Merged Silver Over 40.00 / Real and fake prices

I'll admit, I don't understand the importance of a closed trust, you appear to know more about Sprott (and his hedge fund?) than me.

And it is important for you to understand what it is if we are going to make comparisons to alternatives. A closed-end fund has a fixed number of shares and new shares can only be created by initial public offerings via management (PSLV). ETFs can create more shares if the authorized participants give more assets to the funds and shares can be destroyed by redeeming these assets (SLV). At least, this is from a retail investor side of things. I'm sure I've missed a few details in my simplified overview.

did you see, and what do you think about this analysis? http://www.marketoracle.co.uk/Article14756.html

Nope, and starting to read it. It definitely brings up interesting points and displays the diminishing returns on energy. I'll admit I'm not an energy expert though, so I don't want to give an uninformed opinion.

if we are (and we are IMO) heading into a global recession, and as silver is a byproduct in most mining operations, supply is likely to reduce along with the other base metals its mined with as global demand falls?

Wouldn't surprise me.
 
We're getting closer to a $37.50 close

That's the trigger point for the Turk three months to $75 prediction
 
We're getting closer to a $37.50 close

That's the trigger point for the Turk three months to $75 prediction

yes indeed and there's a beauty of an inverse H & S lining up (and in Gold too at 1800 actually) - we will fairly soon get a live demo of whether TA has any validity at all IMO



and frankly I totally agree with Sprott's latest analysis, central banks are in global splurge mode, it has to go somewhere.

IMO the Dow & S&P would be at least 20% lower if they hadn't been printing a trillion a month since last November
 
Weird.

I mentioned my last post to Karen, and guess what two things were within reach of her computer...

6925663715_c51c25b2d9_z.jpg
 
time will tell. will you credit him if he's right, or declare "luck"?

Good question, but you probably already know my take on this...

It takes a lot more than one, or even a handful of successful predictions to deserve "credit".

Even if a commodity moves randomly, many will guess right on occasion, and with enough people guessing, some will appear to have abilities and insight which may involve luck more than skill/intuition.

From a summary of "Fooled By Randomness" (forgive me if I've posted any or all of this before):

The past decade has witnessed the release of many books about risk management, but none have managed to illustrate the role that random events play in life and markets as well as Fooled by Randomness. Writing in a leisurely and personal style that makes this complex subject utterly accessible, the author, Nassim Taleb, instructs us on how to account for randomness in our decision making, and illustrates the many ways in which we confuse luck with skill.

“It is foolish to think that an irrational market cannot become even more irrational.”

This confusion, when applied to the market, often results in lucky fools - people who have succeeded due to essentially random events beyond their control, but deem themselves skilled investors. Such perceptions cause people to overlook real volatility and focus only on returns.

The potential for randomness can be a disruptive force in whatever you are doing. People can be lucky fools without ever even being aware that they are successful by virtue of luck. Such good fortune will be reflected in the way they act and think, since an increase in personal performance for whatever reason causes a rise in serotonin, enhancing leadership abilities.

“Evolutionary psychology claims that such physical manifestations of one’s performance in life, just like an animal’s dominant condition, can be used for signaling: it makes the winners seem easily visible, which is efficient in mate selection.”

Successful people appear more powerful and dominant, just as an animal’s behavior signals other animals about his dominance. But with a single shift of fortune, that could all be taken away.

“Never ask a trader if he is profitable; you can easily see it in his gesture and gait.”

Unfortunately, most people don’t pay enough attention to randomness. They underestimate the effects of randomness and have little understanding of how probability affects events.



BTW, I skimmed through the Sprott analysis. It may be correct in every detail, but every detail is public knowledge. That's why silver is at $35.35 at this moment, and not $15 or $75.

I would definitely not bet on silver NOT moving higher over some predefined time span - but I would be careful not to just assume that it will.
 
Good question, but you probably already know my take on this...

It takes a lot more than one, or even a handful of successful predictions to deserve "credit".

Even if a commodity moves randomly, many will guess right on occasion, and with enough people guessing, some will appear to have abilities and insight which may involve luck more than skill/intuition.

From a summary of "Fooled By Randomness" (forgive me if I've posted any or all of this before):

The past decade has witnessed the release of many books about risk management, but none have managed to illustrate the role that random events play in life and markets as well as Fooled by Randomness. Writing in a leisurely and personal style that makes this complex subject utterly accessible, the author, Nassim Taleb, instructs us on how to account for randomness in our decision making, and illustrates the many ways in which we confuse luck with skill.

“It is foolish to think that an irrational market cannot become even more irrational.”

This confusion, when applied to the market, often results in lucky fools - people who have succeeded due to essentially random events beyond their control, but deem themselves skilled investors. Such perceptions cause people to overlook real volatility and focus only on returns.

The potential for randomness can be a disruptive force in whatever you are doing. People can be lucky fools without ever even being aware that they are successful by virtue of luck. Such good fortune will be reflected in the way they act and think, since an increase in personal performance for whatever reason causes a rise in serotonin, enhancing leadership abilities.

“Evolutionary psychology claims that such physical manifestations of one’s performance in life, just like an animal’s dominant condition, can be used for signaling: it makes the winners seem easily visible, which is efficient in mate selection.”

Successful people appear more powerful and dominant, just as an animal’s behavior signals other animals about his dominance. But with a single shift of fortune, that could all be taken away.

“Never ask a trader if he is profitable; you can easily see it in his gesture and gait.”

Unfortunately, most people don’t pay enough attention to randomness. They underestimate the effects of randomness and have little understanding of how probability affects events.



BTW, I skimmed through the Sprott analysis. It may be correct in every detail, but every detail is public knowledge. That's why silver is at $35.35 at this moment, and not $15 or $75.

I would definitely not bet on silver NOT moving higher over some predefined time span - but I would be careful not to just assume that it will.

so is it your position that it should be virtually impossible to be a consistently profitable trader over a long period? that's what I would infer from your posts?
 
this is interesting, yesterday evening we had what looked like a pretty standard silver bear raid with massive amounts of paper shorts dumped on the markets over a few minutes, and which usually induces a "waterfall" slide downwards, but this one failed.

6926648117_5f972d70dc_z.jpg


large image 122.5 million Oz of paper sorts contracts dumped in 7 minutes

the formation you see there with holding and immediate bounce is know in certain silver watchers circles as a "FUBM" as a hat tip to JPM's Blythe Masters, and is extraordinary bullish, there were several of these shortly before silver powered up to $50 last year

full post on Silver Doctors
 
Last edited:
We're getting closer to a $37.50 close

That's the trigger point for the Turk three months to $75 prediction

silver on another tear today, $36.50 $36.75 $36.90 $37.00! currently, looking really strong, not long now till the big test..

Turk not any less excited.."something big is about to happen"

“This is a great start to the week for the precious metals, Eric. We need to see this kind of strength to make sure both gold and silver follow through in the next few trading days to confirm the big gains from last week where gold climbed 2.9%, while silver soared 6.4%. It is remarkable to see both metals hold their gains with no profit taking. Clearly, traders see something big is about to happen, and so do I.”

“In this regard, I have mentioned several times my expectation that once resistance at $35 is taken out, silver will climb to $68-$70 in 2 to 3 months. I still expect that outcome, but of course, only time will tell. I thought it might be tough going for silver in the $35-$36 area, but maybe not based on the strength we are seeing today.

But regardless, Eric, I expect the silver price will begin to accelerate to the upside once $36 is hurdled. In many ways silver is positioned today like it was back in the summer of 2010. Long-time KWN listeners will remember the events from back then and my bullish views about silver. I feel the same way today.”

edit, touched $37.20 - still at $37.15 could even be today? looks like maybe a capitulation short squeeze to me now.
 
Last edited:
Silver closed at $37.26.

That said, try this thought experiment...

Look at any chart of silver, and ask yourself if any perceived "resistance level" is real or imagined.

I hold that this kind of thinking is just loaded with paraedolia and post hoc reasoning.

A "resistance level" may hold, with prices dropping back below it. Or I may be broken through (as is the apparent forecast here). Or it may continue to be challenged.

Fine. But does any of this hold meaningful predictive power? I mean, any movement of silver away from $35 (or not) could be interpreted as being an effect of an imaginary "resistance level".

Put another way, what could silver do that would falsify the "$35 resistance level" hypothesis?

And kevsta, I still owe you a response to a prior (good) question - I haven't forgotten about it.
 
Silver closed at $37.26.

That said, try this thought experiment...

Look at any chart of silver, and ask yourself if any perceived "resistance level" is real or imagined.

I hold that this kind of thinking is just loaded with paraedolia and post hoc reasoning.

A "resistance level" may hold, with prices dropping back below it. Or I may be broken through (as is the apparent forecast here). Or it may continue to be challenged.

Fine. But does any of this hold meaningful predictive power? I mean, any movement of silver away from $35 (or not) could be interpreted as being an effect of an imaginary "resistance level".

I disagree with this. if you have spent any time watching charts you should definitely be able to see the price action marking out support and resistance, the price will often "bounce" off of it many times, before either failing and heading away for a longer period, or "break through" and when it does it will usually violently accelerate away (again either up or down depending on whether we are talking S or R)

these areas definitely exist, it's just the point where you have approx 50/50 buyers and sellers and a lot of money in orders at those points, and will stay as support or resistance until one side overpowers the other convincingly.

and then once resistance is broken through, you can watch the same price action now using that level as support.

remember everybody is looking at the same charts, programming their buy / sell orders in from the same information, so buys & stops are just the other side of these levels, which tends to cause cascading runs up or down once they are penetrated.

it sounds to me like you're saying charts have no meaning at all, and I have to disagree with that, they definitely do. charts just visualize the interaction of human (and now algos replicating humans) behaviour on both the buy and sell side.

Put another way, what could silver do that would falsify the "$35 resistance level" hypothesis?

well actually the way silver breezed straight through 36 yesterday almost invalidates that level :) looked like a big capitulation short squeeze from scaredy shorts to me

And kevsta, I still owe you a response to a prior (good) question - I haven't forgotten about it.

no worries, take your time..
 
Last edited:
...these areas definitely exist...

Maybe.

But did you try to imagine that they didn't?

And if they don't have predictive value, what good are they?

I look at charts of past performance with lines superimposed on them, and simply don't perceive the same thing you do. Whether its silver at $35 or Apple at $500, I don't think drawing lines on historical prices informs us of future movement. At all.

Again, looking at just silver, what price machination would falsify the hypothesis of any given resistance level? Specifically, with resistance at $35 apparently broken, what will silver do today? Next week? Next month? Any prediction may be right or wrong, and if wrong, there will always be post hoc rationalizations and new lines drawn on the updated charts.

Good luck with this kind of thinking. And I continue to keep an open mind on this.
 
Maybe.

But did you try to imagine that they didn't?

And if they don't have predictive value, what good are they?

I look at charts of past performance with lines superimposed on them, and simply don't perceive the same thing you do. Whether its silver at $35 or Apple at $500, I don't think drawing lines on historical prices informs us of future movement. At all.

Again, looking at just silver, what price machination would falsify the hypothesis of any given resistance level? Specifically, with resistance at $35 apparently broken, what will silver do today? Next week? Next month? Any prediction may be right or wrong, and if wrong, there will always be post hoc rationalizations and new lines drawn on the updated charts.

Good luck with this kind of thinking. And I continue to keep an open mind on this.

I think you may be confusing the relative uselessness of technical analysis in terms of predictive value with the ability to use other forms of analysis to predict. Just because you may not understand how people are able to make accurate predictions, doesn't mean they are not able to, or that it's impossible, or akin to reading tea leaves.

I've been right about precious metals for over a decade now, not because I am adept at reading price/volume charts (I'm not), but because I understand (to some degree, at least) the fundamentals driving their supply and demand. You mentioned in another post that you hold NFLX, and AAPL. I gave some off-the-cuff advice to short NFLX, and double down on AAPL. How have those turned out? I'll have to dig up the post, but I'm pretty sure Apple has skyrocketed since then, and I think I understand at least partially why that was. At the 350-360ish level Apple was basically a zero-coupon bond paying the equivalent of 10% with a "coupon" virtually doubling each year. You can't beat that, and I think the market has ultimately come to the same conclusion. Even as Apple eclipses the half-trillion dollar market cap milestone, (a feat managed by only 6 other publically traded companies in history) it sports a PEG ratio of a mere .65, which would suggest it is still a compelling value, if you believe at the very least that its growth will not decline significantly.

So the question isn't really whether people can make accurate predictions, the question is how do you identify whether those predictions were due to prescience, or luck. I am a virtual permabear, so I didn't buy Apple even after making that convictionless prediction. I certainly thought long and hard about it, the comments of some zerohedge contributors probably persuaded me not to, unfortunately for me.
 
Last edited:
Maybe.

But did you try to imagine that they didn't?

And if they don't have predictive value, what good are they?

I look at charts of past performance with lines superimposed on them, and simply don't perceive the same thing you do. Whether its silver at $35 or Apple at $500, I don't think drawing lines on historical prices informs us of future movement. At all.

what convinced me that it does, to a certain extent any way, is watching the price track along, and bounce off those lines, after you've drawn them, into the future.

have you heard of pivot points? these are calculated every day from the previous days range and you can fairly reliably trade off them, in fact this is my most consistently profitable trading, on autopilot, often overnight, I leave small orders to buy at S1, then double at S2 treble at S3, and selling at pivot, R1 and R2 depending where that order bought.

pivot is the light blue line in middle.

178524f4e2bd04a76a.png


..and consistently find this topping up my account (often while I sleep) from my more "speculative" losses :)

this is not in arrears, these extend out in front of you through the day and most of the time do give a fair indication of where the price will likely stall, and very often reverse.

so in a bull trend you buy support and sell the R's and in a bear trend you short the R's and cover the S's, and it works pretty well, barring the occasional spikes or waterfalls, which stop losses (set a little under S3) would protect you from too big a hit, Ive never had them taken out yet, although Im sure it will at some point.

Again, looking at just silver, what price machination would falsify the hypothesis of any given resistance level? Specifically, with resistance at $35 apparently broken, what will silver do today? Next week? Next month? Any prediction may be right or wrong, and if wrong, there will always be post hoc rationalizations and new lines drawn on the updated charts.

I dont know how to answer what would falsify it. but TA can only work within the confines of the overall trend, you need to know (or think you know) which macro direction the trend is running, and then TA can be quite good for predicting the smaller movements, within the general trend.

its sudden trend changes that turn everything around, news, central bankers doing their market manipulation thing etc, at that point I agree TA is suddenly useless, except previous levels can often help you understand where waterfalls may stall and bounce, temporarily, anyway.

Good luck with this kind of thinking. And I continue to keep an open mind on this.

cheers, will keep you informed on progress ;)
 
I've been right about precious metals for over a decade now, not because I am adept at reading price/volume charts (I'm not)

Begging the question, "Is anyone?"

...but because I understand (to some degree, at least) the fundamentals driving their supply and demand.

This. Fundamentals, and perhaps intuition, are the keys to success.

Not chart reading.
 
Begging the question, "Is anyone?"

consistently profitable traders are.

This. [For the average person and non-traders] Fundamentals, and perhaps intuition, are the keys to success.

Not chart reading.

highlighted fix for you ;)

edit, its worth clarifying, I am not including myself in the successful trader category yet, my trading career only started in Dec 2011 and is very much in it's infancy.

I figure that gambling small amounts on leverage will allow me to leave my physical stash alone and follow Jesse Livermore's advice about "sitting tight" making him the money not trying to jump in and out of a bull market.

and when I win (with shorts in particular) it cheers me up about the larger (theoretical) loss on my physical metals
 
Last edited:
consistently profitable traders are.



highlighted fix for you ;)

edit, its worth clarifying, I am not including myself in the successful trader category yet, my trading career only started in Dec 2011 and is very much in it's infancy.

I figure that gambling small amounts on leverage will allow me to leave my physical stash alone and follow Jesse Livermore's advice about "sitting tight" making him the money not trying to jump in and out of a bull market.

and when I win (with shorts in particular) it cheers me up about the larger (theoretical) loss on my physical metals

The problem with trading profitably, assuming you can use simple price/volume analysis to gain predictive value (which I'm skeptical of), is that you are voluntarily churning your own account. You have to overcome bid/ask spreads, commissions, and short term capital gains taxes just to break even. This is an important reason why Warren Buffet, his crony capitalism not withstanding, is as successful as he is. He understands that buying excellent businesses at steep discounts and holding them in perpetuity is the best way to compound wealth. He particularly understands the insurance racket, and thus maximizes his ability to compound his own wealth at insurance premium payers' collective expense. This is not to say that there is never a good time to sell a great company, but that those periods are so few and far between that they are as infrequent as the opportunities to buy them at steep discounts.
 
The problem with trading profitably, assuming you can use simple price/volume analysis to gain predictive value (which I'm skeptical of), is that you are voluntarily churning your own account. You have to overcome bid/ask spreads, commissions, and short term capital gains taxes just to break even.

I get all of that, but it's not that hard to pick a few winners, so as long as you keep the losses small (and am learning after a few teething mishaps)

for example the opportunity to use only $480 to control 600 barrels of oil a couple of weeks back wasn't such a bad guess, TA aided slightly in that I was buying in at predefined (at support) entry levels and so never had to watch it go underwater even briefly.

that one alone would / will bankroll the rest of the years gambling even if I dont get another one right for the rest of the year, but with silver and gold on bull runs it would be very difficult to manage 100% wrong

but thanks for your concern anyway ;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom