Religion's value questioned

To explain further, if becoming religious helps someone, then I believe that yes, it is a positive influence in their life. But if religion is carried to the extent that it begins to cloud judgment, then it is bad, and we should try to get rid of it. Normal spirituality isn't a bad thing - simply believing in the existence of a god and that he forgives sins, while irrational, is not necessarily a negative thing, especially if it helps to improve the believer's quality of life. It is when specifics get involved - young-earth creationism, homophobia, Biblical literalism, etc. - that it starts to be a negative influence. But unless it reaches that point, I see no reason to get rid of it.
 
Let me get this straight:
If (and that's a really big if!) positive thinking actually (!) helps people, then delusion is beneficial to them?
What is your take on breast cancer, for instance? If breast cancer has all these positive effects that its victims sometimes claim, cancer is also a positive influence on their lives and thus should be encouraged?
Of course, it goes without saying that it should not be carried to the extent of dying.

So how do you propose to guarantee that the delusion stays beneficial and does not begin to cloud judgment? And how do you even begin to distinguish between the two kinds of delusion?
(I hope that you are able to see the faulty logic behind this kind of (positive) thinking - unlike BN.)
 
Last edited:
:vk: Dann! We're talking about gangsters here, not Vikings! Gangsters do occasionally change. :) My scenario was a little far-fetched, yes, but it was simply meant to illustrate a point.

Oh well, how silly of me to have imagined you'd attempt an answer. You could say I was even delusional in thinking I might get one. :D What a way to cop out of answering!

If you were suggesting that such a thing could never happen, I have illustrated that it can and it does. You have said nothing that would hint at some solid knowledge that books like The Cross and the Switchblade and Chasing the Dragon are fabrications. If you have such knowledge, tell us what it is. If you don't, then don't make accusations of fabrication. Speculations of it are fine, naturally, but you can't dismiss something as a fabrication when you just don't know.

Perhaps you could be willing to put pragmatism before ideology sometimes? If it can work for some, why knock it?

I've posted examples of how gangsters can turn from violence because they're inspired to follow Jesus and make a fresh start. They may have multiple motives. But surely if they give up violence, it has to be good, even if on dying, they peacefully slip into eternal oblivion when it turns out those pesky atheists were right all along.

Here's an example of a Christian ministry that seems to have turned a lot of people's lives around.

Teen Challenge has grown to include 173 residential programs and numerous evangelism outreach centers in the United States, and 241 centers in 77 other countries. The program's cure rate of 86% has been recognized and substantiated by the U.S. Government's National Institute on Drug Abuse. All Teen Challenge centers operate autonomously.

Teen Challenge graduates include former drug addicts, alcoholics, gang members, prostitutes and others with life-controlling habits. Today, many graduates serve as ministers and missionaries throughout the world.

... which has to be better than still being drug addicts and gangsters, surely.
 
...Removed because I realized after posting how stupid it was. So here's a replacement post.

Dann, as creepy as I feel standing alongside Baby Nemesis, I have to say that I agree with him still. Whether or not it is a delusion, religion does genuinely improve some peoples' lives. I know several people in this vein. You can argue that religion causes harm, but this is on a larger scale than the one that Baby Nemesis is arguing. Baby Nemesis is arguing that, on an individual level, religion can sometimes be a good thing. If it causes someone to turn away from violence in favor of peace, even if that peace is brought from a delusion, then it does have some merit.
The exact point where it becomes detrimental is extremely fuzzy and hard to define. Undoubtedly there is such a point - somewhere very, very close to the point where they start taking religious dogma as fact above science - but its exact position is impossible to determine.
My position is that religion has some value on an individual level, as it does assist some people. However, on a societal level, its costs outweigh its benefits.
 
Last edited:
Pure_Argent said:
Dann, as creepy as I feel standing alongside Baby Nemesis, I have to say that I agree with him still. Whether or not it is a delusion, religion does genuinely
improve some peoples' lives. I know several people in this vein. You can argue that religion causes harm, but this is on a larger scale than the one that
Baby Nemesis is arguing. Baby Nemesis is arguing that, on an individual level, religion can sometimes be a good thing. If it causes someone to turn away
from violence in favor of peace, even if that peace is brought from a delusion, then it does have some merit.

I actually found it highly amusing that you were being pushed into defending religion when you seemed so anti-religion before. I was thinking of posting saying so, but then I decided not to. Well, it seems you're not so militant as I thought.

And I'm a her, not a him.

And I'll answer This while I'm at it:

Dann said:
Let me get this straight:
If (and that's a really big if!)
positive thinking
actually (!) helps people, then delusion is beneficial to them?
What is your take on breast cancer, for instance? If breast cancer has all these positive effects that its victims sometimes claim, cancer is also a positive
influence on their lives and thus should be encouraged?
Of course, it goes without saying that it should not be carried to the extent of dying.

So how do you propose to guarantee that the delusion stays beneficial and does not begin to cloud judgment? And how do you even begin to distinguish between
the two kinds of delusion?
(I hope that you are able to see the faulty logic behind this kind of (positive) thinking - unlike BN.)

I think we're talking about two different types of positive thinking here, Dann. Leaving aside your extreme ideological position that religion is akin to breast cancer, the positive thinking the article talks about seems to be a kind where problems are just brushed under the carpet as if they don't exist, rather than being solved, and people go around trying to convince themselves they're special when they aren't. That's nothing to do with the kind of positive thinking I'm talking about. I've been talking about not wallowing in negativity but being forward-looking, and making positive changes in your life. If religion can help people make beneficial changes in their lives that not only benefit them, but also those around them, because they're no longer terrorising them or hurting them in other ways, how can you take the attitude that it's something that must be entirely eliminated? Not everyone who gets influenced by religion will start thinking in harmful ways.

And it isn't as if atheism is the great purifier. When there are atheists who have a malignant hatred of religion and aggressively try to belittle anyone who dares to speak up for it, how is it any better than religion? The attempts of some militant atheists to blindly eliminate religion from society have led to massive tragedy before. So how is it inherently better than any kind of religious expression at all?

Dann said:
BN's derailing begins on page two and continues until even I get too bored of her.

What you actually mean is that you can't stand the views of anyone who tries to argue that religion can in fact have value. Putting forward arguments as to why religion can have value is not a derail - it's simply taking the thread in a direction you don't like. And you have failed to see all this time that the reason I have argued more fervently than you would have wished is because you have put forward such opposition to even the smallest of arguments. Argument is often a reaction to opposition. The more you argue, the more I will put forward my case. It's a simple matter of cause-and-effect. As I said before, the way to reverse the process is to be quiet. There will be little incentive to argue if there is no opposition to argue against.
 
I would recommend that you begin on page one of this thread.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=46293
BN's derailing begins on page two and continues until even I get too bored of her.

Doesn't look to be derailing to me. Baby Nemesis is actually trying to raise valid points. *shrugs*

I actually found it highly amusing that you were being pushed into defending religion when you seemed so anti-religion before. I was thinking of posting saying so, but then I decided not to. Well, it seems you're not so militant as I thought.

I never claimed to be militant. If I were militant, it would greatly strain a lot of the relationships I have, including those with my immediate family and my best friends, all of whom are religious. I'm the only atheist that I know, not counting the people on this board. I just strongly disagreed with the arguments that you were making in the other threads. Very strongly disagreed.

And I'm a her, not a him.

Oops! My bad. :blush:

I think I occupy a kind of middle ground between the two of you on this issue. Baby Nemesis that religion has intrinsic value, dann that it does not. I'm of the opinion that, under certain circumstances, it can be a good thing - even if the circumstances are ludicrously sugary-sweet and highly unlikely, as in Baby Nemesis' last example. However, there isn't any way to monitor its effects on each individual, or to determine when religion has crossed the line into fanaticism. While religion might help the occasional individual by improving their outlook on life (as long as religion doesn't replace common sense or thinking), I do believe that, overall, the world would likely be a better place without it. Even with the few people that it helps, there are many more whose lives are affected in a negative way.
 
Pure_Argent said:
Doesn't look to be derailing to me. Baby Nemesis is actually trying to raise valid points. *shrugs*...

I never claimed to be militant. If I were militant, it would greatly strain a lot of the relationships I have, including those with my immediate family
and my best friends, all of whom are religious. I'm the only atheist that I know, not counting the people on this board.

Goodness! Keep this up and I might even get to like you! :eek:

Pure_Argent said:
I just strongly disagreed withthe arguments that you were making in the other threads. Very strongly disagreed.

Well you shouldn't have. :)

If you partly mean what I said about the Old Testament, see my latest post on the issue, and you might understand more where I'm coming from. It relates to what I posted here a few posts ago about punishment. I said I wouldn't raise such an issue in the religion forum. But I decided to after all.

Pure_Argent said:
I think I occupy a kind of middle ground between the two of you on this issue. Baby Nemesis that religion has intrinsic value, dann that it does not. I'm
of the opinion that, under certain circumstances, it can be a good thing - even if the circumstances are ludicrously sugary-sweet and highly unlikely,
as in Baby Nemesis' last example. However, there isn't any way to monitor its effects on each individual, or to determine when religion has crossed the
line into fanaticism. While religion might help the occasional individual by improving their outlook on life (as long as religion doesn't replace common
sense or thinking), I do believe that, overall, the world would likely be a better place without it. Even with the few people that it helps, there are
many more whose lives are affected in a negative way.

How do you know it only helps a few? And it wasn't my "last" example that was sugary. The one about whether you'd warn gangsters not to go to a preacher with a reputation for making converts of gangsters and inspiring them to give up violence because you thought if they were converted they'd just be falling prey to a delusion was a bit far-fetched, as I said. But conversions and subsequent changes in lifestyle might happen more often than you think. See that old Jackie Pullinger thing again, for example, Claims Of Miraculous Cure From Heroin Addiction Through The Use Of The Gift Of Tongues. :D Or look a few posts back at my quote from the website about the Teen Challenge organisation.

Teen Challenge has grown to include 173 residential programs and numerous evangelism outreach centers in the United States, and 241 centers in 77 other
countries. The program's cure rate of 86% has been recognized and substantiated by the U.S. Government's National Institute on Drug Abuse. All Teen Challenge centers operate autonomously.

Teen Challenge graduates include former drug addicts, alcoholics, gang members, prostitutes and others with life-controlling habits. Today, many graduates serve as ministers and missionaries throughout the world.

It's an organisation run by Christians with an emphasis on how people in the program need to change their lifestyles/the importance of taking sin seriously. If it's true they have a rehabilitation rate of 86%, that's way way higher than many secular rehabilitation programs.

I didn't say religion has "intrinsic" value. Religion's value in any given circumstance will depend on how it manifests itself. And some religious traditions will be more inspiring and healthy than others.

I can't dispute your opinion that the world as a whole would be better off without religion, because I'm not sure there's any way of knowing. What evidence do you have that the world as a whole would be better off without religion, when the pros and cons of it are weighed up? Wouldn't it depend to a large extent on the circumstances in which religion was eliminated? I mean, for example, Stalin's Russia can't have been better without it. On the other hand, a world where everyone had high living standards and scientific educations that taught them to think critically might be better off without it. Could the world be just as it is now except without religion? How much negativity is caused by religion and how much by other things? Can they be separated out so easily?
 
You can argue that religion causes harm,

However, that would be a little besides the point since it would not focus on what religion is, i.e. a delusion called into being by circumstances detrimental to people’s wellbeing. Instead it focuses on the alleged effects that religion may or may not have, which is your as well as BN’s position.

but this is on a larger scale than the one that Baby Nemesis is arguing. Baby Nemesis is arguing that, on an individual level, religion can sometimes be a good thing. If it causes someone to turn away from violence in favor of peace, even if that peace is brought from a delusion, then it does have some merit.

Do you see? This is no longer a question of what religion is. Instead you say: It does not really matter what religion is, i.e. delusion. Let us focus instead on the beneficial (or detrimental) effects that it may have. That this delusion is a reaction to unpleasant circumstances beyond people’s control becomes irrelevant.

The exact point where it becomes detrimental is extremely fuzzy and hard to define. Undoubtedly there is such a point - somewhere very, very close to the point where they start taking religious dogma as fact above science - but its exact position is impossible to determine.

That is the very nature of delusion, isn’t it? And it makes it impossible to find a point between the alleged good and bad effects, about which you may argue for ever with BN.

My position is that religion has some value on an individual level, as it does assist some people. However, on a societal level, its costs outweigh its benefits.

This is the point where your argument with BN begins: Are the alleged effects of religion a blessing or a curse? What religion is in and of itself, however, has now become irrelevant since delusion may (allegedly) assist.

Doesn’t look to be derailing to me. Baby Nemesis is actually trying to raise valid points. *shrugs*

No, not really. Where I am trying to determine what religion is, she is trying to prove that religion has positive effects. You could do the same thing with her favourite example, the gangbangers: ‘Is it entirely negative to be in a gang? Why always focus on the bad aspects when there are so many good ones? Doesn’t it provide its members with self-esteem? Doesn’t if offer them necessary protection in an otherwise hostile world?’
That would be a similar way of neglecting what gangs actually are.

I never claimed to be militant. If I were militant, it would greatly strain a lot of the relationships I have, including those with my immediate family and my best friends, all of whom are religious. I’m the only atheist that I know, not counting the people on this board. I just strongly disagreed with the arguments that you were making in the other threads. Very strongly disagreed.

You misunderstand the point: You are as militant as BN claims that you are. What you claim is irrelevant. (That your alleged militancy is a lie is besides the point. You should instead focus on the effect of the lie - as does BN.) :)

Oops! My bad. :blush:

You should have noticed that Diana is female.

I think I occupy a kind of middle ground between the two of you on this issue.

No, not really. You completely accept her premise that religion is to be equated with its alleged effects.

Baby Nemesis that religion has intrinsic value, dann that it does not.

No, BN insists that that religion has positive effects. That is very different from intrinsic value. This, by the way, is the reason why she obsessively insists on her own basic delusion: that religion contains a beneficial element, some kind of substrate, which could be extracted and put to good use by unbelievers in secular therapeutic circumstances, i.e. the essence of good in religion.

I’m of the opinion that, under certain circumstances, it can be a good thing - even if the circumstances are ludicrously sugary-sweet and highly unlikely, as in Baby Nemesis’ last example.

I won’t even argue with you about that point. This is your argument with BN, not mine. However, you should at least be aware that the circumstances in this case aren’t merely ludicrously sugary-sweet and highly unlikely” but pure fabrication.
A similar case could therefore be made for the gangbangers: ‘But if the leader of a gang addressed a group of youngsters abandoned by their abusive parents, all alone in the world, and gave them a new perspective of life, self-esteem and a reason to live, wouldn’t that be a good thing?’
That is the kind of reasoning you are accepting into when you buy into her particular delusion.

Forgive me for the italics and (!)s in the following quotation (except for would, which is your own:
However, there isn’t any way to monitor its effects on each (!) individual, or to determine when (!) religion has crossed the line into fanaticism. While religion might help the occasional individual by improving (!) their outlook on life (as long as religion doesn’t replace common sense or thinking), I do believe that, overall, the world would likely be a better place without it. Even with the few people that it helps (!), there are many more whose lives are affected in a negative way.

This is where your futile argument with BN takes off: Instead of concentrating on what religion actually is, you start counting! Who can come up with more examples of alleged good and bad effects?
You are actually right that it is impossible to determine when delusion has crossed the line into fanaticism since the delusion is one and the same. Not only hijackers believe in the story of the 72 virgins. (And even they were watching porn the night before 9/11, I’ve heard, which seems to indicate that there was a limit to their fanaticism.)

The point isn’t so much that ”the world would likely be a better place without it”, (i.e. without religion). The point is that the world is a pretty ****** place. If it weren’t, religion would have no place in it. I.e. bad circumstances favour religion, which is why there aren't many atheists in foxholes. (See p. one of this thread.)

I have to insist with Barbara Ehrenreich that, no, I never think that delusion is okay!, which is only one of the reasons why I’d like to do away with the circumstances that make people dependent on and sometimes even addicted to delusions.
So I guess that we will have to agree to disagree: I don’t consider delusion an improvement of ”their outlook on life”! I wouldn’t clap my hands in joy at the delusion of the saviour Harry Potter even though I don’t doubt that it was a comforting delusion to the children of Beslan.
I’d worry about the treatment of children, there and elsewhere, but I am well aware that I’m very old-fashioned in that respect ...
 
Last edited:
Corr, this is funny! This thread is called "Religion's value questioned", and you're chiding us for talking about religion's value, rather than simply discussing the notion that religion is a delusion? LOL.

And why do you say you're "trying to determine" what religion is, when in fact it seems you decided that long ago, and have absolutely no intention of being moved from that rigid stance? What you seem to want in reality is for everyone else to "determine" that you are correct and come around to your way of thinking. But constantly using the tactic of knee-jerk polar opposition to what they say is not a very persuasive one - it doesn't really help your cause, if, indeed, anything would.

Dann said:
A similar case could therefore be made for the gangbangers: ‘But if the leader of a gang addressed a group of youngsters abandoned by their abusive parents,
all alone in the world, and gave them a new perspective of life, self-esteem and a reason to live, wouldn’t that be a good thing?’
That is the kind of reasoning you are accepting into when you buy into her particular delusion.

And if this "new perspective" meant turning away from violence, what in the name of everything atheistic would be wrong with that?!

Your own fanaticism is just beginning to disgust me. You insist that all accounts of people turning away from violence because they've been inspired by religious means are fabrications, without providing a jot of evidence that they are. Your immovability on any issue that strays from your dogmatic position hurts your cause rather than helps it - it makes you less convincing to people able to see more than one point of view.
 
Pure_Argent, I know from experience that it is not always easy to distinguish between something in and of itself and its effects (real or imaginary), but this brand new example may be useful:

A similar case could therefore be made for the gangbangers: ‘But if the leader of a gang addressed a group of youngsters abandoned by their abusive parents, all alone in the world, and gave them a new perspective of life, self-esteem and a reason to live, wouldn’t that be a good thing?’
That is the kind of reasoning you are accepting when you buy into her particular delusion.

And if this "new perspective" meant turning away from violence, what in the name of everything atheistic would be wrong with that?!

You might as well defend cocaine addiction with the question that if cocaine makes you happy, healthy, wealthy, a better parent and kind to animals ... what in the name of Christ Almighty would be wrong with being addicted to it?

It is futile to tell BN that, well, "turning away from violence" is not what membership of a gang is about, since she'll insist on identifying the thing in and of itself with its effects, real or made up for the occasion.
This is the way in which pure fabrication presents itself as an argument in her fantasy world.
 
However, that would be a little besides the point since it would not focus on what religion is, i.e. a delusion called into being by circumstances detrimental to people’s wellbeing. Instead it focuses on the alleged effects that religion may or may not have, which is your as well as BN’s position.

Yes, it is. Because this thread is about religion's value, which has everything to do with its effects.

Do you see? This is no longer a question of what religion is. Instead you say: It does not really matter what religion is, i.e. delusion. Let us focus instead on the beneficial (or detrimental) effects that it may have. That this delusion is a reaction to unpleasant circumstances beyond people’s control becomes irrelevant.

Yes, it is relevant. But being a delusion does not remove the other effects, and these other effects do sometimes have value, which is what this discussion is about.

That is the very nature of delusion, isn’t it? And it makes it impossible to find a point between the alleged good and bad effects, about which you may argue for ever with BN.

Yes, it is impossible to find an objective answer to a subjective issue. But that doesn't change the situation. Not knowing where it starts to become a negative thing does not change the fact that it does have some positive effects.

This is the point where your argument with BN begins: Are the alleged effects of religion a blessing or a curse? What religion is in and of itself, however, has now become irrelevant since delusion may (allegedly) assist.

Yes, this is where I differ from Baby Nemesis. There are several things that she considers positive effects of religion that I don't (as well as some moral issues that we disagree on). But I do believe that there are some positive effects to religion. That's all I'm saying.

No, not really. Where I am trying to determine what religion is, she is trying to prove that religion has positive effects.

Uh, but this is a thread for discussing religion's value, not its truth or falsity.

You misunderstand the point: You are as militant as BN claims that you are. What you claim is irrelevant. (That your alleged militancy is a lie is besides the point. You should instead focus on the effect of the lie - as does BN.) :)

What?

You should have noticed that Diana is female.

If someone had pointed out to me that her name was Diana, maybe I would have. :P

No, not really. You completely accept her premise that religion is to be equated with its alleged effects.

No, I don't, and I'll thank you to stop strawmanning. You are the one attempting a thread derail, dann, by trying to change the subject of discussion from the value of religion to its truth or falsity. Take the discussion over to the Religion & Philosophy forums if you want to talk about that.

No, BN insists that that religion has positive effects. That is very different from intrinsic value. This, by the way, is the reason why she obsessively insists on her own basic delusion: that religion contains a beneficial element, some kind of substrate, which could be extracted and put to good use by unbelievers in secular therapeutic circumstances, i.e. the essence of good in religion.

Yes, her thoughts on that issue are kind of ludicrous. But your entire argument hinges on the fact that your opponent will define "intrinsic value" the same way you do. If your opponent doesn't, they can keep saying that religion can have value even if it is a delusion - which is what I'm saying.
Take, for example, magic tricks. Would you claim that a magic trick loses all its value if someone believes that it is actually magic, just because they're deluded?

I won’t even argue with you about that point. This is your argument with BN, not mine. However, you should at least be aware that the circumstances in this case aren’t merely ludicrously sugary-sweet and highly unlikely” but pure fabrication.

Agreed.

A similar case could therefore be made for the gangbangers: ‘But if the leader of a gang addressed a group of youngsters abandoned by their abusive parents, all alone in the world, and gave them a new perspective of life, self-esteem and a reason to live, wouldn’t that be a good thing?’
That is the kind of reasoning you are accepting into when you buy into her particular delusion.

I'm not sure, but I think that you mean that this gang leader is recruiting new people into the gang. If you are, then you're using the false analogy fallacy. Religious groups do not actively go out and commit crimes. Gangs do.

Forgive me for the italics and (!)s in the following quotation (except for would, which is your own:

This is where your futile argument with BN takes off: Instead of concentrating on what religion actually is, you start counting! Who can come up with more examples of alleged good and bad effects?[/quote]

Uh, no. I don't claim that. I don't think that religion is a good thing. But this thread is about discussing religion's overall value. I was simply weighing in with my two cents to say that it can have some positive effects, whether or not it is delusion.

So I guess that we will have to agree to disagree: I don’t consider delusion an improvement of ”their outlook on life”! I wouldn’t clap my hands in joy at the delusion of the saviour Harry Potter even though I don’t doubt that it was a comforting delusion to the children of Beslan.
I’d worry about the treatment of children, there and elsewhere, but I am well aware that I’m very old-fashioned in that respect ...

And again, I'm not saying that it's an improvement on their outlook. I don't favor delusion over depression. All I am saying is that, yes, good can come out of religion. Maybe not much, maybe as a result of delusion, but good all the same. Even if the gang members are now self-deluded in their outlook, they are no longer killing people, which is a good thing (and yes, I know that this is a horribly stupid example). No matter their personal situation, less killing is positive.

You might as well defend cocaine addiction with the question that if cocaine makes you happy, healthy, wealthy, a better parent and kind to animals ... what in the name of Christ Almighty would be wrong with being addicted to it?

Well, if that were the ONLY affects of cocaine addiction, I would say nothing. But let's assume that cocaine has both those fake positive effects and its real negative ones. Even if it is a bad thing to be addicted to cocaine under these circumstances, it cannot be said that the kind to animals part is a negative effect. There is still a small benefit from the cocaine addiction, no matter its other effects. It would still be a great thing to get rid of the cocaine addiction, because overall it is a horrible thing, but it is nice to be happy, wealthy and a better parent.
 
Dann said:
You might as well defend cocaine addiction with the question that if cocaine makes you happy, healthy, wealthy, a better parent and kind to animals ...
what in the name of Christ Almighty would be wrong with being addicted to it?

I am beginning to seriously consider exiting this thread, on ethical grounds. In fact, I may very well do so in the next few days. It's one thing to battle someone when you think they might have a hope of being spurred to put forward a decent argument if you show up the flaws in what they're saying; it's quite another to continue to do so when it becomes apparent from the sheer bizarreness of their arguments that ... well, something more is going on than mere wilful ignorance. Something possibly pathological. In any case, I will respond to this post. It may be one of the last I will respond to.

My point was that if a gang leader inspired his gang to give up violence, they might well still call themselves a gang, but they'd hardly be a gang in the conventional sense of the word, would they. They'd be a kind of prototypical non-violent gang. In reality, most people would cease to refer to them as a gang. They would probably start doing completely new, non-violent activities, perhaps sports, perhaps community work, perhaps something educational. Unlike your cocaine and breast cancer examples, it wouldn't simply be a matter of a few positive effects happening while the bulk of what happened was still harmful. So how could anything be wrong with it?

Of course, it would be different if they gave up violence but still went into battle with other gangs. Now obviously that would make their behaviour harmful, to themselves. But that would be extremely unlikely.

The fact that your anti-religious position is so extreme that it seems you wouldn't even accept the idea that it could be a good temporary measure if people turned to religion and were inspired to turn away from violence by it, - that their religious belief could simply fulfil the purpose of making them stop harming society while better and non-religious measures were being prepared that could help them stay non-violent, and that they would hopefully lose their religion when such measures were put in place, shows that your position is frankly sick. At least that's the way it seems. Far better, you seem to be saying, that these people are violent than that they should turn to religion, helping to prop up an evil system of delusion that needs to be eliminated! There is something seriously wrong with your priorities.

Or again, if you absolutely do not believe it's possible that anyone could be inspired to give up violence by turning to religion, for one thing, your position flies in the face of a lot of the evidence, and for another, you have not explained what grounds you have for holding such a position, or what evidence you have for such an extreme one.

As for the evidence for lots of people turning away from violence when they have turned to religion, I put more impressive evidence in this thread than a few gangster stories. Take what I put here earlier - the evidence researched by that atheist historian who put together the two-part television documentary on how the warrior culture of Ireland was transformed by Christianity after the fall of the Roman Empire.
See him interviewed.

And then there were the eight thousand cannibals I mentioned who apparently threw down their weapons when they became Christians and experienced some of the benefits of a more advanced civilisation in the 1960s. From this set of reports:

The society is one of several mission groups working in the interior of West Irian among tribes just emerging from a stone-age culture. A phenomenal response to the message of the Gospel has been witnessed among some of those warring cannibal tribes.

Notably, in the Swart Valley alone, since 1960, some 8,000 of the Dani tribe have become Christians, weapons and fetishes have been discarded and literacy has become widespread.

It's very unlikely these were "fantasy" cannibals, wouldn't you agree?

What makes your responses difficult to understand or tolerate is the fact that it seems you would prefer them to have stayed as violent cannibals if the alternative was that they would be inspired to turn from violence by Christianity. You don't even think it would be best if they turned to Christianity as a temporary measure while other methods of civilising them were looked into, at which point, they could be taught the benefits of atheism. No. If turning from violence involves them turning to religion at all, it seems you would rather they didn't turn to religion but stayed violent.

Now I think I understand your position so clearly, I'm not going to be able to continue to tolerate this conversation. So very soon, I think I will cease to read what you say, unless you can tell me I've misunderstood your position and it isn't in fact as extreme as that. Perhaps you just haven't been expressing yourself very well, and your opinion does in fact make sense?

(And yes, people have committed violence in the name of Christianity; but if you notice, that flies in the face of the way the Bible commands Christians to behave; and if you look at who the people were who spurred those people on to commit violence, you might notice a pattern.)
 
It is not really "a bit of a stretch to say" that "religion causes withdrawal symptoms when people abandon it."
Have you considered polling the atheists and non religionists no this set of forums to get a read on a small sample size of your alleged withdrawal symptoms?

A number of them have mostly expressed relief at being out of it, over at R & P.

Just an idea, since most of the people who post on this site are atheist or agnostic.

DR
 
What is it about this board?...are the mods so afraid of being seen as biased by posters who have a religious "bent" that they will allow this "junk" to be posted without any call for evidence?

What a load of mindless religious crap.
Sir: Please don't get irritated at the mods about this. It is not their job to defend or challenge a proposition, that is what members do to and for each other. The mods just make sure we all stay roughly on topic and within the rules established at the JREF for forum interactions.

DR
 
Do you have any updates on the pentacostal movement and its influence in South America, dann?
If all they do is piss off the Pope, isn't that some sort of inherent good, at least in the entertainment sense? ;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom