Merged Silver Over 40.00 / Real and fake prices

Originally Posted by michaelsuede
Silver broke 46 today.

40 to 46 in 12 days.

.....and then back down to 32 in 6 months,

That's a -20% return on your investment, impressive !

I have a strong suspicion we'll be around (if not through) $46-$50 by year-end, and probably never look back again.

also why do people always assume that everybody bought at the very top?

..at $32 most of my silver was still up by 80-100%

the small amounts bought regularly since, including some at high $30s hardly touch the aggregate bottom line which is about +100% since I started buying in 09

yes, its been a terrible investment, that just looks like getting worse every day ;)

and we don't need inflation or hyperinflation for silver to get into the hundreds of dollars, the fundamentals will put it there eventually.

Sprott's thoughts on this. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j-eaU4gepKw#t=1m30s
 
Last edited:
I have a strong suspicion we'll be around (if not through) $46-$50 by year-end, and probably never look back again.

also why do people always assume that everybody bought at the very top?

..at $32 most of my silver was still up by 80-100%

the small amounts bought regularly since, including some at high $30s hardly touch the aggregate bottom line which is about +100% since I started buying in 09

yes, its been a terrible investment, that just looks like getting worse every day ;)

and we don't need inflation or hyperinflation for silver to get into the hundreds of dollars, the fundamentals will put it there eventually.

Well everything happens eventually :D

I'm not saying that silver (or some other commodity) isn't a sensible component of an investment portfolio. Silver and gold are used as hedges in uncertain times and these times are more uncertain than most.

Silver does have limitations, it can only yield capital gain unlike other investments which provide dividends or interest. In fact over the very long term it's very important. I recall hearing on the radio that £100 invested 50 years ago in a FTSE tracker (if they existed back then) would be worth £9000 or so without dividend re-investment but £700,000+ with dividend re-investment.

All that is by-the-by. My regular postings are in response to the OP subsequent posts which claimed:

  • $40 was only the start of the rise in the price of silver
  • The steep rise was imminent
  • That a single silver coin pre 1946 (actually pre 1964) would but food for several days
  • Hyperinflation was soon to begin

So far none of the above has come to pass yet. The spot price of silver has been floating between $30 and $40 an ounce for the last six months and that there is little evidence of hyperinflation in the UK economy yet.

Of course all of this could be just around the corner but with doom-mongers not offering any timeline for their predictions they cannot be falsified.

We could be here in 50 years time, with silver say at $300/oz and that would represent a 6% inflation year on year more or less and still they could be claiming that hyperinflation was just around the corner.
 
The spot price of silver has been floating between $30 and $40 an ounce for the last six months...

Looks like I nailed the prediction I made back in August...

"Now the question is, where is the market going next - higher or lower? To which I answer "Yes! Unless it stays the same, of course"."
 
Looks like I nailed the prediction I made back in August...

"Now the question is, where is the market going next - higher or lower? To which I answer "Yes! Unless it stays the same, of course"."

:th:

Now please tell me that this week's lotto numbers will be unique numbers between 1 and 49 and I'll be convinced of your gift :D
 
Spot price is just over $34

I'm 1/3 short (2/3 long) silver at 35.50, I'd love to see another plunge, every $1 down from here is approx 1 more "free" Kg now.

..which is why I think it probably wont fall much further :(
 
I'm 1/3 short (2/3 long) silver at 35.50, I'd love to see another plunge...

kevsta,

What exactly is the logic here?

If you're expecting another plunge, why would you be long at all?

Or is this some kind of "straddle" strategy, where you hope to profit whichever way it goes?

Just curious - remember, I think markets like these are inherently unpredictable, so profiting from trades of any sort, including straddles, will remain an elusive goal to most who try, esp. once transactions costs and taxes are figured in.

Investing, and holding, with the goal of long term asset protection is another matter.
 
kevsta,

What exactly is the logic here?

If you're expecting another plunge, why would you be long at all?

Or is this some kind of "straddle" strategy, where you hope to profit whichever way it goes?

Just curious - remember, I think markets like these are inherently unpredictable, so profiting from trades of any sort, including straddles, will remain an elusive goal to most who try, esp. once transactions costs and taxes are figured in.

Investing, and holding, with the goal of long term asset protection is another matter.

Im not trading on leverage, this is physical holdings which are easily sold, commissions are small, tax not applicable.

the strategy is invest / hold primarily, but occasionally attempting to picking interim tops and selling out a percentage, depending on *perceived* liklihood of further plunges.

there are a few analysts I watch, 3 of which called the last silver plunge days ahead, and an email list with several metals millionaires on it i get too which has been pretty bearish on silver (short term) lately.

if having sold some (betting on a drop) silver should head off up to heights way above where we are now and not look like coming back any time soon, I would probably stomach the "loss" and buy the extra silver back.

I can also sell it into different currencies and when you get that right you can sometimes profit from the FX movement too.

If you just buy and don't look at the prices you can deal with the big dives, but with the ease you can be out and back in the gambler in me makes me look for gains :)

I also trade the GSR as time and circumstance allows, but its pretty slow, which is why I started looking for faster trades.

doing this over the last year though has increased my Kg and Oz by about 8% so its going ok thus far.
 
Last edited:
kevsta,

What exactly is the logic here?

If you're expecting another plunge, why would you be long at all?

Or is this some kind of "straddle" strategy, where you hope to profit whichever way it goes?

Just curious - remember, I think markets like these are inherently unpredictable, so profiting from trades of any sort, including straddles, will remain an elusive goal to most who try, esp. once transactions costs and taxes are figured in.

Investing, and holding, with the goal of long term asset protection is another matter.

update - lost nerve / patience, hit the buy back in at $31.50 @ 2.854 kg profit on the round trip.

probably watch the whole lot slide to $25 over the next few days now..

still, am happy with that for basically hitting a button, waiting 10 days, and hitting it again, timing the exact tops and bottoms is usually way beyond my nervous capabilities

ok bring on the printing (or rumours of) and up we go again :)
 
Again, I'm confused...

Wouldn't the gains you had in your short position be more than offset by the 2/3 of your investment which is long?

only if I sold it? it's long term physical holdings, and I count profit and total in Kg / Oz, not $ or € ?

yes, if I had to liquidate the overall numerical value I would receive this very moment would be less.

when we hit or surpass $34.50 again that doesn't matter much any more does it?

if you believe the long term bull case for silver and I very much do, the only thing that matters is how much of it I have, not what some fluctuating digits in the meantime say from day to day.

kapiche?
 
I have a strong suspicion we'll be around (if not through) $46-$50 by year-end, and probably never look back again.

A verifiable prediction made on 30 October 2011, thank you.

Current spot price is $31.60/oz so kevsta is looking for a 50% increase in the next 5 weeks.
 
A verifiable prediction made on 30 October 2011, thank you.

Current spot price is $31.60/oz so kevsta is looking for a 50% increase in the next 5 weeks.

haha, a suspicion isnt a prediction, and things have changed a little since then (almost hourly in fact) I'm not sticking by that. if the ECB / IMF / backdoor FED swaps or whatever printathon doesn't go ahead and Europe collapses into it's debt vortex it could be 50% down instead of up from here.

if they do stick save it with a few trillion of imaginary money from somewhere we could maybe get back on track.

if you want a verifiable prediction, ok, I'll stick my neck out and say I predict silver will have traded at or above $75 by 31st Dec 2012. :)
 
Last edited:
haha, a suspicion isnt a prediction, and things have changed a little since then (almost hourly in fact) I'm not sticking by that. if the ECB / IMF / backdoor FED swaps or whatever printathon doesn't go ahead and Europe collapses into it's debt vortex it could be 50% down instead of up from here.

if they do stick save it with a few trillion of imaginary money from somewhere we could maybe get back on track.

if you want a verifiable prediction, ok, I'll stick my neck out and say I predict silver will have traded at or above $75 by 31st Dec 2012. :)

Riiight so a strong suspicion isn't a prediction particularly when it calls for a 50% rise in the spot price of silver in 5 weeks.

Thank you for the prediction though. I just need to come back to it in approximately 57 weeks time.


edited to add....

I have to say though that peaking at $75 is a lot less bullish than probably never trading below $46 again,
 
Last edited:
Riiight so a strong suspicion isn't a prediction particularly when it calls for a 50% rise in the spot price of silver in 5 weeks.

for a bright lad, it doesnt seem like you can count very well? :)

A verifiable prediction made on 30 October 2011, thank you.

if the "prediction" (and it wasn't, it was a leaning, a feeling, or a suspicion) was made on 31st October, that would have been nearly 9 weeks at that point? but you are correct, I was wrong.

Thank you for the prediction though. I just need to come back to it in approximately 57 weeks time.

pleasure, I have been around since 2007, and will be here pointing out the continually rising gold price for the foreseeable future, so if I'm wrong, you'll get plenty of opportunity for gloating ;)

edited to add....

I have to say though that peaking at $75 is a lot less bullish than probably never trading below $46 again,

haha yes, I suspect, if you look, you could find quite a lot of people (market pros, unlike me) who are considerably less bullish with developments in the last 4 weeks?

reacting to new market developments is not exactly unheard of, especially when the call moves substantially in the opposite direction in the meantime.

would you like examples? ;)
 
Last edited:
the strategy is invest / hold primarily, but occasionally attempting to picking interim tops and selling out a percentage, depending on *perceived* liklihood of further plunges...
If you just buy and don't look at the prices you can deal with the big dives, but with the ease you can be out and back in the gambler in me makes me look for gains :)...doing this over the last year though has increased my Kg and Oz by about 8% so its going ok thus far.

Good for you.

I'm glad your recognize the "gambler" in you. I think trading in and out of any commodity in the belief one can predict short term price moves is doomed in the long run - markets have a way of moving either randomly, or at least randomly enough that profiting from small moves consistently remains an elusive goal.

I think you might find that, overall, the best strategy is to simply buy and hold silver - that is if you think the long term trend will be upward, or if you're doing so to protect against inflation.

But hell, even gamblers win sometimes, so best of luck to you!
 
Good for you.

I'm glad your recognize the "gambler" in you. I think trading in and out of any commodity in the belief one can predict short term price moves is doomed in the long run - markets have a way of moving either randomly, or at least randomly enough that profiting from small moves consistently remains an elusive goal.

I think you might find that, overall, the best strategy is to simply buy and hold silver - that is if you think the long term trend will be upward, or if you're doing so to protect against inflation.

But hell, even gamblers win sometimes, so best of luck to you!

gracias amigo :)

and yes, its definitely gambling alright, at the point of commitment it's always basically a 50/50 bet, up or down, however much chartology, support, resistance, pivot points and news flow you try and factor in.

I'm sure you're right, buy and hold is safer long term, and if or when I get burned by a large unexpected upwards move I'll lick my wounds and return to sensibility again.

at the moment though I think it's a relatively safe bet we wont be getting any sudden $20 spikes upwards, i think even The Don agrees with me on that :)
 
at the moment though I think it's a relatively safe bet we wont be getting any sudden $20 spikes upwards...:)

Key word: relatively

Have you read Taleb's "The Black Swan"? Tough going at times, but worthwhile.

Next up on my reading list is his earlier book "Fooled By Randomness".

In any case, what effect would a worldwide pandemic have on the price of silver? A third World War? A virus that took down the internet? Or something totally unforeseen? It's like the old saw about the psychic saying, "I didn't see THAT coming!"

That's the thing about Black Swans - its the thing that no one, or nearly no one, foresaw that bites everybody on the ass.

Anyway, you seem to have your wits about you. Please keep us informed on how your trading goes, both good and bad.
 
Key word: relatively

Have you read Taleb's "The Black Swan"? Tough going at times, but worthwhile.

Next up on my reading list is his earlier book "Fooled By Randomness".

In any case, what effect would a worldwide pandemic have on the price of silver? A third World War? A virus that took down the internet? Or something totally unforeseen? It's like the old saw about the psychic saying, "I didn't see THAT coming!"

That's the thing about Black Swans - its the thing that no one, or nearly no one, foresaw that bites everybody on the ass.

Anyway, you seem to have your wits about you. Please keep us informed on how your trading goes, both good and bad.


speaking of spikes, Sprott buying another $1.5 billion of silver

http://profitimes.com/free-articles/sprott-to-buy-1-5b-of-silver-bullion/

I didnt know this:

Because Sprott today represents ½ the size of the Hunt brothers wallet and their attempt to corner the silver market in 1979-80

exactly the kind of event you're talking about, better stop the out and in for a bit and sit tight I think.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom