You can argue that religion causes harm,
However, that would be a little besides the point since it would not focus on
what religion
is, i.e. a delusion called into being by circumstances detrimental to people’s wellbeing. Instead it focuses on the alleged
effects that religion may or may not have, which is your as well as BN’s position.
but this is on a larger scale than the one that Baby Nemesis is arguing. Baby Nemesis is arguing that, on an individual level, religion can sometimes be a good thing. If it causes someone to turn away from violence in favor of peace, even if that peace is brought from a delusion, then it does have some merit.
Do you see? This is no longer a question of what religion
is. Instead you say: It does not really matter what religion is, i.e. delusion. Let us focus instead on the beneficial (or detrimental)
effects that it may have. That this delusion is a reaction to unpleasant circumstances beyond people’s control becomes irrelevant.
The exact point where it becomes detrimental is extremely fuzzy and hard to define. Undoubtedly there is such a point - somewhere very, very close to the point where they start taking religious dogma as fact above science - but its exact position is impossible to determine.
That is the very
nature of delusion, isn’t it? And it makes it impossible to find a
point between the alleged good and bad
effects, about which you may argue for ever with BN.
My position is that religion has some value on an individual level, as it does assist some people. However, on a societal level, its costs outweigh its benefits.
This is the point where
your argument with BN begins: Are the alleged
effects of religion a blessing or a curse?
What religion is in and of itself, however, has now become irrelevant since delusion may (allegedly)
assist.
Doesn’t look to be derailing to me. Baby Nemesis is actually trying to raise valid points. *shrugs*
No, not really. Where
I am trying to determine what religion
is,
she is trying to prove that religion has
positive effects. You could do the same thing with her favourite example, the gangbangers: ‘Is it entirely
negative to be in a gang? Why always focus on the
bad aspects when there are so many
good ones? Doesn’t it provide its members with
self-esteem? Doesn’t if offer them necessary
protection in an otherwise hostile world?’
That would be a similar way of
neglecting what
gangs actually are.
I never claimed to be militant. If I were militant, it would greatly strain a lot of the relationships I have, including those with my immediate family and my best friends, all of whom are religious. I’m the only atheist that I know, not counting the people on this board. I just strongly disagreed with the arguments that you were making in the other threads. Very strongly disagreed.
You misunderstand the point: You are as militant as BN claims that you are. What
you claim is irrelevant. (That your alleged militancy is a
lie is besides the point. You should instead focus on the
effect of the lie - as does BN.)
Oops! My bad.
You should have noticed that Diana is female.
I think I occupy a kind of middle ground between the two of you on this issue.
No, not really. You completely accept her premise that religion is to be equated with its alleged
effects.
Baby Nemesis that religion has intrinsic value, dann that it does not.
No, BN insists that that religion has positive
effects. That is very different from
intrinsic value. This, by the way, is the reason why she obsessively insists on her own basic delusion: that religion contains a beneficial element, some kind of substrate, which could be extracted and put to good use by unbelievers in secular therapeutic circumstances, i.e. the essence of
good in religion.
I’m of the opinion that, under certain circumstances, it can be a good thing - even if the circumstances are ludicrously sugary-sweet and highly unlikely, as in Baby Nemesis’ last example.
I won’t even argue with you about that point. This is your argument with BN, not mine. However, you should at least be aware that the circumstances in this case aren’t merely
ludicrously sugary-sweet and highly unlikely” but pure
fabrication.
A similar case could therefore be made for the gangbangers: ‘But if the leader of a gang addressed a group of youngsters abandoned by their abusive parents, all alone in the world, and gave them a new perspective of life, self-esteem and a reason to live, wouldn’t that be a good thing?’
That is the kind of reasoning you are accepting into when you buy into her particular delusion.
Forgive me for the
italics and (!)s in the following quotation (except for
would, which is your own:
However, there isn’t any way to monitor its effects on each (!) individual, or to determine when (!) religion has crossed the line into fanaticism. While religion might help the occasional individual by improving (!) their outlook on life (as long as religion doesn’t replace common sense or thinking), I do believe that, overall, the world would likely be a better place without it. Even with the few people that it helps (!), there are many more whose lives are affected in a negative way.
This is where your futile argument with BN takes off: Instead of concentrating on what religion actually
is, you start
counting! Who can come up with more examples of alleged good and bad
effects?
You are actually right that it is impossible to determine when delusion
has crossed the line into fanaticism since the
delusion is one and the same. Not only hijackers believe in the story of the 72 virgins. (And even they were watching porn the night before 9/11, I’ve heard, which seems to indicate that there was a limit to their fanaticism.)
The point isn’t so much that
”the world would likely be a better place without it”, (i.e. without religion). The point is that the world is a pretty ****** place. If it weren’t, religion would have no place in it. I.e. bad circumstances favour religion, which is why there aren't many atheists in foxholes. (See p. one of this thread.)
I have to insist with
Barbara Ehrenreich that,
no, I never think that delusion is okay!, which is only one of the reasons why I’d like to do away with the circumstances that make people dependent on and sometimes even addicted to delusions.
So I guess that we will have to agree to disagree:
I don’t consider
delusion an improvement of
”their outlook on life”!
I wouldn’t clap my hands in joy at the delusion of the saviour Harry Potter even though I don’t doubt that it was a comforting delusion to the children of Beslan.
I’d worry about the treatment of children, there and elsewhere, but I am well aware that I’m very old-fashioned in that respect ...