Skeptibunkers and Anxious Sheeple: A Challenge.

OS just wants to pretend that anecdotes are acceptable evidence. Same as always, same as "Ufologist" and other gamers.

You see, anecdotes are proper evidence. Totally acceptable. True skeptics know this. Pseudoskeptics just won't accept this evidence because they're puppets of the establishment. Too afraid of the truth, they are in denial.

The pseudoskeptic doesn't have an open mind. He wants proof, so he refuses to acknowledge perfectly valid evidence just because it doesn't jive with the "official" story.

Those mean scientists just want to keep all discoveries for themselves, and make sure they're government-approved for public consumption. Otherwise the Men in black come and cover everything up.

Everything is a matter of opinion. Who are these scientists to decide anecdotes are not valid evidence? We're talking evidence, not proof, right?

Evidence is anything that can fit into any of the dictionary definitions for evidence. So what, if scientists use a specific definition? Why do they get to make the rules?

Anecdotes = Evidence

Null = Nonsense

Skeptic = A genius who is skeptical of everything, especially the scientific method. Loves the golden middle.

Pseudoskeptic = Silly sheeple who think they are skeptics, but are not open-minded enough to accept anecdotes as evidence.
 
OS just wants to pretend that anecdotes are acceptable evidence. Same as always, same as "Ufologist" and other gamers.

You see, anecdotes are proper evidence. Totally acceptable. True skeptics know this. Pseudoskeptics just won't accept this evidence because they're puppets of the establishment. Too afraid of the truth, they are in denial.

The pseudoskeptic doesn't have an open mind. He wants proof, so he refuses to acknowledge perfectly valid evidence just because it doesn't jive with the "official" story.

Those mean scientists just want to keep all discoveries for themselves, and make sure they're government-approved for public consumption. Otherwise the Men in black come and cover everything up.

Everything is a matter of opinion. Who are these scientists to decide anecdotes are not valid evidence? We're talking evidence, not proof, right?

Evidence is anything that can fit into any of the dictionary definitions for evidence. So what, if scientists use a specific definition? Why do they get to make the rules?

Anecdotes = Evidence

Null = Nonsense

Skeptic = A genius who is skeptical of everything, especially the scientific method. Loves the golden middle.

Pseudoskeptic = Silly sheeple who think they are skeptics, but are not open-minded enough to accept anecdotes as evidence.

Well said.
 
I used to be a UfOlogyologist. I almost never got tired of studying those who study UFOs.
 
I can't say anything about the examples I've left off your list, but do you really need evidence of the first I have left?

If you do need to see evidence of skeptics attacking the arguer and not the argument, AAH should provide rich ground for evidence hunters.

Pseudo-skepticism isn't all that relevant as it's what climate change deniers do and there's not a lot elsewhere.

Unqualified and irrational support for TBTB? Have a look in any of the shooting threads. This thread is a good example, and since I started it, I've been following most of it and there are a couple of classic posters defending the indefensible.
This thread is 77 pages long. I have looked at the first 5 and the last 5 pages. Nowhere did I see unqualified and irrational support for TPTB. The nearest I could find was Belz and Skeptic Tank, who argued forcefully that the police were justified in what they did. In this one case, and a case that has polarised opinion worldwide. In a thread full of criticism of the police. How about you narrow this down a bit and point to what specifically you think counts as this kind of support?
I'd also add in the likes of this post in that vein as well: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=10910596#post10910596

A clear case of an alleged skeptic making things up to support a story even the officials didn't suggest.
No, it isn't. It is a clear case of someone relying on evidence that was later shown to be incorrect. Unless you can demonstrate otherwise. Just because someone has a different point of view doesn't mean they are making things up. There is a thing called confirmation bias, you know.
Shilling is a little harder to evidence, because shills are by their nature somewhat reticent about their shilling.

However, there is ample proof that climate denial includes online shills, as does support for Vladimir Putin.

It's not a great leap of logic to suggest at least one of them has posted here.
Please reread my OP. I am not interested in your 'leaps of imagination'. I am asking for actual quotes, from actual members of this actual forum.
 
I am asking for actual quotes, from actual members of this actual forum.

Which would be an idiotic question because a shill isn't going to admit to being one and anything else is asusmption and supposition.

Interesting you mention confirmation bias, because the thread now seems to be exactly that for you. If they agree with you, you're right, and if not, they're wrong.
 
Which would be an idiotic question because a shill isn't going to admit to being one and anything else is asusmption and supposition.

Interesting you mention confirmation bias, because the thread now seems to be exactly that for you. If they agree with you, you're right, and if not, they're wrong.

I'm not saying a shill would admit to shilling. What I am saying is that people have levelled accusations of shilling at forum members, without supporting said accusations. I would like to see why they are coming to these conclusions.
Regarding confirmation bias: I could easily give you a list of the posts criticising the police from the thread you linked to. These posts are not subject to interpretation.
You, on the other hand, have not listed any specific posts. I'm not saying you're wrong. I'm saying I can't find what you claim is there, and am asking you to show me. Different thing altogether.
 
Shilling is a little harder to evidence, because shills are by their nature somewhat reticent about their shilling.

However, there is ample proof that climate denial includes online shills, as does support for Vladimir Putin.

It's not a great leap of logic to suggest at least one of them has posted here.
Actually, it would take a great leap of logic. Firstly, the sock-puppets in your first link (not shills, btw) would contravene the MA of this forum. Secondly, there is a link in your second article:
http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2011/mar/17/us-spy-operation-social-networks
The technology supports classified blogging activities on foreign-language websites to enable Centcom to counter violent extremist and enemy propaganda outside the US."

He said none of the interventions would be in English, as it would be unlawful to "address US audiences" with such technology, and any English-language use of social media by Centcom was always clearly attributed. The languages in which the interventions are conducted include Arabic, Farsi, Urdu and Pashto.....
"OEV seeks to disrupt recruitment and training of suicide bombers; deny safe havens for our adversaries; and counter extremist ideology and propaganda."....
Persona management by the US military would face legal challenges if it were turned against citizens of the US, where a number of people engaged in sock puppetry have faced prosecution.

Last year a New York lawyer who impersonated a scholar was sentenced to jail after being convicted of "criminal impersonation" and identity theft.

It is unclear whether a persona management programme would contravene UK law. Legal experts say it could fall foul of the Forgery and Counterfeiting Act 1981, which states that "a person is guilty of forgery if he makes a false instrument, with the intention that he or another shall use it to induce somebody to accept it as genuine, and by reason of so accepting it to do or not to do some act to his own or any other person's prejudice". However, this would apply only if a website or social network could be shown to have suffered "prejudice" as a result.
So it would definitely be against US law, and possibly against UK law as well.
Now, acting unlawfully has never been a problem for the CIA, and probably not for MI5 or 6 either, but you have to wonder why they would potentially expose themselves to lawsuits by using sock-puppets on this forum? What benefit would offset this possible loss? It certainly wouldn't deter any potential suicide bombers- they are a bit thin on the ground here.
Why would they bother?
 
Do not personalize the topic. It is not about the other posters. Keep it civil.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: kmortis
 
Hey, Cosmic, you sly devil, you! Methinks thou dost protest too much.
Why do I get the feeling you set all of this up for me? You can’t count Ontario because, as you see below, in the second sentence you claim Ontario’s thread was always about Bigfoot, so that lets him off the hook. That leaves just me.

Right off the bat I see something that is very telling and damning with your first two sentences as follows:

The 'Mentality of Skeptics' thread was purportedly started to expose the alleged closed-mindedness, cognitive dissonance and denialist approach of many members here.
It quickly became clear that this was not, in fact, the aim of the thread: it was, in fact, another Bigfoot thread.


It was not purportedly about anything but the mentality/psychology of skeptics, period. It was never intended to be about Bigfoot. I have posted this PM between Ontario and I several times and there seems to be a psychological blindspot when SkeptiBunkers™ read it.

Ontario is responding to my PM asking him if he thought I was off base about pounding and pounding on the psychology aspect of his OP. His response as follows:

12th December 2015 02:07 PM
OntarioSquatch : Re: possible derailing of thread
Your posts were all on topic. It was the discussion on the existence of Sasquatch that derailed it.

As you can plainly see, Ontario never intended it to be about Bigfoot, but rather, the mentality/psychology of skeptics. I find it offensive that the people on that thread kept trying to pull down the thread’s intention, which seems to be unsettling to some, to something the majority of people feel comfortable wallowing in…woo bashing!

Cosmic, dealing with you is not like running into a brick wall, it’s like running into an Adamantium wall. Before I get into anything with you I need to take a litmus test.

Below are two sentences and I respectfully ask you to answer with any one of the choices:

Sentence 1: Like to be a little more specific? Or does your argument lose traction if you're forced to discuss the facts?

Sentence 2: Hey, Cosmic! Like to be a little bit more specific, or does your argument lose traction if you’re forced to discuss psychology?

Do you think one of these sentences is disrespectful?
•If so, which one and why?

Do you think both sentences are disrespectful?
•If so, why?

Do you think neither sentence is disrespectful?
•Please elaborate.

I will address some of your points in other posts open to all posters. I spent too much time and energy in the Mentality thread on you to the exclusion of others. There were many posts that I would have liked to address, but there’s only so much time and so much energy. Depending on what you do or don’t do on this post will determine in large part the extent of my future interactions with you.

Good luck.
 
...
The 'Mentality of Skeptics' thread was purportedly started to expose the alleged closed-mindedness, cognitive dissonance and denialist approach of many members here.
...
It was not purportedly about anything but the mentality/psychology of skeptics, period. ...


Aren't you of the opinion that these many members here are in fact pseudo-skeptics and the op and perhaps you are the (real) skeptics?

E.T.A.: I left a question for you in the other thread, here and here.
 
Last edited:
Hey, Cosmic, you sly devil, you! Methinks thou dost protest too much.
Why do I get the feeling you set all of this up for me? You can’t count Ontario because, as you see below, in the second sentence you claim Ontario’s thread was always about Bigfoot, so that lets him off the hook. That leaves just me.

Right off the bat I see something that is very telling and damning with your first two sentences as follows:

The 'Mentality of Skeptics' thread was purportedly started to expose the alleged closed-mindedness, cognitive dissonance and denialist approach of many members here.
It quickly became clear that this was not, in fact, the aim of the thread: it was, in fact, another Bigfoot thread.


It was not purportedly about anything but the mentality/psychology of skeptics, period. It was never intended to be about Bigfoot. I have posted this PM between Ontario and I several times and there seems to be a psychological blindspot when SkeptiBunkers™ read it.

Ontario is responding to my PM asking him if he thought I was off base about pounding and pounding on the psychology aspect of his OP. His response as follows:

12th December 2015 02:07 PM
OntarioSquatch : Re: possible derailing of thread
Your posts were all on topic. It was the discussion on the existence of Sasquatch that derailed it.

As you can plainly see, Ontario never intended it to be about Bigfoot, but rather, the mentality/psychology of skeptics. I find it offensive that the people on that thread kept trying to pull down the thread’s intention, which seems to be unsettling to some, to something the majority of people feel comfortable wallowing in…woo bashing!

Cosmic, dealing with you is not like running into a brick wall, it’s like running into an Adamantium wall. Before I get into anything with you I need to take a litmus test.

Below are two sentences and I respectfully ask you to answer with any one of the choices:

Sentence 1: Like to be a little more specific? Or does your argument lose traction if you're forced to discuss the facts?

Sentence 2: Hey, Cosmic! Like to be a little bit more specific, or does your argument lose traction if you’re forced to discuss psychology?

Do you think one of these sentences is disrespectful?
•If so, which one and why?

Do you think both sentences are disrespectful?
•If so, why?

Do you think neither sentence is disrespectful?
•Please elaborate.

I will address some of your points in other posts open to all posters. I spent too much time and energy in the Mentality thread on you to the exclusion of others. There were many posts that I would have liked to address, but there’s only so much time and so much energy. Depending on what you do or don’t do on this post will determine in large part the extent of my future interactions with you.

Good luck.

Why don't you start a psychology of skeptics thread? I would be happy to participate and answer any questions you might have. That way you don't have to complain how every other thread is not the psychology thread you so strongly wish it to be.

Win. Win.
 
I would prefer the pseudo part to be proven with evidence rather than simply asserted :)
 
Last edited:
Hey, Cosmic, you sly devil, you! Methinks thou dost protest too much.
Why do I get the feeling you set all of this up for me? You can’t count Ontario because, as you see below, in the second sentence you claim Ontario’s thread was always about Bigfoot, so that lets him off the hook. That leaves just me.
I don't think I made any attempt to conceal the fact that this thread is aimed at you, OS and bubba, among others. It just took you rather longer than I expected to realise it.....

:rolleyes:
Right off the bat I see something that is very telling and damning with your first two sentences as follows:

The 'Mentality of Skeptics' thread was purportedly started to expose the alleged closed-mindedness, cognitive dissonance and denialist approach of many members here.
It quickly became clear that this was not, in fact, the aim of the thread: it was, in fact, another Bigfoot thread.


It was not purportedly about anything but the mentality/psychology of skeptics, period. It was never intended to be about Bigfoot. I have posted this PM between Ontario and I several times and there seems to be a psychological blindspot when SkeptiBunkers™ read it.

Ontario is responding to my PM asking him if he thought I was off base about pounding and pounding on the psychology aspect of his OP. His response as follows:

12th December 2015 02:07 PM
OntarioSquatch : Re: possible derailing of thread
Your posts were all on topic. It was the discussion on the existence of Sasquatch that derailed it.

As you can plainly see, Ontario never intended it to be about Bigfoot, but rather, the mentality/psychology of skeptics. I find it offensive that the people on that thread kept trying to pull down the thread’s intention, which seems to be unsettling to some, to something the majority of people feel comfortable wallowing in…woo bashing!
I venture to disagree. OS kept bringing it back to Bigfoot. Other posters objected. I saw an easy solution, which was to create a separate thread in which you, OS and others of your persuasion could post specific examples of the kind of behaviour you keep insisting is rampant on this forum.

Cosmic, dealing with you is not like running into a brick wall, it’s like running into an Adamantium wall. Before I get into anything with you I need to take a litmus test.

Below are two sentences and I respectfully ask you to answer with any one of the choices:

Sentence 1: Like to be a little more specific? Or does your argument lose traction if you're forced to discuss the facts?

Sentence 2: Hey, Cosmic! Like to be a little bit more specific, or does your argument lose traction if you’re forced to discuss psychology?

Do you think one of these sentences is disrespectful?
•If so, which one and why?

Do you think both sentences are disrespectful?
•If so, why?

Do you think neither sentence is disrespectful?
•Please elaborate.

No. You are not going to hijack another thread with your pet obsession. As has been said by others, if you want to start a psychology thread, by all means do so. This thread was created so you, OS, bubba and anyone else can post specific examples of the specific behaviour I outlined in my OP. I note that you have the time to try to steer us OT, but somehow not enough to post examples of what I was asking for.
So, if you want to wax poetical about the kinds of metaphorical walls you envisage me as, do it in another thread. My stance is unchanged from my OP: show the posts you object to, so we can see where you're coming from. If it is real, as I said in my OP (which you should probably re-read), I will change my approach if I am doing what you and others are claiming I am doing. Others may well follow suit, though I cannot claim to speak for anyone other than myself. Conversely, if you continue to twist and turn like a ....twisty turny thing, either ignoring or excusing your inability to furnish such posts, then you really should stop with the accusations. This is not a brick wall, nor indeed a wall of any sort: this is your opportunity, and OS's and anyone else's, to prove your point about the behaviour you keep complaining about.


I will address some of your points in other posts open to all posters. I spent too much time and energy in the Mentality thread on you to the exclusion of others. There were many posts that I would have liked to address, but there’s only so much time and so much energy. Depending on what you do or don’t do on this post will determine in large part the extent of my future interactions with you.

Good luck.
Post your evidence or not. I can't say I'll lose any sleep over it. It will be your loss: here's your chance to do this without being accused of going OT. Take it or leave it, as you wish.
Good luck!
 
Pretty sure we all have default positions.
This is, and continues to be, the problem with the assertion there. We do all have default positions. If we did not, we would end up in a miasma of uncertainty about everything, and unable ever to accept any inductive conclusion at all. Will the sun rise tomorrow? Only probably. Are there fairies at the bottom of my garden? Well, there weren't any to see this morning, but there might be tonight, or they might be invisible. The default position of certain persons here is the relaxation of rules for a certain set of unknowables. For them, substantive denial of those constitutes an inability to accept ambiguity. The official "anti-pseudoskeptic" position as stated amounts to the assertion that a reasonable person must accept the possibility of anything anyone suggests - that any serious suggestion must be considered an unproven possibility no matter how unlikely.

I think we all have a default position, and part of it is based on what degree of unlikelihood we decide to allow as possible. I doubt many of those who accuse others of being SkeptiBunkers® or Pseudoskeptics also expect us to believe that our politicians are reptilian space invaders, and some at least are probably willing to accept that the world is not run by a cabal of Jewish bankers, and so forth. What varies is the decision of what level of craziness we accept as too silly, how much violation of what we know and believe is too much. For some of us, the Ozark howler and the stinkape are on one side of the tipping point and for others not. But the fact that you can move the gray point on the picture of your world does not mean there is none.
 
This is, and continues to be, the problem with the assertion there. We do all have default positions. If we did not, we would end up in a miasma of uncertainty about everything, and unable ever to accept any inductive conclusion at all. Will the sun rise tomorrow? Only probably. Are there fairies at the bottom of my garden? Well, there weren't any to see this morning, but there might be tonight, or they might be invisible. The default position of certain persons here is the relaxation of rules for a certain set of unknowables. For them, substantive denial of those constitutes an inability to accept ambiguity. The official "anti-pseudoskeptic" position as stated amounts to the assertion that a reasonable person must accept the possibility of anything anyone suggests - that any serious suggestion must be considered an unproven possibility no matter how unlikely.

I think we all have a default position, and part of it is based on what degree of unlikelihood we decide to allow as possible. I doubt many of those who accuse others of being SkeptiBunkers® or Pseudoskeptics also expect us to believe that our politicians are reptilian space invaders, and some at least are probably willing to accept that the world is not run by a cabal of Jewish bankers, and so forth. What varies is the decision of what level of craziness we accept as too silly, how much violation of what we know and believe is too much. For some of us, the Ozark howler and the stinkape are on one side of the tipping point and for others not. But the fact that you can move the gray point on the picture of your world does not mean there is none.

Basically skepticism =/= solipsism.

What I observe about pseudoskeptics is that they have a disagreement about what constitutes a reliable information source. Every homeopath I know considers himself to be a True Skeptic. I consider them pseudoskeptics. They consider me a pesudoskeptic. The rift is that I think medical literature is reliable. They think the medical literature is a rubber stamp for allopathic quackery. Debate is complicated because there's not a lot of common ground.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom