Should Ahmadinejad be allowed to speak at Columbia University?

Let's hope they have some weight. I hope the Bush administration won't do anything until the elections, and maybe there could be a more open dialogue between the Democrats and the people opposing Ahmadinejad in Iran.

I guess that's the only way to have some kind of progress.

ETA: but then again, will the Ayatollahs listen also?
Or build a political consensus with France, Russia and China while continuing strong opposition to the development of nuclear weapons by Iran. The Republican Administration in the USA almost had that vis-a-vis Saddam & Iraq but decided incomprehensibly to throw it all away.

I don't think Western governments ought to ply their trade with opposition parties in Iran. They tried that with the "exiles" in Iraq and nothing came of it. In fact, Western governments have a very poor track record when dealing with opposition parties or "exiles" in hostile nations. They stand much better when they employ political means with one another to dissuade "rogue" nations from suicide.
 
This isn't being widely reported, but after his speech where he was challenged to respond to his views on the holocaust/etc. The chancellor of Colombia responded to the speech:

Mr. Ahmadinejad, what you've just said is one of the most insanely idiotic things I have ever heard. At no point in your rambling, incoherent response were you even close to anything that could be considered a rational thought. Everyone in this room is now dumber for having listened to it. I award you no points, and may God have mercy on your soul.
 
That makes this kind of behavior ok?

Let me get this straight, speech can be suppressed so long as there are examples of tolerated expression? Really?

Any other words you'd like to put in my mouth? :rolleyes:

The Painter made the following claims:

1. He claimed that Conservative or Republican organizations are not allowed to speak at Columbia. Clearly, that is not true, as is demonstrated by the presence of multiple University-supported on-campus Conservative and Republican organizations.

2. He claimed that "You are allowed to speak [at Columbia] only if the left wing wants you too." Which is simply emotional, sensationalist crap. There's no nicer way of putting it.


If you want to talk about that particular incident, fine--off-topic for this thread, but hey, go nuts. His claims about Columbia, however, were simply over-the-top and ridiculous.
 
Guys, this is getting frustrating for me as you are not relating your opinions to what I have actually said.
Are taboos like murder really 'pretty silly' to you when you talk about them out loud?

Come on, this is getting rediculous.

And I need to keep repeating myself for every poster here as you don't actually refer to what I said. It's like you have something you want prove and will do it even if doesn't relate to what I have said.

Yairhol, in the nicest possible way, we do refer to what you say. It's just very difficult how you can defend not allowing people to discuss "taboos" in public without governmental approval. I don't think you understand the basic concept of freedom of speech and what it means to a free and open democracy.

An example of a "silly taboo" would be with the Chinese New Year and the fact that some Chinese believe everyone should refrain from using bad or foul language or "unlucky words". Negative terms and the chinese word for "four", which sounds like the word for death, are also considered taboo. So should we not discuss them?
 
2. He claimed that "You are allowed to speak [at Columbia] only if the left wing wants you too." Which is simply emotional, sensationalist crap. There's no nicer way of putting it.
It's hyperbolic but not without any merit. My understanding is that this behavior is common. Conservatives are often not allowed to speak at these types of events. So what if there is a presence on campus? So what if there are websites? Some people are kept from speaking in open forums.

In the past others have argued the right of the protesters to speak out is equal to the speakers.

I don't know. It seem like what is being said is that might makes right. If you have a majority that can shout you done then the shouts take precedent.

Perhaps if people wanted to shout down Ahmadinejad that should have been ok.

If you want to talk about that particular incident, fine--off-topic for this thread, but hey, go nuts.
I don't think it's off topic. Who should have a right to speak at Columbia?
 
Egslim said:
The benefit of freedom of speech is that it allows society to evolve faster, because many more ideas are discussed and some are likely to be improvements that can be implemented.
Exactly what I have said in my last posts. Thank you for clearing that up and for agreeing with me.

Egslim said:
The benefit of freedom of speech is that it allows society to evolve faster, because many more ideas are discussed and some are likely to be improvements that can be implemented. Considering that Israel has serious issues with settlers, Palestinians and a number of neighbouring countries, the country could actually use some brilliant ideas to deal with them.
Are you saying that you have absolute freedom of speech in the U.S.?
 
Good morning RandFan.

It's hyperbolic but not without any merit. My understanding is that this behavior is common. Conservatives are often not allowed to speak at these types of events.

Could I ask on what you base this understanding? And on what grounds you claim that conservative speakers are "often" not allowed to speak at Columbia events?

So what if there is a presence on campus? So what if there are websites? Some people are kept from speaking in open forums.

Which people? I've only been here for a little over two years, so I may not be familiar with any other instances of this kind of thing happening, and would be genuinely interested to learn of any specific instances you could bring to my attention. I do know that the Columbia Conservatives regularly hold their meetings, invite speakers and - as far as I know - suffer no disruption. Hell, they even invited John Ashcroft to speak on campus a couple of years ago, and while he was an extremely unpopular visitor, nobody prevented him from speaking.

Perhaps I should provide a little extra detail on the Gilchrist business. The people who stormed the stage were not some amorphous group of "left-wingers", but a specific group, the Chicano club, who obviously had their own reasons for finding what Gilchrist had to say objectionable, and who had been directly and openly goaded by Glichrist in his talk, not, of course, that this excuses their actions. The students involved were disciplined by the University, President Bollinger sent out a series of e-mails to the whole University in which he was quite emphatic that this kind of behaviour was not acceptable and would not be tolerated, and opinion among the student body from what I can gather was that the students in question were clearly in the wrong, for however much you may disagree with what someone has to say, you do not stop him or her from saying it.

If your general point is to argue that Columbia as a whole is a left-leaning institution, then I won't argue with you on that one. However, to claim that conservative speakers are frequently prevented from appearing at Columbia is going to require a bit more evidence.
 
But doesn't democracy have limits to freedom of speech? Should a pro natzi person (maybe not Ahmadinijad...but I wouldn't be surprised if he is) be given a stage? Should a child molester be given a stage?

Well Nazi have been given stages and defended by jewish lawyers. The child molester well who owns the stage? Michael Jackson seems to have gotten stages after most people seemed to think he was a child molester.(not so much recently)
Should a person supporting world terror be given a stage in the country that he has so many times declared he wants to see destroyed?

This would sort of depend on the exact things being said.
 
Ultimately, I do not have any control over who speaks at Colombia. What I did find interesting is they canceled a speaking visit by the leader of the Minutemen. When they asked the minutemen guy about them inviting the holocaust denier to speak, he said that the speech should go on. Some right wingers are clamoring that since the minuteman wasn't allowed to speak, neither should the holocaust denier.

As usual, the partisan pile-on will go on.

So the leader of the minute men is a world leader now?

Here I thought he was barely a blip on domestic politics.
 
I'm not sure exactly what you're saying here... who asked the Minutemen guy about the holocaust denier, and why? It sounds like the set-up for a bad joke: "A Minuteman, a Holocaust denier, and a 9-11 CT nut walk into a bar..."

But how do you make a joke with only one person walking into a bar?
 
I beg to differ.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taboo
"A taboo is a strong social ban against words, objects, actions, discussions, or people that are considered undesirable or offensive by a group, culture, or society."
If we take the definition which regards to society then what I have said firmly stands its ground.
Minority opinions are always welcomed and not all minority opinions are taboo (in fact, most of them are not) as long as they are not pro violence, hatred or the likes towards others. (of course I'm not rewriting the laws here so what I'm saying is general and must be regarded as such)
On a side note, I don't understand how that men-boy association is allowed to advertize itself if underage sex is illegal (is it not illegal?).

So you also think that all those people trying to get marijuana legalized should also not be allowed to speak as it is also illegal?
 
And who decides if what is illegal is wrong, dumb or no longer valid? You? me?
If I think making murder illegal is dumb should I actively act or advertize it publicly?

I like it, so you agree that when micegination was illegal confronting it should have been illegal also?

You have just ruled the civil rights movement illegal.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom