So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Hopefully this works. My first attempt to embed a video. Something new from Rebecca Watson. This should jump start the conversation.

**Edit** Apparently, I'm not allowed to post outside URLs until I make more than 15 posts to the forum. But, if interested, you may find the video here:

//youtu.be/7m1sm8z7i0I

 
paraphrase

"I just want to thank all of you who paid attention to me."

Mission accomplished. :cool:
I love the straw man. Like someone really asked her how they could get laid if they couldn't corner a woman in an elevator.

"Most normal people get that".

Thing that gets me is that it is obvious that not for one moment has any valid criticism gotten through to her. Everyone doesn't get it but she does.
 
paraphrase

"I just want to thank all of you who paid attention to me."

The more I see of her, the more I realize that her only usable weapon is snark; and it's quantum snark, at that. She is clearly out of her depth, here.

The rest of my comments are petty, but when that snark has a co-morbidity with an irritating vocal fry and the now ubiquitous penchant for ending every statement with a high rising terminal, she comes off as a walking cliche. </petty>

It seems to me that it's beyond futile to address, much less take seriously, Youtube comments. Isn't that what basically got her into this mess in the first place? Conflating random Youtube comments with Stef McGraw's criticisms?

One hopes for a more substantive counterpoint that actually defends her position rather than taking the extreme of the extreme and holding it up as and (the) example of her opposition. This is a straw man, no?
 
Hopefully this works. My first attempt to embed a video. Something new from Rebecca Watson. This should jump start the conversation.

**Edit** Apparently, I'm not allowed to post outside URLs until I make more than 15 posts to the forum. But, if interested, you may find the video here:

//youtu.be/7m1sm8z7i0I
I don't think you are allowed to post links until you have about 15 posts.

I see someone else has helped you out. When you do get privileges the youtube code is
 
Last edited:

I think I've given myself whiplash from how hard I facepalmed.

Her entire video was strawman. No one argued that she should be cornered in an elevator. Unless a man getting on an elevator with a woman is considered cornering. She also equated every disagreement as saying this.

Then she goes to say she had to turn her notifications off because "other youtubers" followers" were harrassing her.

Then she switches full ad-hominem saying that these people wanted sex advice from her, and saying "well you can't get laid because you're a loser, try a real doll or a fleshlight."

The only thing I've learned through this is that Rebecca and Skepchicks are incapable of having a rational discussion about sexism, and that Rebecca is milking this for as much attention as she can get. I'm pretty sure this video was made to stir the bees nest again so she can profit off of her divisive agenda.
 
The only thing I've learned through this is that Rebecca and Skepchicks are incapable of having a rational discussion about sexism, and that Rebecca is milking this for as much attention as she can get. I'm pretty sure this video was made to stir the bees nest again so she can profit off of her divisive agenda.

You know, there's something I am wondering, as I am fairly new to skepticism.

Was anywhere near this amount of discussion or shows of support when Mohammed Bouyeri killed Theo Van Gogh and stabbed a letter into his chest threatening the life of Ayan Ali Hirsi, the feminist atheist who had previously received widespread death threats after making a movie with Van Gogh criticizing Islam's view towards women? Did the skeptical community rally around her when she was under siege and had to go into hiding after Van Gogh's murder, and raise a firestorm of publicity about the issue, and about the work Hirsi had done throughout her life that put her at such risk?
 
Last edited:
You know, there's something I am wondering, as I am fairly new to skepticism.

Was anywhere near this amount of discussion or shows of support when Mohammed Bouyeri killed Theo Van Gogh and stabbed a letter into his chest threatening the life of Ayan Ali Hirsi, the feminist atheist who had previously received widespread death threats after making a movie with Van Gogh criticizing Islam's view towards women? Did the skeptical community rally around her when she was under siege and had to go into hiding after Van Gogh's murder, and raise a firestorm of publicity about the issue, and about the work Hirsi had done throughout her life that put her at such risk?

Not enough of a big deal was made about it, and not nearly enough people got outraged by it, even in the skepchick site. Ironically Richard Dawkins and the RDF have been the biggest proponents of her speaking out against female oppression in Islam. You know what, that kind of puts what he said into perspective. I think RW hit a nerve with RD because his organization actually does something to help women who are actually being harmed, and Rebecca came out and said the skeptic movement was sexist because she gets hit on too much and gets hate mail.

Richard Dawkins actually does something and gives ayaan ali hirsi a spot on the RDF website to speak freely about sexism in Islam, uses the RDF to provide childcare at skeptic conventions.

Rebecca Watson throws parties and whines about being uncomfortable in an elevator.

Hmm I think Dawkins wins as a skeptic fighting for oppressed women, not Rebecca.
 
Rebecca (her name) was suspended for using a sock puppet, and upon her return got SUPER-moderator powers (she used to be a moderator at some point) due to a bug, and abused those powers to screw around with the forum, for which she was banned.

Seriously?
 
You know, there's something I am wondering, as I am fairly new to skepticism.

Was anywhere near this amount of discussion or shows of support when Mohammed Bouyeri killed Theo Van Gogh and stabbed a letter into his chest threatening the life of Ayan Ali Hirsi, the feminist atheist who had previously received widespread death threats after making a movie with Van Gogh criticizing Islam's view towards women? Did the skeptical community rally around her when she was under siege and had to go into hiding after Van Gogh's murder, and raise a firestorm of publicity about the issue, and about the work Hirsi had done throughout her life that put her at such risk?

No; there was nowhere near that amount of discussion.

However, there's another factor involved. There's a magical reality distortion field around anything related to Islam or Muslims, both in the skeptical movement and in (at least) American feminism.
 

........................................… ________
....................................,.… ................``~.,
.............................,.-".....… ........................"-.,
.........................,/...........… .............................":,
.....................,?...............… .................................\,
.................../..................… ..................................,}
................./....................… ...........................,:`^`..}
.............../......................… ......................,:"........./
..............?.....__................… ......................:`.........../
............./__.(....."~-,_..........… ...................,:`........../
.........../(_...."~,_........"~,_.... ................,:`........_/
..........{.._$;_......"=,_......."-, _.......,.-~-,},.~";/....}
...........((.....*~_......."=-._..... .";,,./`..../"............../
...,,,___.\`~,......"~.,.............. ......`.....}............../
............(....`=-,,.......`........… ...........(......;_,,-"
............/.`~,......`-.............… .............\....../\
.............\`~.*-,..................… ..............|,./.....\,__
,,_..........}.>-._\..................… ..............|..............`=~-,
.....`=~-,_\_......`\,................… ...............\
...................`=~-,,.\,..........… ................\
................................`:,,..… .................`\..............__
.....................................`… ...............,%`>--==``
......................................… ......._,-%.......`\
...................................,<`… -&``................ `

Ok. I'll get a doll.

She forgot to recommend something to women who disagree with her though. Well, I guess the clerks at the sex shop will be helpful.

So she reacts to the most unreasonable voices of criticism and ignores the most reasonable points that have been made against her position.

I'm impressed with such in-depth knowledge of critical thinking.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom