So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sockpuppet thread

Thread where she mentions getting her mod powers back.

If you look through the forum notices you'll probably find the suspension notice for Radial Tire and the ban notice for rebecca.
Thanks, I got my wires crossed and confused Rebecca with someone else. I thought she had been banned a year or too earlier. I guess we didn't cross paths much after I stopped posting in forum community. Now I need to figure out who it was that did get banned way back then.
 
........................................… ________
....................................,.… ................``~.,
.............................,.-".....… ........................"-.,
.........................,/...........… .............................":,
.....................,?...............… .................................\,
.................../..................… ..................................,}
................./....................… ...........................,:`^`..}
.............../......................… ......................,:"........./
..............?.....__................… ......................:`.........../
............./__.(....."~-,_..........… ...................,:`........../
.........../(_...."~,_........"~,_.... ................,:`........_/
..........{.._$;_......"=,_......."-, _.......,.-~-,},.~";/....}
...........((.....*~_......."=-._..... .";,,./`..../"............../
...,,,___.\`~,......"~.,.............. ......`.....}............../
............(....`=-,,.......`........… ...........(......;_,,-"
............/.`~,......`-.............… .............\....../\
.............\`~.*-,..................… ..............|,./.....\,__
,,_..........}.>-._\..................… ..............|..............`=~-,
.....`=~-,_\_......`\,................… ...............\
...................`=~-,,.\,..........… ................\
................................`:,,..… .................`\..............__
.....................................`… ...............,%`>--==``
......................................… ......._,-%.......`\
...................................,<`… -&``................ `

....
I bet you were good at Etch-a-Sketch. :)
 
I finally had a chance to listen to the Point of Inquiry podcast interviewing Rebecca. It was sorta like two different interviews. The first part was necessarily about Elevatorgate, and necessarily involved the presentation of the white-washed Rebecca version which had little to do with reality. The second part was interesting in that it was the first time I had heard Rebecca make a reasonable case for feminism and skepticism. And of course, the elevator incident had nothing to do with her concerns or with the rational ways in which the two could fit together. Unfortunately, I think that Rebecca has done a large amount of damage to her cause. In the minds of those unfamiliar with her message, now feminist/skepticism will be about making men out to be creeps at skeptical events.

I don't know how much of her case is legitimate. The problem with carving out a niche for yourself is that you have to make it appear as though there is a distinct problem and you have to pretend that no one else is addressing the issue (hence the need for your voice). Rebecca mostly refers to informally gathered information ('lots' of women write her about being hit on at skeptic meetings) and her perceptions about the subject matter and speaker and attendee gender at skeptical conferences. This would really benefit from a more formal data collection, as Rebecca hasn't demonstrated that she is capable of avoiding misrepresentations and misperceptions. In the blogosphere echo-chamber, people confirm her perceptions, but we would all recognize that this is highly unreliable were it on a topic like homeopathy. And the idea that these issues don't arise otherwise, that the topics addressed under "skepticism" are the topics of interest to rich, white, men, doesn't seem valid on it's face - for example, that the religious right's war on women doesn't get included in the discussions of the religious right's war on science seems to be false. I can certainly buy that progress can be made. But why not offer data instead of stories which will only be compelling to the already converted?

Anyway, Chris Mooney referred to her as a rising star of the skeptical movement. I suppose I can't really criticize her if I haven't made the effort to find out why. But I still don't understand "why?"

Linda
 
... Anyway, Chris Mooney referred to her as a rising star of the skeptical movement. I suppose I can't really criticize her if I haven't made the effort to find out why. But I still don't understand "why?"

Linda


I think her rising star's part of the reality star phenomenon; largely a product of internet blogs, the web's answer to reality tv. She blogs and video-blogs regularly about herself and her life, serial candor which gives fans a personal connection. When she was member here, anytime she had done anything, or anything crossed her mind -- I remember she started a thread "I have a turnip" -- you could be sure there would be a thread about it (and I don't mean that to be disparaging; that sort of casual conversation over the net is fun; I think I posted a recipe in the turnip thread). I think she has a good sense of humor, more in touch with pop culture than academics such as Dawkins are typically, so is easier to identify with for skeptics her age and non-academics. She's obviously put a lot of work into the skepchick site, a lot of work into marketing it and herself, and deserves a lot of credit for being successful at it.

I've already mentioned my problems with some of the ill-considered marketing for her site in light of complaints about EG's lack of consideration for her comfort, and in passing a troubling history of cliquish "attack the attacker" in the face of even well-meant criticism (just the latest example at TAM, where a couple of attendees mentioned that each Skepchick had emailed the dozen or so presenters asking them to set aside a portion of their talk to denounce Dawkins for his comments -- I'm sure Neil deGrasse Tyson appreciated that); however, since they seem destined to be a prominent face of skepticism for the near future at least, optimists might chalk it up to growing pains, and hope any important issues that have been raised get a fair and rational hearing once everyone's calmed down and grown up a little (even me, if that's possible). Maybe even a good thing in the long run? (Can leopards change their spots? Leotards their socks?) We'll see.
 
I deeply admire Rebecca Watson for having found a way to immunize herself against any criticism forever. Any disagreement is obviously a manifestation of the impotent tears of Man-Children Who Just Don't Get It, or worse, the Victorian masochism of self-loathing, obsequious daddy-issue women blind to their servility.

I hate the internet.
 
(just the latest example at TAM, where a couple of attendees mentioned that each Skepchick had emailed the dozen or so presenters asking them to set aside a portion of their talk to denounce Dawkins for his comments -- I'm sure Neil deGrasse Tyson appreciated that);

Is there a source? I'd like to put this, or at least something about TAM 9 in the timeline.
 
What is it with some people that they cannot see any valid arguments that deviate from their world view. It's one thing to take a side and another to attack the opposing side and only pick out the worst examples and paint everyone who opposes with the same brush. Disappointing but let's bear in mind we are talking about humans here. Being a self proclaimed skeptic or critical thinker or belonging to a group that tends to share those values does not insure anything.
 
I deeply admire Rebecca Watson for having found a way to immunize herself against any criticism forever. Any disagreement is obviously a manifestation of the impotent tears of Man-Children Who Just Don't Get It, or worse, the Victorian masochism of self-loathing, obsequious daddy-issue women blind to their servility.
A man can take issue with RW and a lot of the arguments made by her and her supporters without being a forehead-sloping, knuckle-dragging, grunt-expelling Neanderthal

I hate the internet.
Me too, except for the porn.

... oh damn!
 
....(just the latest example at TAM, where a couple of attendees mentioned that each Skepchick had emailed the dozen or so presenters asking them to set aside a portion of their talk to denounce Dawkins for his comments -- I'm sure Neil deGrasse Tyson appreciated that); ....
I find this extremely difficult to believe. Is there any evidence? Who made the claim?


Then again, there was this Dear Richard letter campaign on SkepChick.
 
Last edited:
Is "Skepchick" an official designation? I thought it was just a general word that some female skeptics chose to call themselves but the way it's used in the last few posts makes me think there is an official Skepchick group.
 
Is "Skepchick" an official designation? I thought it was just a general word that some female skeptics chose to call themselves but the way it's used in the last few posts makes me think there is an official Skepchick group.
It's essentially a brand marketed initially by RW and later a larger group of women joined the fray.
 
It's essentially a brand marketed initially by RW and later a larger group of women joined the fray.

But when someone says that RW (allegedly) tried to get each Skepchick to contact the speakers, is that a defined group of women or does it just mean that RW tried to get some female skeptics she knew at TAM to do it.

This reminds me...I wonder whatever happened to Girl 6. As I recall it was her idea to start TAM. That turned out to be pretty fruitful idea.

And as I recall it was somebody other than Randi's idea to start the forum. Can you imagine where we'd be today without TAM and the forum? Maybe we'd still just be coming here once a week to read Randi's columns.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom