Sandy Hook parents sue Alex Jones for defamation

It should be obvious. They've been accused of conspiracy to pervert the course of justice.

Dave

It isn't obvious. I have no idea the status of their standing in their community. The community may have rallied around them because of jones's garbage statements.
 
you keep dancing around what has been asked. Are you saying that if they were defamed, that the results of a trial indicating so would not be a best predictor?
you only use the phrase - The results of a trial is probably our best predictor if defamation occurred - only when describing the win you want. not the loss that is also possible.

Analogy

I go in for a medical test. I want the results to be accurate. I hope they are negative.

No one thinks I want the results to be negative regardless if I have an illness or not. I'm also not taking the test necessarily with the presumption that i don't have the illness.
 
Last edited:
Analogy

I go in for a medical test. I want the results to be accurate. I hope they are negative.

No one thinks I want the results to be negative regardless if I have an illness or not. I'm also not taking the test necessarily with the presumption that i don't have the illness.


but we are not talking about you and a mythical medical test.
 
BTC makes a fundamental mistake: he pretends that a court's decision can alter historical facts.
What Jones is accuser of happened in the past, and no verdict will ever change that. The pain and damage inflicted on the victins (if any) was inflicted in the past, and no verdict can ever uninflict it.

The only thing that can change is people's OPINION about whether or not the deed crosses the applicable legal thresholds. Indeed, these thresholds may vary in the future (some things that used to be crimes now are considered rights).

We know at least some of the historical facts. Enough to form a judgement, perhaps assess probabilities. No court decision is necessary.

Now Bob prefers a not-guilty finding, believing that such a finding would lower the probability that Jones is criminally or civilly liable below a threshold of significance, but that is an unsure bet, and betrays a lack of understanding of how Bayesian inference works. If Jones us, in fact, guilty then a not-guilty verdict is most definitely not preferable, because it cannot possibly change the historical fact - it would add a miscarriage of justice on top of the damages already incurred.

Not using information already recorded in history to form judgement is the opposite of skeptical and enlightened. It's plain dumb.
 
BTC makes a fundamental mistake: he pretends that a court's decision can alter historical facts.
What Jones is accuser of happened in the past, and no verdict will ever change that. The pain and damage inflicted on the victins (if any) was inflicted in the past, and no verdict can ever uninflict it.

The only thing that can change is people's OPINION about whether or not the deed crosses the applicable legal thresholds. Indeed, these thresholds may vary in the future (some things that used to be crimes now are considered rights).

We know at least some of the historical facts. Enough to form a judgement, perhaps assess probabilities. No court decision is necessary.

Now Bob prefers a not-guilty finding, believing that such a finding would lower the probability that Jones is criminally or civilly liable below a threshold of significance, but that is an unsure bet, and betrays a lack of understanding of how Bayesian inference works. If Jones us, in fact, guilty then a not-guilty verdict is most definitely not preferable, because it cannot possibly change the historical fact - it would add a miscarriage of justice on top of the damages already incurred.

Not using information already recorded in history to form judgement is the opposite of skeptical and enlightened. It's plain dumb.

See post #47
 
We know at least some of the historical facts. Enough to form a judgement, perhaps assess probabilities. No court decision is necessary.

I disagree that it is enough to form a judgement.

ETA: just like the medical test, while I have some evidence that the test will come back positive, I hope it is negative.
 
Last edited:
Are you a Sandy Hook truther or something? You're literally defending Alex Jones. One of the biggest scam artists and ******** that's walking on this planet in the past 20 years.

I'm the opposite. It is probably more than likely he committed defamation.
 
I disagree that it is enough to form a judgement.

ETA: just like the medical test, while I have some evidence that the test will come back positive, I hope it is negative.

You conveniently ignore almost the entirety of my post, to form a reply that is stupid and most obviously FALSE on its face. Of course any non-zero amount of information, whether reliable or not, is enough to form a judgement.
 
I disagree that it is enough to form a judgement.

ETA: just like the medical test, while I have some evidence that the test will come back positive, I hope it is negative.

Second ETA: I'm bad at Bayesian inference. Wouldn't a finding for Jones alter our probability that he didn't defame?
 
You conveniently ignore almost the entirety of my post, to form a reply that is stupid and most obviously FALSE on its face. Of course any non-zero amount of information, whether reliable or not, is enough to form a judgement.

Let me clarify. I don't think we should be going around forming and sharing pointless judgements with little information.
 
Last edited:
Arguments by analogy are as worthless as judgements without context.

Dave

Then remove the analogy. Hoping a finding that no one was defamed in a process available to determine if someone was defamed is not a judgement that a person wasn't defamed. It is independent of any judgement if a person was defamed or not.
 
Last edited:
This is an odd place for this thread to be located. It's not a conspiracy that the parents are suing Alex Jones.
 
How? Wanting a negative test result on a medical screening is not a judgement that I don't have the disease.

Your analogy doesn't really work. A negative medical test is not proof that you don't have a disease. False negatives occur, just like bad judgements at trial. Also, pretty much everyone wants to not have a disease, which doesn't apply to defamation trials. Not everyone wants the defendant to win.
 
Your analogy doesn't really work. A negative medical test is not proof that you don't have a disease. False negatives occur, just like bad judgements at trial. Also, pretty much everyone wants to not have a disease, which doesn't apply to defamation trials. Not everyone wants the defendant to win.

I also said in a similar post we want tests to be accurate. I want the right verdict. I hope the right verdict is a judgement for Jones because I hope people do not suffer damages.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom