[split]WTC7 and CD - split from: Question for Ryan Mackey

Ron, what do you think caused the collapse of WTC7?


I'm guessing that the heavy damage caused by all the debris that fell on it and the resultant extensive fires that burned for hours had something to do with it. Who knows?--maybe those fuel tanks played a role. But, I'm willing to wait for the NIST Report to find out what serious researchers conclude. How about you?
 
I'm guessing that the heavy damage caused by all the debris that fell on it and the resultant extensive fires that burned for hours had something to do with it. Who knows?--maybe those fuel tanks played a role. But, I'm willing to wait for the NIST Report to find out what serious researchers conclude. How about you?


I believe it was a controlled demolition, due to its completeness, symmetry, and rapid descent. Whether it was for safety reasons or not we don't know as that isn't being discussed.
 
Last edited:
I believe it was a controlled demolition, whether it was for safety reasons or not we don't know as that isn't being discussed.

Well that makes sense.

Blow up a building for safety (ie. legit) reasons and then....cover it up!

:dl:
 
I believe it was a controlled demolition, whether it was for safety reasons or not we don't know as that isn't being discussed.


So, why do demolition experts reject the fantasist myth about explosives? What do you know that they don't?
 
So, why do demolition experts reject the fantasist myth about explosives? What do you know that they don't?

If you are speaking of Brent Blanchard, his article was not very convincing to myself and several other engineers I work with.

How many demolition experts are out there, besides Blanchard, saying unequivocally that WTC7's collapse could not have been a controlled demolition?

Danny Jowenko is one who certainly believes it was a controlled demolition.

If fire would have been the cause for the collapse of that building it would have been asymmetric to some degree and there would have been at least some protraction prior to collapse. It was too complete. For all of the columns to fail simultaneously and rapidly, due to asymmetric fires, strains credulity.
 
Last edited:
If you are speaking of Brent Blanchard, his article was not very convincing to myself and several other engineers I work with.

You do realize you are making a logical fallacy here with an appeal to authority here don't you?

How many demolition experts are out there, besides Blanchard, saying unequivocally that WTC7's collapse could not have been a controlled demolition?

Danny Jowenko is one who certainly believes it was a controlled demolition.

The real issue here is that there is a great lack of demolition experts claiming 9/11 was a controlled demolition. You can't pretend that the majority are simply being quiet and not speaking up so as to pretend to have some kind of support. But as usual, you just make empty complaints instead of actually pointing out flaws.

And as usual the retort on the lack of credible demolition experts backing the 9/11 woo is Jowenko, a guy who also does not agree about WTC 1&2 being a CD and was given cherry picked material for WTC 7 so as to lead him to believe it was. Do you think it's honest to do that? Don't you think it would be more honest to present him with all the evidence instead of just the bits that present a conspiracy theory? It's dishonest.
 
If you are speaking of Brent Blanchard, his article was not very convincing to myself and several other engineers I work with.

You do realize you are making a logical fallacy here with an appeal to authority here don't you?


It's a safe bet that no one here thinks you work with engineers. No engineer could possibly be so uninformed and so uncomfortable with basic science. Typically, you provide no evidence that you have actually read Blanchard's apper. What did he get wrong?



How many demolition experts are out there, besides Blanchard, saying unequivocally that WTC7's collapse could not have been a controlled demolition?

Danny Jowenko is one who certainly believes it was a controlled demolition.


There are no demolition experts, apart from Danny Jowenko, who take the demolition myth seriously. Incidentally, you concede that Jowenko is correct when he states that the collapses of the Towers do not in any way resemble demolitions?
 
It's a safe bet that no one here thinks you work with engineers. No engineer could possibly be so uninformed and so uncomfortable with basic science. Typically, you provide no evidence that you have actually read Blanchard's apper. What did he get wrong?

It doesn't mean a hill of beans whether you or anybody else on here thinks I work with engineeers or not. The fact is I am one and I do work with a lot of engineers in the Aerospace industry. In fact, since you are in New York and not too far from me, as I live in South Jersey and work in Southeastern Pennsylvania, why don't we bet a few thousand dollars on your claim and you can take a ride down and I'll introduce you to the people I work with.

I wasn't trying to do a critique of Blanchard's article in that comment. I merely mentioned that it was not convincing to me and others I know. There was no need to support that statement with anything else.

I'll discuss Blanchard's work tomorrow if I get time.


There are no demolition experts, apart from Danny Jowenko, who take the demolition myth seriously. Incidentally, you concede that Jowenko is correct when he states that the collapses of the Towers do not in any way resemble demolitions?

How do you know there aren't any other demolition people who believe WTC7 was a controlled demolition? I haven't heard any give an opinion other than Blanchard and Jowenko.

As for Jowenko and the Twin Towers I haven't heard his comment on that.

As far as I am concerned I have done structural design work for static and dynamic loads for years and I don't need to appeal to authority on these matters as you apparently feel the need to. The facts are the facts and if the supposed expert's opinion doesn't line up with the facts then it isn't worth the paper it is written on. I don't know if you have read the paper I wrote concerning the towers. It is on the Journal of 911 Studies and that will tell you what I believe happened there. Goodnight.
 
Last edited:
The real issue here is that there is a great lack of demolition experts claiming 9/11 was a controlled demolition. You can't pretend that the majority are simply being quiet and not speaking up so as to pretend to have some kind of support. But as usual, you just make empty complaints instead of actually pointing out flaws.

And as usual the retort on the lack of credible demolition experts backing the 9/11 woo is Jowenko, a guy who also does not agree about WTC 1&2 being a CD and was given cherry picked material for WTC 7 so as to lead him to believe it was. Do you think it's honest to do that? Don't you think it would be more honest to present him with all the evidence instead of just the bits that present a conspiracy theory? It's dishonest.

Why is NIST having such a hard time with explaining the collapse of WTC7, as something other than controlled demolition, if there is all this evidence you speak of? You need to get for real.
 
I believe it was a controlled demolition, due to its completeness, symmetry, and rapid descent.
Now you just need to explain the lack of very loud booms of the demolition charges going off. Funny how no one speaks of hearing those very loud and distinctive sounds, funny how none of the many video cameras in the area recorded those very loud and distinctive sounds.
 
Last edited:
Why is NIST having such a hard time with explaining the collapse of WTC7, as something other than controlled demolition, if there is all this evidence you speak of? You need to get for real.

Nonlinearity.
 
If you are speaking of Brent Blanchard, his article was not very convincing to myself and several other engineers I work with.

How many demolition experts are out there, besides Blanchard, saying unequivocally that WTC7's collapse could not have been a controlled demolition?

Danny Jowenko is one who certainly believes it was a controlled demolition.


Why? I suppose Jowenko's article is very convincing. Oh wait, he hasn't written an article, but merely commented on a video, the circumstances which he knew nothing of. I like that reasoning.

You keep bringing up your engineers as if the CD theory has backing amongst the engineering community. Well, I'll counter for the umpteenth time as someone who works on skyscraper design and construction. ALL of the engineers and contractors I know mock with extreme contempt advocates of 9/11 cd.

Why not include the commentary of those who were there and observed WTC7 instead of Jowenko who had no idea what he was viewing?

From the Blanchard article.

Several demolition teams had reached Ground Zero by 3:00 pm on 9/11, and these individuals witnessed the collapse of WTC7 from within a few hundred feet of the event. We have spoken with several who possess extensive experience in explosive demolition, and all reported hearing or seeing nothing to indicate an explosive detonation precipitating the collapse. One eyewitness told us, "We were all standing around helpless..we knew full well it was going to collapse. Everyone there knew. You gotta remember there was a lot of confusion and we didn't know if another plane was coming....but I never heard explosions like demo charges. We knew with the damage to that building and how hot the fire was, that building was gonna go, so we just waited and a little later it went."


Ok ladies and gentlemen of the jury, we present to you eyewitness testimony by demolition experts on the site of the collapse versus the view of a demolition expert who wasn't there and had no idea of what he was viewing. So far Jowenko has explained squat on why he believes WTC7 was felled by explosives. Guess who you side with. Amazing. I hope you never serve on a jury.


This is a message from Chief of Department (ret.) Daniel Nigro, addressing the conspiracy theories surrounding the collapse of WTC7. Thank you very much for this statement, Mr. Nigro. The work you and your colleagues did that day will never be forgotten. I have been in contact with him, and he gave me the permission to publish this. I have confirmed with our moderator Lisa Simpson, that this message really is from him.

Got to my page http://911guide.googlepages.com/danielnigro for this message and his bio. Here is the message part:


Regarding WTC 7: The long-awaited US Government NIST (National Institute of Standards and Technology) report on the collapse of WTC 7 is due to be published at the end of this year (although it has been delayed already a few times [ adding fuel to the conspiracy theorists fires!]). That report should explain the cause and mechanics of the collapse in great detail. Early on the afternoon of September 11th 2001, following the collapse of WTC 1 & 2, I feared a collapse of WTC 7 (as did many on my staff).
The reasons are as follows:

1 - Although prior to that day high-rise structures had never collapsed, The collapse of WTC 1 & 2 showed that certain high-rise structures subjected to damage from impact and from fire will collapse.
2. The collapse of WTC 1 damaged portions of the lower floors of WTC 7.
3. WTC 7, we knew, was built on a small number of large columns providing an open Atrium on the lower levels.
4. numerous fires on many floors of WTC 7 burned without sufficient water supply to attack them.

For these reasons I made the decision (without consulting the owner, the mayor or anyone else - as ranking fire officer, that decision was my responsibility) to clear a collapse zone surrounding the building and to stop all activity within that zone. Approximately three hours after that order was given, WTC 7 collapsed.

Conspiracy theories abound and I believe firmly that all of them are without merit.

Regards, Dan Nigro
Chief of Department FDNY (retired)


http://wtc7lies.googlepages.com/eyewitnessaccountsofthewithdrawalfromwtc
 
Why is NIST having such a hard time with explaining the collapse of WTC7, as something other than controlled demolition, if there is all this evidence you speak of? You need to get for real.

Once again, playing the conspiracy shuffle. moving from one argument to another while avoiding each previous one.

NIST isn't having trouble with WTC7, they had the research of WTC 1&2 sped up with greater funding and man power to answer the real issues that needed to be addressed. Appeasing Wooers is not on their priority list. And they have not had any trouble in the CD department as they have stated that they have already ruled out any possibility of a CD.

BTW, why is the Woo movement having such a hard time explaining their demolition theories as anything other than conjecture?
 
As for Jowenko and the Twin Towers I haven't heard his comment on that.

Of course not. It only made up the majority of his interview.

realcddeal said:
I don't know if you have read the paper I wrote concerning the towers. It is on the Journal of 911 Studies and that will tell you what I believe happened there.

And it was no doubt "peer-reviewed." :rolleyes:
 
From the standpoint of construction safety, WTC 7 is more important than WTC 1 and 2.

WTC 1 and 2 suffered events that no typical structure should ever experience, and are well beyond our ability to cheaply protect against through passive means. Their collapse was a surprise only to a few technically ignorant people, who collectively haven't produced a single coherent argument why they believe what they believe.

WTC 7, on the other hand, experienced a severe but much more ordinary situation: being pummeled by debris and suffering a lengthy fire. While WTC 1 and 2 are only likely to be repeated by other deliberate, evil, conscious, murderous acts of terrorism, WTC 7's case could happen again -- a demolition gone bad, perhaps; a landslide or seismicity; an underground utilities explosion.

Even if this was not the case, the fact that WTC 7 stayed standing so much longer than WTC 1 and 2 suggests that it was much more able to handle its problems, and thus a much better test of engineering systems in the function for which they were designed. Its evolution and eventual failure are far more interesting to civil engineers.

Additionally, we have seen signs that the WTC 7 investigation has grown in scope over time. This was not the case for WTC 1 and 2. The WTC 7 investigation should also cover a few loose ends, such as the probable cause and effect (if any) of steel sulfidation noted but thus far deferred.

Thus, no secret that the WTC 7 investigation is taking so long. Its results are ultimately much more important, even if it has nothing whatsoever to do with politics.

One would have thought this obvious to an engineer, but sometimes we all need a little help.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom