Sandy Hook parents sue Alex Jones for defamation

The "Sandy Hook parents" chose to become public figures by choosing to appear on news media. If you want to say the consequences of that are horrible, that's just the tragedy of reality.

Are you a politician? None of what you've written answers my question.

Should I be allowed to tell all of my friends and yours that you indulge in illegal and reprehensible activity? Am I at liberty to run round telling the world about it and maybe publish a book entitled "MicahJava's Illegal and Reprehensible Activity all over the Western Hemisphere"? (Read about the remarkable interaction with Thai 'ladies', marvel at the the wonder of what he can do with three balloons and a peanut. "A work of unparalleled truth" Alex Jones)


"I like freedom" is a political statement, not a Hallmark card. It comes with some good and some bad. Innocent people could get hurt, but then again people could get hurt the other way too. It is possible to disagree with having the maximum amount of freedom at all times. I happen to think that is the best way. If you disagree, say so.


Yes, but am I allowed to publish my book? Or would you restrict my freedom to do so?
 
Last edited:
We are living in a time of a legal test of the 1st amendment. Seems that malicious actors are trying to walk the razor's edge of protected speech. What counts as a protected opinion and open slander, harassment, or incitement to harassment is a tricky question that I have no simple response for.

One thing is abundantly clear, these trolls hiding behind 1A are among the worst people.

His lawyers blacked out the portion of the certificate that includes where Noah Pozner is buried, out of a concern that conspiracy theorists would desecrate the grave in a misguided effort to show he is not buried there.

That's abhorrent. I hope only the worst for these people.
 
I would rather see the Sandy Hook parents tortured in camps than have them partially responsible for removing a sliver of freedom.

I think torturing people in camps mandates a removal of freedom.
 
Freedom of speech does not absolve you of the consequences of your speech. That book is tantamount to libel, and if there are people that have harassed the Sandy Hook parents to the degree that is being claimed (and from what I have read there is no reason to think he's lying), the people who wrote the book could and should be responsible for causing the harassment.
 
I would rather see the Sandy Hook parents tortured in camps than have them partially responsible for removing a sliver of freedom.

Freedom of speech does not equal freedom from speech.

If I walk into a predominantly African-American nightclub and start calling people the N-word, I should expect the profound beating that follows.

If I write a book claiming that Patrick Stewart is indeed the head of the Illuminati without any documented evidence proving that he is, then I should expect Stewart to sue my butt into oblivion.

The Sandy Hook parents have a Constitutional right of redress, a freedom you want to take away.

Actual crisis actor conspiracies have been conceived of before (1967 Operation Northwoods memo and the Bush-Blair 2003 Memo), so it's not like the conspiracy theorists started it.

I've missed your post featuring a poor grasp of easy history.

Operation Northwoods was conceived in 1962, not 1967, by the JFK NSC as part of a list of proposals to justify invading Cuba. JFK, RFK, and the rest of the NSC shot the idea down BECAUSE IT WAS TOO STUPID TO WORK.

Yes, your hero, JFK, for a moment considered a "false flag
operation.

As far as Iraq goes, the Bush Administration's NSC seem to have been lead by right-wing 9-11 Truthers. The war in Iraq was their "New Investigation".

Plus, people wouldn't be so quick to judge them if they were aware of the true war-mongering nature of the U.S. for the last sixty years, and would especially become more sympathetic to the crazier crowd if they were aware of all the evidence surrounding the assassinations of the 60's.

Yes, for the last 60 years the United States has exited in a vacuum.

Conspiracy watchdogs are important in society because conspiracies happen.

Yes, and not one CTist has run wild with the mysterious deaths of FSB agents involved in the 2016 US election hackings. Not a lot of FSB Truthers out there for some reason.

Besides, Alex Jones is technically more innocent than almost all mainstream media entities because he called BS on the Iraq war from the very beginning, an Iraq was a pointless mass murder that cost 1.5 million+ lives.

You ignore so many facts to embrace this.

Who here wants their freedom of speech to be decided by a committee of Kyle's mom from South Park? Because there's no argument that that's what we're going to get.

That is not what is happening in this case. Alex Jones is being taken to court for accusations he has made on his show - without evidence - that have directly lead to these families being threatened with death by CTists.

They have not won the case yet, and the judge/jury might side with Alex Jones.

This is Due Process, a cornerstone of that "Freedom" you claim is being threatened.
 
The "Sandy Hook parents" chose to become public figures by choosing to appear on news media. If you want to say the consequences of that are horrible, that's just the tragedy of reality. "I like freedom" is a political statement, not a Hallmark card. It comes with some good and some bad. Innocent people could get hurt, but then again people could get hurt the other way too. It is possible to disagree with having the maximum amount of freedom at all times. I happen to think that is the best way. If you disagree, say so.

I'm curious how you justify fascist terror threats under the hollow banner of Freedom?

How can you argue on one thread that the JFK assassination and the 9-11 attacks were part of a right-wing conspiracy, and then defend Nazis on this thread?

Or are you even aware that this is what you are doing?

The Sandy Hook parents didn't choose anything, they were chosen by the cruelest of fates when a spoiled, mentally ill rich kid shot his way into their kid's school, and killed a bunch of them. The press stuck microphones in their faces and they spoke, that was it. If someone killed my kid I would become a crusader in a New York Minute.

You only care about human suffering when it suits your political world view. If you can't show compassion for the murder of 20 kindergartners then how can we see your lamentations over the deaths of Iraqis as anything but crocodile tears?

I hope they win. I hope Jones and other like him ends up penniless living under a highway overpass in Omaha.
 
I'm curious how you justify fascist terror threats under the hollow banner of Freedom?

How can you argue on one thread that the JFK assassination and the 9-11 attacks were part of a right-wing conspiracy, and then defend Nazis on this thread?

Or are you even aware that this is what you are doing?

The Sandy Hook parents didn't choose anything, they were chosen by the cruelest of fates when a spoiled, mentally ill rich kid shot his way into their kid's school, and killed a bunch of them. The press stuck microphones in their faces and they spoke, that was it. If someone killed my kid I would become a crusader in a New York Minute.

You only care about human suffering when it suits your political world view. If you can't show compassion for the murder of 20 kindergartners then how can we see your lamentations over the deaths of Iraqis as anything but crocodile tears?

I hope they win. I hope Jones and other like him ends up penniless living under a highway overpass in Omaha.

Dude, a bit harsh. What the hell did Omaha ever do to you?
 
I would rather see the Sandy Hook parents tortured in camps than have them partially responsible for removing a sliver of freedom.

And I would see those who advocate torturing people in camps as an infinitely greater threat to freedom than those pointing out how idiotic their persecution fantasies are.

Dave
 
Last edited:
The "Sandy Hook parents" chose to become public figures by choosing to appear on news media. If you want to say the consequences of that are horrible, that's just the tragedy of reality. "I like freedom" is a political statement, not a Hallmark card. It comes with some good and some bad. Innocent people could get hurt, but then again people could get hurt the other way too. It is possible to disagree with having the maximum amount of freedom at all times. I happen to think that is the best way. If you disagree, say so.

Scum like Alex Jones propelled Sandy Hook victims into the media spotlight with their lies. Innocent people got hurt by a man with a gun and Jones and his ilk choose to make money out of it. That seem reasonable to you? If it does I'd take a good look at yourself in the mirror and throw a rock at it.

I completely disagree with your utterly stupid non sequitur that being a victim of an atrocity makes you fair game for morons and charlatans in the name of freedom.
 
The "Sandy Hook parents" chose to become public figures by choosing to appear on news media.

No, Sandy Hook parents were forced to take that path because of the pack of lies told by a vile, despicable, and barely sub-human pile of steaming faeces called Alex Jones, and the rancid turds who support him and follow him. Some of those rancid turds physically threatened the lives of Sandy Hook parents.

I would rather see the Sandy Hook parents tortured in camps than have them partially responsible for removing a sliver of freedom.

I'd rather see Alex Jones and those who agree with him tortured in these camps of yours... they would certainly be more deserving of such treatment than the parents of murdered middle-schoolers

Freedom is more important than butthurt.

Being threatened by nutcase conspiracy theorists because your children have been murdered in a mass shooting is not "butthurt", its a tragedy.

Who here wants their freedom of speech to be decided by a committee of Kyle's mom from South Park? Because there's no argument that that's what we're going to get.

I would be quite happy to have my "freedom of speech" curtailed to the point where if I publicly accused people of faking their child's murder, I would need to prove, in a Court of Law that what I am accusing them of is true. I would still have freedom of speech, as long as accusatory speech is verifiable truth.

The world would be a lot more civil place if everyone had to be accountable for what they publicly said about others.
 
Yes.

This isn't a case of someone being mistaken. This is a case of someone spreading blatant lies. At best without performing the basic steps one would expect a reasonable person to perform to determine their truth before making the accusations, and at worst a malicious and deliberate callousness as to the effect of their speech on others in the name of personal profit.

This type of speech is not any "watchdog of freedom", it's non-government propaganda.

There are reasons that pretty much every civilized country in the world has libel and slander laws.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom