Merged Silver Over 40.00 / Real and fake prices

Thanks for that.

On the one hand, everything in that article is public knowledge - hence, in theory, its already factored into the price of silver, and even to some extent into the future price of silver.

On the other hand, I still cling to the belief that perhaps intuition can allow an individual investor to profit from insights that he gains from information like this. Most evidence to the contrary.

As far as the Hunt brothers, I recall somewhat vaguely the shenanigans that were going on in the late 70's/ early 80's. Here's a summary:

The Hunt Brothers and the Silver Bubble
Brian Trumbore
President/Editor, StocksandNews.com

In 1973, the Hunt family of Texas, possibly the richest family in America at the time, decided to buy precious metals as a hedge against inflation. Gold could not be held by private citizens at that time, so the Hunts began to buy silver in enormous quantity.

In 1979 the sons of patriarch H.L. Hunt, Nelson Bunker and William Herbert, together with some wealthy Arabs, formed a silver pool. In a short period of time they had amassed more than 200 million ounces of silver, equivalent to half the world's deliverable supply.

When the Hunt's had begun accumulating silver back in 1973 the price was in the $1.95 / ounce range. Early in '79, the price was about $5. Late '79 / early '80 the price was in the $50's, peaking at $54.

Once the silver market was cornered, outsiders joined the chase but a combination of changed trading rules on the New York Metals Market (COMEX) and the intervention of the Federal Reserve put an end to the game. The price began to slide, culminating in a 50% one-day decline on March 27, 1980 as the price plummeted from $21.62 to $10.80.

The collapse of the silver market meant countless losses for speculators. The Hunt brothers declared bankruptcy. By 1987 their liabilities had grown to nearly $2.5 billion against assets of $1.5 billion. In August of 1988 the Hunts were convicted of conspiring to manipulate the market.


source: http://www.buyandhold.com/bh/en/education/history/2000/hunt_bros.html

In retrospect, it appears to have clearly been a bubble. You had to be there, however, to realize that at the time, no one knew that and a lot of people thought silver could only go higher - even from $50. I think anyone "predicting" a huge pullback to near $10 was seen as a pessimistic loon by many.

So don't totally discount the possibility that silver could pull back to $5/oz in our lifetimes. I still hold the best strategy is still to buy and hold, dollar cost averaging if you're in a position to do so.
 
Thanks for that.

On the one hand, everything in that article is public knowledge - hence, in theory, its already factored into the price of silver, and even to some extent into the future price of silver.

On the other hand, I still cling to the belief that perhaps intuition can allow an individual investor to profit from insights that he gains from information like this. Most evidence to the contrary.

As far as the Hunt brothers, I recall somewhat vaguely the shenanigans that were going on in the late 70's/ early 80's. Here's a summary:

The Hunt Brothers and the Silver Bubble
Brian Trumbore
President/Editor, StocksandNews.com

In 1973, the Hunt family of Texas, possibly the richest family in America at the time, decided to buy precious metals as a hedge against inflation. Gold could not be held by private citizens at that time, so the Hunts began to buy silver in enormous quantity.

In 1979 the sons of patriarch H.L. Hunt, Nelson Bunker and William Herbert, together with some wealthy Arabs, formed a silver pool. In a short period of time they had amassed more than 200 million ounces of silver, equivalent to half the world's deliverable supply.

When the Hunt's had begun accumulating silver back in 1973 the price was in the $1.95 / ounce range. Early in '79, the price was about $5. Late '79 / early '80 the price was in the $50's, peaking at $54.

Once the silver market was cornered, outsiders joined the chase but a combination of changed trading rules on the New York Metals Market (COMEX) and the intervention of the Federal Reserve put an end to the game. The price began to slide, culminating in a 50% one-day decline on March 27, 1980 as the price plummeted from $21.62 to $10.80.

The collapse of the silver market meant countless losses for speculators. The Hunt brothers declared bankruptcy. By 1987 their liabilities had grown to nearly $2.5 billion against assets of $1.5 billion. In August of 1988 the Hunts were convicted of conspiring to manipulate the market.


source: http://www.buyandhold.com/bh/en/education/history/2000/hunt_bros.html

were you aware of the massive short positions on silver held by 9 of the 23 members voting on the changes? major vested interests in changing the rules and crushing the price, corruption and insider dealing at it's finest.

In retrospect, it appears to have clearly been a bubble. You had to be there, however, to realize that at the time, no one knew that and a lot of people thought silver could only go higher - even from $50. I think anyone "predicting" a huge pullback to near $10 was seen as a pessimistic loon by many.

I don't think people understood that it was possible for the authorities to just change the rules when they were losing. if that hadn't been possible, well who knows what may have happened.

So don't totally discount the possibility that silver could pull back to $5/oz in our lifetimes. I still hold the best strategy is still to buy and hold, dollar cost averaging if you're in a position to do so.

I think this is highly unlikely now, based on the fundamentals, ever increasing list of applications, declining supply, declining ore grades, declining EROI and devaluing medium (money) upon which we buy it.

anything is possible, but this is a serious outside bet now IMO, far more likely we see $1000 in my lifetime than $5. Mr Sprott, mentioned above thinks it's a 30 bagger from here in the next decade and is betting $1.5 billion on that, I'm with him.
 
Apparently Sprott has written to lots of silver producers encouraging them to save in silver rather than FIAT too. this wouldnt exactly hurt the price either..

Sprott brought up the letter when asked where he sees gold and silver headed,

“It’s hard to define it, who knows? I mean if you had a printing scenario you have no idea where the price of gold goes because you have no idea how much they are going to print. If you had a total bust and people feared the banking system and started buying gold, I have no idea what they would take the price of gold to because, of course, by that time all of the currencies would almost be worthless as well.”

.."Put it into silver, it’s a way better asset than having a bank deposit that pays zero interest rate and you take all of the risk of the bank on. You know if enough people accept that thinking, I mean, at the margin, you bring all of those buyers in (to silver), who knows where the price is going to go? But it won’t bear any relationship to where it is today.”
 
Current silver spot price is a touch under $32/oz

I know this is tiresome for me to keep bringing up, I just want to highlight to those who were forecasting imminent US hyperinflation and the ability to buy several days worth of food for the amount of silver in a pre 1946 (sic) coin.



kevsta's prediction of peaking at over $75 in 2012 is still on though...
 
Current silver spot price is a touch under $32/oz

I know this is tiresome for me to keep bringing up, I just want to highlight to those who were forecasting imminent US hyperinflation and the ability to buy several days worth of food for the amount of silver in a pre 1946 (sic) coin.

kevsta's prediction of peaking at over $75 in 2012 is still on though...

ok so I just went back to page 1 to see where you're coming from with that. is he still around?

re my prediction, 13 months, Im pretty confident, and I'm in exceptionally good company.

James Turk totally nailed the action all year up until the most recent Sept smashdown where he stayed a bit too bullish for year-end calls.

Turk silver to $70 fast

This move is going to catch a lot of people by surprise as evidenced by the extremely low sentiment readings. Those low readings are a clear indication that there is a lot of money on the sidelines that is waiting to jump on board.”

“That money will come into the market like a tidal wave with just a little bit more upside progress. Importantly, I think we are going to see more upside progress as we work toward the end of the year. There are two important developments from a technical perspective.

The first we have already spoken about, namely the bullish flag pattern on the weekly silver chart (above). When silver breaks out to the upside, this flag measures to a target price of around $68 to $70. More importantly, the jump out of the flag should happen more quickly than the $18 to $50 move we saw back in 2010 and early 2011, which took about nine months....

when Sprott decides to start whopping his $1.5billion around we can expect some more fireworks I think.

be nice if the Govts of the world could kick off with some more serious money printing to get us started too, its getting a bit dull all this waiting around.
 
Last edited:
re my prediction, 13 months, Im pretty confident, and I'm in exceptionally good company.

Even if people are blindly guessing, about 1/2 will end up being right. Does that qualify them as "good company".

James Turk totally nailed the action all year up until the most recent Sept smashdown where he stayed a bit too bullish for year-end calls.

Sounds like "special pleading" to me. But good to know that James Turk is always right...except when he's wrong!
 
c'mon now, nobody can be right all the time, you're being unreasonable.

traders just have to be right more than they are wrong, on aggregate.

what is "special pleading" is it a JREF term?
 
From the James Turk blog it isn't entirely clear what he is predicting.

I think he's saying that silver will reach $70/oz in much less than 9 months:

So taken together, these two developments are very bullish and suggest much higher prices in both gold and silver over the next few months.

To me this reads in the 3-6 month timeframe but equally it could be the next 5 years I guess. That's what I find frustrating about these kind of predictions, would it have been so hard for him to say "I think silver will have traded at $70/oz by June 2012".

kevsta has been kind enough to provide a verifiable prediction, why couldn't James Turk (the man who faultlessly predicts the movement of the price of silver - as long as it's going up :D)
 
Current spot price is still under $30 so:

  • MichaelSuede's hyperinflation hasn't happened YET. We still can't feed ourselves for several days for the silver in a small coin
  • For kevsta to be correct, the spot price of silver will need to go up by 150% at some point over the next 12 months
  • For James Turk to be right it'll need to go up by 135% "fast" - I'm being generous and will say by mid-year

My personal feeling is that James Turk is an excellent predictor of the direction of the silver price when it's going up.

My prediction is that silver will trade higher than $30 at some point in the next year, but no higher than $50. I am however not certain enough to back my own prediction with my own money :D
 
Last edited:
If you've watched this market for long enough, you realize that nearly anything can happen.

I would not be surprised if silver went down to $20/oz and hovered in that range for a decade or more. Or lower.

Or shot to $100/oz and never looked back.

If you like silver, just dollar-cost-average and don't imagine you have any hope of predicting the future or timing the market. At best, price predictions on any traded commodity are a 50/50 proposition. IMHO, of course.
 
If you've watched this market for long enough, you realize that nearly anything can happen.

I would not be surprised if silver went down to $20/oz and hovered in that range for a decade or more. Or lower.

Or shot to $100/oz and never looked back.

dwindling above ground supplies and ever increasing demand make this a much more likely upwards bet, to me.

If you like silver, just dollar-cost-average and don't imagine you have any hope of predicting the future or timing the market. At best, price predictions on any traded commodity are a 50/50 proposition. IMHO, of course.

short term, I would agree, although you could also say "at worst" a 50/50 proposition couldn't you?

unless you've ever tried trading on leverage of course, in which case you realize that the market watches you, and you alone, and ALWAYS does exactly the opposite of what you need, when you need it :)
 
I'm currently reading "Fooled By Randomness" by Taleb.

Good read so far.

This is not directly applicable, but still may be of interest:

6553597341_7018d6acde_z.jpg
 
A lot of silver is traded in the form of certificates. I'd be very surprised if these certificates were 100% backed by silver.

oh they're not, no shadow of doubt, SLV and Comex Futures are "paper silver" run on the fractional reserve basis (same as Gold)

more CT prone metalsheadz believe these ETFs have been instituted to divert public money away from the metals themselves (and mining shares) and to allow bankster driven price control by massive naked shorting with "silver" they don't have and cannot possibly ever obtain.

even without the CT element, there is no doubt whatsoever that there is massively more silver traded, than exists, about 100x more according to a member of the Comex.

If all of a sudden everybody who thought they had some silver in the form of these ETFs actually wanted to have it, well, "to the moon" would be a very conservative estimate.
 
SLV and Comex Futures are "paper silver" run on the fractional reserve basis (same as Gold)
This has been covered before (see below). The net asset value of the SLV trust is completely backed by silver. Of course derivative positions (net shorts and the associated synthetic longs which are those where the shares are lent out) are not, and never are in any derivative market, whether that is financial derivatives or regular commercial derivatives such as airline reservations.

If all of a sudden everybody who thought they had some silver in the form of these ETFs actually wanted to have it
Also dealt with in the quote.

SLV claims they have x holdings of silver

SLV actually has x-(some amount) of silver
If you think that iShares/Blackrock are lying on this page, you can blow the whistle. I will assume your suspicion is groundless until I hear about it in the press.

As investors invest in SLV thinking they are getting an asset fully backed in silver, while they may be getting worthless paper.
It has been explained (post 90) that if investors think that they are wrong. You don't buy ETFs from the operator of the trust, as the "E" in the name suggests you buy them on an exchange. That is, you buy them from other market participants who are selling. Other participants may have borrowed the ETF to go short, and if they have borrowed it then someone else who is long has lent it out (or authorised their broker to do so). And if they have lent it, they can't redeem it before they call it back.

ETFs are derivatives. Calling foul on them because all the long positions in the market (which is quite different from all the shares in issue) are not being backed by underlying is complaining that they are not something that they never said they were.

The addition of the worthless paper to the silver market drives down the spot and futures price of silver itself because investors falsely believe there is more physical silver in existence than there actually is
If by "worthless paper" you mean synthetic long positions (longs where the ETF has been lent out) and synthetic short positions (where it has been borrowed and sold), then (i) there is nothing worthless about them because they are synthetic [Recall you said: "There is nothing inherently wrong with private debt products or shares of ownership." in post 114], and (ii) there is--funnily enough--always an equal value of synthetic longs and shorts. There cannot not be. Therefore you have not justified why this would depress the price, spot or forward. Market sentiment is what lifts and depresses prices. I have a hard time believing that sentiment is pessimistic.

As investors discover that SLV may not be able to cover all of its paper issue with actual silver, they start demanding physical delivery.
Investors who are long SLV but who have lent it out (or allowed their broker to do so) can't do that anyway.

Beyond this, your assertion that the $ silver price is some kind of artificially depressed "inverse bubble", which is what I understand you to be saying, seems to veer into extraordinary claim territory.
 
The objective of the iShares Silver Trust is for the value of the shares of the iShares Silver Trust to reflect, at any given time, the price of silver owned by the iShares Silver Trust at that time, less the iShares Silver Trust's expenses and liabilities.
Leaves a little wriggle room but I will take iShares Silver Trust's word for it for now.

The shorting issue is a separate question altogether. As long as the original owner can not trade his silver shares while they are on loan, the volume of silver traded will still rise but no new shares will be created.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom