Merged Silver Over 40.00 / Real and fake prices

Michael, just how much silver are you hoarding? > 1,000 oz? > 10,000?

I really find it difficult to believe that anyone with more market savvy than ideology would hold onto silver at whatever low price you bought in at just for the shininess. At 10,000 oz., you could've cashed out at $50, waited ten days and bought your 10k oz back at a $160,000 discount. Same amount of silver in the hole in your back yard and 160,000 bucks to buy tinned tuna, ammunition, and bottled water and enough left over to carpet the bunker.
 
Last edited:
[ . . . ] I really find it difficult to believe that anyone with more market savvy than ideology would hold onto silver at whatever low price you bought in at [ . . . ]
I don't think there's any record on this forum of michaelsuede being bullish or long silver before 1st April, when the spot price was $37.8.
 
Man, that stuff is volatile.
Which is why margin/collateral requirements get raised

so much for margin hikes reducing volatility.
Who thinks that? They are to reduce credit/counterparty risk. If I'm your broker and I sold you a synthetic silver position and its volatility subsequently spiked, I'm going to demand more collateral or close you out, and that's nothing so altruistic as me wanting to reduce volatility.

today's insane commodities plunge is brought to you by margin hikes in crude.
That would be tail wagging dog

(ETA: Of course if people long of commodities don't have the readies to meet margin calls, then of course they have to sell, which can exacerbate a price gap downwards if enough people do it . . . this would be an example of a correlated mistake--a lot of people too highly leveraged with insufficient apprehension of risk)
 
Last edited:
In short, never believe that the real price of something is what you saw on eBay.
You think?? ;)

Should eBay become a market maker rather than a clearing agent, and should it facilitate leverage and short positions in stuff, I would pay more attention to its commodity prices.
 
Michael, just how much silver are you hoarding? > 1,000 oz? > 10,000?

I really find it difficult to believe that anyone with more market savvy than ideology would hold onto silver at whatever low price you bought in at just for the shininess. At 10,000 oz., you could've cashed out at $50, waited ten days and bought your 10k oz back at a $160,000 discount. Same amount of silver in the hole in your back yard and 160,000 bucks to buy tinned tuna, ammunition, and bottled water and enough left over to carpet the bunker.
In his defense, 160K is worthless in a hyperinflation scenario. And, despite a "watch it go up tomorrow" posts, in general he has not posed as somebody that can predict short term trends. His thesis, such as it is, is all based on long term economic trends. You can't make short term buy/sell decisions on long term models, SFAIK.

Edit: there are also significant tax consequences to selling, requiring quite a large move in prices to just break even. As it turns out, we've seen that move, but to expect anyone (who believes it's going to $1500) to have that kind of crystal ball is a bit excessive in my opinion.
 
Last edited:
In his defense, 160K is worthless in a hyperinflation scenario. And, despite a "watch it go up tomorrow" posts, in general he has not posed as somebody that can predict short term trends. His thesis, such as it is, is all based on long term economic trends. You can't make short term buy/sell decisions on long term models, SFAIK.

160K on Thursday May 12th, 2011 would be a whole lot of hard goods, though, n'est-ce-pas? So unless the global collapse comes around midnight tonight, he could've converted that worthless fiat currency into something tangible. (Even if that was another 5000 oz of silver. Oh, and as of right now, that's $170,000 as the morning market is about $33.
 
What's the definition of hyper inflation?

For me it conjures up images of 1930's Germany and people firing up the stove with bank-notes.

It seems to me that there are many shades of inflation before we reach an extreme scenario like that.

Zimbabwe is mentioned a lot in this context.
Holy crap. If that is the level of mismanagement needed to bring about hyper-inflation, the US is far removed from it.....
Ummm.....no.

Because once the train gets into runaway mode, it's basically over.

You might look at the point in Weimer republic or Zimbabwe where that "runaway train first emerged", not the currency value at the end point when the train inevitably crashed. Secondly, you would look at the reasons why the runaway mode might or possibly could occur, and what signals in the economy one might could read to indicate such was occurring.

We are definitely seeing Bernanke, Geither, and Obaby as a couple of dogs chasing their own tails right now. Some of the signals that a runaway mode could be in place already, or that it could emerge, do exist.

On the positive side, it seems you have the Tea Party ("Taxed enough already") and a small to medium sized group of Republicans, who seem to recognize this and at least seem to want to stop it. "Stopping it" does not mean a return to the glory days of the dollar, it may mean a new stasis where the dollar is worth perhaps 40 cents of it's current value. Or perhaps 20 cents or 10 cents.

"Stopping it" means stopping the runaway inflation cycle, and retaining the public confidence which directly implies no hyperinflation. This will require extreme amounts of political will and most democracies when faced with this issue have failed.
 
Last edited:
Michael, just how much silver are you hoarding? > 1,000 oz? > 10,000?

At 10,000 oz., you could've cashed out at $50, waited ten days and bought your 10k oz back at a $160,000 discount.

Its just SO easy to look back and see what one "could have done".

How about if he had cashed out at $50, and the price had surged to $500?

I only wish I could go back and buy and sell Apple or Microsoft at all the right times.

"Playing" or "timing" markets is difficult at best, and perhaps impossible in principle. Good luck to anyone trying to do that in commodities.

For those purchasing metals as a possible way to insure against inflation, these movements up and down are interesting at best, but insignificant in the long run.
 
Michael, just how much silver are you hoarding? > 1,000 oz? > 10,000?

I really find it difficult to believe that anyone with more market savvy than ideology would hold onto silver at whatever low price you bought in at just for the shininess. At 10,000 oz., you could've cashed out at $50, waited ten days and bought your 10k oz back at a $160,000 discount. Same amount of silver in the hole in your back yard and 160,000 bucks to buy tinned tuna, ammunition, and bottled water and enough left over to carpet the bunker.

I hold physical, so it's not as easy as dumping ETF holdings.

I have no intention of selling my silver. It is in rounds and junk coins. The next time I sell my silver it will be for food and shelter, not dollars.
 
Its just SO easy to look back and see what one "could have done".

How about if he had cashed out at $50, and the price had surged to $500?

I only wish I could go back and buy and sell Apple or Microsoft at all the right times.

"Playing" or "timing" markets is difficult at best, and perhaps impossible in principle. Good luck to anyone trying to do that in commodities.

For those purchasing metals as a possible way to insure against inflation, these movements up and down are interesting at best, but insignificant in the long run.

Oh, I see. You're taking this hoary tale seriously. I'm not.
 
I hold physical, so it's not as easy as dumping ETF holdings.

I have no intention of selling my silver. It is in rounds and junk coins. The next time I sell my silver it will be for food and shelter, not dollars.

But you could've made a bundle of fiat money which you could've converted to even more shiny metal. Why wouldn't you have taken advantage of the people who are trying to manipulate the market and beaten them at their own game.

And if you had any kind of real holding (by which I mean more than you can keep in your sock drawer), you could've made enough to buy "shelter", e.g. what most of us refer to as "a house". Or quite a lot of food. You'd rather stand on principle, and miss out on your desire to fill those two basic needs, or a chance to double your shiny metals holdings?

I don't think so, Michael.
 
Last edited:
160K on Thursday May 12th, 2011 would be a whole lot of hard goods, though, n'est-ce-pas? So unless the global collapse comes around midnight tonight, he could've converted that worthless fiat currency into something tangible. (Even if that was another 5000 oz of silver. Oh, and as of right now, that's $170,000 as the morning market is about $33.
Once again, you cannot make short term buy/sell decisions on long term economic models.

I own a stock now I could have made out like a bandit on if I had sold when it was at $22. Right now it is around 17 or so. But I had no idea that it would drop, or when, whether it will drop further, or go up. So, I hold, because I value it's assets more in the 50-60 range.

And, let's face it, Michael was predicting an imminent rise when it was at $50. You can't chastise him for not investing in the opposite direction of where he thought the market was heading.
 
But you could've made a bundle of fiat money which you could've converted to even more shiny metal. Why wouldn't you have taken advantage of the people who are trying to manipulate the market and beaten them at their own game.

And if you had any kind of real holding (by which I mean more than you can keep in your sock drawer), you could've made enough to buy "shelter", e.g. what most of us refer to as "a house". Or quite a lot of food. You'd rather stand on principle, and miss out on your desire to fill those two basic needs, or a chance to double your shiny metals holdings?

I don't think so, Michael.

Well if I had time traveling powers I probably would teleport back in time and sell my metal and do exactly what you said.

So thanks for pointing out what I could have done had I been in possession of a time machine.

I'd also buy lottery tickets.
 
Michael, just how much silver are you hoarding? > 1,000 oz? > 10,000?

I really find it difficult to believe that anyone with more market savvy than ideology would hold onto silver at whatever low price you bought in at just for the shininess. At 10,000 oz., you could've cashed out at $50, waited ten days and bought your 10k oz back at a $160,000 discount. Same amount of silver in the hole in your back yard and 160,000 bucks to buy tinned tuna, ammunition, and bottled water and enough left over to carpet the bunker.

In other words, you find it hard to believe that silver investors might not be market timers, speculators, or weak hands. I have > 10,000oz of silver, and I haven't sold an ounce. I find it hard to believe you're a better investor than I am, despite your Monday morning quarterbacking. Could have, should have, would have.
 
I know there are things written in this thread which I find hard to believe also.
 
In other words, you find it hard to believe that silver investors might not be market timers, speculators, or weak hands. I have > 10,000oz of silver, and I haven't sold an ounce. I find it hard to believe you're a better investor than I am, despite your Monday morning quarterbacking. Could have, should have, would have.

I didn't even consider selling at this supposed "peak".

Hardly paid any attention to it at all.

Yep, it was like the shadow of a fly passing overhead.
 
In other words, you find it hard to believe that silver investors might not be market timers, speculators, or weak hands. I have > 10,000oz of silver, and I haven't sold an ounce. I find it hard to believe you're a better investor than I am, despite your Monday morning quarterbacking. Could have, should have, would have.

Huh? I sold mine at 48, so I think I did okay.

Actually - I just gave it to my daughter. It was a remnant of the last silver bug fiasco... I bought a small fistful at 17 almost 30 years ago, and watched it drop to 11, so I left the 20 ounces sitting around in NYC as a reminder to not get caught up in such, again. When I was following this thread, I checked and they still had the little 1 oz bars, so I told her to go ahead and take 'em.

I hope you guys don't have to wait as long to take your losses. (The thousand bucks to her was a windfall to my daughter - she bought tickets to Helsinki to some event she wanted to attend but couldn't afford, right now. To me, it would've been a considerable loss - $340 in a money market account in '83 would've netted much more, by now.) Yeah, you may see 50 again in a week, sure. But you also may see 25 in a month and wait ten years to see 50 again. Good luck.
 
Huh? I sold mine at 48, so I think I did okay.

Actually - I just gave it to my daughter. It was a remnant of the last silver bug fiasco... I bought a small fistful at 17 almost 30 years ago, and watched it drop to 11, so I left the 20 ounces sitting around in NYC as a reminder to not get caught up in such, again. When I was following this thread, I checked and they still had the little 1 oz bars, so I told her to go ahead and take 'em.

I hope you guys don't have to wait as long to take your losses. (The thousand bucks to her was a windfall to my daughter - she bought tickets to Helsinki to some event she wanted to attend but couldn't afford, right now. To me, it would've been a considerable loss - $340 in a money market account in '83 would've netted much more, by now.) Yeah, you may see 50 again in a week, sure. But you also may see 25 in a month and wait ten years to see 50 again. Good luck.

I've been in silver since 2000, with an average basis slightly over five bucks. I'm not waiting to see $50, I'm a long term investor. I'm sure the fundamentals in silver, and especially the US dollar are identical to 1980 when the Hunt brothers were newsworthy, right? I risk more than 20 ounces on a hand of blackjack in Vegas. I'm betting against the US dollar, I don't need luck.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom