Sandy Hook parents sue Alex Jones for defamation

I also said in a similar post we want tests to be accurate. I want the right verdict. I hope the right verdict is a judgement for Jones because I hope people do not suffer damages.

I think we all do, just like we all hope for a negative medical test. But your analogy then falls apart. We don't all agree what the correct verdict is. I hope he is found guilt of defamation, because I believe he has defamed people who have suffered damages from his defmation.

Also, I'm going to go investigate if Vegas is taking bets on this case. Jones is going to lose, I'd bet money on it given decent odds. ETA: strike that the case is in Texas, not Conneticut as I assumed.
 
Last edited:
I think we all do, just like we all hope for a negative medical test. But your analogy then falls apart. We don't all agree what the correct verdict is. I hope he is found guilt of defamation, because I believe he has defamed people who have suffered damages from his defmation.

Also, I'm going to go investigate if Vegas is taking odds on this case. Jones is going to lose, I'd bet money on it given decent odds.

I think we do agree what the correct verdict is.
 
Your analogy doesn't really work. A negative medical test is not proof that you don't have a disease. False negatives occur, just like bad judgements at trial. Also, pretty much everyone wants to not have a disease, which doesn't apply to defamation trials. Not everyone wants the defendant to win.



Yes, if you're going to "hope for" something, you should be hoping for an accurate judgement (or test result). If he's guilty, he should pay up, if you're sick, you want to know it so you can get treatment.

But Jones vs. the truth is less "I hope I don't actually have cancer" and more "I hope that isn't actually a knife sticking out of my chest". The problem is so clearly obvious to an unbiased observer that "hoping" it isn't defamation/a knife in your chest is ridiculous. If you're not a Sandy Hook Truther, basically the only way Jones wins this case is if the judge rules that the victims are public persons, and as such, it's okay to defame them. And that's not an outcome any reasonable person should be "hoping" for.
 
I also said in a similar post we want tests to be accurate. I want the right verdict. I hope the right verdict is a judgement for Jones because I hope people do not suffer damages.


One would think the hope would be that the right verdict is delivered whichever way it goes, no?
you seem to have a problem admitting that if they were defamed and Jones is found guilty, that would be the 'right verdict' since you insist on stating only that Jones be found not guilty would be the 'right verdict'.
you keep dancing around that.
I don't think you are alex jones so your medical analogy fails. you have no skin in the game.
 
Last edited:
One would think the hope would be that the right verdict is delivered whichever way it goes, no?
you seem to have a problem admitting that if they were defamed and Jones is found guilty, that would be the 'right verdict' since you insist on stating only that Jones be found not guilty would be the 'right verdict'.
you keep dancing around that.
I don't think you are alex jones so your medical analogy fails. you have no skin in the game.

I have no problem saying if he defamed them he should be found guilty. I thought I did say that.

I hope to both the right verdict, and I hope that if the verdict is right, that those families were never harmed.
 
Yes, if you're going to "hope for" something, you should be hoping for an accurate judgement (or test result). If he's guilty, he should pay up, if you're sick, you want to know it so you can get treatment.

But Jones vs. the truth is less "I hope I don't actually have cancer" and more "I hope that isn't actually a knife sticking out of my chest". The problem is so clearly obvious to an unbiased observer that "hoping" it isn't defamation/a knife in your chest is ridiculous. If you're not a Sandy Hook Truther, basically the only way Jones wins this case is if the judge rules that the victims are public persons, and as such, it's okay to defame them. And that's not an outcome any reasonable person should be "hoping" for.


There are other ways.

A) he never lied
B) their reputations were never harmed
 
I don't think you are alex jones so your medical analogy fails. you have no skin in the game.

My skin is a general interest of not liking to see people harmed by others. They were likely harmed by Jones (an opinion I try to avoid sharing because I don't think it is appropriate to share judgements, but it feels necessary at this point). I would really like to find out I was wrong about that and they were not harmed.
 
There are other ways.

A) he never lied
B) their reputations were never harmed


But both of those are objectively hugely unlikely. We're not talking about something he might say in the future, we're talking about things he has already said, over the course of years. There's no way he can claim to be ignorant of the refutations of the "crisis actor" claims, so he must have been lying (absent a claim of actual insanity on his part, a claim he has steadfastly denied for years as well), or at least aware of the possibility that it was a lie (leading to the issue of malice - he didn't care about the truth either way, so long as it played to his narrative). And their reputations have been harmed, at least in so far as actual people have already been convicted for actually issuing actual death threats to the victims of Sandy Hook.

Now, you could quibble about how much their reputations have been damaged, but the damage exists.
 
I have no problem saying if he defamed them he should be found guilty. I thought I did say that.

I hope to both the right verdict, and I hope that if the verdict is right, that those families were never harmed.

but the verdict would still be 'right' if they were harmed and he's found guilty. this is where your word game comes into play. you only want it to be 'right' if he's found innocent.
 
but the verdict would still be 'right' if they were harmed and he's found guilty. this is where your word game comes into play. you only want it to be 'right' if he's found innocent.

That makes no sense. Of course I want it right in either case. If someone says I hope the test says I don't have cancer, no one then points out that isn't true if the test is wrong.
 
but this is not about cancer or emotions. it's about a legal proceeding.
 
So? Just like those cases, saying I hope for a certain result does not imply I want that result regardless of truth.

True, it means that you hope for things that we already know are not true


We do know that Sandy Hook happened
We do know that Alex Jones has claimed it was staged and has accused the parents of being actors
We do know that some of the parents have been threatened


Your hope has to be that one of those is untrue.
 
My skin is a general interest of not liking to see people harmed by others. They were likely harmed by Jones (an opinion I try to avoid sharing because I don't think it is appropriate to share judgements, but it feels necessary at this point). I would really like to find out I was wrong about that and they were not harmed.

I'd like to see him lose so that he'll cry again and look like a fool. And that's the least he can get. Accusing people of mass murder and feeding the hundreds of thousands of conspiracy drones in this country with propaganda is no small thing to me.
 
I also said in a similar post we want tests to be accurate. I want the right verdict. I hope the right verdict is a judgement for Jones because I hope people do not suffer damages.

Stop trying to sound philosophical when you can't even matter tense.

They either did our did not suffer damages. Your philosophy only functions (not makes sense mind you) when the statement uses the present tense, but we are talking of past actions.
 
My skin is a general interest of not liking to see people harmed by others. They were likely harmed by Jones (an opinion I try to avoid sharing because I don't think it is appropriate to share judgements, but it feels necessary at this point). I would really like to find out I was wrong about that and they were not harmed.

What about Jones?

If they have not been harmed he has. So to have any consistency you would have to hope for neither as both contain large amounts of people negatively effected.
 
Stop trying to sound philosophical when you can't even matter tense.

They either did our did not suffer damages. Your philosophy only functions (not makes sense mind you) when the statement uses the present tense, but we are talking of past actions.

I think they did suffer damages. I'm hoping I'm wrong about that.
 
They have a case. The first part of a defamation case is providing documentation of Jones making the statement(s), and that won't be a problem. The trick is documenting the damage to the victims, which will mostly be emotional pain. Can they show they've lost work time? Have they been forced into extended therapy due to the false statements? Can they show permanent psychological damage?

I'm betting in this case - yes.

https://injury.findlaw.com/torts-and-personal-injuries/defamation-law-the-basics.html

http://www.alllaw.com/articles/nolo/civil-litigation/evidence-defamation-lawsuit.html
 
They have a case. The first part of a defamation case is providing documentation of Jones making the statement(s), and that won't be a problem. The trick is documenting the damage to the victims, which will mostly be emotional pain. Can they show they've lost work time? Have they been forced into extended therapy due to the false statements? Can they show permanent psychological damage?

I'm betting in this case - yes.

https://injury.findlaw.com/torts-and-personal-injuries/defamation-law-the-basics.html

http://www.alllaw.com/articles/nolo/civil-litigation/evidence-defamation-lawsuit.html

I don't understand how the first article explicitly says it hurt reputation, and brought up missing work. Is there only work time lost by reputation or emotional distress? If you skipped work because of distress, but no one at work cared because it didn't affect your reputation, is that harm for purposes of defamation?
 
And how big is the chance that he might thrown in behind bars?

In a civil suit like this one, almost none.In the US, people do not go to jail when they lose a civil case.
Only way this happens is if Jones does something really stupid during the trial, and gets tossed in the slammer for "contempt of court" or fails to obey a court order. . And even that technically is a different offense then his defamaing the Sandy Hook victims.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom