Sandy Hook parents sue Alex Jones for defamation

Now that it is all clear again to all what the First Amendment is and isn't (oh and it isn't absolute in time and space: when I stand under your bedroom window at 2AM with a bullhorn and "exercise free speech", the police is totally in their rights to drag me off if I don't stop), a couple of serious legal questions about the US system.

First: is it possible, in the context of a defamation suit like this, that claimants ask the court to forbid defendant from repeating the same defaming statements that are the subject of the suit?

With "possible", I mean: does the law allow this in principle, and it has at least once in legal history been granted.

With "forbid" I mean: either in principle rule that a repeat of the statements will also be defamatory, or already explicitly set a monetary penalty so it would save the burden of a new lawsuit.

Second: Is it possible to pre-emptively forbid someone to publish defamatory statements? Scenario: defendant is preparing a book, and the claimant gets wind of that and gets hold of (relevant parts of) the draft at the publisher's. Claimant files suit attempting to forbid publication of the book in its current form.
 
First: is it possible, in the context of a defamation suit like this, that claimants ask the court to forbid defendant from repeating the same defaming statements that are the subject of the suit?

My guess is that's gonna be the angle he's gonna try and argue, that all he's doing is "repeating" rumors and that makes it "news."
 
But the difference is, The Onion is marketed as satire. Its audience is smart enough to recognize that the material is meant to be comical.

Yes. If we don't let the crazy nutjob criminally slander the parents of dead children and order assault strikes on pizza parlors with imaginary child sex dungeons today then tomorrow we're gonna be denied "Loved Ones Recall Local Man’s Cowardly Battle With Cancer" headlines in an obvious parody newspaper.


That's another major difference. When The Onion uses a real person in its stories, it's always someone famous, which puts them in the "public person" arena when it comes to defamation. Otherwise, they only refer to the generic "Local Man" with their non-specific bits of satire.

Jones went after a specific group of private individuals. Having been the victim of a crime cannot reasonably lead to the conclusion that they are public persons for the purposes of defamation, so he'll be facing much stricter standards than The Onion would face in such a lawsuit.
 

The legal process is the best method we have for determine if defamation occurred. It is a better world to not be defamed rather than defamed and compensated. A judgement that he did not defame them is a better indicator that they were not defamed than a judgement that he did.
 
That's another major difference. When The Onion uses a real person in its stories, it's always someone famous, which puts them in the "public person" arena when it comes to defamation. Otherwise, they only refer to the generic "Local Man" with their non-specific bits of satire.

Jones went after a specific group of private individuals. Having been the victim of a crime cannot reasonably lead to the conclusion that they are public persons for the purposes of defamation, so he'll be facing much stricter standards than The Onion would face in such a lawsuit.

And how big is the chance that he might thrown in behind bars?
 
Last edited:
The legal process is the best method we have for determine if defamation occurred. It is a better world to not be defamed rather than defamed and compensated. A judgement that he did not defame them is a better indicator that they were not defamed than a judgement that he did.
The highlighted sentance may be the stupidest statement I have ever read.
 
Do you disagree with it?

It's not a matter of agreeing or disagreeing.

Of course not being found guilty is a better sign of not being guilty than being found guilty.
But that has no bearing on why you would prefer that he isn't found guilty.
You simply haven't answered the question.
 
It's not a matter of agreeing or disagreeing.

Of course not being found guilty is a better sign of not being guilty than being found guilty.
But that has no bearing on why you would prefer that he isn't found guilty.
You simply haven't answered the question.

I did. Not being defamed is better than being defamed and compensated. If a fair process sides with him, than it is less likely the families were defamed.
 
but if they were indeed defamed...........?

surely him being found guilty and having to compensate them would be a fair process also correct? or is what you are trying to allude without saying it is that it would not be?
 
Do you disagree with it?

It only makes sense in the absence of contextual information. In this instance, we know that the relatives of murder victims feel upset and offended that Jones has claimed publically that their dead relations either never existed or are not dead, and that they are all complicit in a crime by lying about the deaths. Given this contextual information, it seems to me that the following may result in an acquittal:

(1) The finding that Jones's statements are factually true. This would be an unpleasant finding in that they almost certainly are not true, and if they were we would be living in a dystopian nightmare.

(2) The finding that Jones never made any such statements. This would be a bizarre finding given that the statements are well documented.

(3) The finding that the statements, though untrue, are not defamatory. This would be an unpleasant finding because it would in effect mean that anybody could be accused of anything out of simple malice, and would have no recourse in law.

So, despite the general principle that it's preferable that no crime has been committed, in this specific instance I disagree very strongly with it. I hope Jones loses because the facts of the case seem clearly established in this instance, and in general it is a better world if principles of justice are upheld than if they are ignored.

Dave
 
but if they were indeed defamed...........?

surely him being found guilty and having to compensate them would be a fair process also correct? or is what you are trying to allude without saying it is that it would not be?

If they were defamed they should be compensated. If they were not, then they should not be. The results of a trial is probably our best predictor if defamation occurred. Therefore I hope they are found to not have been defamed. Therefore I hope Jones wins.
 
It only makes sense in the absence of contextual information. In this instance, we know that the relatives of murder victims feel upset and offended that Jones has claimed publically that their dead relations either never existed or are not dead, and that they are all complicit in a crime by lying about the deaths. Given this contextual information, it seems to me that the following may result in an acquittal:

(1) The finding that Jones's statements are factually true. This would be an unpleasant finding in that they almost certainly are not true, and if they were we would be living in a dystopian nightmare.

(2) The finding that Jones never made any such statements. This would be a bizarre finding given that the statements are well documented.

(3) The finding that the statements, though untrue, are not defamatory. This would be an unpleasant finding because it would in effect mean that anybody could be accused of anything out of simple malice, and would have no recourse in law.

So, despite the general principle that it's preferable that no crime has been committed, in this specific instance I disagree very strongly with it. I hope Jones loses because the facts of the case seem clearly established in this instance, and in general it is a better world if principles of justice are upheld than if they are ignored.

Dave

But you maybe didnt describe defamation. You said they are upset. You didn't say they suffered damages.my understanding is that simple hurt feelings are not defamation.
 
If they were defamed they should be compensated. If they were not, then they should not be. The results of a trial is probably our best predictor if defamation occurred. Therefore I hope they are found to not have been defamed. Therefore I hope Jones wins.

you keep dancing around what has been asked. Are you saying that if they were defamed, that the results of a trial indicating so would not be a best predictor?
you only use the phrase - The results of a trial is probably our best predictor if defamation occurred - only when describing the win you want. not the loss that is also possible.
 
But you maybe didnt describe defamation. You said they are upset. You didn't say they suffered damages.my understanding is that simple hurt feelings are not defamation.

Being accused of a crime and losing standing in the community is a damage. Mental distress is a damage. There's a threshold, and the job of the court is to determine what that threshold is, but in this instance my personal opinion is that it's been met and that recompense should be sought.

In general, we're allowed to use context to inform judgements. I realise you disagree with that principle, but let's not let this thread be derailed into yet another discussion of that.

Dave
 
you keep dancing around what has been asked. Are you saying that if they were defamed, that the results of a trial indicating so would not be a best predictor?
you only use the phrase - The results of a trial is probably our best predictor if defamation occurred - only when describing the win you want. not the loss that is also possible.

If they were defamed, it seems like a trial verdict that they were defamed would be more likely.
 
Being accused of a crime and losing standing in the community is a damage. Mental distress is a damage. There's a threshold, and the job of the court is to determine what that threshold is, but in this instance my personal opinion is that it's been met and that recompense should be sought.

In general, we're allowed to use context to inform judgements. I realise you disagree with that principle, but let's not let this thread be derailed into yet another discussion of that.

Dave

You didn't say they lost standing in the community. I don't know if mental distress without loss of standing is damages for defamation.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom