Merged Rep. Giffords Shot In Tucson

ETA: What is fascinating about this is the double-standard that comes with it. For example, calling for Shirley Sherrod to be fired over a largely manufactured controversy, while saying that Juan Williams' rights were being infringed and calling censorship when he was fired from NPR for saying that Muslim people on airplanes make him nervous.
The Juan Williams one was a perfect opportunity for Republicans. They hate NPR so they get to slam them, while appearing to take the high road. It was a clear win-win for them.
 
His shaving his head should make his execution easier.

Good thinking.

Why are people unaware of just how disturbed schizophrenics are mentally? My brother was saying the same thing, the guy deserves the death penalty.

Untreated schizophrenics are experiencing a world of hallucinations. Their brains are on the fritz. They are not thinking normally, rationally, realistically, or however one can describe it.

Would you feel that a person who had a heart attack while driving and the subsequent crash killed 6 people was responsible and should go to jail for manslaughter?

Yet when it is the brain that is totally malfunctioning, you hold the individual responsible. It's sad that people misunderstand how jumbled untreated schizophrenic brains are.
 
Send him the money.

Then Bob can be 'thunderously' proud to have won the bet on a minor technicality.


It doesn't matter, really. Whether he will ever admit it or not, I won the bet, fair and square, on the terms that he originally stated; albeit on a rather silly, thunderous technicality.

Of course, there is not any way that he would ever admit that his calls for Sarah Palin to be sued or otherwise “held responsible” for the acts of a madman that had nothing whatsoever to do with her, simply on the basis of how her campaign chose to express certain points, amount to exactly the sort of subversion of the First Amendment that would rationally have satisfied the terms of his wager without relying on a silly technicality.

In any event, the $20 is completely beside the point, which was to illustrate the folly of using words as carelessly as he does; and of making promises that one has no intent of honoring.
 
Last edited:
The Juan Williams one was a perfect opportunity for Republicans. They hate NPR so they get to slam them, while appearing to take the high road. It was a clear win-win for them.

I would disagree, due to the fact that so many people (including you, which I mean with all respect) forgot that to "win," Republicans had to say that it was a bad thing for a company to neglect to employ someone in the capacity of a commentator for saying something somewhat racist in a public setting.
 
Why are people unaware of just how disturbed schizophrenics are mentally? My brother was saying the same thing, the guy deserves the death penalty.

Untreated schizophrenics are experiencing a world of hallucinations. Their brains are on the fritz. They are not thinking normally, rationally, realistically, or however one can describe it.

Would you feel that a person who had a heart attack while driving and the subsequent crash killed 6 people was responsible and should go to jail for manslaughter?

Yet when it is the brain that is totally malfunctioning, you hold the individual responsible. It's sad that people misunderstand how jumbled untreated schizophrenic brains are.

Then find and institutionalize them. If they can't not kill and can pass well enough to get away with it for a while, not fair to other people. Same if they are found, given meds and won't take them. They have no right to kill or harm others because they are troubled/deficient/damaged.

Believe it or not (and I have already noted this) I have known and worked with people with these and other problems. They need help, but I have to be on the side of the people harmed, not the people harming in any situation like this.
 
Have Roger and Amy come out of the house yet? I want to see if they look like Gomez and Morticia.

This is sad. Chances are they either tried to help their son or simply did not have the skills or knowledge to know what to do. Schizophrenics are often relatively normal throughout childhood. Then as a teen or young adult they deteriorate. How would you feel if your child had this illness which we know from overwhelming data is not the result of parenting, and people blamed you for how you 'caused' the illness?

These parents are likely dealing with the grief of the loss of their 'normal' child who is not now normal and never will be again, the grief of the tragedy that has just occurred, and more than likely being falsely blamed for causing their child's mental illness.

I'm sorry these people did not or could not get help for their son, but your comment is inappropriate.
 
President Obama is coming to Tucson for a memorial service tomorrow night. It will be held at our college basketball arena. Its first come first serve with the doors opening at 4pm. I own a coffee shop and could close early to get in line but I have some concerns.

1. Its a small stadium and this has really affected Tucson. I am sure it will be packed so I might not get in.
2. Is this not the perfect opportunity for a copy cat shooter?

On the other hand Its not often a POTUS visits Tucson and I would love the chance to hear and see him in person.

What to do?
 
The Repub Party leadership has courted these voters. It's a goldmine of votes and political activism for their party and they are now addicted to those votes.
Frankly, I think this convenience will pay off less and less as the United States continues to diversify. And things like Instant-Runoff Voting would help, but that's a discussion for another thread. (Reasonable Republicans would defeat the Constitution Party almost every time, if you ask me.)

And the reasonable Republicans are not speaking out against these views.
I've seen it on this board with some of the discussions about the Tea Party. It increased my respect for the conservative posters who said so. And similar things have been done by people like William F. Buckley, trying to isolate the John Birch Society in the 1960's. It can be done again.

Heaven forbid you say, "No, it is not right to come to a political rally with an assault rifle slung over your shoulder."
Well, I would say. More on that in a minute.

And maybe that's part of the problem. The right seems to have trouble drawing the line between a point of view and an extreme version of that point of view.
Which is my point. Don't let them blur the distinctions. And those of us who are not Republicans shouldn't blur it, either. Certainly not for cheap gotchas.

But you have to get them to say publicly, to their constituents, why they don't agree with these fringe beliefs and tactics. And they need to explain why it's wrong to shoot up churches and museums and medical clinics. De-mainstream these ideas and the GOP won't have to appeal to the factions that think them.

And this would certainly help clean up the national discourse.
 
Last edited:
There is a segment of the population defined by anti-government politics that is literally preparing to launch a war of terrorism against civilized society. That's what Dr. Tiller's murder was about, that's what the killings above were about. Instead of "waving the bloody shirt," we need to acknowledge that there is, right now, a virulent strain of anti-government political philosophy that, when combined with patriotic gun fantasies, is really, really dangerous, and certain pundits and politicians are inflaming that group for personal gain.

This doesn't mean republicans are wrong about the issues they argue, it doesn't even mean they have to stop calling us names, it does mean that they have to stop the demonization rhetoric (Tiller the Baby Killer).

That was a well worded post, and the remembrance of our bloody history outlined in those articles is downright eerie. I agree with all the sentiments you've expressed herein...

... but, we have to remind ourselves that we still don't know what - in this particular instance - the motivation was for the shooter to commit these atrocities.

It is entirely possible that these are two separate issues: not everyone who attacks a politician does so for political reasons. Just remember John Hinckley, Jr.
 
President Obama is coming to Tucson for a memorial service tomorrow night. It will be held at our college basketball arena. Its first come first serve with the doors opening at 4pm. I own a coffee shop and could close early to get in line but I have some concerns.

1. Its a small stadium and this has really affected Tucson. I am sure it will be packed so I might not get in.
2. Is this not the perfect opportunity for a copy cat shooter?

On the other hand Its not often a POTUS visits Tucson and I would love the chance to hear and see him in person.

What to do?

Actually, that is a somewhat ideal location for such an event. Areas like that will be much easier for the Secret Service to control and survey for threats/vectors of attack, etc. ahead of time. Wide open spaces are more difficult as far as I know.
 
Does history speak? Can it tell us anything about the current level of political discourse and violence?

Here are facts of history just from June 2010. Is this the list Loughner belongs on?

======================================================

June 2010—Rick Barber, a Tea Party candidate seeking the Republican nomination in Alabama’s Second Congressional District, runs a campaign ad in which he dicusses contemporary political issues with America’s Founding Fathers. After Barber states “I would impeach him” and rails about the “progressive income tax,” the Internal Revenue Service, and health care reform, a Founding Father replies, “Gather your armies.” Several Founding Fathers are depicted as being armed with pistols.


June 9, 2010—Addressing the Obama administration and the Democratic-controlled Congress, FOX commentator Glenn Beck says, “Shoot me in the head if you try to change our government—I will stand against you. And so will millions of others.” Beck also compares American Progressives to Osama bin Laden and claims “they want to overthrow our entire system of government.”


June 27, 2010—Rick Barber, a Tea Party candidate seeking the Republican nomination in Alabama’s Second Congressional District, runs a campaign ad in which he compares taxation and “the tyrannical health care bill” to slavery and the extermination of Jews in Nazi Germany. “We live in perilous times … We are all becoming slaves to our government,” Barber warns. The “army of voters” depicted in the ad includes individuals who are openly armed with guns. In a follow-up editorial in the Washington Post, Barber makes reference to “the possibility of evil conducted on a grand scale” and states, “Totalitarianism doesn’t come all at once … The road to serfdom is a long one, but I fear that we are well on the way.”


July 2, 2010—The Wyoming Department of Revenue suspends sales tax collections at the state’s gun shows because of “increasing animosity” toward field tax agents. Dan Noble, director of the department’s Excise Tax Division, cites one particular incident at a gun show that “crossed the line” and says, “We tend to have more trouble at gun shows than any place … I have 10 field reps throughout the state, and every one of them has experienced some animosity … I don’t want to put my people at risk.”


July 3, 2010—Joyce Kaufman, a conservative radio hosts on WFTL in Florida, tells a crowd of supporters at a Fort Lauderdale Tea Party event, “I am convinced that the most important thing the Founding Fathers did to ensure me my First Amendments rights was they gave me a Second Amendment. And if ballots don’t work, bullets will. This is the standoff. When I say I’ll put my microphone down on November 2nd if we haven’t achieved substantial victory, I mean it. Because if at that point I’m going to up into the hills of Kentucky, I’m going to go out into the Midwest, I’m going to go up in the Vermont and New Hampshire outreaches and I’m going to gather together men and women who understand that some things are worth fighting for and some things are worth dying for.”


July 6, 2010—Herb Titus, a lawyer for Gun Owners of America, tells Religion Dispatches, “... the purpose of the right to keep and bear arms—is to defend yourself against a tyrant.” Titus goes on to cite the “totalitarian threat” posed by “Obamacare” and “what Sarah Palin said about the death panels.”


July 11, 2010—Supporters of Tea Party candidate Joe Miller openly carry assault rifles and handguns during a community parade in Eagle River and Chugiak, Alaska, while young children march alongside them. Miller, who is running against Senator Lisa Murkowski in the Republican primary, was endorsed by former Alaska governor Sarah Palin, who described him as a “true Commonsense Constitutional Conservative.”


July 18, 2010—California Highway Patrol officers arrest Byron Williams, 45, after a shootout on I-580 in which more than 60 rounds are fired. Officers had pulled Williams over in his pick-up for speeding and weaving in and out of traffic when he opened fire on them with a handgun and a long gun. Williams, a convicted felon, is shot several times, but survives because he is wearing body armor. Williams, a convicted felon, reveals that he was on his way to San Francisco to “start a revolution” by killing employees of the ACLU and Tides Foundation. Williams’ mother says her son was angry at “Left-wing politicians” and upset by “the way Congress was railroading through all these Left-wing agenda items.”


July 26, 2010—A proposed ordinance that would prohibit residents from firing air rifles and other low-powered weapons within 500 feet of a building (unless fired in a target range) is pulled from consideration in Exeter Township, Pennsylvania, after the Board of Supervisors receives a number of angry and threatening phone calls from gun owners. Citing a National Rifle Association “Action Alert” that claimed Exeter supervisors were “consider[ing] a broad and overreaching attack on our Second Amendment freedoms,” Exeter Township Police Chief Christopher Neidert says, “This was totally false information that was put out. The anger was building, and I was concerned that someone might actually get hurt.”


July 30, 2010—Camp Hill prison guard Raymond Peake, 64, is charged with robbery and the murder of Todd Getgen. Peake allegedly shot Getgen to death at a local shooting range and stole Getgen’s custom, silenced AR-15 rifle. Investigators follow Peake to a storage unit when they find three firearms: Getgen’s AR-15 rifle, a scoped Remington rifle that had been reported stolen from the range in May, and a second AR-15 rifle. Thomas Tuso is also arrested and charged with conspiracy, receiving stolen property and other crimes. Peake tells police that he and Tuso had been stealing guns “for the purpose of overthrowing the federal government.”


August 14, 2010—Former Arizona sheriff Richard Mack—who gained fame in anti-government circles by joining a mid-1990s lawsuit against the federal government over the Brady Bill requirement that state law enforcement agencies conduct background checks on gun purchasers—tells those in attendance at the American Policy Center’s 2010 Freedom Action Natonal Conference, “My dear friends, I pray for the day that the first sheriff in this country is the one to fire the shot heard ’round the world and take out some IRS agents!”


August 17, 2010—Patrick Gray Sharp, 29, opens fire on the Department of Public Safety in McKinney, Texas, and unsuccessfully attempts to ignite gasoline and ammonium nitrate in a trailer hitched to his truck. Sharp is armed with an assault rifle, a .45-caliber semiautomatic pistol, and a 12-gauge shotgun. He is killed after an exchange of gunfire with police arriving on the scene. Miraculously, no one else is hurt. Sharp’s roommate, Eric McClellan describes him as “a great guy” and states, “We’re Texans. We have a right to bear arms.”


August 23, 2010—Thomas Pidgeon is arrested after he attempts to bring a fully loaded .45-caliber handgun into a Cook County courthouse. Pidegon was supposed to attend a foreclosure hearing that day. His home was to be sold to a lender in North Carolina after New York-based BNY Mellon filed an action against him in the county.


September 1, 2010—James Jay Lee, 43, takes hostages at the Discovery Communications building in Silver Spring, Maryland, while armed with two starter pistols and four improvised explosived devices. After pointing a gun at one of the hostages, he is shot and killed by police. Lee, a radical environmental activist, had previously issued 11 demands through a webpage that Discovery was to meet “immediately.” The demands involved the content of programming on the Discovery Channel. Lee had also declared on his MySpace page, “It’s time for REVOLUTION!!!”


September 16, 2010—Patricia Stoneking, the President of the Kansas State Rifle Association, tells Fox News, “People need to arm themselves, We have the right to put limits on our government, and that’s what [the Second Amendment] does.” Explaining why America’s Founding Fathers drafted the amendment, she says, “They knew government could become tyrannical. We have the right to defend ourselves from a rogue government.”


September 30, 2010—Kevin Terrell, a self-described “colonel” who founded a group of “freedom fighters” in Kentucky, predicts war with “the jackbooted thugs” of Washington within a year. Referring to the arrest of Hutaree militia members earlier in the year, Terrell says, “There was a lot of citizens out there in the bushes, locked and loaded. It’s only due to miracles I do not understand that civil war did not break out right there.”


September 30, 2010—Steve Kendley, a deputy sheriff running for sheriff in Lake County, Montana, threatens “a violent conflict” with federal agents if “they are doing something I believe is unconstitutional.”


October 15, 2010—Conservative radio show host Glenn Beck lays out a hypothetical scenario on the air where the government is considering taking his children because he refused to have them receive a mandatory flu vaccine. Beck tells his audience that his response to the government would be “Meet Mr. Smith and Mr. Wesson.”


October 21, 2010—Pastor Stephen Broden, the Republican candidate for U.S. Representative in Texas’ 30th Congressional District, tells WFAA-TV in Dallas that the violent overthrow of the government is an “option” that remains “on the table.” “Our nation was founded on violence,” states Broden. “I don’t think that we should ever remove anything from the table as it relates to our liberties and our freedoms.”


October 22, 2010—Texas Department of Corrections officers searching for a missing person, Gill Clements, 69, are confronted by a neighbor while on Clements’ property in Henderson County. Howard Tod Granger, 46, points an AK-47 semiautomatic assault rifle at one of the officers, who recalls, “He told us to get off the property or he would kill us all.” Later that afternoon, officers return to Granger’s home with a search warrant and an armored vehicle filled with 13 SWAT members. Granger opens fire on the vehicle, discharging at least 30 rounds before authorities shoot and kill him. Police find guns and “many rounds of ammunition” in Granger’s house. They also find the body of Clements, buried in a shallow grave on Granger’s property.


November 3, 2010—James Patock, 66, of Pima County, Arizona, is arrested on the National Mall in the District of Columbia after law enforcement authorities find a .223 caliber rifle, a .243 caliber rifle barrel, a .22 caliber rifle, a .357 caliber pistol, several boxes of ammunition, and propane tanks wired to four car batteries in his truck and trailer. Patock former neighbor in Arizona reported that, “He hated the president. He hated everything. He said if he got a chance he would shoot the president.” Patock tells authorities he is a member of the National Rifle Association.


November 4, 2010—On his radio show, conservative host Glenn Beck fantasizes about President Obama being decapitated during a trip to India, saying, “If anybody thinks he was a Muslim over here, well God forbid, they think he was a Muslim over there because he left his religion for Christianity, death sentence, behead him.” Beck then tells his listeners that “God forbid” this should happen, as there would be a “New World Order” overnight in the United States.


November 4, 2010—Fox News host Bill O’Reilly fantasizes about killing a Washington Post reporter while on the air, saying, “Does sharia law say we can behead Dana Milbank?” O’Reilly also tells co-host Megyn Kelly, “I think you and I should go and beat him up.”


November 10, 2010—Public schools in Broward County, Florida, go into lockdown after an email threat is received by WFTL 850 AM. The email is sent to conservative radio host Joyce Kaufman in response to remarks she made at a Tea Party event in July (“If ballots don’t work, bullets will”). The email expresses support for her view of the Second Amendment and says that to further “their cause…something big will happen at a government building in Broward County, maybe a post office maybe even a school.” A phone call is then received at the station, allegedly from the emailer’s wife, warning that he is preparing to go to a Pembroke Pines school and open fire.


November 23, 2010—Larry Pratt, the Executive Director of Gun Owners of America, writes an editorial in The Register Citizen in which he calls for state and county sheriffs to organize large, armed “posses” as “a check on the unconstitutional exercise of federal power.”


November 29, 2010—U.S. Rep. Joe Barton (R-TX), the ranking Republican on the House Energy and Commerce Committee, circulates a PowerPoint presentation to his colleagues in which he compares the Obama administration to the Nazi regime in Germany and likens himself to Gen. George Patton, bragging, “Put anything in my scope and I will shoot it.”


********** followed by event under consideration ******************

January 8, 2011—Jared Lee Loughner, 22, shoots U.S. Rep. Gabrielle Giffords (D-AZ) and 19 others at a “Congress in Your Corner” event at a Safeway supermarket in Tucson, Arizona. He kills six, including federal judge John Roll, and wounds 14, including Giffords, who is shot in the head. Loughner has an extensive history of mental illness, yet is able to purchase two handguns and a high-capacity ammunition magazine legally at Sportsman’s Warehouse on November 30, 2010. In a YouTube video posted in December 2010, Loughner states, “You don’t have to accept the federalist laws … Nonetheless, read the United States of America’s Constitution to apprehend all of the current treasonous laws.”
 
Last edited:
Then find and institutionalize them. If they can't not kill and can pass well enough to get away with it for a while, not fair to other people. Same if they are found, given meds and won't take them. They have no right to kill or harm others because they are troubled/deficient/damaged.

Believe it or not (and I have already noted this) I have known and worked with people with these and other problems. They need help, but I have to be on the side of the people harmed, not the people harming in any situation like this.
Who is it you are telling to "find and institutionalize them"?

Who should fund this given the current climate of decreasing government services and safety nets?

Do we have any Republican proposals to increase mental health services throughout the county? Is it up to the sates who are currently experiencing severe budget cutbacks?

In our state the public voted against a number of increased taxes including a proposal to tax incomes over $250,000 (after deductions mind you), and against including soda pop in the taxable category (we have no sales tax on food) after soda corporate interests from out of state poured millions into a campaign against the tax.

I voted FOR both taxes, BTW and I drink lots of soda. It's obvious to me that people who think it's all about too much spending are wrong. And here is a perfect example. You spout out, "something should be done!" Just how do you propose that happen when so many people prefer not to contribute to the community good?
 
Last edited:

Back
Top Bottom