Should Ahmadinejad be allowed to speak at Columbia University?

I'm sorry, Gurdur, but the only way I could be convinced such a person exists is by a link to a youtube video that is no less than one hour in length.

+ |
Inasmuch.
:confused:
===
you are wrong and my mad YouTube skillz prove it.
 
But it didn't keep you from making statement about what he said about Israel, did it?


I doubt that he said that he wants to use nuclear weapons to
wipe out Israel - did he? :confused:

You may remember that this is what the fuss is about.

And the whole world knows what bunch of losers the Witch-hunters
were in case of Iraq, don't we? :boggled:

And what's the threat to America? :rolleyes:
 
I doubt that he said that he wants to use nuclear weapons to
wipe out Israel - did he?
You claimed that he said that his solution to the Palestinian situation is that Israel withdraw from Palestine.

In fact, you have no idea what he said the solution to the Palestinian situation is, do you? You just assumed.
 
Yes, I missed most of the speech and was able to catch the
last questions in the Q&A round. But the responses in here are
rather about "WTF?!?? N-Word are allowed to bear arms, too?"

Witchhunting.


I love this quote, mostly because I have absolutely no clue what it means.


So? He said he's not interested in the bomb, they are allowing
the UN to inspect the site, they have no WMD program and there
is no evidence for such.


..yet.


Do you honestly believe what Ahmadinejad is saying? You don't believe anything Bush says, do you? Why should you believe Ahmadinejad which is an even bigger nut? Is it because he's on the same side as you in the battle against America? Did you also believe it when Ahmadinejad stated that homosexuality does not exist in Iran?
 
Overall, letting him speak was a good idea, people will see him for what he really is, in denial about pretty much everything.
 
I love this quote, mostly because I have absolutely no clue what it means.

..yet.

Do you honestly believe what Ahmadinejad is saying? You don't believe anything Bush says, do you? Why should you believe Ahmadinejad which is an even bigger nut? Is it because he's on the same side as you in the battle against America?


No, I don't believe more in Ahmadinejad's words than I do believe
in Bush honesty. But unless there is evidence for a nuclear threat
for the US or Israel, I don't accept doing the same failure as we,
the west did in Iraq.

Fear- and War-mongering is no solution. And yes, I believe that
everyone should have the same rights - which means: If the US
and America are not willing to get rid of their nuclear stock, they
surely are not in the position to rant about others trying to get
a nuclear reactor.

Or to sum it up:

1110746f6db53e8e86.jpg
 
I doubt that he said that he wants to use nuclear weapons to
wipe out Israel - did he? :confused:

You may remember that this is what the fuss is about.

And the whole world knows what bunch of losers the Witch-hunters
were in case of Iraq, don't we? :boggled:

And what's the threat to America? :rolleyes:


This overlaps with the posts in this thread, if you'd like to comment there.
 
Wait until he hits you with YouTube vids, photoshopped pix and inasmuches and then see how you feel about that.

Honestly, it's not right to compare Oliver to Ahmadinejad. Oliver is a good bloke, he's just annoying.
 
I found this interesting article, where it is suggested that the US might be putting too much emphasis on this man. http://www.nytimes.com/2007/09/24/world/middleeast/24iran.html?_r=1&oref=slogin

Maybe he is just a tease, a political troll, a loud mouth who likes to provoque, with very little support from back home. If he is this inconsequential, then this should be treated as an inconsequential visit. US officials should downplay his importance by ignoring his rhetoric, so that heads cool down and real diplomacy can have a chance.
I wouldn't call Ahmadinejad inconsequential. But amateur political observers have to remember that Iran is no more embodied in this single figure than Iraq was in Saddam.

Here's a pretty decent look at the military problems now faced by Iran: http://www.carlisle.army.mil/usawc/Parameters/04autumn/russell.htm. Russia's attitude toward a potential military rival is discussed there too. Here's a somewhat dated perspective on the internal political challenges in Iran: http://www.netnative.com/news/01/may/1037.html. And Ahmedinejad is an acknowledged "populist" who scorns political parties: http://www.webneveshteha.com/en/weblog/?id=2146308987. In other words, he's made a few enemies in his own country.

All that said, and I've made it clear on this sub-forum that I feel that Iran is virtually isolated and without many good options if push came to shove, their president ought to be accorded the same courtesy that any dignitary is due upon their arrival to the US or any other civilised nation.
 
This overlaps with the posts in this thread, if you'd like to comment there.


I will. But my point is the same. Witch-hunting already brought
the US into a quagmire. I can't believe that Americans will be
so dumb again - on the other Hand they elected Bush twice.

Anyway: There is no evidence for Nuclear Weapons and NO, I
don't accept Trutherlogic here:

"WTC7 = Controlled demolition = planned = Inside Job."

Unfortunately: Some in here behave exactly this way without
the evidence supporting their view. Woo, indeed.
 
Anyway: There is no evidence for Nuclear Weapons


... yet.


Again with the Oliver logic where someone who wants to kill you isn't a threat to you until after he's killed you.

Anyway, do go to the other thread.
 
In other words, he's made a few enemies in his own country.

Let's hope they have some weight. I hope the Bush administration won't do anything until the elections, and maybe there could be a more open dialogue between the Democrats and the people opposing Ahmadinejad in Iran.

I guess that's the only way to have some kind of progress.

ETA: but then again, will the Ayatollahs listen also?
 
Last edited:
You just broke my irony meter.

*sigh*

That's the third one gone this month.

I need to find a more durable brand.

DR


Well, usually RandFan is an competitive discussion partner, but he
lost it within the "Bush-Hitler" thread. But I love you nevertheless
for your sarcastic sense of humor. :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom