Sandy Hook parents sue Alex Jones for defamation

We do know that Sandy Hook happened
We do know that Alex Jones has claimed it was staged and has accused the parents of being actors
We do know that some of the parents have been threatened
As to the last, there's even a woman behind bars for issuing death threats.

How far is Alex Jones' divorce case? Have the assets already been divided? I hope so, otherwise he'll only suffer half the damage.
 
You know, it's ironic that people get suspended or kicked off the site for some pretty minor offenses, but a guy who constanly hijacks and disrupts threads get away scot free.
 
You know, it's ironic that people get suspended or kicked off the site for some pretty minor offenses, but a guy who constanly hijacks and disrupts threads get away scot free.

I expressed my opinion of what I would hope to see happen at a trial for defamation here. That is the topic here.
 
I don't understand how the first article explicitly says it hurt reputation, and brought up missing work. Is there only work time lost by reputation or emotional distress? If you skipped work because of distress, but no one at work cared because it didn't affect your reputation, is that harm for purposes of defamation?

If the defamation leads to people harassing you, leaving death threats, and constantly barraging you with disgusting attacks the stress may be enough to cause you to miss work or have other health issues. I understand you personally might be too unempathetic to understand that, but the courts may decide otherwise.
 
If the defamation leads to people harassing you, leaving death threats, and constantly barraging you with disgusting attacks the stress may be enough to cause you to miss work or have other health issues. I understand you personally might be too unempathetic to understand that, but the courts may decide otherwise.
It isn't a matter of understanding. The article did not state what you just wrote.

And is that defamation or incitement? The guy assaulted at the Trump rally sued for incitement, but I don't know if that was generally speaking, or a specific term in civil suits.
 
If the defamation leads to people harassing you, leaving death threats, and constantly barraging you with disgusting attacks the stress may be enough to cause you to miss work or have other health issues. I understand you personally might be too unempathetic to understand that, but the courts may decide otherwise.
The major legal hurdle will be, IMHO, to prove the causality of that chain. i.e., that the death threats and barraging was caused by Alex Jones' utterances.
 
The major legal hurdle will be, IMHO, to prove the causality of that chain. i.e., that the death threats and barraging was caused by Alex Jones' utterances.

But do they even need to bother with defamation at that point or is that incitement?
 
They have a case. The first part of a defamation case is providing documentation of Jones making the statement(s), and that won't be a problem. The trick is documenting the damage to the victims, which will mostly be emotional pain. Can they show they've lost work time? Have they been forced into extended therapy due to the false statements? Can they show permanent psychological damage?

I'm betting in this case - yes.

https://injury.findlaw.com/torts-and-personal-injuries/defamation-law-the-basics.html

http://www.alllaw.com/articles/nolo/civil-litigation/evidence-defamation-lawsuit.html

If it were a jury trial I would happily vote for gigantic loss of fundage and prison time for any ******* conservative slime shown to give out lies and/or misleading info about any real people.
 
In a civil suit like this one, almost none.In the US, people do not go to jail when they lose a civil case.
Only way this happens is if Jones does something really stupid during the trial, and gets tossed in the slammer for "contempt of court" or fails to obey a court order. . And even that technically is a different offense then his defamaing the Sandy Hook victims.

Hope he does!!!!:D
 
If it were a jury trial I would happily vote for gigantic loss of fundage and prison time for any ******* conservative slime shown to give out lies and/or misleading info about any real people.

I'd love to see Jones broke and out of his line of work.

The First Amendment make's Info Wars possible. All anyone has to do is preface any wacko charge with the word "Allegedly", and they're free to say whatever they wish. This comes from case law where accusations were made on air and in print that cost someone a lot of money. That's why you'll hear or read the words in cases where guilt is obvious because it avoids legal problems down the road.

The other escape words are "Hypothetically, and "In my opinion".

The flip-side is that there are legitimate reasons to allow this. Watergate is an example of the legitimate use of "Allegedly" to advance investigating journalism
 
Second ETA: I'm bad at Bayesian inference. Wouldn't a finding for Jones alter our probability that he didn't defame?
It would, but quite possibly not significantly. For example, if we are 99% sure he defamed, an acquittal might alter that to 97%.
 
How? Wanting a negative test result on a medical screening is not a judgement that I don't have the disease.
Actually, it is a judgement that you don't have the desease. For if you left open the possibility, and you have the desease, then you would welcome a positive result, for it would set you on course toward proper treatment, which a false negative would not.
If already have enough information to assume you have the desease, such that a negative test result would more likely be a false negative, you will want a positive result.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom