Should Ahmadinejad be allowed to speak at Columbia University?

Really? Can you quote someone?


I moved to this thread to keep this one on topic:

icon1.gif
Time to kick Iran (
multipage.gif
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ... Last Page)
Oliver (17th July 2007)
 
Well, usually RandFan is an competitive discussion partner, but he
lost it within the "Bush-Hitler" thread. But I love you nevertheless
for your sarcastic sense of humor. :)

Anyone who did not think that thread was in the humor section probably would "lose it".
 
My point is this (and I'm sorry it does not relate directly to the speech at the university but I had to make my point clear once and for all):
Taboo is something that the people decide upon. In each society it can be different but probably basic taboos will be similar. When I state my mind, I use the word taboo to relate to what action or idea I think should be taboo. As I have stated before, taboo for me are things that have to do with violence against others like murder, theft, rape etc. Things that under no excuse should happen. Science of course must not be taboo, the right to religion must not be taboo and so on. Basically you can say that violating another person's natural rights is taboo in my opinion. And so taboo should be illegal and not advocated for in public. In order to make myself clear, I do not think people should have an open stage to say their mind against this taboo. Privately people can arrange groups and talk about it at home or in meetings but not get a public stage for it. The group meetings can be in order to discuss changes that this group might want to make to what is considered today a taboo. They can write their congressman about it and this topic can be discussed in the proper house in order to have the possibility to change that taboo (law).
After saying this, if you guys think otherwise, (for example you would like to see people calling others to perform acts of (for example) murder freely because you think their freedom of speech should be given to them) then we certainly don't agree with eachother.​

Cleon said:
Er, yes, I'm aware of this. That was a rhetorical question addressing this poorly-thought-out idea:
My idea is very solidly based and in fact Israel goes by this thought out idea. I can imagine that most modern countries do. Maybe the U.S. is different I don't know.

Thanks for listening guys and as I said I just wanted to make my opinion clear.

Regards,
Yair
 
Now for Ahmadinejad. Where can I watch the whole interview with him?

Thanks,
Yair
 
In my opinion, what is considered taboo in society should not be legally advertized or given freedom of speech.

You ain't from around here, so you are not expected to understand, but your opinion on limitations to free speech has crossed the line in our society into taboo territory.

Carry on. Say what you want.
 
My idea is very solidly based

And yet, you can't seem to defend it.

Atheism is taboo in many societies. Should it be illegal to hold public atheist meetings?

Darwinism was considered taboo (and still is, in some circles). Should it be illegal to publicly endorse Darwinism?

Do you really want this sort of system:

Privately people can arrange groups and talk about it at home or in meetings but not get a public stage for it. The group meetings can be in order to discuss changes that this group might want to make to what is considered today a taboo. They can write their congressman about it and this topic can be discussed in the proper house in order to have the possibility to change that taboo (law).


Where people need government approval before saying what they think?

and in fact Israel goes by this thought out idea.

So? That just says a lot about how "democratic" Israel really is.
 
The word “taboo” entered English by way of Tahitian, the language of a barbarous society. It isn’t really of much use in defining the laws of a more advanced* culture.

In old-time Hawaii, there was a taboo (kapu in Hawaiian) prohibiting women from eating pork and bananas. As so often among barbarians, breaking the taboo meant death. In other words, what was kapu was against the law. Of course, women sometimes broke the taboo in secrecy – but I doubt that they ever openly advocated its repeal. Speaking against a taboo was as bad as breaking it; it was “dangerous to social order,” as the big kahunas always like to put it. (I’d love to see the ladies marching and protesting under banners reading “More Pork for Women!” and “Our Bananas Ourselves!” but not in Iran. I hate bloodshed.)

Literate societies don’t have to conflate mere taboos with law. We can paint with a finer brush. “A man’s opinion does not break my leg or rob my purse,” is approximately how Jefferson put it.

*Are we really more advanced than pre-contact Tahiti? Yeah, I guess so. We aren’t as bad as Mr. Ahmadibtsplk anyway. Not yet. Not as long as Columbia flies her flag.
 
Should he be allowed to speak? Yes
Next question, why aren’t Conservative or Republican organizations allowed to speak at Columbia?
This is nothing but a sham. There is no freedom of speech at Columbia. You are allowed to speak only if the left wing wants you too.


Students stormed the stage at Columbia University's Roone auditorium yesterday, knocking over chairs and tables and attacking Jim Gilchrist, the founder of the Minutemen, a group that patrols the border between America and Mexico
The College Republicans expressed their concern about the lack of free speech for opposing viewpoints on the Columbia campus in the wake of the evening's events. "We've often feared that there's not freedom of speech at Columbia for more right-wing views — and that was proven tonight," the executive director of the Columbia College Republicans, Lauren Steinberg, said.
http://www.nysun.com/article/41020
The fact that the rioting students could be heard yelling, "He has no right to speak!" was telling. Apparently, in their minds, neither Gilchrist nor anyone else with whom they disagree has a right to express their viewpoints. In any other setting this would be called exactly what it is -- totalitarianism.

http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/g/a/2006/11/29/cstillwell.DTL

Editorial: Columbia U. brownshirts stomped on First Amendment


the video
 
I think puppy avatars should be taboo and I think I can find enough people to agree with me,........


but I'll still let you speak out about it.:)
 
Should he be allowed to speak? Yes
Next question, why aren’t Conservative or Republican organizations allowed to speak at Columbia?

You mean like these guys?

Columbia University College Republicans
Campus Crusade for Christ @ Columbia
Columbia College Conservative Club
Columbia College Libertarians

Their websites, which are all hosted on Columbia's site, don't seem to indicate any problem speaking their mind.

This is nothing but a sham. There is no freedom of speech at Columbia. You are allowed to speak only if the left wing wants you too.

Well, that's a sensationalist load of crap. Thanks for playing, though.
 
Cleon, your words are making it clear that you didn't read what I have written carefully.
Since I don't want to keep on forever talking about this I'll just say that since I said:
yairhol said:
taboo for me are things that have to do with violence against others like murder, theft, rape etc. Things that under no excuse should happen. Science of course must not be taboo, the right to religion must not be taboo and so on. Basically you can say that violating another person's natural rights is taboo in my opinion.
then why are you asking me if the right to religion (or lack of it) should be taboo? I've answered that. And why are you asking about Darwinism (the right to research science)? I've answered that also. You're so sure that you are correct that you become blind/deaf to what others write/say.

Cleon said:
Do you really want this sort of system:.....
Where people need government approval before saying what they think?
You're twisting what I said and that's not fair. Read again what I wrote in this post and before and you will realize that you have done me wrong here. taking only part of what I said and saying that THIS is what I think is plain...you find the right word for that.

Regards,
Yair

P.S. - Is the speech available now on the internet?
 
Cleon, your words are making it clear that you didn't read what I have written carefully.
Since I don't want to keep on forever talking about this I'll just say that since I said:

then why are you asking me if the right to religion (or lack of it) should be taboo? I've answered that. And why are you asking about Darwinism (the right to research science)? I've answered that also. You're so sure that you are correct that you become blind/deaf to what others write/say.

Not at all, it's just that you cannot back up your own ideas with any logic. That's not my fault.

It all comes down to, who decides what ideas (not actions--ideas) are "taboo" enough to be forbidden? Government? A special Commission of Standards and Virtue? Who?

If advocating theft is on the Great Blacklist Of Things That Shall Not Be Spoken, does that mean it should be forbidden to advocate raising taxes? Socialism? Police seizure of property?

You're twisting what I said and that's not fair. Read again what I wrote in this post and before and you will realize that you have done me wrong here. taking only part of what I said and saying that THIS is what I think is plain...you find the right word for that.

Yes. You said that for people to change what is "taboo," they write their congressman (assuming that's still legal) and ask them to change it. Your exact words were " They can write their congressman about it and this topic can be discussed in the proper house in order to have the possibility to change that taboo (law)."

Which means...You have to ask the government for permission to speak your mind.

You may not like the words I used to characterize your position, but that does not mean the characterization is invalid.
 
In each society it can be different but probably basic taboos will be similar.
Hardly, taboos differ greatly between societies and historical timeframes. That includes societies where sexual relationships with minors were acceptable and the killing of a slave legal.
At the same time people would be lynched for following a different religion.

When I state my mind, I use the word taboo to relate to what action or idea I think should be taboo.
And who are you to decide that? Because I guarantee you there are people in other societies and timeframes who disagree with your opinions. The only way to find the best solution is through reason, and that means discussion, with a democratic vote to decide.

My idea is very solidly based and in fact Israel goes by this thought out idea. I can imagine that most modern countries do. Maybe the U.S. is different I don't know.
If it is really true that Israel goes by this idea, that's a serious mark against the nation.

And you're wrong that the US is different than other nations in this. For example, in the Netherlands we recently had a political party for legalization of sex with minors. Needless to say the disgust they received was inversely proportional to the votes they got, but the party was not forbidden. And we had an easy time spotting the idiots...

(edited to replace "truth" with "best solution")
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by yairhol
taboo for me are things

This is one of the points, what's taboo for you may not be taboo for anyone else. Besides, there is nothing wrong about talking about taboo things. Often time taboos are pretty silly if you talk about them out loud and get other's opinions.
 
Egslim,you're just arguing for the sake of arguing. Your replies show that clearly:
Egslim said:
Hardly, taboos differ greatly between societies and historical timeframes. That includes societies where sexual relationships with minors were acceptable and the killing of a slave legal.
At the same time people would be lynched for following a different religion.
Will murder today in Israel, U.S., France, Italy, Spain, Belgium, Poland, Swiss, Norway, U.K. and the rest of the western world, be considered illegal and the infrigement of basic human rights to live? Of course!
So why are you giving me excuses for your poor position? Did you really think I would give my opinion as I did about every timeframe since the dawn of man or did it occur to you that maybe I'm talking about these days. I don't think I should have added a time frame in my upper posts.

Egslim said:
And who are you to decide that? Because I guarantee you there are people in other societies and timeframes who disagree with your opinions. The only way to find the truth is through reason, and that means discussion, with a democratic vote to decide.
Again, for argument's sake you say unsupported comments. You're talking about 'truth' which I don't know what you mean by that and did I ever say that the taboos should not be discussed about? On the contrary, I said that people can make any changes they see fit to these taboos and I also stated what MY taboos were. You even quoted me saying this so I don't know what you were trying to say here.
Egslim said:
If it is really true that Israel goes by this idea, that's a serious mark against the nation.
We live with it very well thank you. Not having people go on national television calling for others to murder eachother is OK by my book. It is you who should question your morals.

Egslim said:
And we had an easy time spotting the idiots...
Spoken like a true narrow minded person. They're idiots because they don't agree with you. right. Not very well thought out as Cleon would say.
 
Last edited:
SkepticGuy said:
This is one of the points, what's taboo for you may not be taboo for anyone else. Besides, there is nothing wrong about talking about taboo things. Often time taboos are pretty silly if you talk about them out loud and get other's opinions.
Guys, this is getting frustrating for me as you are not relating your opinions to what I have actually said.
Are taboos like murder really 'pretty silly' to you when you talk about them out loud?

Come on, this is getting rediculous.

And I need to keep repeating myself for every poster here as you don't actually refer to what I said. It's like you have something you want prove and will do it even if doesn't relate to what I have said.
 
You mean like these guys?

Columbia University College Republicans
Campus Crusade for Christ @ Columbia
Columbia College Conservative Club
Columbia College Libertarians

Their websites, which are all hosted on Columbia's site, don't seem to indicate any problem speaking their mind.



Well, that's a sensationalist load of crap. Thanks for playing, though.

Tell me how many speakers did they shout down? You don't want to admit the left groups were wrong for doing what they did? You call it sensationalist, oh no it's real. Crap, right back at you. Did you even watch the video?
 
Egslim,you're just arguing for the sake of arguing. Your replies show that clearly:
I'm using ridiculous examples to demonstrate your position is logically indefensible.

The reason I mention older timeframes is because it is very likely in the future actions that are illegal/taboo now will become legalized. It is self-centered to consider taboos as they are now to be the final version, history shows that taboos have been continually evolving.

Will murder today in Israel, U.S., France, Italy, Spain, Belgium, Poland, Swiss, Norway, U.K. and the rest of the western world, be considered illegal and the infrigement of basic human rights to live?
No. There are societies where euthanasia is considered murder, and others where it is legalized.

There is also the far greater non-Western world to take into account.

did I ever say that the taboos should not be discussed about?
Yes, you said they could not be discussed at university or TV.

We live with it very well thank you.
The benefit of freedom of speech is that it allows society to evolve faster, because many more ideas are discussed and some are likely to be improvements that can be implemented. Considering that Israel has serious issues with settlers, Palestinians and a number of neighbouring countries, the country could actually use some brilliant ideas to deal with them.

Spoken like a true narrow minded person. They're idiots because they don't agree with you. right. Not very well thought out as Cleon would say.
I was referring to the pedofiles. And while you are right pedofiles aren't really idiots, I consider the ability to spot pedofiles if anything even more useful.
Do however feel free to call me narrowminded for disagreeing with people who advocate legalizing sex with six-year olds, I will wear that badge with honour.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom