldg. 7 in 2002 and they had no answer then anyway. Essentially there was no official explanation for Bldg. 7's collapse then and there still isn't. Do you disagree with that?

It is conceivable that Silverstein was simply telling the truth about Bldg. 7 that day since there is no other explanation.

You are off the wall and I am simply wasting my time trying to explain anything to you. You and your friend Ronald Wieck just seem to be individuals who are desperately attempting to hold onto a belief and feel free to call other people liars with no real basis. There is something wrong with the story we have been given about 911 and you two are the real fantasists who want to think otherwise.

You are up kind of late aren't you? Don't you have any tours to give tomorrow? I woke up at 2:30 and decided to see what was going on. Did you do something similar or are you on the late shift tonight?
 
Last edited:
I know what I heard and I only have myself to answer to on that. As for proof to others you are right in that I don't have absolute proof, only my word, and that is why I was loathe to even mention it here and other places. There is proof for others to see that the show I mentioned does exist.

You should try to see if you can get a copy of the show.

I believe the show exists. I even believe that they featured Mr. Silverstein. None of that is particularly extraordinary. However, it's an enormous leap from there to believe that Mr. Silverstein claimed (or "admitted" as though it was nothing) that somehow, a burning 47-story skyscraper, cordoned off by the FDNY, was rapidly rigged with explosives and leveled as a matter of "public safety." Honestly, that goes beyond the extraordinary, and into the realm of "mad." Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, as the sage would say.

What we have is no evidence. Thus we can safely reject it for now.

Nonetheless, I will contact them anyway, and see how far I get.
 
Last edited:
realcddeal said:
... I wasn't asking questions such as "how the hell would they have performed a controlled demolition on a blazing skyscraper at Ground Zero?" because at the time I wasn't thinking how much would have been involved and didn't know what the level of fire in Bldg. 7 was, nor was I suspicious of anything, only puzzled about the complete collapse of Bldg. 7. ...

Ah, but your expert, Danny Jowenko, seems to believe it was possible to rig building 7 for CD on the day. Why are you not reassured by Mr Jowenko's statement?
 
Last edited:
Did you watch "Oil, Smoke, and Mirrors" yet? It is only a 50 minute video. Get back to me after you watch that and we can discuss it.
So you're saying your assertion is based solely on this one program? Got anything else to back up? Any other sources you can cite? Like, say, the amount of petroleum or natural gas reserves in Afghanistan? Like, say, documents explaining how this supposed control over the oil in Iraq is going to be conducted? Surely you realize the effect on the world oil market there'd be if the U.S. unilaterally grabbed exclusive control of a major part of the world's reserves? There are no supporting documents, reports, news articles, etc., on web site you can post to further your claim?

All I can say is, so far this supposed control over foreign oil hasn't done the U.S. one bit of good.
 
Last edited:
So you're saying your assertion is based solely on this one program? Got anything else to back up? Any other sources you can cite? Like, say, the amount of petroleum or natural gas reserves in Afghanistan? Like, say, documents explaining how this supposed control over the oil in Iraq is going to be conducted? Surely you realize the effect on the world oil market there'd be if the U.S. unilaterally grabbed exclusive control of a major part of the world's reserves? There are no supporting documents, reports, news articles, etc., on web site you can post to further your claim?

All I can say is, so far this supposed control over foreign oil hasn't done the U.S. one bit of good.


Corsair, didn't Alan Greenspan recently say something about Iraq being about oil? Didn't Hans Blix say something about Iraq being about oil? Did you watch the film yet?

In case you haven't noticed there are people in Iraq who are fighting the oil takeover by U.S. oil companies. The Iraqi parliament is dragging it's collective feet and haven't passed the new hydrocarbon law yet have they? So how would it do the U.S. any good at this point?

There are several websites which claim Iraq is all about oil. Congressman Dennis Kucinich attended a rally of American Iraqi's to protest the takeover and in their words theft of Iraqi oil. You can watch a video of that rally on You Tube.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZTb3SLa_2VE

and in Australia there was this news story

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j7t_u641NyM&feature=related

and here is our own Amy Goodman on Democracy Now talking about it

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-CVYj3iuODw&feature=related
 
Last edited:
and what does Iraq have to do with teh fact that you still haven't produced an audio clip of the History channel program where you claim LS said that wTc 7 was demoed for safety reasons.

instead of posting here, shouldn't you be looking for that show or contacting the history channel?
 
As for your supposed incompatibility, my believing that Bldg. 7 was a controlled demolition, after watching Silverstein say it in 2002 is not incompatible with doubting the official explanations in 2006, after reading Steven Jones' paper.
Okay, I see that I have to explain this to you for the fourth time. I will try to make it simpler yet.

You have an unshakeable belief that in 2002 or 2004 you saw Larry Silverstein say WTC 7 was demolished for safety reasons.

Agreed?

However, you also say that you believed the engineering community's collapse explanations, into 2006. Remember?
These are relatively old articles on the subject of 911 (2003 to 2005 time frame). I didn't see that there was more to it until March 2006, so I would have went along with those articles at that time also.
The engineering community has never claimed that WTC 7 was demolished for safety reasons.

Therefore your claims are incompatible. If you believed both of them at once, there is something very wrong with your thought process.

This is the fourth time we've been through your denial of this. Do you understand now why your position is untenable?

Why would I doubt Silverstein in 2002 when I watched him say that the building was taken down for safety reasons?
Because no rational person would be able to explain how that is possible, and because no one, anywhere, reported this absolutely astonishing achievement, before the 2002 TV show or since.

Do you understand this, Mr. Szamboti? Please do your best to think this through logically before you reply, and remember that you have the choice to stop digging this hole.
 
Last edited:
Okay, I see that I have to explain this to you for the fourth time. I will try to make it simpler yet.

You have an unshakeable belief that in 2002 or 2004 you saw Larry Silverstein say WTC 7 was demolished for safety reasons.

Agreed?

However, you also say that you believed the engineering community's collapse explanations, into 2006. Remember?

The engineering community has never claimed that WTC 7 was demolished for safety reasons.

Therefore your claims are incompatible. If you believed both of them at once, there is something very wrong with your thought process.

This is the fourth time we've been through your denial of this. Do you understand now why your position is untenable?

Because no rational person would be able to explain how that is possible, and because no one, anywhere, reported this absolutely astonishing achievement, before the 2002 TV show or since.

Do you understand this, Mr. Szamboti? Please do your best to think this through logically before you reply, and remember that you have the choice to stop digging this hole.

If you would read what I said you would have noticed that I made a distinction between the towers and Bldg. 7.

I will say it again for you.

I believed that Bldg. 7 was a controlled demolition for safety reasons from the time I saw the Larry Silverstein interview in 2002. I did not believe the towers were controlled demolitions at the time and what I said to TAM was that up until early 2006 I would have accepted the official reports on the towers, which is what those other articles were parroting, as they hadn't done any investigations of their own.

I hadn't looked at any of this in detail until 2006, and all I knew until then was what we were told by the MSM and what I saw Larry Silverstein say in that interview. You are trying to grab a hook where there isn't one. Go away Mark and get some sleep. It seems you have been up all night. Don't you ever work?
 
Last edited:
Tony Szamboti can be heard in this video lecturing a NORAD officer about what happened on 9/11.
Google Video This video is not hosted by the ISF, the ISF can not be held responsible for the suitability or legality of this material. By clicking the link below you agree to view content from an external website.
I AGREE


Description from 9/11blogger:
While conducting our truth action for the 11th of August on South Street in Philadelphia we encountered an officer with NORAD. Initially as he approached our location he was irate and proceeded to admonish our message as he continued his path past our post and around the corner.

Mark Peters, aware of the psychological constraints by which many are afflicted, made an appeal to conscience and effectively halted this temporarily unidentified person long enough to establish that he was on the floor of NORAD on 9/11.

The first few minutes of the conversation were not recorded due to the fortuitous nature of the incident however we can sufficiently enumerate the items discussed. The conversation began with a question by Mark to the officer about his whereabouts on the morning of 9/11 and about the atmosphere of the NORAD facility as events on the morning of 9/11 transpired.

The NORAD officer informed Mark that on the morning of September 11, 2001 he was on duty monitoring radar when what he describes as mass confusion erupted. The video begins with the arrival of Tony Szamboti and Nick Carangi after which Mark Peters elucidates Norman Mineta's testimony before the 9/11 Commission regarding Dick Cheney's actions in the PEOC on the morning of 9/11.

This factoid seemed to intrigue the NORAD officer to a level where Tony Szamboti (mechanical engineer) thought it a good idea to convey more controversial information about the anomalies in the WTC collapse. The officer did not seem to agree with Szamboti's posits on controlled demolition however he did confirm Szamboti's statements about exercises and drills by affirming that on the morning of 9/11 NORAD was in an exercise mode.

The officer asked not to be filmed, so we surreptitiously filmed the ground capturing the audio while Nick Carangi asked the officer what his role was at NORAD to which he replied, "I was Commanding the Air Warning Center" and added credibility to his statement by showing his business card which clearly was an official NORAD article.
Though he didn't give us his business card, he did take a compilation DVD with 9/11 Mysteries, TerrorStorm and LC2ndEd, and with a promise to watch the DVD and his endorsement of our efforts, he bade us farewell.

Listen to the goddamned ignorance.
Listen to the goddamned ignorance.

These sad, sad, deliberately ignorant people.
 
Last edited:
Tony, this just occurred to me. Ron Wieck has been having trouble finding people who will discuss their 9/11 claims with me on Hardfire. This week he challenged TC329 to do so, but I introduced the condition that TC had to first do some of the research that he's been saying he'd do since last year.

I have no such conditions for you, and since you and several organizations and websites tout your engineering credentials, perhaps you'd like the chance to present your case on TV.

I don't speak for Ron – he may have other plans – but if he's willing to have you as a guest, are you willing to meet me? I'll be glad to restrict the the discussion to subjects you're comfortable with.
 
Tony, this just occurred to me. Ron Wieck has been having trouble finding people who will discuss their 9/11 claims with me on Hardfire. This week he challenged TC329 to do so, but I introduced the condition that TC had to first do some of the research that he's been saying he'd do since last year.

I have no such conditions for you, and since you and several organizations and websites tout your engineering credentials, perhaps you'd like the chance to present your case on TV.

I don't speak for Ron – he may have other plans – but if he's willing to have you as a guest, are you willing to meet me? I'll be glad to restrict the the discussion to subjects you're comfortable with.

Mark, I realize that this (911) is an emotionally charged issue and do want to say that even though you and Ron are on other sides of the fence from me on this, and sometimes are both prone to using ad hominem, I somehow do not hold it against either of you.

However, I think due to its emotional nature, and where you and Ron stand on this issue, that it would likely be a two against one. That does matter on TV, as the amount of time one gets to speak counts. Although I don't think he always argues the strongest points and in some cases is flat out wrong scientifically, I did notice that in your debate with Jim Fetzer on the show. Given that, I am not sure I would like to be a guest on Hardfire at this time.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, really...as if in the eventuality that Silverstein et. al. really were NWO, they would spill their secrets just because they were called to testify. Truthers seem to have an unshakable belief in the power of the oath.

Thanks for the welcome!

-Sporanox
Well, you see, if they were under oath, and then lied, they would instantly burst into flame, and their real demonic selves would be revealed for all to see.
It's very simple, actually.

Oh, and :welcome2
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom