Skeptoid Podcast: Cell phones and airlines

Hush! The enemy is listening! Don't say I didn't tell you when you hear about the suicide command that steered a Boeing into the Empire State Building using only their cell phones!
 
I'm with firecoins.
The principal danger of permitting cellphones on aircraft is that after five hours sitting next to some moron rabbiting on a cellphone, it would be quite understandable if any decent , meek , mild human being tore the bastard's throat out. As no sharp edged tools are permitted, he would have to do so using teeth and a plastic fork, which could be messy.

The day they permit these tools of the Devil to be used is the day I release my patented pocket EMP device for public use. And I don't care if I'm on an Airbus and the flight controls default to DOS 5. Given the choice between listening to boring lackwits on cellphones or falling 33,000 feet in a spiralling plunge to a fiery death, pass me the flamethrower !

Bic Pen, not teeth and plastic fork.
 
Just an FYI: We don't have SIM cards in the US.

Maybe, the two industries could get together and make the phones safer?

So if you want to upgrade your phone you get a new number? If you want to keep the old one you need to get the phone company to do something? And changing phones means you lose your contact lists?

In Australia the SIM card contains all such information. I could take my SIM card out and put it in another phone and that phone would act like my own phone.
 
Last edited:
Correction:

I said in the podcast that there are no FAA laws regarding personal electronics. A pilot friend and I were going through his FAA book this morning and found the reference. I can't give the exact text since he already left with the book, but the closest law says that all devices are banned by default except any that the operator or pilot allow. So it was a trifle misstated, but still comes to the same thing.

:)
 
Airphones

Isn't it all just a transparent attempt to keep us using those expensive phones that they put on the planes already?

Someone's got to be making money on those things, and they won't anymore if people can just use their cell phones.
 
Well, I was suggesting that since enforcement is lax (how could they know a cell phone in someone's carry on bag was left on?) that a new regulation preventing cell phones from going through airport security would be in order.

You think that would work out? :)
 
Isn't it all just a transparent attempt to keep us using those expensive phones that they put on the planes already?

Someone's got to be making money on those things, and they won't anymore if people can just use their cell phones.
Well, with the advent of cell phones, FAA allows Internet access via seatback phone, which is likely to be a larger demand.

Still, regarding cell phone use, I am not inclined to dismiss the IEEE article and the research conducted by the authors.
 
You think that would work out? :)
IIRC, during a certain high alert period last year, passengers were required to put their laptop computers in their checked baggage and were not permitted to bring them aboard aircraft, or were required to put them in gate-checked bags and were not allowed to bring them aboard aircraft. Cell phones are of course easily concealed, unless maybe the authorities want to tune their metal detectors or use other means to find concealed phones or other radio devices.
 
Wasn't that a question of what you would be able to hide inside a computer? I have heard people tell that they were asked by airport security to switch on their computers in order to prove that they were fully functional and not merely used as a means of transporting explosives (whatever) onboard.
 
IIRC, during a certain high alert period last year, passengers were required to put their laptop computers in their checked baggage and were not permitted to bring them aboard aircraft, or were required to put them in gate-checked bags and were not allowed to bring them aboard aircraft. Cell phones are of course easily concealed, unless maybe the authorities want to tune their metal detectors or use other means to find concealed phones or other radio devices.

There's a huge difference between a high alert period and the everyday humdrum. I could see that cells were not allowed on board during a high alert period, but I cannot imagine it would be accepted that people leave their cells at home, if they are to fly. No business man would ever fly again.

The cells could be stowed away during flight, though.
 
It would work out just as well as the new liquid rule.

No, because people can go without carrying a bottle of Coke on board. But try to ban cell phones, and you'll have a revolution on your hands.

You can get a new bottle when you land, but demand that people get a new cell every time they travel somewhere? No way.
 
All I know, is that if they do end up banning cell phones in the cabin, and I then see someone carrying a cell phone, I'll kill the f***er. On the spot. No questions asked. He's dead.
 
No, because people can go without carrying a bottle of Coke on board. But try to ban cell phones, and you'll have a revolution on your hands.

You can get a new bottle when you land, but demand that people get a new cell every time they travel somewhere? No way.
All people need to do is to turn them off. A ban is probably not required. They'd probably be asked to put them in checked luggage or in a gate-checked bag. Luggage compartments can be shielded, etc.
 
No, because people can go without carrying a bottle of Coke on board. But try to ban cell phones, and you'll have a revolution on your hands.

You can get a new bottle when you land, but demand that people get a new cell every time they travel somewhere? No way.

The urge to smoke is much stronger than the urge to use a cell phone, and look.. no smoking on planes.
 
Pyrrho - What is your theory on why cell phones are permitted through security and not required to be checked in luggage, like a firearm?
 
Just an FYI: We don't have SIM cards in the US.

Maybe, the two industries could get together and make the phones safer?

Actually, yes we do. My cell phone from T-Mobile has a SIM card. The trick is this. SIM cards are used in phones using one particular communication protocol (I think it's GSM). That protocol is used more or less universally in Europe and, apparently, Australia. Cell phone carriers in the USA use about four different protocols. Sprint, f'rinstance, uses CDMA IIRC. Sprint phones do not have SIM cards. T-Mobile, obviously, uses the European protocol whether it's GSM or something else. Every phone I've ever gotten from them had a SIM card.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom