Peter Morris
Muse
- Joined
- May 12, 2003
- Messages
- 938
princhester said:If it suits you to take what someone says literally, there is no one on the planet more willing to do so than you. When Randi says "there are no underground rivers" you ignore any context and ignore any qualifying comments in surrounding paragraphs and ignore other comments on other occasions that clarify what he means and stick to the literal through thick and thin. He said No Underground Rivers, so he means No Underground Rivers. Period. Randi is wrong and a liar and don't you try to tell Peter he meant anything other than precisely what he said, and all Princhester does is try pathetically to interpret what Randi said as meaning something other than what Randi said.
The exact opposite is true.
I have shown Randi's comments about underground rivers withi9n the context of speeches attacking dowsers, and comments repeated on several occasions, which eliminates any sensible doubt as to what he was talking about.
Princhester, by contrast takes one sentence, or a few words out of context, and tries to attach a meaning to ythose words that simply isn't there. He insists his interpretation of those particular words is right, ignoring the rest of what Randi said in that article, ignoring what Randui said on other occasions, ignoring everyone else's interpretation of the words.