[split]WTC7 and CD - split from: Question for Ryan Mackey

And I think that you and other twoofers need to stop accusing innocent people of all manner of crimes without a scintilla of evidence.

Why don't you open your eyes to the fact that there are legitimate questions which need to be answered concerning what happened on Sept. 11, 2001. I am not accusing anyone of actually committing a crime. I am saying certain people should be questioned, who have not been questioned to date. Everyone who needs to be questioned isn't necessarily a suspect.
 
You have no proof of the comment. The link you provided has no transcript and no audio or video of the statement.

It was only intended to show that Silverstein was on such a show and that I am not making it up as some here would childishly put it.

I did try to get a video of the show in the last year from the History Channel and was told it was not available to the public.
 
Wait, just a moment.

You're claiming that you saw, on a History Channel documentary, Larry Silverstein state: "WTC 7 was destroyed in a controlled demolition for safety reasons." Correct?

Why has nobody else seen this?

What do you recall that he actually said? Please get as close to the actual verbiage as possible. This is going to be extraordinarily difficult to verify...

You should, at the very least, consider that your recollection of the History Channel show could be in error. If this statement cannot be found, as I'm confident it won't, will you then change your beliefs regarding WTC 7?


Ryan, don't ask me to prove a negative on why nobody else has brought it up. I shouldn't have to tell you that. It wasn't a documentary, it was an interview type show called History's Business which airs on Sunday mornings.

See if you can get a video of the show. I am sure of what I saw and heard and I explained earlier that I was not suspicious at the time, but was always puzzled about Bldg. 7's complete collapse up until that point. Larry Silverstein said, when asked by the interviewer as to what happened to Bldg. 7, "Oh, Bldg. 7 was a controlled demolition for safety reasons". I have tried to get a video copy of this show but was not successful as they said it was not available to the public.
 
It was only intended to show that Silverstein was on such a show and that I am not making it up as some here would childishly put it.

I did try to get a video of the show in the last year from the History Channel and was told it was not available to the public.
Audio from other episodes of the series are available at: http://www.history.com/media.do?med...s+Business&action=search&showName=-1&x=15&y=6

They also provide audio from some of their older shows on iTunes.
 
Realcddeal said:
When I saw the History Channel show in Sept. 2002 and Larry Silverstein made the comment about Bldg. 7 being a controlled demolition for safety reasons it made sense to me as it was logical. I was not suspicious about the events of 911 except for being puzzled about the complete collapse of Bldg. 7 and that was then settled.

Woa dude....you're like, totally tripping out!

You seem to hear things that not even other twoofers hear.
 
Ryan, don't ask me to prove a negative on why nobody else has brought it up. I shouldn't have to tell you that. It wasn't a documentary, it was an interview type show called History's Business which airs on Sunday mornings.

I'm not asking you to prove a negative that nobody else saw it, I'm merely remarking that it is awfully suspicious. The Truth Movement should be jumping all over this, if it was true. The fact that they aren't doesn't prove anything -- but it does raise your true burden of proof.

What I'm asking you to do is prove a positive, namely that he did indeed say this. I simply don't buy it.

How would he even know?

If what you say is true, it means that Fire Chief Nigro is a liar. We can source his statement. We cannot source yours. Until proven otherwise, the balance suggests that you merely heard him wrong. That's all there is to it.


I have tried to get a video copy of this show but was not successful as they said it was not available to the public.

This may be true, but you have to admit, it's awfully convenient. Who did you contact? May I try to contact them and see what they say? Please send a PM with contact information, and I will not make it public.
 
How do you know?

It is apparent that had it been said, it would have been an earth-shattering revelation, and in the realm that most of us inhabit - called reality - it would have been front page news all over the globe had he actually said any such thing.

What you are saying is patently ridiculous on its face.

No, what I said is simply reality. It would be helpful if you acquainted yourself with it.

I showed you the link showing Silverstein was on that show.

I know that he was on the show. You haven't shown me anything I didn't already know. I've posted about it before. The fact that he was on the show is not at all in dispute. The words that you ascribe to him are what is in dispute.

I watched him say it

I do not believe you. I think that you are either (a) mistaken; or (b) deliberately making crap up.

and then four years later the story is different.

See above. I do not believe you when you claim he said that it was a controlled demolition, therefore, I do not believe your assertion that "the story" has changed.

I was not suspicious when I heard him say it.

Of course not, why should you be if he didn't say what you now claim he said.

As for a large proportion of the free world hearing about it...

See above. It would have been an earth-shattering revelation that would not have been confined to those watching the episode at the time.

I called the History Channel in the last year, after reading Steven Jones' paper and realizing the potential of that comment with the conspiracy theories whirling around, and they told me it was not available to the public.

Sure, you did.

And what did you do about it after that? Have you approached any authorities or law enforcement agencies to tell them about this? Have you made any written requests to them to ask about the episode? Have you advised authorities/law enforcement agencies that the History Channel is in on this vast conspiracy? Have you contacted the insurers who paid out billions of dollars on the WTC buildings (including ~800 million on WTC7) to alert them to this startling, earth-shattering evidence that nobody on the planet except you noticed? If not, why not?

You don't know and just because you don't want to believe it doesn't make it untrue.

I don't believe it because it is ridiculous on its face and not supported by any evidence whatsoever.

I am not making this up and did not have an axe to grind.

I don't believe you.

I heard it innocently enough and only later after hearing about Jones' theory of pre-positioned cutter charges did I start questioning due to what I had heard.

As I said above, I don't believe you. I think that you are either mistaken or deliberately making it up.
 
Last edited:
This may be true, but you have to admit, it's awfully convenient. Who did you contact? May I try to contact them and see what they say? Please send a PM with contact information, and I will not make it public.
I can save you one call. The History Channel store does not have a listing for the series at all. I had to direct them to the HistoryChannel.com site to prove the show originated there and give them a starting point. They still found nothing.

As shown above there are several audio programs from the series that you can listen to online, a program on Larry Silverstein is not listed among them. The only mention of LS in a search of the site brings up the 9/11 Conspiracy movies they have listed. There is a listing for the series "History's Bussiness" on iTunes, but I am at work and cannot access the details of which ones are available.
 
Last edited:
Why don't you open your eyes to the fact that there are legitimate questions which need to be answered concerning what happened on Sept. 11, 2001.

My eyes are wide open, and I have examined the evidence to date carefully. I will examine any additional evidence that you care to bring to the table with equal care and give it all due consideration, but so far, you haven't brought any. What questions do you think need to be answered that have not been answered to your satisfaction? Please be specific, and please use your own words.

I am not accusing anyone of actually committing a crime. I am saying certain people should be questioned, who have not been questioned to date. Everyone who needs to be questioned isn't necessarily a suspect.

It has become apparent over the past several years that twoofers rarely accuse anyone by name, or directly, or of anything specific; rather, you accuse by innuendo and insinuation, which is the lowest, sleaziest form of accusation, frankly.

So, again, be specific and name names. Who do you say "needs to be questioned", on what basis, on what subjects, to what end, and which of them are and are not "suspects" (and for those who are "suspects", please also set out the crimes that they are "suspects" in). What form do you envision this "questioning" to take? Which of the people you name in answer to my queries above have not already been questioned? And, who will do the questioning that you envision?
 
I can save you one call. The History Channel store does not have a listing for the series at all. I had to direct them to the HistoryChannel.com site to prove the show originated there and give them a starting point. They still found nothing.

I wasn't talking about the Store. I was planning to go straight to the show's producers.

Surely something of such earth-shattering importance is worth a few inquiries in the real world, no?

In any case, I cannot believe that Chief Nigro was lying, not without a whole lot more and verified evidence. $100 says realcddeal simply misheard or misremembers.
 
Ahem. After reading through this thread so far, I'm detecting a profound lack of something:


Point: Top demolition expert Brent Blanchard has published a paper refuting the conclusion that WTC7 was brought down in a controlled demolition.

Counterpoint: I don't believe Brent Blanchard, and neither do a lot of people I know. <--- who may or may not be engineers


Point: Danny Jowenko said that WTC 1 and 2 did not fall from CDs.

Counterpoint: I don't know of that quote, so I'll ignore it.


Point: Basically no demolition experts are in support of the CD theory.

Counterpoint: Why is NIST having such a hard time fighting my awesomeness? You need to get for real.


Point: Why should the US secure oil when neighboring countries will always sell it to us?

Counterpoint: Watch this Google documentary.


Point: NYFD Chief Daniel Nigro is on record saying that WTC7 was not a CD, and he has the authority to make such a statement.

Counterpoint: I recall that on an obscure talk show five years ago Larry Silverstein said WTC7 was a CD. My memory is superior to written statements by the NYFD.


Point: It's ridiculous to think you can trust your five-year-old memory to prove a crucial point of your argument.

Counterpoint: I showed you the link showing Silverstein was on that show. And I recall he said what he said. Therefore I am right.


Hmm...doesn't seem to be much substance here.

-Sporanox
 
Ahem. After reading through this thread so far, I'm detecting a profound lack of something:

...snip...
Point: Basically no demolition experts are in support of the CD theory.

Counterpoint: Why is NIST having such a hard time fighting my awesomeness? You need to get for real.
...snip...

Hmm...doesn't seem to be much substance here.

-Sporanox
I wondered if he really thought the tax payers should foot the bill and engineers should spend the time for a new investigation because he didn't like the first.

If I haven't already, welcome to the forum Sporanox.
 
I wondered if he really thought the tax payers should foot the bill and engineers should spend the time for a new investigation because he didn't like the first.

If I haven't already, welcome to the forum Sporanox.

Yeah, really...as if in the eventuality that Silverstein et. al. really were NWO, they would spill their secrets just because they were called to testify. Truthers seem to have an unshakable belief in the power of the oath.

Thanks for the welcome!

-Sporanox
 
Yeah, really...as if in the eventuality that Silverstein et. al. really were NWO, they would spill their secrets just because they were called to testify. Truthers seem to have an unshakable belief in the power of the oath.

Thanks for the welcome!

-Sporanox
Yeah. If these people commited one of the most unforgivable sins in recorded history, why would swearing on a bible suddenly make them repent?

I thinks it's the same mentality that thinks if they yell at Rudy Guilliani on the street, he will bust down crying and confess all.
 
I find it hilarious that Mr. Szamboti expects us to take his outrageous claim seriously, based on his recollection alone. He can't produce a single other person who can attest what he thinks he saw, when there should be thousands of them, yet we're just supposed to take his word for it. Bizarre. Same deal with MaGZ's ludicrous claim that he saw a missile strike WTC7 on some Fox News coverage.
 
I find it hilarious that Mr. Szamboti expects us to take his outrageous claim seriously, based on his recollection alone. He can't produce a single other person who can attest what he thinks he saw, when there should be thousands of them, yet we're just supposed to take his word for it. Bizarre. Same deal with MaGZ's ludicrous claim that he saw a missile strike WTC7 on some Fox News coverage.
I was willing to do a little leg work for him, and honestly tried to find some recording of the program he is talking about. If he can produce audio or audio/video of the program (or a well sourced transcript) I'll listen to (read) it, apologize, and maybe doubt the Generally Accepted Story.
 
Mark, they are not incompatible and I explained this to you before.

I was puzzled over Bldg. 7's complete collapse from the time I heard about it on the evening of Sept. 11, 2001. It hadn't been hit by a plane and even though the news said it had some damage and some fires I was still puzzled at its total and complete to the ground collapse. When I saw the History Channel show in Sept. 2002 and Larry Silverstein made the comment about Bldg. 7 being a controlled demolition for safety reasons it made sense to me as it was logical. I was not suspicious about the events of 911 except for being puzzled about the complete collapse of Bldg. 7 and that was then settled.

I would have accepted the fire and damage claims made about the towers from that time until early 2006 as I was not suspicious. I watched Silverstein say Bldg. 7 was a controlled demolition in 2002 so I wouldn't/couldn't have accepted other claims on it. If it wasn't clear I hope it is now.

In March of 2006 I started hearing about a BYU physics professor bringing up issues with molten metal in the rubble of all three collapsed buildings at Ground Zero. At first I was dismissive but said to myself I should read what he was saying before judging. Well after reading what Steve Jones said about there being pre-positioned cutter charges in the buildings, and knowing I had seen Silverstein say it was a controlled demolition for safety reasons, but not immediately being willing to accept what Steven Jones was saying, I had to ask myself when there would have been a chance to set the charges in Bldg. 7, as it couldn't have been done that day. That is what got me to start looking at this a little deeper. Here is a link that shows that Larry Silverstein was on that show I watched called History's Business. It was on at 8:30 AM on Sunday mornings.

http://couchville.com/show/history's-business/larry-silverstein

I would like to know why the story changed. I think Larry Silverstein and others need to come clean.


You are lying about Silverstein claiming that building 7 was a controlled demolition. Let's be clear about this: you do not "remember" him saying this because he never said anything of the sort. You are lying.

How can I be sure? Easy--it wasn't front-page news on every daily in the country. Really, it's as simple as that. Something you fantasists always overlook is that any scrap of your "evidence," if validated, would win a Pulitzer Prize for the reporter who broke the story.

Maybe every news outlet in the country is part of the Impossibly Conspiracy. So, why can't you peddle your snake oil in other countries?
 
Which is to say, I'd start having doubts when pigs sprout wings...

Somehow, some way, I'm waiting for RealCD to reach an epiphany and loop the whole thing back to the "pull it" quote, at which point JREFers will be practically falling over one another to repeat themselves for the trillionth time.

-Sporanox
 
Last edited:
Mark, they are not incompatible and I explained this to you before.
I'll explain this to you once more, Tony Szamboti, and I'll try to make it even simpler for you.

You said that until 2006 you would have accepted that the buildings collapsed from damage and fire.

You also said that in 2002 you heard Larry Silverstein state that WTC 7 was destroyed by a controlled demolition for safety reasons, and that nothing can change your mind about that.

These are two completely different reasons for collapse. If you believed them both, there must be something very wrong with your thought process, since obviously they can't both be true.

It seems clear that you're just making this stuff up as you go, which is not how rational adults behave.

So please stop doing it, okay? That's not asking a lot.
 
Last edited:
As for a large proportion of the free world hearing about it, how many people do you know who watch History's Business on Sunday mornings?

I actually have watched a few episodes, one was on a men's wear store in Manhattan (I was doing other things with it on). I found the show rather stiff, and only interesting from a retail customer service perspective. The only other things on were infomercials.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom