Skeptibunkers and Anxious Sheeple: A Challenge.

This particular piece of fiction from our resident game-player says it all with regards to his "credibility."

That's a common theme with a lot of "skeptics". They go from believing in Bigfoot to suddenly believing in the non-existence of Bigfoot and then back to believing. They never accept the fact that they don't know. The anxiety that uncertainty brings is apparently too much some people to handle.

From page.7 of the Bigfoot: Patterson Gimlin Film - part:5 - post#261
 
Bigfoot is lol cmon get over it. Nobody talks about Bigfoot seriously. Go out and talk to people.
 
So if I am open to evidence, I consider that evidence, and upon evaluating that evidence I reject it as unreliable, does that make me a skeptic or a pseudoskeptic?

Here's how OS' game is like and unlike baseball:

OS pitches the ball to me; I hit the ball.
I pitch the ball to OS; he runs out of the batter's box to go to the restroom and concession stand and then, without ever returning to bat, grabs another ball and pitches to someone else on an adjacent field. He repeats this stunt until every field at the park is occupied with someone either hitting his pitches are waiting for him to pick up his bat.

Sometime later, he goes to a crappy sports bar to brag about how many games he won that night.
 
Correction:

- doesn't take a position that lacks the necessary proof.

You've stated, on more than one occasion, that you 100% believe, and yet you've not had any necessary proof, considering the fact that you've admitted to neither seeing one, nor ever searching for one.

All of your evidence has been gleaned online, mate. End of story. Get a grip.
 
It's impossible to prove that someone's in denial if they're denying a possibility and not an established fact, but you can still make an accurate determination based the person's behaviour.


Denialists/Pseudoskeptics

- Reject evidence
- Consider their unproven position to be the default
- React with anger when the opposing view is presented
- Favor things that are official or widely accepted
- Dislike ambiguity


Skeptics

- Are open to any evidence
- Consider all possibilities
- Don't have a default position unless it's proven
- Are willing to question widely held ideas
- Can handle ambiguity


A pseudoskeptic's primary interest is to discredit claims that conflict with their belief. You'll notice that they tend to focus on just one particular subject (e.g 9/11, bigfoot).

There's a bit of push-polling happening there.

Let's replace "Denialists/Pseudoskeptics" with....Anti-Vaxxers, Bigfooters, Truthers, Homeopathic Medicine Believers, Flat Earthers, White Supremacists, Camry Drivers, Tea Drinkers, Cloggers, Chess Players... - pick any one

- Reject evidence
- Consider their unproven position to be the default
- React with anger when the opposing view is presented
- Favor things that are official or widely accepted
- Dislike ambiguity

BTW, where did these lists come from? Are these hatched from an OntarioSquatch brain, or is there something more substantial behind them? Reason for asking is that the claimed characteristics of a Skeptic appear to be somewhat skewed. There's a lot of focus on "proof" rather than the weight of evidence.
 
Last edited:
I would like to see actual examples of the following, as alleged, repeatedly, by certain members here:
  • Insulting, aggressive posts that attack the arguer, not the argument. (Probably best to exclude Beachnut from this, really....:) )
  • Pseudo-skepticism.
  • Unqualified, uncritical support for governments, police forces and other establishment organisations.
  • Shilling for corporations or security forces.

I can't say anything about the examples I've left off your list, but do you really need evidence of the first I have left?

If you do need to see evidence of skeptics attacking the arguer and not the argument, AAH should provide rich ground for evidence hunters.

Pseudo-skepticism isn't all that relevant as it's what climate change deniers do and there's not a lot elsewhere.

Unqualified and irrational support for TBTB? Have a look in any of the shooting threads. This thread is a good example, and since I started it, I've been following most of it and there are a couple of classic posters defending the indefensible.

I'd also add in the likes of this post in that vein as well: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=10910596#post10910596

A clear case of an alleged skeptic making things up to support a story even the officials didn't suggest.

Shilling is a little harder to evidence, because shills are by their nature somewhat reticent about their shilling.

However, there is ample proof that climate denial includes online shills, as does support for Vladimir Putin.

It's not a great leap of logic to suggest at least one of them has posted here.
 
And do you know if any of them are hiring?
This. And I believe I can show I'm not a hired shill because I would put far more effort into my posts if I were being paid. One must have pride in ones profession. Amateurs, not so much.
 
It's impossible to prove that someone's in denial if they're denying a possibility and not an established fact, but you can still make an accurate determination based the person's behaviour.


Denialists/Pseudoskeptics

- Reject evidence

Here's some Bigfoot evidence. If you reject it you are one of the bad guys.
 

Attachments

  • westmoreland_samsherry.jpg
    westmoreland_samsherry.jpg
    59.4 KB · Views: 269
If OS denies that these are real Bigfoot tracks does that make him a pseudoskeptic? How does that work? Does he have immunity to that label?
 
Correction:

- doesn't take a position that lacks the necessary proof.

I meant: - rejects all evidence that falls short of "proof".

You've been asked for examples of the behaviour you're trying to highlight, and you respond by quibbling over the definition of that behaviour. A reasonable skeptic will draw the provisional conclusion that the behaviour you're trying to highlight is in fact as imaginary as some of the other things you believe in, because evidence for it is absent. So how about actually providing the evidence you've been asked for to support your position?

Dave
 
You've been asked for examples of the behaviour you're trying to highlight, and you respond by quibbling over the definition of that behaviour. A reasonable skeptic will draw the provisional conclusion that the behaviour you're trying to highlight is in fact as imaginary as some of the other things you believe in, because evidence for it is absent. So how about actually providing the evidence you've been asked for to support your position?

Dave

In other words, OS is showing pseudoskepticism about pseudoskepticism?
 
Well, at least he's consistent in his belief that it's irrational to disbelieve in something there's no credible evidence for. Maybe there are fairies at the bottom of my garden.

Dave

Well it appears to depend on which fourm he's posting on.
In regards to the PGF there seems to be some conflict in his own mind.
These where posted within 24hrs of each other

BFF (Bigfoot Fantasy w/Friends)


ISF
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom