Merged Silver Over 40.00 / Real and fake prices

Since its inception date (28 April 2006) the annualised return of <SLV US> is 17.74% and that of Silver itself (spot, London fix) is 18.83% for the same period. Expenses are 0.5% per annum (plus a little bit, probably).

I have the NAV and silver price for every day between then and now and I don't see any evidence that the trust NAV/share has ever deviated from the silver price by anything more than frictional noise.
 
Since its inception date (28 April 2006) the annualised return of <SLV US> is 17.74% and that of Silver itself (spot, London fix) is 18.83% for the same period. Expenses are 0.5% per annum (plus a little bit, probably).

I have the NAV and silver price for every day between then and now and I don't see any evidence that the trust NAV/share has ever deviated from the silver price by anything more than frictional noise.

Return Comparison here

Also consider the trading cost. I'm seeing about an 8% difference in spot price verses buying Canadian Silver Maple Leaf coins. I imagine the cost to trade SLV shares is considerably less.
 
saw this the other day on silver's fundamentals. interested in comments (from anybody who can bring themselves to watch a 5 minute video)



interesting figures from it. 700 million Oz mined per year = $20 billion @ current price.

50-100 million Oz purchased for investment per annum = $1.5-$3 billion

164 billionaires in the world, 64 in China. if one just billionaire wants to buy physical silver he could take an entire year's worth of (investment) silver on his own. - would this be allowed?

Buffet bought 100 million Oz at $7-$9 per Oz, its now $30, he says he sold at a loss but wont give details?

CT? or a pretty good reason for the silver manipulation that Bart Chilton of the CTFC says he thinks goes on?

along with this lot who all have a vested interest (and Washington lobby) in prices remaining low

this is so going way up at some point.

btw James Turk has now committed to a timescale, he says next 3 months

http://kingworldnews.com/kingworldn...d_is_Great,_But_Silver_is_the_Next_Apple.html

If anything, the patten has now become stronger because silver is now testing support in the high 20s and looks like it is forming a double bottom. I still think this flag pattern will send silver to $70 in three months, once silver has broken out to the upside. Because it is a descending flag pattern, the breakout pattern has now moved down to $37.50, but $35 is the more important resistance level.

Once theses two levels are taken out, that three month move to $70 begins. So, as I see it, just keep accumulating physical silver here. The fundamentals for silver continue to remain very bullish and only time will tell if silver is the next Apple. I continue to expect that silver will go much higher and reach my $400 per ounce forecast....
 
Last edited:
Actually, to be fair, that is not what he is saying. It is only AFTER silver has broken through the $35 and $37.50 resistance levels that he believes silver will go to $70. So, his 3-month prediction doesn't start until silver closes at $37.50 or higher sometime in the future.

ah ok, well spotted, didnt read it properly, I did think that was possibly a bit optimistic what with the liquidationary climate prevalent in Europe at the moment.
 
So if I understand.

Once silver has closed (closed where ? It's traded internationally) above $37.50 then it will progress to $75 within three months of that date.

So if silver never* gets to $37.50 again then Turk's prediction is still technically valid.







* - yes, never is a long time, but if silver still bumps along in the $25-$35 range for the next few years or even retreats back to $5
 
if one just billionaire wants to buy physical silver he could take an entire year's worth of (investment) silver on his own. - would this be allowed?

Well, this is what happened to the last ones who tried:

http://www.nytimes.com/1989/12/21/business/2-hunts-fined-and-banned-from-trades.html

2 Hunts Fined And Banned From Trades
By KURT EICHENWALD
Published: December 21, 1989

Nelson Bunker Hunt and William Herbert Hunt, the former billionaires whose fortunes collapsed after a failed effort to corner the world silver market a decade ago, will pay fines of $10 million each and be banned from trading in the American commodity markets in a partial settlement of charges stemming from the episode, Government officials and lawyers said yesterday.

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission, which regulates the commodity markets, announced yesterday that it had accepted the settlement from Nelson Bunker Hunt. In addition, Government officials said, announcement of an acceptance of a settlement with William Herbert Hunt is expected later this week.

The settlements with the regulatory body are part of the reorganization plans filed by the brothers in Dallas. They filed for protection from their creditors under Chapter 11 of the Federal Bankruptcy Code in September 1988 as a result of costs incurred in fighting lawsuits stemming from their forays into silver.

The $10 million will be in addition to a multimillion-dollar settlement reached by Nelson Bunker Hunt to pay back taxes, fines and interest to the Internal Revenue Service. The I.R.S. will be paid 80 percent of the liquidation value of Mr. Hunt's personal estate. In bankruptcy proceedings, those assets, which include oil and real estate interests, were valued at about $150 million.

A similar plan has been structured for William Herbert Hunt.
 
So, the government will use force against anyone who threatens to expose government criminality. Big surprise.
If these guys had succeeded in cornering the silver market (given that they would have used printing press money to do so) you would probably be arguing that they should have the silver confiscated so that we can have sound money.
 
if one just billionaire wants to buy physical silver he could take an entire year's worth of (investment) silver on his own. - would this be allowed?
Individuals cornering the silver market is not in the interests of banking corporations so we can expect a lot of resistance to the move.
 
Last edited:
Individuals cornering the silver market is not in the interests of banking corporations so we can expect a lot of resistance to the move.

I've been thinking about this a lot since I last posted here.

one one hand, if I am a billionaire and think silver is hugely undervalued, say by a factor of 100x and wanted to accumulate as much as I can afford to and wait for price to catch up with my theory, why shouldn't be allowed to do that?

on the other hand, silver is irreplaceable in many of its uses and applications worldwide, and there is actually so little of it above ground that it would be damaging to many industries if the price was 100x higher, and we would have higher prices for everything that uses it.

but isn't this just a free market at work? why should there be government interference by way of legislation or price control on something that is much more valuable than current price suggests?

If the mining companies take note of Sprott's call to action we might see truer price discovery yet IMO.

many have said they are giving it serious consideration.
 
why should there be government interference by way of legislation or price control on something that is much more valuable than current price suggests?
Banker: "These guys are making a huge profit cornering the silver market"
Politician: "So?"
Banker: "I want to make that profit myself"
Politician: "Ok, I will make what they are doing illegal"
 
Banker: "These guys are making a huge profit cornering the silver market"
Politician: "So?"
Banker: "I want to make that profit myself"
Politician: "Ok, I will make what they are doing illegal"

in every country? how do you do that in a global market place?

granted, currently it is done by corralling most of the speculation into paper silver that doesn't exist and allows endless piling on of shorts while the price is rising (which would be financial suicide in a real market)

but without that in place, how does one government control a global market?
 
in every country? how do you do that in a global market place?

granted, currently it is done by corralling most of the speculation into paper silver that doesn't exist and allows endless piling on of shorts while the price is rising (which would be financial suicide in a real market)

but without that in place, how does one government control a global market?
There are lots of ways to influence politicians (graft is just one of them). You can be pretty sure that whichever country you are in, if you try to corner the silver market then that country's government will go after you.

Governments can't corner the silver market because their international creditors might not like it.
 
There are lots of ways to influence politicians (graft is just one of them). You can be pretty sure that whichever country you are in, if you try to corner the silver market then that country's government will go after you.

Governments can't corner the silver market because their international creditors might not like it.

what about if an international corporation beyond the reach of any one government did it?

or, just for fun, say a consortium of all the biggest Middle Eastern oil producing countries did it? the US and NATO cant invade them all at the same time, they'd run out of oil trying.
 
what about if an international corporation beyond the reach of any one government did it?

or, just for fun, say a consortium of all the biggest Middle Eastern oil producing countries did it? the US and NATO cant invade them all at the same time, they'd run out of oil trying.

Sounds like the sort of thing Dr. Evil might try.

Find an essential commodity, corner the market for it, then hold the entire world hostage - for ONE MILLION DOLLARS!!!

I have a feeling this is the sort of thing that would ultimately sort itself out. To actually profit from the machinations, they'd eventually have to sell and to the extent they sold the supply would go back up and the price would go back down. They'd make money, sure, but how much of a return ultimately for the amount invested and at risk?

Like baseball, if it was easy, then anyone could do it!

I plan on watching your video. Just remember, all the information contained therein is already out there and factored into the current price of silver and silver futures. The price now is exactly where it should be - were it not for all the factors people put forth, it might well be trading at $5/oz.
 
I plan on watching your video. Just remember, all the information contained therein is already out there and factored into the current price of silver and silver futures.

The price now is exactly where it should be - were it not for all the factors people put forth, it might well be trading at $5/oz.

that's one way of looking at it. :) ..another is that there could be a massive speculative paper silver bubble, that may one day *pop*
 
what about if an international corporation beyond the reach of any one government did it?
You mean, like a bank? :D

or, just for fun, say a consortium of all the biggest Middle Eastern oil producing countries did it? the US and NATO cant invade them all at the same time, they'd run out of oil trying.
Maybe not but international banking corporations that start losing money because of the activity would certainly be able to do something about it. Money is more powerful than conventional armaments.
 
As promised, I just watched the video.

Impression #1: I did not know about Buffet's 1998 venture. Interesting.

Impression #2: Huh?

In any case, I think the video conflates controlling one year's production of investment silver with controlling all investment silver. It ignores the buffering effect of all the extant silver in the world and all future production. I still hold that after the chaos, year two would return silver to a fair market price. As it did with the Hunt brothers fiasco.

But What Do I Know™?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom