Skeptoid Podcast: Cell phones and airlines

Oh, I dunno...



You can carry cigs on board, but you can't lit'em up. Likewise, people can carry cells on board, but simply not be allowed to switch them on.

You missed my point. Unpopular regulations CAN be enforced.

Also, it's easy to check whether someone's smoking or not. Not so easy to check a cell phone in a carry on bag.
 
Firearms go "boom". Cell phones don't.

I'm not sure that answers my question. They don't have to go boom to represent a danger, as you've proposed. I'm asking for your theory on why they're allowed to be brought into the passenger cabin at all, if they can interfere with avionics. Generally anything that's dangerous is either not allowed on board the plane, or is required to be checked.
 
I'm not sure that answers my question. They don't have to go boom to represent a danger, as you've proposed. I'm asking for your theory on why they're allowed to be brought into the passenger cabin at all, if they can interfere with avionics. Generally anything that's dangerous is either not allowed on board the plane, or is required to be checked.
First, I don't have a theory. All I could possibly offer are guesses and opinions, which do not qualify as "theory".

If I had to guess, I'd guess that cell phones are allowed aboard aircraft because cell phones are not inherently dangerous, just as DVD players, laptop computers, and GameBoys are allowed aboard--they are not inherently dangerous. There is concern that cell phones can interfere with avionics; the IEEE article supports this concern, yet does not go so far as to claim that cell phone use can bring down an aircraft, although they do speculate on the possibility that cell phone interference might have contributed to accidents. It seems unlikely that isolated cell phone use can cause a crash, yet it does seem likely that cell phone use *could* interfere with avionics and thereby contribute to accidents. One of the the IEEE authors' concerns was for cell phones that are not properly made, i.e. they are not properly shielded, etc. This could be a very real problem.

Most people seem to obey the request to turn of their cell phones, but of course, there are people who either forget or who think they know better or who think they shouldn't have to do anything they don't want to do. Isolated use may not be a problem. Unrestricted use might be a problem, as is evidenced by the valid research done for the IEEE article.

A firearm is inherently dangerous, so they are not allowed in the cabin, except in the hands of a qualified air marshal.

There is a real risk here of dismissing evidence we don't like because it interferes with our opinion. Should evidence show that cell phone use couldn't possibly interfere with avionics, sure, let everybody yammer on their phones during any given flight. I'll take the train.
 
Last edited:
Both have the potential to bring down the plane.
I think the primary concern is that a firearm has the potential to kill people. So might a cell phone, but it would take a lot more work trying to use a cell phone as a deadly weapon. The risks from a firearm vastly outweighs the risk from a cell phone, and it would be incorrect and fallacious to equate the two.

A cell phone or other electronic luxury item interfering with avionics might cause a navigational error, and in crowded skies, especially when leaving or approaching an airport--let's say Dulles, for example--an error of a thousand feet might prove fatal to more than one aircraft. Air travel has become so routine that people take for granted the skill and attention to detail that is required to successfully pilot an aircraft--and the last thing I want to do is make the pilot's job any harder than it is. Sure, maybe the pilot can execute a course correction, but why take the risk of giving him or her the extra problem, especially when the aforementioned interference has not been definitively ruled out?
 
Last edited:
You missed my point. Unpopular regulations CAN be enforced.

Yes, I argued that earlier. The problem is not the rules, but how they are enforced.

Also, it's easy to check whether someone's smoking or not. Not so easy to check a cell phone in a carry on bag.

I should hope it was! :eek:

You may be able to hide a few cigs in the bottom of your pocket, but you go through metal detectors, and your carry on bag is screened, too. Cell phones will definitely be found.
 
You may be able to hide a few cigs in the bottom of your pocket, but you go through metal detectors, and your carry on bag is screened, too. Cell phones will definitely be found.
Right. We have to pass through metal detectors and have to empty our pockets before we do. However, the system isn't foolproof, and people can pass through metal detectors with prohibited items. The advent of full-body x-ray screening will probably do much to prevent people from concealing items on their person...aside from the privacy concerns.
 
I would not like to have to have an x-ray every time I get on board an aircraft. X-rays are dangerous. This would be very true for frequent fliers.

Maybe we need two levels of security. One level for frequent fliers and another higher level for people who rarely fly.
 
Also, it's easy to check whether someone's smoking or not. Not so easy to check a cell phone in a carry on bag.

It's quite easy; carry-on bags have to go through an x-ray at security, it would be easy enough to catch any smuggled cell phones there. And it would be pretty hard to slip one through the metal detector.

That said, I leave my cell phone on when flying all the time, and I haven't died yet. Not even once. I do, however, favor the regulation against using them, but only because I don't want to be stuck in a window seat listening to someone's 5-hour conversation with Aunt Mildred.
 
It's quite easy; carry-on bags have to go through an x-ray at security, it would be easy enough to catch any smuggled cell phones there. And it would be pretty hard to slip one through the metal detector.

That said, I leave my cell phone on when flying all the time, and I haven't died yet. Not even once. I do, however, favor the regulation against using them, but only because I don't want to be stuck in a window seat listening to someone's 5-hour conversation with Aunt Mildred.

I'm sure they wouldn't want you listening on their conversation with Aunt Mildred, either. Don't be such a nosy seat neighbour, then. :p
 
Right. We have to pass through metal detectors and have to empty our pockets before we do. However, the system isn't foolproof, and people can pass through metal detectors with prohibited items. The advent of full-body x-ray screening will probably do much to prevent people from concealing items on their person...aside from the privacy concerns.

You don't even need a full-body X-ray screening. You have to go through a metal detector anyway.
 
You don't even need a full-body X-ray screening. You have to go through a metal detector anyway.
Yes, but people have been known to pass through metal detectors with objects that should have been detected. Not that I'm recommending full-body x-ray.
 
Yes, but people have been known to pass through metal detectors with objects that should have been detected. Not that I'm recommending full-body x-ray.

You will still catch the vast majority of cell phones.

No system is without holes.
 
Hello all!

If I may interject here since there is some confusion regarding the use of cell phones on aircraft.

As a pilot myself, there is a regulation that essentially states that no personal electronics (cell phones, computers, electric shavers, radios, etc.) should be used by the passengers when the plane is in the landing and take off phase. During cruise, the pilot has the discretion to allow the use of such devices.

The idea is that during landing and take off (the most critical phase of aircraft operation) there is a possibility that the use of personal electronics could interfere with the aircraft's navigation and/or communication equipment.

Now then, larger commercial aircraft tend to use shielded and robust electronics and as such it is quite unlikely that personal electronics could actually cause such problems. However, there has not been the extensive testing and evaluation that would be required to actually establish the fact (it would probably take years and cost millions to do such testing). Therefore, the FAA has taken the conservative stance of implementing rules which restrict the use of personal electronics.

As for my experience, I have the good fortune to do flying and I have seen plenty of people use cell phones, computers, radios, etc. during landing, cruise, take-off, etc. and it has not caused any problems at all except for some occasional clicking sounds over the intercom.

However, until such a time when (and if) the rules are updated, then one still needs to follow them. So if you are on board plane, then please use (or not use) your personal electronics as directed.

Thanks much!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom