Should Ahmadinejad be allowed to speak at Columbia University?

Exactly what I have said in my last posts. Thank you for clearing that up and for agreeing with me.

How is what he wrote agreeing with what you wrote here?

Originally Posted by yairhol
In my opinion, what is considered taboo in society should not be legally advertized or given freedom of speech.



Are you saying that you have absolute freedom of speech in the U.S.?

As close as we and the ACLU can make it.
 
Good morning RandFan.

Could I ask on what you base this understanding? And on what grounds you claim that conservative speakers are "often" not allowed to speak at Columbia events?

Which people? I've only been here for a little over two years, so I may not be familiar with any other instances of this kind of thing happening, and would be genuinely interested to learn of any specific instances you could bring to my attention. I do know that the Columbia Conservatives regularly hold their meetings, invite speakers and - as far as I know - suffer no disruption. Hell, they even invited John Ashcroft to speak on campus a couple of years ago, and while he was an extremely unpopular visitor, nobody prevented him from speaking.

Perhaps I should provide a little extra detail on the Gilchrist business. The people who stormed the stage were not some amorphous group of "left-wingers", but a specific group, the Chicano club, who obviously had their own reasons for finding what Gilchrist had to say objectionable, and who had been directly and openly goaded by Glichrist in his talk, not, of course, that this excuses their actions. The students involved were disciplined by the University, President Bollinger sent out a series of e-mails to the whole University in which he was quite emphatic that this kind of behaviour was not acceptable and would not be tolerated, and opinion among the student body from what I can gather was that the students in question were clearly in the wrong, for however much you may disagree with what someone has to say, you do not stop him or her from saying it.

If your general point is to argue that Columbia as a whole is a left-leaning institution, then I won't argue with you on that one. However, to claim that conservative speakers are frequently prevented from appearing at Columbia is going to require a bit more evidence.
Fair enough. I'm more than happy to give your word credence over rumor that I've heard.
 
Originally Posted by Egslim
The benefit of freedom of speech is that it allows society to evolve faster, because many more ideas are discussed and some are likely to be improvements that can be implemented.

Skeptic Guy said:
How is what he wrote agreeing with what you wrote here?

yairhol said:
The group meetings can be in order to discuss changes that this group might want to make to what is considered today a taboo. They can write their congressman about it and this topic can be discussed in the proper house in order to have the possibility to change that taboo (law).


Originally Posted by yairhol
Are you saying that you have absolute freedom of speech in the U.S.?

Skeptic Guy said:
As close as we and the ACLU can make it.
Exactly to my point so you agree with me as well. I'm glad. I only added that, taboo subjects, which I had described in detail before, will not be given a stage publicly. I'll give you an example of how this is the same in the U.S. One day you wake up and decide that murder should be legalized (what a nice person you are :p). And having written what you have in this forum you're sure that you have freedom of speech as you wish and you do not agree with Yair (yairhol) on what he had said (that some subjects will not be freely talked about in public). So you go to the nearest hill you find and shout to the people underneath: "I think you should murder the president of the united states. I don't like his diplomatic blah blah and I call on each and every one of you to find the best way you can to murder him today."
Can you guess how many second will pass until the FBI arrests you? hint: It's not that big of a number.
So what do you know. You do have some subjects which are taboo to speak freely in public. Wait, hold the press, isn't that exactly what Yair (yairhol) has said some many posts ago?
And why should we not talk about it freely? Because we're dealing with humans. There will always be those who will listen to what they are told if the person speaking is charismatic enough. Germans in the 1930's for example...

I hope you can now agree with me more.
 
Last edited:
Yairhol, since Ahmadi... has been allowed to speak and spoke, do you think it was a bad idea? He avoided almost every question and repeated the same old stuff, and even made the West laugh out loud with his homosexuality remark.

Can you say it wasn't so bad after all?
 
One day you wake up and decide that murder should be legalized (what a nice person you are :p). And having written what you have in this forum you're sure that you have freedom of speech as you wish and you do not agree with Yair (yairhol) on what he had said (that some subjects will not be freely talked about in public). So you go to the nearest hill you find and shout to the people underneath: "I think you should murder the president of the united states. I don't like his diplomatic blah blah and I call on each and every one of you to find the best way you can to murder him today."
This hypothetical is confusing. The speech involved is not advocating for the legalization of murder, but advocating the commission of a specific murder while it is illegal.

What's your point, that the criminalization of soliciting a crime is an infringement of free speech?


So what do you know. You do have some subjects which are taboo to speak freely in public.
Speaking about a subject is not the same as advocacy of a specific crime.

There are entire publications dedicated to the decriminalization of drugs. Currently all the activity discussed in those magazines are illegal. And yet, we don't ban its publication.

So we are free to discuss the topic. If you want to legalize murder, you are welcome to discuss that topic to your heart's content. Nobody in America will arrest you for it.

What you can't do is encourage someone to commit a crime. That's not free speech. The sooner you understand that, the sooner your arguments will begin to make sense.

I hope you can now agree with me more.
I actually agree with you less now than I did before.
 
Pardalis said:
Yairhol, since Ahmadi... has been allowed to speak and spoke, do you think it was a bad idea? He avoided almost every question and repeated the same old stuff, and even made the West laugh out loud with his homosexuality remark.

Can you say it wasn't so bad after all?
Hi Pardalis,
The contents of his speech and the answers he gave to the questions were known beforehand. It was not hard to guess them since he gave the same speech 2 days before to cbs: http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2007/09/21/60minutes/main3286706_page5.shtml
you can find here the same contents of his speech.
I was not against the contents of his speech because but because I think it is a disgrace to let a person calling for the destruction of the U.S. and parts of the western world a stage to speak while we know in advance that most of what he will be saying will be lies lies and more lies. It was obvious he will not say "I hate the U.S. and Israel and want them both destroyed". He will have to lie about that and give excuses in order to divert the question. But the whole world knows what's really on his mind since he has been saying it for years and years. And the whole world knows how women are mistreated (understatement) in Iran but he lied about it so bluntly by saying they are more appreciated than me. And on and on he lied and lied. And be sure that in his next speech in Iran he will call again for the destruction of the cancer of this world which are the United States and Israel. That is why I was against the speech.

I'm glad that he got booed at times but sad that he also got cheered at times.
 
marksman said:
This hypothetical is confusing. The speech involved is not advocating for the legalization of murder, but advocating the commission of a specific murder while it is illegal.

What's your point, that the criminalization of soliciting a crime is an infringement of free speech?
I accept your comment.
Please add to the story above that the person was also yelling "I call for the murder of our president to be legal if we don't like his ways" (or something like that). but my main point still remains the same.

marksman said:
There are entire publications dedicated to the decriminalization of drugs. Currently all the activity discussed in those magazines are illegal. And yet, we don't ban its publication.
You have clearly not read what I had written some many posts ago and on which I based my story on.
It's somewhere on page 3 of this thread I think...maybe page 2...I don't remember sorry.

marksman said:
I actually agree with you less now than I did before.
That's not a smart thing to say when clearly you have not read the relevant parts of what I had written before (hint: many posts ago).
 
Please add to the story above that the person was also yelling "I call for the murder of our president to be legal if we don't like his ways" (or something like that). but my main point still remains the same.
No, it isn't, because the sentence you just stated, while grammatically tortured, is not prohibited by the First Amendment. And since you were trying to give an example of speech not protected in America, your hypothetical no longer applies.

Heck, it's not far from things actually written by Thomas Paine and Thomas Jefferson.

You have clearly not read what I had written some many posts ago
Yairhol, you have to stop accusing people of misreading you merely because we point out that you are being inconsistent.

I've been following this whole sorry discussion. It originally seemed to me that you were inartfully trying to distinguish between speech that a culture deems impolite (i.e., "taboo") and speech that a government can illegalize (i.e., censorship). But now it appears you are advocating that a society is justified in banning speech on taboo subjects.

I cannot agree with that argument. There should be no subject that cannot be discussed. Only behavior should be criminalized.
 
marksman said:
I cannot agree with that argument. There should be no subject that cannot be discussed. Only behavior should be criminalized.
Since you said you have read throughout this sorry discussion (then why are you reading it?) I will only say that your reading comprehension is lacking since I said that
The group meetings can be in order to discuss changes that this group might want to make to what is considered today a taboo. They can write their congressman about it and this topic can be discussed in the proper house in order to have the possibility to change that taboo (law).
Does the sentence above have "discuss", "group meetings in order to discuss", "changes", "topic can be discussed", "possibility to chage that taboo (law)" in it?
I'm sorry but you have just made your whole last post a joke.
As I have stated (90 times and counting) I don't understand what you guys are arguing with me for since what I said is common througout maybe all of the modern western world. Read the story above. now read it again. Again....good...and again. Maybe now you understand it. Now read my posts from way back (but not too back) where I stated how I think freedom of speech should be and see that we agree. Unless of course you don't agree which is also fine with me since this is a discussion and everyone is entitled to his/her own opinions.
I love it how people think they are so smart and mock others while they are so basically full of it with no basis in reality for what they think they are. Meeting different people is great.
 
Last edited:
Since you said you have read throughout this sorry discussion (then why are you reading it?) I will only say that your reading comprehension is lacking since I said that
Now, maybe this is a language problem,but when you wrote there can be "group meetings to discuss" that sounds like some government sponsored discussiopn about "taboo" subjects, indicating that outside the "group meetings" such discussion could be prohibited. If that's not what you meant then you have nobody to blame for the confusion but yourself.

And that's the entirety of our objections to what you write. Your language is overly broad and bombastic. When pushed on it you claim the words you write were intended to be narrow.

As I have stated (90 times and counting) I don't understand what you guys are arguing with me for since what I said is common througout maybe all of the modern western world.
Maybe you intend to describe that which is common in the Western world. But what you actually write is broad and does not comport. No matter how often it is read.

I love it how people think they are so smart and mock others
At no time have I mocked you. I have tried to write in a respectful and civil manner. Perhaps in the future, you should lay off the personal attacks.
 
Thanks to marksman I'm improving my english:
Words in your posts that I did not know:
inartfully - lacking art. (in-art.....makes sense)
comport - to behave in a certain manner.
advocacy - defense, support.

No hard feelings man.
 
Originally Posted by Egslim
The benefit of freedom of speech is that it allows society to evolve faster, because many more ideas are discussed and some are likely to be improvements that can be implemented.






Originally Posted by yairhol [URL]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/helloworld2/buttons/viewpost.gif[/URL]
Are you saying that you have absolute freedom of speech in the U.S.?


Exactly to my point so you agree with me as well. I'm glad. I only added that, taboo subjects, which I had described in detail before, will not be given a stage publicly. I'll give you an example of how this is the same in the U.S. One day you wake up and decide that murder should be legalized (what a nice person you are :p). And having written what you have in this forum you're sure that you have freedom of speech as you wish and you do not agree with Yair (yairhol) on what he had said (that some subjects will not be freely talked about in public). So you go to the nearest hill you find and shout to the people underneath: "I think you should murder the president of the united states. I don't like his diplomatic blah blah and I call on each and every one of you to find the best way you can to murder him today."
Can you guess how many second will pass until the FBI arrests you? hint: It's not that big of a number.
So what do you know. You do have some subjects which are taboo to speak freely in public. Wait, hold the press, isn't that exactly what Yair (yairhol) has said some many posts ago?
And why should we not talk about it freely? Because we're dealing with humans. There will always be those who will listen to what they are told if the person speaking is charismatic enough. Germans in the 1930's for example...

I hope you can now agree with me more.

I think I followed the quotes you were trying to use to justify your statement that Egslim was agreeing with you. I believe you are suggesting that we set-up some sort of group to review the petitions of claimants for free speech and liase with our government for approval. Sort of like the old Soviet Union's Politburo, but they never seemed to be able to get the "free speech" concept down. That's a very cumbersome description, but it could be shortened to "censorship by committee", which is not the equivelant of free speech.

Since you said you have read throughout this sorry discussion (then why are you reading it?) I will only say that your reading comprehension is lacking since I said that
Does the sentence above have "discuss", "group meetings in order to discuss", "changes", "topic can be discussed", "possibility to chage that taboo (law)" in it?
I'm sorry but you have just made your whole last post a joke.
As I have stated (90 times and counting) I don't understand what you guys are arguing with me for since what I said is common througout maybe all of the modern western world. Read the story above. now read it again. Again....good...and again. Maybe now you understand it. Now read my posts from way back (but not too back) where I stated how I think freedom of speech should be and see that we agree. Unless of course you don't agree which is also fine with me since this is a discussion and everyone is entitled to his/her own opinions.
I love it how people think they are so smart and mock others while they are so basically full of it with no basis in reality for what they think they are. Meeting different people is great.

Bolding mine. Pot...meet kettle.

Yair, no one, no one, no one...no one...is agreeing with you and the only person mocking others seems to be yourself. I am sorry that you don't understand the difference in what you are describing and true free speech, but there is a big difference.

You say that everyone is entitled to his/her own opinion, but that's not true. As a favorite writer of mine, Harlan Ellison, said (and until recently the quote was in my sig), and I paraphrase: "You are not entitled to your opinion, that's horse pucky, you are entitled to your informed opinion. Without facts and evidence, the opinion is meaningless". I need to put that back in...it's important.
 
Last edited:
Skeptic Guy said:
"You are not entitled to your opinion, that's horse pucky, you are entitled to your informed opinion. Without facts and evidence, the opinion is meaningless".
That's a strange and untrue quote. Let's say you bring a flower to your wife. You bring a blue flower just because you like the color blue. She may like red. Your opinion is that blue is better looking than red. There is no reason or pages and pages of explanations for this. You just like blue better than red.
Did I misunderstand the quote?
 
I think I followed the quotes you were trying to use to justify your statement that Egslim was agreeing with you. I believe you are suggesting that we set-up some sort of group to reviews the petitions of claimants for free speech and liase with our government for approval. Sort of like the old Soviet Union's Politburo, but they never seemed to be able to get the "free speech" concept down. That's a very cumbersome description, but it could be shortened to "censorship by committee", which is not the equivelant of free speech.
I have no idea what you're talking about but that's ok. The OP does not concern with what I, you or anyone else think the law should be about free speech. This whole freedom of speech started with me saying something very innocent which later I found myself needing to defend. That was not my intention in replying to this thread. My view of free speech remains as I had described it. If you don't agree with me that's fine. No need to make a whole big deal of it. So what if it is the most common and agreed upon in most modern western countries. Maybe in the U.S. it's different (I doubt it but I may be wrong).
I can't make myself anymore clearer than that.
But let it go, we don't have to agree.

Regards,
Yair
 
Skeptic Guy, Can you find the flaw in what I said as compared to the quote you gave?
some opinions can be personal and do not need to be informed.
Since your quote is so general, it should apply to all opinions of every kind. Unless you want to change the quote which I will allow you to do. :rolleyes:
 
I have no idea what you're talking about but that's ok. The OP does not concern with what I, you or anyone else think the law should be about free speech. This whole freedom of speech started with me saying something very innocent which later I found myself needing to defend. That was not my intention in replying to this thread. My view of free speech remains as I had described it. If you don't agree with me that's fine. No need to make a whole big deal of it. So what if it is the most common and agreed upon in most modern western countries. Maybe in the U.S. it's different (I doubt it but I may be wrong).
I can't make myself anymore clearer than that.
But let it go, we don't have to agree.

Regards,
Yair

But the bolded statement is incorrect. The US is not practicing "freedom of speech" as you describe it and for the life of me I can't think of a democracy that is. Germany is the closest with their insistance, if I recall correctly, that no one can discuss Nazism.
 
No hard feelings man.
Not a problem, yairhol. I suspected (or rather, hoped) that our disagreement was because of translation issues.

Skeptic Guy, I don't think yairhol is disagreeing. I think this is a simple language issue. I suggest we all just let this thread die now.
 
Skeptic Guy, Can you find the flaw in what I said as compared to the quote you gave?
some opinions can be personal and do not need to be informed.
Since your quote is so general, it should apply to all opinions of every kind. Unless you want to change the quote which I will allow you to do. :rolleyes:

Ok, let me take a stab at it, but I don't want to derail the discussion...the example you gave was not exactly what we were talking about, but let's run with it. If I say I, personally, like blue better than red, that's ok. That means that there is something in the chemical make-up of my brain that "prefers" blue over red. No problem. The problem with the opinion would start if, as you suggest in your example, that I state that blue is a better color than red, full stop. That's irrational and not based on fact. But as long as I keep it as a personal preference...that's cool.

But let's say that I said that homosexuality is wrong and that anyone that practices it is moraly reprehensible and mentally deficient. That is not based on any facts and is wrong. Not illegal to say, just wrong. Not based on fact. Kaka...etc.

And while I think the thread should die, I really think Yairhol is disagreeing, which is ok, that's what the forum is for.
 
Did I misunderstand the quote?

Yes. Very much.

You will never be called upon to vote for your favorite color. Your personal preferences and you opinion about your personal preferences are irrelevant.

Your opinions about free speech and any other topics of relevance are of no value unless formed after consideration of the facts.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom