Maybe.
But did you try to imagine that they didn't?
And if they don't have predictive value, what good are they?
I look at charts of past performance with lines superimposed on them, and simply don't perceive the same thing you do. Whether its silver at $35 or Apple at $500, I don't think drawing lines on historical prices informs us of future movement. At all.
what convinced me that it does, to a certain extent any way, is watching the price track along, and bounce off those lines, after you've drawn them, into the future.
have you heard of pivot points? these are calculated every day from the previous days range and you can fairly reliably trade off them, in fact this is my most consistently profitable trading, on autopilot, often overnight, I leave small orders to buy at S1, then double at S2 treble at S3, and selling at pivot, R1 and R2 depending where that order bought.
pivot is the light blue line in middle.
..and consistently find this topping up my account (often while I sleep) from my more "speculative" losses
this is not in arrears, these extend out in front of you through the day and most of the time do give a fair indication of where the price will likely stall, and very often reverse.
so in a bull trend you buy support and sell the R's and in a bear trend you short the R's and cover the S's, and it works pretty well, barring the occasional spikes or waterfalls, which stop losses (set a little under S3) would protect you from too big a hit, Ive never had them taken out yet, although Im sure it will at some point.
Again, looking at just silver, what price machination would falsify the hypothesis of any given resistance level? Specifically, with resistance at $35 apparently broken, what will silver do today? Next week? Next month? Any prediction may be right or wrong, and if wrong, there will always be post hoc rationalizations and new lines drawn on the updated charts.
I dont know how to answer what would falsify it. but TA can only work within the confines of the overall trend, you need to know (or think you know) which macro direction the trend is running, and then TA can be quite good for predicting the smaller movements, within the general trend.
its sudden trend changes that turn everything around, news, central bankers doing their market manipulation thing etc, at that point I agree TA is suddenly useless, except previous levels can often help you understand where waterfalls may stall and bounce, temporarily, anyway.
Good luck with this kind of thinking. And I continue to keep an open mind on this.
cheers, will keep you informed on progress
