[split]WTC7 and CD - split from: Question for Ryan Mackey

How do you know there aren't any other demolition people who believe WTC7 was a controlled demolition? I haven't heard any give an opinion other than Blanchard and Jowenko.

As for Jowenko and the Twin Towers I haven't heard his comment on that.


This is why fantasists have a reputation for dishonesty. Who has heard of Danny Jowenko who doesn't know what he thinks of the collapses of the Towers?


As far as I am concerned I have done structural design work for static and dynamic loads for years and I don't need to appeal to authority on these matters as you apparently feel the need to. The facts are the facts and if the supposed expert's opinion doesn't line up with the facts then it isn't worth the paper it is written on. I don't know if you have read the paper I wrote concerning the towers. It is on the Journal of 911 Studies and that will tell you what I believe happened there. Goodnight.



I have read what engineers and scientists here think of your paper. I note that you are unable to refute their criticisms.
 
Last edited:
realcddeal wrote:
"It doesn't mean a hill of beans whether you or anybody else on here thinks I work with engineeers or not. The fact is I am one and I do work with a lot of engineers in the Aerospace industry. In fact, since you are in New York and not too far from me, as I live in South Jersey and work in Southeastern Pennsylvania, why don't we bet a few thousand dollars on your claim and you can take a ride down and I'll introduce you to the people I work with.

I wasn't trying to do a critique of Blanchard's article in that comment. I merely mentioned that it was not convincing to me and others I know. There was no need to support that statement with anything else.

I'll discuss Blanchard's work tomorrow if I get time."


If you work with engineers, why won't they set you straight? Compared to the other engineers here, you seem to know very little.

I'd be interested in hearing you discuss Brent Blanchard's paper. The need to support your statement regarding it is obvious. Blanchard is a top professional in the demolition industry and demolition specialists overwhelmingly reject the fantasist moonshine about explosives.
 
Additionally, we have seen signs that the WTC 7 investigation has grown in scope over time. This was not the case for WTC 1 and 2.
I have to take issue with that. The NIST investigation only came about after the FEMA/ASCE investigation was deemed to be inadequate in many ways.
 
How many demolition experts are out there, besides Blanchard, saying unequivocally that WTC7's collapse could not have been a controlled demolition?


All of the demolition experts who actually witnessed WTC7 collapse believe that not only was it not a CD, but performing a CD on the building would have been impossible.

Next?

-Gumboot
 
For all of the columns to fail simultaneously and rapidly, due to asymmetric fires, strains credulity.

What strains my credulity is how you can imply that all the columns failed simultaneously. How, exactly, did the collapse of the east mechanical penthouse about 6 seconds before the total collapse occur if columns 79 to 81 failed simultaneously with all the rest? How did the building kink develop if all the remaining columns failed simultaneously? And how, by backing up your theories with assertions which are not only demonstrably but obviously untrue, do you hope to convince anyone that you have an argument worth taking seriously?

Dave
 
There is direct visual evidence for a fire induced collapse.

See here:


As the eastern penthouse falls into the building, a 'ripple' can be seen falling through the building - in fact the entire structure seems to flex at one point. We then see the main penthouse fall, with the eastern side slightly ahead. It's clear evidence that the penthouse debris fell to the lower floors and damaged or destroyed the two transfer trusses that were directly beneath it.
 
SO Tony, are you and your "engineers at work" also unconvinced by the NIST interim report on WTC7? Will you AND your engineer colleagues at work READ the final report? I can assume that your engineer colleagues at work, like yourself, cannot remain silent about the murder of 3000 people by the USG and will be coming public like yourself? right?

http://www.icivilengineer.com/News/WTC/structure.php

Here is what most of your colleagues in the engineering profession think. I Don't see much Woo on the topic listed here. Are these people just shills?

TAM:)
 
Last edited:
SO Tony, are you and your "engineers at work" also unconvinced by the NIST interim report on WTC7? Will you AND your engineer colleagues at work READ the final report? I can assume that your engineer colleagues at work, like yourself, cannot remain silent about the murder of 3000 people by the USG and will be coming public like yourself? right?

http://www.icivilengineer.com/News/WTC/structure.php

Here is what most of your colleagues in the engineering profession think. I Don't see much Woo on the topic listed here. Are these people just shills?

TAM:)


These are relatively old articles on the subject of 911 (2003 to 2005 time frame). I didn't see that there was more to it until March 2006, so I would have went along with those articles at that time also. You should see if you can find some current articles backing the official story by the majority of the engineering profession. I think a lot of people are starting to question this now, but there are still many who have not looked into it. Backing the present government explanation does not make one a shill. It means either one has not looked into it thoroughly or does not have the ability to reason and break down the baloney we have been fed. Just this year (2007) Dr. James Quintiere came out and said he wishes someone would peer review the NIST report and encourages those in the engineering profession to look into these collapses for themselves. Now just ask yourself why he would say that?

I also would not say it was the US government that murdered 3000 people on Sept. 11, 2001. I would say it was criminal elements who have infiltrated our government, for their own aims, namely the use of our military for securing oil.

Architects and Engineers for 911 Truth is a growing organization so it seems people in the engineering profession are starting to come forward, as they learn that there are serious problems with what we have been told.

Nobody I have shown the collapse of WTC7 to has said it was possible that the building could have collapsed the way it did due to asymmetric damage and fires. They all believe it was a controlled demolition once they have seen it's collapse. I can't speak for my colleagues on reading the NIST report on WTC7 but I will certainly read it.

Here is an article on alternative energies which you and others might be interested in

http://www.fastcompany.com:80/magazine/120/motorhead-messiah.html
 
Last edited:
These are relatively old articles (2004 and 2005 time frame). I didn't see that there was more to it until March 2006. I would have went along with those articles at that time also.

Tony Szamboti, just stop. This is pathetic. Please, just stop.

realcddeal said:
I watched Larry Silverstein use the actual words "Bldg. 7 was a controlled demolition for safety reasons" on a History Channel show called History's Business in late 2002, so I absolutely know I am right about that and none of yours or Popular mechanics non-engineering editors can say different.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=3057023&postcount=343
 
Now don't get me wrong, having engineering knowledge is great and all, but without an understanding on how explosives work and how demolitions are done you can't possibly understand what an actual CD is. Have you ever actually held a pound stick of TNT? What about Composition 4, Composition B, Tetrytol, or Dynamite? Do you know what a ring main is, or a line main? Do you know how to calculate the amount of explosives needed to cut structural steal? How about the Relative Effectiveness Factor of different explosives, and for that matter why you would need to know it to begin with? For every different type of structure there is a different process you employ to bring it down controllably.
 
Tony Szamboti, just stop. This is pathetic. Please, just stop.


Mark, all I want is a new investigation into what occurred on Sept. 11, 2001. There are many serious and legitimate questions which need answers and a lot of people who had access to those buildings who were never questioned.

I want Marvin Bush and Wirt Walker III and the supervisors of ACE elevator Co. questioned under oath along with Jerome Hauer and a number of others.

What is your problem with doing that?

I also want to know why the story I heard Larry Silverstein say concerning WTC7 was changed.
He needs to be questioned under oath also.

If you can't handle it why don't you just put me on ignore. Otherwise you seem to be the pathetic one here.
 
Last edited:
If you work with engineers, why won't they set you straight? Compared to the other engineers here, you seem to know very little.

I'd be interested in hearing you discuss Brent Blanchard's paper. The need to support your statement regarding it is obvious. Blanchard is a top professional in the demolition industry and demolition specialists overwhelmingly reject the fantasist moonshine about explosives.


Ron, your willingness to sanction Blanchard based solely on his being in the demolition industry is telling about you. It also doesn't appear that you are in a position to judge an engineer's worthiness.

I don't have Blanchard's article right in front of me now but just the big canard of his about controlled demolition being possible only from the bottom up is ridiculous. The towers could have been taken down every three stories from the impact sites down, with each of those being bottom up. The upper stories could have been a bottom up demolition in their own right.

Are you going to say it is physically impossible to do that?
 
Last edited:
Mark, all I want is a new investigation into what occurred on Sept. 11, 2001.
The old investigation isn't done yet, shouldn't we wait until it's done and read it before calling for a new one?
There are many serious and legitimate questions which need answers and a lot of people who had access to those buildings who were never questioned.

I want Marvin Bush and Wirt Walker III
Their company no longer worked for the WTC after 1998 and Marvin Bush stopped working for them (and reportedly sold his stock) in 2000. They only helped develop a way for the new security systems installed by another company to integrate. Why should they be questioned about anything? I had access to the building once, should I be questioned?
and the supervisors of ACE elevator Co. questioned under oath along with Jerome Hauer and a number of others.

What is your problem with doing that?
Because these are not legitimate questions.

I also want to know why the story I heard Larry Silverstein say concerning WTC7 was changed.
Because the people who spread the "pull it" myth and the ones you probably first heard it from were misrepresenting what he was saying.

If you can't handle it why don't you just put me on ignore. Otherwise you seem to be the pathetic one here.
You are the one who hasn't done any research outside of conspiracy sites, and doesn't think for themself. That's pathetic.
 
Last edited:
The old investigation isn't done yet, shouldn't we wait until it's done and read it before calling for a new one?
The WTC1 and WTC2 investigation is done and I think it fell far short, so do many other engineers.

Their company no longer worked for the WTC after 1998 and Marvin Bush stopped working for them (and reportedly sold his stock) in 2000. They only helped develop a way for the new security systems installed by another company to integrate. Why should they be questioned about anything?

Wrong, Wirt Walker III was involved up through January 2002. Marvin Bush was there when they installed a new security system in the late 90's. Installation of a security system could be used as a cover for other activities. A thorough investigation would look into it for completeness alone.

You are the one who hasn't done any research outside of conspiracy sites, and doesn't think for themself. That's pathetic.
This comment is ridiculous and you have no basis for saying it. Saying something like this with no basis provided makes it appear that you haven't looked at both sides of the argument.
 
Last edited:
I would say it was criminal elements who have infiltrated our government, for their own aims, namely the use of our military for securing oil.
Mind explaining that last part? Secure how? Why? Canada and Mexico sell more crude oil to the U.S. than Saudi Arabia does. And besides, as long as the U.S. is willing to pay money for a barrel of oil, there'll be countries happy to sell it to the U.S.
 
Mind explaining that last part? Secure how? Why? Canada and Mexico sell more crude oil to the U.S. than Saudi Arabia does. And besides, as long as the U.S. is willing to pay money for a barrel of oil, there'll be countries happy to sell it to the U.S.

Corsair, we discussed this before and obviously just disagree. Apparently you don't believe that we are in Afghanistan and Iraq for oil.

You should watch Oil, Smoke, and Mirrors on Google video. It is far from being my only reason for believing what I do, along with many others, it is just something that might give you an appreciation for what I am saying.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom