Skeptoid Podcast: Cell phones and airlines

yup. So does this event spell the end of cell phones on all airplanes and tighter enforcement of current prohibitions?

Jan. 16, 2007 4:06 | Updated Jan. 16, 2007 4:07US: Man burned after cell phone ignites in pocket

ASSOCIATED PRESS, VALLEJO, California
A cell phone apparently ignited in a man's pocket and started a fire that burned his hotel room and caused severe burns over half his body, fire department officials said. Luis Picaso, 59, was in stable condition Monday with second- and third-degree burns to his upper body, back, right arm and right leg, Vallejo Fire Department assistant chief Kurt Henke said.

More at:
http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1167467741722&pagename=JPost/JPArticle/ShowFull

A few more references to the above:

http://www.cnn.com/2007/US/01/15/cell.phone.fire.ap/

http://www.fresnobee.com/384/story/24302.html

http://abclocal.go.com/kgo/story?section=local&id=4937611

http://www.mercurynews.com/mld/mercurynews/news/local/16467412.htm
 
Last edited:
Didn't the Mythbusters have an episode about cell phones - the older analog phones did cause interference, but the new ones did not, if I remember correctly.

One pilot, with a commercial line, told me that the FAA wasn't concerned about having phones on after takeoff, as much as the FCC, Federal Communications Commission, which regulates phones, radio frequencies, also does not want this. For example, this quote:

"The FAA is not alone in its prohibition of in-flight cell phone use. The Federal Communications Commission has a ban of its own, although it has nothing to do with safety. The FCC says signals emitted by phones in the air have the potential to engage multiple cell towers and thereby cause interference with calls on the ground. There is no scientific proof behind the FCC dictate, however; the agency never commissioned a study that conclusively proved its hypothesis." (from a 2002 article from Cable World)
 
When I flew back from TAM 4 I had my video ipod on and was watching Dawkins' Root of all Evil. During takeoff I was asked to turn my ipod off.

My ipod?

WTF?



ETA: I would love to know exactly how an ipod causes interference.
 
When I flew back from TAM 4 I had my video ipod on and was watching Dawkins' Root of all Evil. During takeoff I was asked to turn my ipod off.

My ipod?

WTF?



ETA: I would love to know exactly how an ipod causes interference.

Your ipod probably does not cause interference problems.

However, the FAA has not conclusively proven that an ipod does not cause interference problems and until they do so, then use of your ipod during the flight will continue to be restricted.
 
Your ipod probably does not cause interference problems.

Quite right. While I could be on board with devices that actively emit radio emissions like laptops with wifi or cellular cards, cellular phones, PDAs with wifi or bluetooth etc. I have to roll my eyes at the restriction of devices that have no capacity for emitting anything of consequence.

However, the FAA has not conclusively proven that an ipod does not cause interference problems and until they do so, then use of your ipod during the flight will continue to be restricted.

Actually iirc, it would be the RTCA that would make this reccomendation to the FAA (Wasn't there a report due in 2005 from them?) Interestingly they haven't thought about certain digital hearing aides that can cause interference with certain other technologies...

Like I said, certain technologies are most certainly an understandable thing to restrict, however I highly doubt any specific restrictions will translate well to untrained flight attendants that may not know a PDA from a cell phone...
 
Quite right. While I could be on board with devices that actively emit radio emissions like laptops with wifi or cellular cards, cellular phones, PDAs with wifi or bluetooth etc. I have to roll my eyes at the restriction of devices that have no capacity for emitting anything of consequence.

Actually iirc, it would be the RTCA that would make this reccomendation to the FAA (Wasn't there a report due in 2005 from them?) Interestingly they haven't thought about certain digital hearing aides that can cause interference with certain other technologies...

Like I said, certain technologies are most certainly an understandable thing to restrict, however I highly doubt any specific restrictions will translate well to untrained flight attendants that may not know a PDA from a cell phone...

Hello all!

If I may interject here since there is some confusion regarding the use of cell phones on aircraft.

As a pilot myself, there is a regulation that essentially states that no personal electronics (cell phones, computers, electric shavers, radios, etc.) should be used by the passengers when the plane is in the landing and take off phase. During cruise, the pilot has the discretion to allow the use of such devices.

The idea is that during landing and take off (the most critical phase of aircraft operation) there is a possibility that the use of personal electronics could interfere with the aircraft's navigation and/or communication equipment.

Now then, larger commercial aircraft tend to use shielded and robust electronics and as such it is quite unlikely that personal electronics could actually cause such problems. However, there has not been the extensive testing and evaluation that would be required to actually establish the fact (it would probably take years and cost millions to do such testing). Therefore, the FAA has taken the conservative stance of implementing rules which restrict the use of personal electronics.

As for my experience, I have the good fortune to do flying and I have seen plenty of people use cell phones, computers, radios, etc. during landing, cruise, take-off, etc. and it has not caused any problems at all except for some occasional clicking sounds over the intercom.

However, until such a time when (and if) the rules are updated, then one still needs to follow them. So if you are on board plane, then please use (or not use) your personal electronics as directed.

Thanks much!

Speaking as an EMI Engineer in the Aerospace who's responsible for the EMC properties of flight control, engine control and cabin entertainment systems for commercial aircraft, cell phones are a pain in the butt. The problem is, the FCC standards that the phones have to me are way more laxed than the ones that define the envrionment that my boxes do. To allow cells on aircraft would mean re-testing each of them to the new environment, and (more importantly) getting FAA certification for each and every cell phone (or other electronic device).

Every one.

Every upgrade.

Every time.

This would tie up the FAA for years. It takes a considerable amount of time to qualify these things. Primarly for all the paperwork involved. I do know that there are some items out there that are sensitive to cell phones (at least one of these things as since been upgraded to remove this vunerability, but AFAIK the old version is still in use). It's way easier for all involved to have a blanket ban than do the qualification.

And not everyting in a big airliner is shielded. Cable shielding is heavy, so it's used judiciously. We prefer to filter, unless the magnetics would weigh more than the associated cable shielding would. Bear in mind, that if I were to have a cable that ran the length of a 747 (say), that's approx 600' of cable, even a 1 oz/ft increase of weight amounts to a considerable increase. There are some things that HAVE to have shielded cables (Ethernet, ARINC, RS485 and other com protocols), but those tend to be shorter runs and the exceptions. There's WAY more single ended and differential discretes than there are coms.

Fowl, why was you iPod requested to be turned off? Partly for the reasons above, partly due to an institutional paranoia that hit a zenith after 911. It's very easy to make a transmitter look like something else (iPod, cell phone etc). Now, why a bad guy who's gonna do naughty things with a look-alike item would comply with the "not during take-off" request, I have no answer; I've rarely been able to make sense of prohibitive rules/laws.

I have some cow-irkers around here who have iPods...maybe I should take one into my lab and just see what the emissions are across the RF band.
 
As a pilot myself, there is a regulation that essentially states that no personal electronics (cell phones, computers, electric shavers, radios, etc.) should be used by the passengers when the plane is in the landing and take off phase. During cruise, the pilot has the discretion to allow the use of such devices.

We were just looking in the regs the other day. Wish I had written down the rule or page number, but I didn't.

Essentially, everything is blacklisted by default, however pilots and operators can allow any personal electronics devices they want. There is no mention of "cruise phase only", they can be used during takeoff and landing also by the same rule. Airlines make that up on their own.
 
We were just looking in the regs the other day. Wish I had written down the rule or page number, but I didn't.

Essentially, everything is blacklisted by default, however pilots and operators can allow any personal electronics devices they want. There is no mention of "cruise phase only", they can be used during takeoff and landing also by the same rule. Airlines make that up on their own.

Sorry if I sound a bit fussy, but that is not entirely correct.

True, the airlines do fly with an internal rule that essentially states no passenger electronics are to be used during the landing and take-off phase. Then at cruise, the pilot has the discretion to allow such devices to be used. The airlines also have other rules that do not appear in the FAA regulations such as having the crew wear uniforms, provide inflight entertainment, and so on.

But in this case, the FAA also has a rule about the use of personal electronic devices while on the plane.

Specifically, I checked my 2004 FAR/AIM last night and here is what I found:

91.21 Portable Electronic Devices

(a) Except as provided in paragraph (b) of this
section, no person may operate, nor may any op-
erator or pilot in command of an aircraft allow the
operation of, any portable electronic device on
any of the following U.S.-registered civil aircraft.
(1) Aircraft operated by a holder of an air carrier
operating certificate or an operating certificate, or
(2) Any other aircraft while it operated under
IFR.

(b) Paragraph (a) of this section does not apply
to -
(1) Portable voice recorders;
(2) Hearing aids;
(3) Heart pacemakers;
(4) Electric shavers; or
(5) Any other portable electronic device that the
operator of the aircraft has determined will not
cause interference with the navigation or commu-
nication system of the aircraft on which it is to be
used.

(c) In the case of an aircraft operated by a
holder of an air carrier operating certificate or an
operating certificate the determination required
by paragraph (b)(5) of this section shall be made
by that operator of the aircraft on which the partic-
ular device is to be used. In the case of other air-
craft, the determination may be made the by pilot
in command or other operator of the aircraft.

Anyway, since commercial flying is usually done under IFR (Instrument Flight Rules) even when the weather is plenty good for VFR (Visual Flight Rules) since flying under flying under IFR provides clearances, radar monitoring, separation from other aircraft, communications with those on the ground, etc. Anyway, the concern is that since the landing and takeoff phase is the most instrument intensive portion of the flight, one has to be very, very careful that the use of personal electronic devices do not interfere with the communication and/or navigation equipment. While it is equally conceivable that use of personal electronic devices could cause problems at this portion of the flight as well, it is generally far easier to recover from such event several thousand feet above the ground as opposed to dealing with them when one is just a few hundred feet above the ground.

I hope this helps!
 
Sorry if I sound a bit fussy, but that is not entirely correct.

True, the airlines do fly with an internal rule that essentially states no passenger electronics are to be used during the landing and take-off phase. Then at cruise, the pilot has the discretion to allow such devices to be used. The airlines also have other rules that do not appear in the FAA regulations such as having the crew wear uniforms, provide inflight entertainment, and so on.

But in this case, the FAA also has a rule about the use of personal electronic devices while on the plane.

Specifically, I checked my 2004 FAR/AIM last night and here is what I found:



Anyway, since commercial flying is usually done under IFR (Instrument Flight Rules) even when the weather is plenty good for VFR (Visual Flight Rules) since flying under flying under IFR provides clearances, radar monitoring, separation from other aircraft, communications with those on the ground, etc. Anyway, the concern is that since the landing and takeoff phase is the most instrument intensive portion of the flight, one has to be very, very careful that the use of personal electronic devices do not interfere with the communication and/or navigation equipment. While it is equally conceivable that use of personal electronic devices could cause problems at this portion of the flight as well, it is generally far easier to recover from such event several thousand feet above the ground as opposed to dealing with them when one is just a few hundred feet above the ground.

I hope this helps!

Certainly appreciate the clarifications there! Thanks.

Functionally I see no difference between a digital voice recorder and any of the ipods (expept the video ipod, which actually uses a hard drive) due to the use of flash ram, and a digital converter. They are in function the same essential thing, except that most ipods don't record voice without an additional piece of 3rd party hardware.
 
Speaking as an EMI Engineer in the Aerospace who's responsible for the EMC properties of flight control, engine control and cabin entertainment systems for commercial aircraft, cell phones are a pain in the butt. The problem is, the FCC standards that the phones have to me are way more laxed than the ones that define the envrionment that my boxes do. To allow cells on aircraft would mean re-testing each of them to the new environment, and (more importantly) getting FAA certification for each and every cell phone (or other electronic device).

Every one.

Every upgrade.

Every time.

This would tie up the FAA for years. It takes a considerable amount of time to qualify these things. Primarly for all the paperwork involved. I do know that there are some items out there that are sensitive to cell phones (at least one of these things as since been upgraded to remove this vunerability, but AFAIK the old version is still in use). It's way easier for all involved to have a blanket ban than do the qualification.

And not everyting in a big airliner is shielded. Cable shielding is heavy, so it's used judiciously. We prefer to filter, unless the magnetics would weigh more than the associated cable shielding would. Bear in mind, that if I were to have a cable that ran the length of a 747 (say), that's approx 600' of cable, even a 1 oz/ft increase of weight amounts to a considerable increase. There are some things that HAVE to have shielded cables (Ethernet, ARINC, RS485 and other com protocols), but those tend to be shorter runs and the exceptions. There's WAY more single ended and differential discretes than there are coms.

Fowl, why was you iPod requested to be turned off? Partly for the reasons above, partly due to an institutional paranoia that hit a zenith after 911. It's very easy to make a transmitter look like something else (iPod, cell phone etc). Now, why a bad guy who's gonna do naughty things with a look-alike item would comply with the "not during take-off" request, I have no answer; I've rarely been able to make sense of prohibitive rules/laws.

I have some cow-irkers around here who have iPods...maybe I should take one into my lab and just see what the emissions are across the RF band.

Thanks!!! That clears much up for me.

However if you do test the ipod,l do make sure to test the video ipod as well as the nano or shuffle. Since as pointed out above personal recorders (which are mostly flash ram and digital converters nowadays) are allowed, the only one of the ipods that really doesn't fir that design schema would be the video, but I would be interested in both of them as well as a personal digital recorder (any standard model will do I suspect) being tested and having the results to look at.
 
Certainly appreciate the clarifications there! Thanks.

Functionally I see no difference between a digital voice recorder and any of the ipods (expept the video ipod, which actually uses a hard drive) due to the use of flash ram, and a digital converter. They are in function the same essential thing, except that most ipods don't record voice without an additional piece of 3rd party hardware.

Personally, I think you are quite right and there should be no problem. As for me, I have seen quite a few personal electronic devices (cell phones, satellite phones, satellite radios, portable DVD players, laptop PCs, handheld games, digital cameras, etc.) used on planes over the last few years and they have not caused any real problems whatsoever.

However, you should be advised that the FAA is about the most conservative regulatory agency there is and until they are completely satisfied that there is no problem with your ipod, then they will continue to rule that they do have a problem with your ipod.

Sorry, but that is just the way it is!
 
Personally, I think you are quite right and there should be no problem. As for me, I have seen quite a few personal electronic devices (cell phones, satellite phones, satellite radios, portable DVD players, laptop PCs, handheld games, digital cameras, etc.) used on planes over the last few years and they have not caused any real problems whatsoever.

However, you should be advised that the FAA is about the most conservative regulatory agency there is and until they are completely satisfied that there is no problem with your ipod, then they will continue to rule that they do have a problem with your ipod.

Sorry, but that is just the way it is!

That may be the way it is, but I certainly don't have to agree with their practices, even if forced to abide. ;)


ETA: Interesting that the military hasn't been asked to report on the use of computers/non-flight related technology, as they run many aircraft with a whole slew of equipment not intended to be taken into the air originally. IIRC, Air Force One (or more accurately the 747 comissioned to the president that uses that call sign most) has quite an impressive slew of communication, computer and other equipment on it as well...
 
Last edited:
In my experience, takeoff and landing are about the only times that you DON'T use the VOR.

Ummm,

The VOR is quite extensively during landing. Many airports have VOR Approaches and for those with Precision Approaches, most systems make use of the VOR Head that is equipped with a Glideslope Indicator (that really comes in handy).

Now then, during the immediate Takeoff phase (which lasts just several minutes, at the most), the VOR is not used. But again, that VOR Head with the Glide Slope indicator is often used.

However, during this period the VOR will be pre-tuned to the appropriate frequency and when the plane is ready to go on course, then the VOR is used pretty much from then on out.

On the other hand, if you just wish to limit your discussion to say about the last 60 seconds before you land or the first 60 seconds after you takeoff, then yes, one can say that the VOR is not used during these periods.
 
That may be the way it is, but I certainly don't have to agree with their practices, even if forced to abide. ;)


ETA: Interesting that the military hasn't been asked to report on the use of computers/non-flight related technology, as they run many aircraft with a whole slew of equipment not intended to be taken into the air originally. IIRC, Air Force One (or more accurately the 747 comissioned to the president that uses that call sign most) has quite an impressive slew of communication, computer and other equipment on it as well...

Well, one thing to note is that the military have different standard that they build non-aircraft boxen to. All the boxen associated with the 747 (from the FADEC to the Yaw, Spoiler, Aleron controllers and other flight controls) are built to a version of RTCA/DO-160, and all the coms gear etc is built to MIL-STD-461. Taken as a whole, the MS is stricter (althought you could make a case for the emissions levels, but I'd return with that the scan rates are slower for the MS, so it's still the harder test).

Plus, if the Military puts it on an airframe, it's been built for that purpose in mind. That's what keeps people like me employed. :D

In other news, I discussed the idea of quickly scanning an iPod with a cow-irker and he liked the idea. I have an empty chamber with a spare ground plane already installed (the test unit is out for post-test functional testing). We might be able to sneak in and give a quick scan. If I do, I'll post the data here. It'll be to the RTCA DO-160 RF Radiated Emissions (sec 21) limits, cause that's what I was testing, and it's the most applicable limit.

Understand, this does not constitute a qual test. This, at best, would be an enigineering evaluation. Do not use this data to try to get the FAA to change. It could get me in trouble, ok? Ok.
 
Update:
I've secured an iPod Nano. I have the chamber. Hopefully here soon, we'll be in test, and I'll be able to sneak it in during lunch or something.
 
I prefer cell phones stayed banned because I find people on cell phones annoying. I do not want to hear someone yammer on the entire flight about utter nonsense. It interferes with by normal thought pattern.

It is stupid to ban cell phones on the basis no one will hear life saving announcements. No one listens to those anyway.

Yep. I want airplanes to be a cell-free zone just because I don't want to listen to the person next to me arguing with his/her spouse, boss, whatever while confined in close quarters. I don't give a rat's arse whether or not it is safe. People can and do survive flights without smoking and without talking on cell phones.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom